Research Article
BibTex RIS Cite

İsrail Siyasetini Anlamada Tarihin Rolü: Haçlı Seferleri ile Siyonizm Hareketi Arasında Benzerlik Örneği

Year 2020, , 85 - 102, 30.06.2020
https://doi.org/10.31456/beytulmakdis.691601

Abstract

References

  • Abdul-Latif, H. Mafhum al-Sahyuniyah ‘ind Abdulwahab Al-Misiri. Unpublished MA thesis, Islamic University, Gaza, 2013.
  • Abu-Allam, Abdullah. Al-Urdun. Dar al-Falah, n.d.
  • Al-Misiri, Abdulwahab. Mawsuat al-Yahud wal-Yahudiyah wal-Sahyuniyah. Beirut: Dar al-Shuruq, 1999.
  • Al-Qalbini, A. “Hittin: Istilham al-Madi wa-Istishraf al-Mustaqbal”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Al-Salih, Nidal. “Sultat al-Tarikh ala al-Siyasah”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.2659, 2009.
  • Al-Wagsili, M. Ahamiyat al-Tarikh Inda al-Muslimin wal-Sahayinah. Majalat al-Bayan, vol.336m 2015.
  • Ammarah, M. Islamiyat al-Sirah hawl al-Quds wa-Filistin, Cairo: Dar Nahdat Misir, 1998.
  • El-Awaisi, Abd al-Fattah. Nazariyat wa-Namadhij Bayt al-Maqdis. Istanbul: Dar al-Usul al-Ilmiyah, 2019.
  • Lewis, Bernard. Al-Arab fi al-Tarikh. Tr.N.A.Faris. Beirut: Dar al-Ilm lil-Malayin.
  • Madiyah, Saeed. “Keith Witelamb fi kitabih Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah wa Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.3316, 2011.
  • Maghrabi, Fuad. “Filistin min waqt ila Akhar: Mulahazat hawl al-Tarikh al-Shafawi”, Majalar Ru’yati Tarbawiyah, vol49. 2012.
  • Mawqi’ Wazarat al-Kharijiyah al-Israiliyah. Wathiqat al-Istiqlal, 2013. https://mfa.gov.il/MFAAR/KeyDocuments/IndependenceDeclaration/Pages/megilat%20haatsmaut.aspx
  • Mu’nis, H. al-Tarikh wal-Mu’arikhun: Dirasah fi Ilm al-Tarikh. Cairo: Dar al-Rashad, 2012.
  • Özlemiş, Mustafa, Tarihin önemi, http://www.mustafaoselmis.com.tr/tarihin-onemi
  • Shakir, Mustafa. “Al-Sira’ al-Arabi al-Sahyuni min al-Gazw al-Salibi ila al-Gazw al-al-Sahyuni wabil-Aks”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Taha, A. Usul al-Bahth al-Tarikhi. Beirut: Dar al-Midar al-Islami, 2004.
  • Whitelamb, K. Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah, Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini. Tr.S.al-Hinidi. Kuwait: al-Majlis al-Watani llil-Thaqafah wal-Funun wal-Adab, 1999.
  • Yusuf, Muhammad. Qira’a Naqdiyah fi maqulat Ard bila Shab li-Shab bila Ard. Beirut: Mu’asast al-Quds al-Dawliyah, n.d.
  • Zahir, Mustafa. Muqarabat fi Dirasat al-Nas al-Tawrati. Damascus: Safahat lil-Dirasat wal-Nashir.

دور التاريخ في فهم السياسة الإسرائيلية: التشابه بين الحروب الصليبية والحركة الصهيونية أنموذجاً

