The PBL vs. Digital Mind Maps Integrated PBL: Choosing Between the two with a view to Enhance Learners’ Critical Thinking

Year 2022, Volume: 9 Issue: 3, 330 - 343, 01.05.2022

Nurkhairo Hidayati , Siti Zubaidah , Sri Amnah

https://doi.org/10.17275/per.22.69.9.3

Cited By: 12

Abstract

Critical thinking plays a crucial role in the learning process. Critical thinking should become the focus of learning since it encourages the development of knowledge and includes the act of contemplating subjects, content, and problems. The current study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) and Digital Mind Maps-Integrated PBL (DMM-Integrated PBL) in improving students’ critical thinking. This quasi-experiment study employed a pretest-posttest control group design, involving 103 university students from the Biology Department of University in Riau, Indonesia, as the sample. The details of each group consist of 31 students in conventional, PBL (37 students), and DMM-Integrated PBL (35 students) classes. The research data was collected using an essay test. The data obtained were analyzed using ANCOVA at a significance level of 5% and an LSD test. Essay test developed based on critical thinking indicators: basic clarification, bases for a decision, inference, advanced clarification, supposition and integration, and strategies and tactics. All the instruments had been validated. The ANCOVA analysis results proved that PBL and DMM-Integrated PBL affected the students' critical thinking. However, the LSD test showed no significant difference between PBL and DMM-Integrated PBL in promoting students' critical thinking. Finally, to promote students’ critical thinking, educators are recommended to use PBL or DMM-Integrated PBL in the classroom.

