İKİNCİ SOFİSTİK DÖNEM: SOFİST, RETOR VE FİLOZOFLARIN DİNİ GÖREVLERİ

Abstract

Edebi kaynaklar, epigrafik belgeler ve nümismatik veriler İkinci Sofistik Dönem’de MS I-III. yüzyıl so­fist, retor ve filozofların mensubu oldukları aile ve al­dıkları eğitim sonucunda, kamusal yükümlülükleri ait olduk­ları toplumsal sınıf içinde dikkat çekici şekilde ba­şarıyla yerine getirdikle­rini ve sahip oldukları parayı cö­mertçe kentleri için harcadıklarını göstermektedir. Bu kişiler βούλαρχος, βου­λευ­τής, γραμματεύς, στρα­τηγός, ἀρχιε­ρεύς, δᾳδοῦχος, ἱερεύς, ἱεροφάντης, νεω­κόρ­ος, νεοποι­ός, περιθύτης, προ­φήτης, ἀγορανόμος, λογιστής ve τα­μίας, γυμνασίαρχος, ἐφήβαρχος, ἀγωνο­θέτης, εἰρήναρ­χος/εἰρηνάρχης, στεφανή­φο­ρος, πρύτα­νις/πρυτανάρχης gibi önemli kent görevlerini üstlen­mişlerdir. Ayrıca eyalet düzeyinde ἀγωνοθέτης, ἀρχι­ερεύς/ἀσιάρχης ve γα­λα­τάρχης’lik gibi oldukça prestijli kamusal görevleri üstlendikleri de belgelenmektedir. Bu makalede ise İkin­ci Sofistik Dönem’de sofist, retor ve filozofla­rın kent­lerde üstlenmiş oldukları dini görev­ler ele alınmakta­dır. Philostratos VS ve epigrafik bel­geler aracılığıyla bu kişilerin arkhiereus, hiereus, dadou­khos, hierophantes, ne­o­koros, neopoios, perithytes ve pro­phetes gibi önemli dini görevleri icra ettikleri belgelen­mektedir. Bu görev­leri kendi kentlerinde olduğu gibi vatandaşı oldukları diğer kentlerde de üstlenmişlerdir. Kamusal görevler üst­lenmede retorların daha aktif ol­du­ğu görülmektedir; ancak dini görev üstlenen sofistle­rin sayısı retorlardan daha fazladır. Filozofların ise ge­nel olarak kamusal görev üstlenme ve imtiyazlar elde etme hususunda sofist ve retorların gerisinde kaldıkları tespit edilmektedir.

Keywords

• Sofist
• Retor
• Filozof
• Memuriyet
• Dini Görevler

THE SECOND SOPHISTIC: RELIGIOUS OFFICIALS OF SOPHISTS, RHETORS, AND PHILOSOPHERS

Abstract

Literary sources, epigraphical documents, and numismatic evidence show that the sophists, rhe­tors, and philosophers that belonged to the most pro­minent and the wealthiest families had an excellent edu­cation and so they officiated successfully many pub­lic services and generously spent their money for the cities in the Second Sophistic Period Ist to IIIrd cen­turies AD . They undertook important municipal ma­gistracies such as βούλαρχος, βουλευτής, γραμμα­τεύς, στρατηγός, ἀρχιερεύς, δᾳδοῦχος, ἱερεύς, ἱερο­φάντης, νεωκόρος, νεοποιός, περιθύτης, προφήτης, ἀγο­ρα­νό­μος, λογιστής ve ταμίας, γυμνασίαρχος, ἐφή­βαρ­χος, ἀγω­νοθέτης, εἰρήναρχος/εἰρηνάρχης, στεφα­νή­φορος, πρύτανις/πρυ­τανάρχης. Also, it is docu­men­ted that they took on quite prestigious provincial magistracies such as ἀγωνοθέτης, ἀρχιερεύς/ἀσιάρχης, and γαλα- τάρχης. In this article, religious services of sophists, rhetors, and philosophers in the Second So­phis­tic Pe­riod are investigated. Philostratos VS and epigraphi­cal documents assert that these persons took on impor­tant religious duties such as arkhiereus, hie­reus, da­doukhos, hierophantes, neokoros, neopoios, pe­rithytes and prophetes. They fulfilled these tasks in their own cities as well as in other cities they became citi­zens. It is obvious that rhetors were more active in public tasks; but, the number of sophists who took on religious duty was more than the rhetors. On the other hand, it is determined that philosophers generally fell behind sophists and rhetors about undertaking public duties and obtaining privileges.