Year 2020, , 85 - 102, 30.06.2020
https://doi.org/10.31456/beytulmakdis.691601

Abstract

في إطار الصراع الإسرائيلي الفلسطيني تشن إسرائيل مع شريكها الغربي حرباً ضروسا على الشعب الفلسطيني والأرض المقدسة، إن الوجه الظاهر من هذه الحرب هو المواجهات والحروب العسكرية، إلا أن هناك وجها أخر لهذا الصراع لا يقل أهمية عن المواجهة العسكرية، ألا وهو الصراع على الهوية والرواية التاريخية. وقد كرس الصهاينة جهودهم في سبيل غاية واحدة، وهي إثبات أحقيتهم في الأرض المقدسة. ونظراً لإدراك الصهاينة بأهمية التاريخ ومدى سلطته على السياسة فقد قاموا ببذل جهود كبيرة من أجل تزييفه واختلاق حق تاريخي لهم في الأرض المقدسة. فقاموا بدراسة بعض النماذج التاريخية دراسة مستفيضة لأخذ العظة وتجنب الأخطاء التي وقعت فيها، وخير مثال على ذلك، الاهتمام الذي أبدوه في دراسة الحملات الصليبية. يأتي هذا البحث ليبين الأهمية التي أولاها الصهاينة للتاريخ وكيف تم استخدامه في اثبات حقهم في الأرض المقدسة، باختلاق تاريخ يهودي وطمس للتاريخ الفلسطيني، مستغلاً ضعف الوعي العربي والفلسطيني بأهمية التاريخ في تثبيت الأحقية في الأرض، وتناولت الدراسة أيضاً مسألة اهتمام الصهاينة بالحملات الصليبية، وذلك لتلافي المصير الذي لاقته الحملات الصليبية.

References

  • Abdul-Latif, H. Mafhum al-Sahyuniyah ‘ind Abdulwahab Al-Misiri. Unpublished MA thesis, Islamic University, Gaza, 2013.
  • Abu-Allam, Abdullah. Al-Urdun. Dar al-Falah, n.d.
  • Al-Misiri, Abdulwahab. Mawsuat al-Yahud wal-Yahudiyah wal-Sahyuniyah. Beirut: Dar al-Shuruq, 1999.
  • Al-Qalbini, A. “Hittin: Istilham al-Madi wa-Istishraf al-Mustaqbal”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Al-Salih, Nidal. “Sultat al-Tarikh ala al-Siyasah”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.2659, 2009.
  • Al-Wagsili, M. Ahamiyat al-Tarikh Inda al-Muslimin wal-Sahayinah. Majalat al-Bayan, vol.336m 2015.
  • Ammarah, M. Islamiyat al-Sirah hawl al-Quds wa-Filistin, Cairo: Dar Nahdat Misir, 1998.
  • El-Awaisi, Abd al-Fattah. Nazariyat wa-Namadhij Bayt al-Maqdis. Istanbul: Dar al-Usul al-Ilmiyah, 2019.
  • Lewis, Bernard. Al-Arab fi al-Tarikh. Tr.N.A.Faris. Beirut: Dar al-Ilm lil-Malayin.
  • Madiyah, Saeed. “Keith Witelamb fi kitabih Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah wa Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.3316, 2011.
  • Maghrabi, Fuad. “Filistin min waqt ila Akhar: Mulahazat hawl al-Tarikh al-Shafawi”, Majalar Ru’yati Tarbawiyah, vol49. 2012.
  • Mawqi’ Wazarat al-Kharijiyah al-Israiliyah. Wathiqat al-Istiqlal, 2013. https://mfa.gov.il/MFAAR/KeyDocuments/IndependenceDeclaration/Pages/megilat%20haatsmaut.aspx
  • Mu’nis, H. al-Tarikh wal-Mu’arikhun: Dirasah fi Ilm al-Tarikh. Cairo: Dar al-Rashad, 2012.
  • Özlemiş, Mustafa, Tarihin önemi, http://www.mustafaoselmis.com.tr/tarihin-onemi
  • Shakir, Mustafa. “Al-Sira’ al-Arabi al-Sahyuni min al-Gazw al-Salibi ila al-Gazw al-al-Sahyuni wabil-Aks”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Taha, A. Usul al-Bahth al-Tarikhi. Beirut: Dar al-Midar al-Islami, 2004.
  • Whitelamb, K. Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah, Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini. Tr.S.al-Hinidi. Kuwait: al-Majlis al-Watani llil-Thaqafah wal-Funun wal-Adab, 1999.
  • Yusuf, Muhammad. Qira’a Naqdiyah fi maqulat Ard bila Shab li-Shab bila Ard. Beirut: Mu’asast al-Quds al-Dawliyah, n.d.
  • Zahir, Mustafa. Muqarabat fi Dirasat al-Nas al-Tawrati. Damascus: Safahat lil-Dirasat wal-Nashir.