Keywords

critical thinking, digital mind maps, problem based learning

Thanks

Our deepest gratitude goes to Universitas Islam Riau, Indonesia

References

• Aksu, G., & Koruklu, N. (2015). Determination the Effects of Vocational High School Students' Logical and Critical Thinking Skills on Mathematics Success. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 59, 181-206.
• Alper, A. (2010). Critical thinking disposition of pre-service teachers. Education and Science, 35 (158), 14-27
• Amrous, N., & Nejmaoui, N. (2016). A developmental approach to the use of critical thinking skills in writing: the case of Moroccan EFL university students. Arab World English Journal (AWEJ), 142–156.
• Applin, H., Williams, B., Day, R., & Buro, K. (2011). A comparison of competencies between problem-based learning and non-problem-based graduate nurses. Nurse Education Today, 31(2), 129–134.
• Arends, R.I. 2012. Learning to Teach. New York. McGraw-Hill
• Bachtiar, S., Zubaidah, S., Corebima, A. D., & Indriwati, S. E. (2018). The spiritual and social attitudes of students towards integrated problem based learning models. Issues in Educational Research, 28(2), 254–270.
• Bailin, S., Case, R., Coombs, J. R., & Daniels, L. B. (1999). Conceptualizing critical thinking. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 31(3), 285–302
• Browne, M. N. & Keeley, S. M. (2010). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking. 10thed. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
• Butler, H. A., Pentoney, C., & Bong, M. P. (2017). Predicting real-world outcomes: Critical thinking ability is a better predictor of life decisions than intelligence. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 25, 38–46.
• Buzan, T. 2011. Learn to Mind Maps Book. Retrieved from http://www.tonybuzan.com/about/mind-
• Carriger, M. S. (2015). Problem-based learning and management development - Empirical and theoretical considerations. International Journal of Management Education, 13(3), 249–259.
• Cheng, S. C., She, H. C., & Huang, L. Y. (2018). The impact of problem-solving instruction on middle school students’ physical science learning: Interplays of knowledge, reasoning, and problem solving. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 14(3), 731–743
• Chikiwa, C., & Schäfer, M. (2018). Promoting critical thinking in multilingual mathematics classes through questioning. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 14(8).
• Cuthell, J., & Preston, C. 2008. Multimodal Concept Mapping in teaching and learning: A MirandaNet Fellowship project. Technology and Teacher Education Annual, 19(3)
• Dwyer, C.P. (2017). To teach or not to teach critical thinking: A reply to Hubner and Kuncel. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 26, 92-95.
• Dwijananti, P., & Yulianti, D. (2010). Development of students’ critical thinking ability through learning problem based instruction in environmental physics courses. Jurnal Pendidikan Fisika Indonesia, 6, 108–114.
• EL-Shaer, A., & Gaber, H. (2014). Impact of problem-based learning on student critical thinking dispositions, knowledge acquisition, and retention. Journal of Education and Practice, 5(14), 74–85.
• Emanet, E. A., & Kezer, F. (2020). The effects of student-centered teaching methods used in mathematics courses on mathematics achievement, attitude, and anxiety: a meta-analysis study. Participatory Educational Research, 8(2), 240-259.
• Ennis, R.H. (2011). The nature of critical thinking: an outline of critical thinking dispositions and abilities. Retrieved from http://faculty.education.illinois.edurhennis/documents. TheNatureofCriticalThinking_51711_000.pdf
• Erdogan, F. (2019). Effect of cooperative learning supported by reflective thinking activities on students’ critical thinking skills. Eurasian journal of educational research, 19(80), 89-112.
• Ersoy, E., & Başer, N. (2014). The effects of problem-based learning method in higher education on creative thinking. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 116, 3494–3498.
• Facione, P. A. (1990). Critical thinking: A statement of expert consensus for purposes of educational assessment and instruction. Research Findings and Recommendations. Retrieved from http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED315423i.
• Farrand, P., Hussain, F., & Hennessy, E. (2002). The efficacy of the mind map study technique. Medical education, 36(5), 426-431
• Faste, H., & Lin, H. (2012). The untapped promise of digital mind maps. Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (pp. 1017-1026). ACM.
• Fisher, R. (2001). Philosophy in primary schools: fostering thinking skills and literacy. Reading, 35(2), 67-73.
• Fong, C. J., Kim, Y., Davis, C. W., Hoang, T., & Kim, Y. W. (2017). A meta-analysis on critical thinking and community college student achievement. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 26, 71–83.
• Fonseca, L., & Arezes, S. (2017). A didactic proposal to develop critical thinking in mathematics: The case of Tomás. Journal of the European Teacher Education Network, 12, 37-48.
