BibTex RIS Cite

IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter

Year 2002, Issue: 18, - , 30.12.2002

Abstract

ÖZET
Bir kısım müsteşrikler, kırâat konusunu Kur’an’da bir eksiklik
olarak görmüş ve bunu daima tenkit etmişlerdir. Bunlardan biri de, Ignace Goldziher’dir.
Goldziher, bazı tenkitlerinde özellikle Taberî’yi referans
göstermektedir. Buna Yusuf (12)-110 ve Âl-i İmrân (3)-161 ayetlerini misal verebiliriz. Mezkûr ayetleri ele aldığımızda Goldziher’in yaptığı aktarımların eksik ve biraz da yanlı olduğu kanaatine vardık. Bu vesileyle konunun arka planını incelemeye çalıştık.
Anahtar Kelimeler: Taberi, Kur’an, Peygamber, Müsteşrik, Ayet, Kırâat, Sahih, Meşhûr, Sazz.

ABSTRACT

Some orientalists had seen “the Qiraat, that is recital of the
Qur’an, as a defect in the Qur’an and criticized it always. One of
them is Ignace Goldziher.
Mr. Goldziher had referred to Taberî in his some critics. We
may give examples some verses of the Qur’an like Yusuf/110 and Al-i Imran/161. When we examined these verses, we have seen that Mr. Goldziher’s quotations from Taberi are deficient and partial.So We have exerted on studying the background of the matter.

Key Words: Taberi, Orientalist, The Prophet, The Qur’an, Verse, Recital, Authentic, Well-Known Recitals, Unusual, Uncommon Recitals.

Year 2002, Issue: 18, - , 30.12.2002

Abstract

There are 0 citations in total.

Details

Primary Language tr; en
Journal Section Makaleler
Authors

Abdulmecit Okcu This is me

Publication Date December 30, 2002
Published in Issue Year 2002 Issue: 18

Cite

APA Okcu, A. (2002). IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi(18).
AMA Okcu A. IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi. December 2002;(18).
Chicago Okcu, Abdulmecit. “IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites That Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter”. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, no. 18 (December 2002).
EndNote Okcu A (December 1, 2002) IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi 18
IEEE A. Okcu, “IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter”, Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, no. 18, December 2002.
ISNAD Okcu, Abdulmecit. “IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites That Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter”. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi 18 (December 2002).
JAMA Okcu A. IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi. 2002.
MLA Okcu, Abdulmecit. “IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites That Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter”. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, no. 18, 2002.
Vancouver Okcu A. IGNACE GOLDZIHER’İN TABERÎ’DEN AKTARIMDA BULUNARAK BAZI KIRÂATLERİ TENKİDİ VE MESELENİN ARKA PLÂNI / Criticism of Ignace Goldziher about Some Quranic Recites that Had Been Quoted from Taberî’s Commentary and the Background of the Matter. Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi. 2002(18).

Creative Commons License
Atatürk Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. ile lisanslanmıştır.