The Role of History in Understanding Israeli Politics: an Analogy between the Crusades and the Zionist Movement as a case study

Year 2020, , 85 - 102, 30.06.2020
https://doi.org/10.31456/beytulmakdis.691601

Abstract

In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict Israel with its Westerns alliance is continuing its extreme war against Palestine and its people. In addition to the military factor in this war there is another important element with is the war toward controlling and reshaping the identity and the historical narratives. The Zionists effort is concentrated on one target; which is proving their eternal right of the Holy Land. Their awareness of importance of history and its role in politics motivates the Zionists to reshape and fabricate the historical facts to support their claims of the Holy Land. They had shown a great deal of interest in studying the previous historical models to avoid their mistakes and conclude some lessons. One of these models is Christian Crusaders which had been intensely studied. This research aims to show the level of Zionists interests in history and how they use it to prove their right in the Holy Land. They take advantage of the Arabs and Palestinian’s ignorance of the important of history to recreate an Israeli history erase the Palestinian History. This paper also present Zionists’ interests in the Christian Crusaders aiming in avoiding their mistakes.

References

  • Abdul-Latif, H. Mafhum al-Sahyuniyah ‘ind Abdulwahab Al-Misiri. Unpublished MA thesis, Islamic University, Gaza, 2013.
  • Abu-Allam, Abdullah. Al-Urdun. Dar al-Falah, n.d.
  • Al-Misiri, Abdulwahab. Mawsuat al-Yahud wal-Yahudiyah wal-Sahyuniyah. Beirut: Dar al-Shuruq, 1999.
  • Al-Qalbini, A. “Hittin: Istilham al-Madi wa-Istishraf al-Mustaqbal”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Al-Salih, Nidal. “Sultat al-Tarikh ala al-Siyasah”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.2659, 2009.
  • Al-Wagsili, M. Ahamiyat al-Tarikh Inda al-Muslimin wal-Sahayinah. Majalat al-Bayan, vol.336m 2015.
  • Ammarah, M. Islamiyat al-Sirah hawl al-Quds wa-Filistin, Cairo: Dar Nahdat Misir, 1998.
  • El-Awaisi, Abd al-Fattah. Nazariyat wa-Namadhij Bayt al-Maqdis. Istanbul: Dar al-Usul al-Ilmiyah, 2019.
  • Lewis, Bernard. Al-Arab fi al-Tarikh. Tr.N.A.Faris. Beirut: Dar al-Ilm lil-Malayin.
  • Madiyah, Saeed. “Keith Witelamb fi kitabih Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah wa Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini”. Al-Hiwar al-Mutamadin, vol.3316, 2011.
  • Maghrabi, Fuad. “Filistin min waqt ila Akhar: Mulahazat hawl al-Tarikh al-Shafawi”, Majalar Ru’yati Tarbawiyah, vol49. 2012.
  • Mawqi’ Wazarat al-Kharijiyah al-Israiliyah. Wathiqat al-Istiqlal, 2013. https://mfa.gov.il/MFAAR/KeyDocuments/IndependenceDeclaration/Pages/megilat%20haatsmaut.aspx
  • Mu’nis, H. al-Tarikh wal-Mu’arikhun: Dirasah fi Ilm al-Tarikh. Cairo: Dar al-Rashad, 2012.
  • Özlemiş, Mustafa, Tarihin önemi, http://www.mustafaoselmis.com.tr/tarihin-onemi
  • Shakir, Mustafa. “Al-Sira’ al-Arabi al-Sahyuni min al-Gazw al-Salibi ila al-Gazw al-al-Sahyuni wabil-Aks”, Majalat Su’un Arabiyah, vol.52, 1987.
  • Taha, A. Usul al-Bahth al-Tarikhi. Beirut: Dar al-Midar al-Islami, 2004.
  • Whitelamb, K. Iktilaq Israil al-Qadeemah, Iskat al-Tarikh al-Filistini. Tr.S.al-Hinidi. Kuwait: al-Majlis al-Watani llil-Thaqafah wal-Funun wal-Adab, 1999.
  • Yusuf, Muhammad. Qira’a Naqdiyah fi maqulat Ard bila Shab li-Shab bila Ard. Beirut: Mu’asast al-Quds al-Dawliyah, n.d.
  • Zahir, Mustafa. Muqarabat fi Dirasat al-Nas al-Tawrati. Damascus: Safahat lil-Dirasat wal-Nashir.
There are 19 citations in total.

Details

Primary Language Arabic
Journal Section Articles
Authors

Issa Baraıjıa

Publication Date June 30, 2020
Published in Issue Year 2020

Cite

APA Baraıjıa, I. (2020). دور التاريخ في فهم السياسة الإسرائيلية: التشابه بين الحروب الصليبية والحركة الصهيونية أنموذجاً. Journal of Islamicjerusalem Studies, 20(1), 85-102. https://doi.org/10.31456/beytulmakdis.691601

ISSN:1367-1936 , e-ISSN:2514-6009