• Gojkov, G., Stojanović, A., & Rajić, A. G. (2015). Critical thinking of students–indicator of quality in higher education. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 191, 591-596.
• Gorghiu, G., Drăghicescu, L. M., Cristea, S., Petrescu, A. M., & Gorghiu, L. M. (2015). Problem-based learning-an efficient learning strategy in the science lessons context. Procedia-social and behavioral sciences, 191, 1865-1870.
• Halpern, D. F. (2003). Thought and knowledge: An introduction to critical thinking (4th ed). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
• Hariyadi, S., Corebima, A. D., & Zubaidah, S. (2018). Contribution of mind mapping, summarizing, and questioning in the RQA learning model to genetic learning outcomes, 15(1), 80–88.
• Hidayati, N., Zubaidah, S., Suarsini, E., & Praherdhiono, H. (2020). The Relationship between Critical Thinking and Knowledge Acquisition: The Role of Digital Mind Maps-PBL Strategies. International Journal of Information and Education Technology, 10(2).
• Hmelo-Silver, C. E. (2004). Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn? Educational Psychology Review, 16(3), 235–266.
• Hu, Y. H., Xing, J., & Tu, L. P. (2018). The effect of a problem-oriented teaching method on university mathematics learning. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 14(5), 1695–1703.
• Imran, M., Shamsi, S., Singh, A., Goel, S., Sharma, P., & Panesar, S. (2015). Problem-based learning versus lecture-based learning in pharmacology in a junior doctor teaching program: a crossover study from northern India. International Journal of Research in Medical Sciences, 3(11), 3296–3299.
• Jbeili, I. M. A. (2013). The impact of digital mind maps on science achievement among sixth-grade students in Saudi Arabia. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 103, 1078–1087.
• Kek, M. Y. C. A., & Huijser, H. (2011). The power of problem-based learning in developing critical thinking skills: Preparing students for tomorrow’s digital futures in today’s classrooms. Higher Education Research and Development, 30(3), 329–341.
• Kim, K., Sharma, P., Land, S. M., & Furlong, K. P. (2013). Effects of active learning on enhancing student critical thinking in an undergraduate general science cours. Innovative Higher Education, 38(3), 223–235.
• Klimovienė, G., Urbonienė, J., & Barzdžiukienė, R. (2006). Developing critical thinking through cooperative learning. Studies about languages, 9, 77-85.
• Kong, L. N., Qin, B., Zhou, Y. qing, Mou, S. Yu, & Gao, H. M. (2014). The effectiveness of problem-based learning on development of nursing students’ critical thinking: A systematic review and meta-analysis. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 51(3), 458–469.
• Laampere, M., Matsak, E., & Kippar, J. (2006). Integrating a concept mapping tool into a virtual learning environment: Pedagogical and technological challenges. In Concept maps: Theory, methodology, technology: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Concept Mapping (pp. 280-287).
• Lin, S. S. (2014). Science and non-science undergraduate students’ critical thinking and argumentation performance in reading a science news report. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 12(5), 1023–1046.
• Mahanal, S.,Zubaidah, S., Bahri, A., Dinnuriya, M.S. 2016. Improving students’ critical thinking skills through Remap NHT in biology classroom. Asia-Pacific Forum on Science Learning and Teaching, 17(2)
• Mahmoud, A. S., & Mohamed, H. A. (2017). Critical Thinking Disposition among Nurses Working in Public Hospitals at Port-Said Governorate. International Journal of Nursing Sciences, 4(2), 128–134.
• McCormick, N. J., Clark, L. M., & Raines, J. M. (2015). Engaging students in critical thinking and problem solving: A brief review of the literature. Journal of Studies in Education, 5(4), 100.
• Masek, A., & Yamin, S. (2012). A Comparative Study of the Effect of Problem Based Learning and Traditional Learning Approaches on Students' Knowledge Acquisition. International Journal of Engineering Education, 28(5), 1161-1167.
• Niwa, M., Saiki, T., Fujisaki, K., Suzuki, Y., & Evans, P. (2016). The Effects of Problem-Based-Learning on the Academic Achievements of Medical Students in One Japanese Medical School, Over a Twenty-Year Period. Health Professions Education, 2(1), 3-9.
• Noonan, M. (2012). Mind maps: Enhancing midwifery education. Nurse Education Today, 33(8), 847−85
• Osman, K., & Kaur, S. J. (2014). Evaluating biology achievement scores in an ICT integrated PBL environment. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 10(3), 185–194.
• Ozkahraman, S., & Yildirim, B. (2011). An overview of critical thinking in nursing and education. Am Int J Contemp Research, 1(2), 190–196.
• Papp, K. K., Huang, G. C., Lauzon Clabo, L. M., Delva, D., Fischer, M., Konopasek, L., … Gusic, M. (2014). Milestones of critical thinking: A developmental model for medicine and nursing. Academic Medicine, 89(5), 715–720.