Keywords

• Sophist
• Rhetor
• Philosopher
• Official Duty
• Religious Official

References

1. Ael. Ar. Orat. (= Aelius Aristeides, Orationes) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Aristides. Ed. W. Dindorf. Leipzig 1829.
2. Publius Aelius Aristides, The Complete Works. Vol. I. Orations I-XVI. Ed. C. A. Behr. Leiden 1986.
3. Publius Aelius Aristides, The Complete Works, Vol. II. Orations XVII– LIII. Ed. C. A. Behr. Leiden 1981.
4. Athen. Deipn. (= Athenaios, Deipnosophistae/Δειπνοσοφιστών) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviri: Athenaei Naucratitae deipnosophistarum libri XV. Ed. G. Kaibel. Leipzig 1890.
5. Cic. Off. (= Marcus Tullius Cicero, De Officiis) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviri: M. Tullius Cicero, De Officiis. Ed. Walter Miller. Cambridge 1913.
6. Dio (= Dion Khrysostomos, Orationes) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviri: Dionis Prusaensis quem vocant Chrysostomum quae exstant omnia. Vol I-II. Ed. J. Arnim. Berlin 1962.
7. Epikt. (= Epiktetos, Dissertationes ab Arriano digestae) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Epicteti dissertationes ab Arriano digestae. Ed. H. Schenkl. Leipzig 1916.
8. Epictetus, The Discourses as Reported by Arrian, the Manual and Fragments. Ed. W. A. Oldfather. London 1956 (The Loeb Classical Library).