• Papushina, I., Maksimenkova, O., & Kolomiets, A. (2017). Digital educational mind maps: A computer-supported collaborative learning practice on marketing master program. Interactive Collaborative Learning, 17–30.
• Qi, A. (2018). A study of the effect of implementing intellectual property education with digital teaching on learning motivation and achievements. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science & Technology Education, 14(6), 2445–2452.
• Quitadamo, I.., Faiola, Celia, L., Johnson, E, J., & Kurtz, Martha, J. (2008). Community-based inquiry improves critical thinking in general education biology. CBE Life Sciences Education, 7(3), 327–337.
• Rosciano, A. (2015). The effectiveness of mind mapping as an active learning strategy among associate degree nursing students. Teaching and Learning in Nursing, 10(2), 93–99
• Savery, J. (2006). Overview of problem-based learning: Definitions and Distinctions. Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem Based Learning, 1(1), 269–282.
• Şen, Ö. F., & Sari, U. (2018). From traditional to reform-based teaching beliefs and classroom practices of elementary science teachers. International Journal of Innovation in Science and Mathematics Education (formerly CAL-laborate International), 26(6), 76-95
• Shishigu, A., Hailu, A., & Anibo, Z. (2018). Problem-based learning and conceptual understanding of college female students in physics. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 14(1), 145–154.
• Simonova, I. (2015). E-learning in Mind Maps of Czech and Kazakhstan University Students. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 171, 1229–1234
• Spencer, J. R., Anderson, K. M., & Ellis, K. K. (2013). Radiant thinking and the use of the mind map in nurse practitioner education. The Journal of Nursing Education, 52(5), 291–293
• Suparni. (2014). Development of critical thinking ability students of mathematical education program through interconnection integration approach. Proceedings of the National Seminar on Mathematics and Mathematics Education. UNY, (November 2013), 978–979.
• Tan, D. K., Koppi, A., & Field, D. J. (2016). First ear agricultural science student perspectives in graduate attribute development through Problem-Based Learning. International Journal of Innovation in Science and Mathematics Education, 24(1), 54-66
• Tseng, K. H., Chang, C. C., & Lou, S. J. (2012). The process, dialogues, and attitudes of vocational engineering high school students in a web problem-based learning (WPBL) system. Interactive Learning Environments, 20(6), 547–562
• Van Blankenstein, F. M., Dolmans, D. H. J. M., Van der Vleuten, C. P. M., & Schmidt, H. G. (2011). Which cognitive processes support learning during small-group discussion? The role of providing explanations and listening to others. Instructional Science, 39, 189–204.
• Vasilyeva, K. K., & Erdyneeva, K. G. (2016). Learning Chinese as a Social and Cultural Factorof in Developing Creativity in Primary School Children. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 233(May), 433–439
• Von Colln-Appling, C., & Giuliano, D. (2017). A concept analysis of critical thinking: A guide for nurse educators. Nurse Education Today, 49, 106–109.
• Vong, S. A., & Kaewurai, W. (2017). Instructional model development to enhance critical thinking and critical thinking teaching ability of trainee students at regional teaching training center in Takeo province, Cambodia. Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences, 38(1), 88–95.
• Wang, Q., & Woo, H. L. (2010). Investigating students’ critical thinking in weblogs: An exploratory study in a Singapore secondary school. Asia Pacific Education Review, 11(4), 541–551.
• Wei, P. C., He, F., & Huang, S. (2018). Effects of instructional multimedia integrated situational approach on students’ learning achievement. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 14(7), 3321–3327.
• Wijnen, M., Loyens, S. M. M., & Schaap, L. (2016). Experimental evidence of the relative effectiveness of problem-based learning for knowledge acquisition and retention. Interactive Learning Environments, 24(8), 1907–1921.
• Yildirim, B., & Ozkahraman, S. (2011). Critical thinking in nursing process and education. International journal of humanities and social science, 1(13), 257-262.
• Yilmaz, A. (2021). The effect of technology integration in education on prospective teachers' critical and creative thinking, multidimensional 21st century skills and academic achievements. Participatory Educational Research, 8(2), 163-199.
• Yusnaeni, Corebima, A. D., Susilo, H., & Zubaidah, S. (2017). Creative Thinking of Low Academic Student Undergoing Search Solve Create and Share Learning Integrated with Metacognitive Strategy. International Journal of Instruction, 10(2), 245–262.
• Zubaidah, S., Corebima, A. D., Mahanal, S., & Mistianah. (2018). Revealing the Relationship between Reading Interest and Critical Thinking Skills through Remap GI and Remap Jigsaw. International Journal of Instruction, 11(2), 41–56.