9. Gal. Med (= Galenos, De libris propriis liber) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviri: Claudii Galeni Pergameni Scripta Minora. Ed. J. Marquardt – G. Helmreich. Leipzig 1891.
10. Paus. (= Pausanias, Graeciae descriptio/Ἑλλάδος Περιηγήσεως) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Pausaniae Graeciae descriptio. Vol. III. Ed. F. Spiro. Stuttgart 1967.
11. Pausanias, Description of Greece. Vol. I, Book I-II. Ed. W. H. S. Jones. London 1918 (The Loeb Classical Library).
12. Philostr. VS (= Philostratos, Vitae Sophistarum/βίοι σοφιστῶν) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Philostratos, Vitae sophistarum. Ed. C. L. Kayser. Leipzig 1871.
13. Philostratus – Eunapius, Lives of the Sophists. Ed. W. C. Wright. Cambridge 1961.
14. Plut. Alc. (= Plutarkhos, Vitae Parallelae/βίοι παράλληλοι/Alcibiades) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Plutarkhos, Plutarchi vitae parallelae. Ed. K. Ziegler. Leipzig 1964.
15. Plutarkhos, The Parallel Lives. Vol. IV. Ed. B. Perrin. London - New York 1959 (The Loeb Classical Library).
16. Strab. (= Strabon, Geographica/Γεωγραφικά) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviriler: Strabonis Geographica. Ed. A. Meineke.
17. Leipzig 1877.The Geography of Strabo. Vols. I-VIII. Ed. H. L. Jones. London - New York 1917-1932 (The Loeb Classical Library).
18. Tac. Ann. (= Publius Cornelius Tacitus, Annales) Kullanılan Metin ve Çeviri: Publius Cornelius Tacitus, The Annals. Ed. J. Jackson. London - New York 1931–1937.
19. Agelidis 2014 S. Agelidis, “Pergamon’da Tanrılar ve Kutsal Alanlar”. Eds. F. Pirson – A. Scholl, Anadolu’da Hellenistik Bir Başkent: Pergamon. İstanbul (2014) 380- 401.
20. Agora XV B. D. Meritt – J. Traill, The Athenian Councillors, The Athenian Agora 15. Princeton 1974.
21. Akgün 2013 E. Akgün, “II. Sofistik Dönem: Yunan Kültürünün Yeniden Canlanışı”. Eds. A. V. Çelgin – N. E. Akyürek-Şahin, Akron 7: Eskiçağ Yazıları 5. İstanbul (2013) 49-73.
22. Akgün-Kaya 2015 E. Akgün Kaya, “Philostratos: Sofist ve Biyografi Yazarı”. Eds. A. V. Çelgin – N. E. Akyürek Şahin, Akron 9: Eskiçağ Araştırmaları 7. İstanbul (2015) 251-270.
23. Akgün-Kaya 2016 E. Akgün Kaya, Anadolu’da II. Sofistik Dönem: Sofist, Retor ve Filozofların Kamusal Alandaki Etkinlikleri. Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi, Akdeniz Üniversitesi. Antalya 2016.
24. Akurgal 1969 E. Akurgal, Ancient Civilizations and Ruins of Turkey: From Prehistoric Times Until the End of the Roman Empire. İstanbul 1969.
25. Anderson 1913 J. G. C. Anderson, “Festivals of Men Askaenos in the Roman Colonia at Antioch of Pisidia”. JRS 3 (1913) 267-300.
26. Anderson 1986 G. Anderson, Philostratus: Biography and Belles – Letters in the Third Century A.D. London, Dover-New Hampshire 1989.
27. Anderson 1993 G. Anderson, The Second Sophistic: A Cultural Phenomenon in the Roma Empire. London 1993.
28. Andreou 2000 V. Andreou, “Remarques sur l’histoire des classes dirigeantes de Milet”. Ed. L. Mooren, Politics, Administration and Society in the Hellenistic and Roman World. Proceedings of the International Colloquium, Bertinoro 19- 24 July 1997. Belgium- USA (2000) 1-13.
29. Aneziri 2003 S. Aneziri, Die Vereine der dionysischen Techniten im Kontext der hellenistischen Gesellschaft: Untersuchungen zur Geschichte, Organisation und Wirkung der hellenistischen Technitenvereine. Stuttgart 2003.
30. Arslan 2007 M. Arslan, Mithradates VI Eupator: Romanın Büyük Düşmanı. İstanbul 2007.
31. Avotins 1975 I. Avotins, “The Holders of the Chairs of Rhetoric at Athens”. HSPh 79 (1975) 313-324.
32. Baz 1998 F. Baz, Roma İmparatorluk Kültü. Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Marmara Üniversitesi. İstanbul 1998.
33. Baz 2008 F. Baz, “M.S. I.-II. Yüzyıllarda Side Antik Kentine Neokoros Unvanı Verilip Verilmediği Meselesine İlişkin Düşünceler”. Eds. H. Alan, A. Kara – O. Yorulmaz, İslam Öncesinden Çağdaş Türk Dünyasına Prof. Dr. Gülçin Çandarlıoğlu’na Armağan. İstanbul (2008) 139-152.
34. Bosch 1967 E. Bosch, Quellen zur Geschichte der Stadt Ankara im Altertum. Ankara 1967.
35. Bowersock 1965 G. W. Bowersock, Augustus and the Greek World. Oxford 1965.
36. Bowersock 1969 G. W. Bowersock, Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire. Oxford 1969.
37. Bowie 1970 E. L. Bowie, “Greeks and their past in the Second Sophistic”. Past & Present 46 (1970) 3-41.
38. Bowie 2009 E. Bowie, “Philostratus. The Life of a Sophist”. Eds. E. Bowie – J. Elsner, Philostratus. Cambridge (2009) 19-33.
39. Brody 2001 L. R. Brody, “The Cult of Aphrodite at Aphrodisias in Caria”. Kernos 14 (2001) 93-109.
40. Buechner 1888 W. Buechner, De Neocoria. Wisconsin-Madison (1888).
41. Burrell 2004 B. Burrell, Neokoroi: Greek cities and Roman Emperors. Leiden 2004.
42. Bussières 2014 D. Bussières, Les associations de technites dionysiaques et l'organisation des concours à l'époque hellénistique. Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Laval Üniversitesi. Québec 2014.
43. Büyükgün 2006 B. Büyükgün, Men Kültüyle İlgili Eskişehir, Afyon, Kütahya ve Pamukkale Arkeoloji Müzelerinde Bulunan Bazı Taş Eserler. Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Anadolu Üniversitesi. Eskişehir 2006.
44. Campanile 1994 M. D. Campanile, Sacerdoti del koinon d’Asia. (I sec. a.C-III. sec. d.C) Contributo allo studio della romanizzazione delle élites provinciali nell 'Oriente Greco. Pisa 1994.
45. Carter 2004 M. Carter, “Archiereis and Asiarchs: A Gladiatorial Perspective”. GRBS 44 (2004) 41-68.
46. Chaniotis 2010 A. Chaniotis, “Aphrodite’s Rivals: Devotion to Local and other Gods at Aphrodisias”. Cahiers Glotz 21 (2010) 235-248
47. CIG Corpus inscriptionum graecarum.
48. CIL Corpus inscriptionum latinarum
49. Clinton 1974 K. Clinton, “The Sacred Officials of the Eleusinian Mysteries”. TAPhSNew Series 64/3 (1974) 1-143.
50. Connolly 1987 A. I. Connolly, “Giving thanks to Artemis”. Ed. G. H. R. Horsley, New Documents Illustrating Early Christianity, 4: A Review of Greek Inscriptions and Papyri Published in 1979. Australia (1987) 127-129.
51. Cousin – Diehl 1886 G. Cousin – C. Diehl, “Inscriptions d'Alabanda en Carie”. BCH 10 (1886) 299-314.
52. Cumont 1933 F. Cumont, “La Grande Inscription Bachique du Metropolitan Museum. II. Commentaire Religieux de l'Inscription”. AJA 37/2 (1933) 232-263.
53. Çevik et al. 2010 N. Çevik, İ. Kızgut – S. Bulut, “Rhodiapolis as a Unique Example of Lycian Urbanism”. Adalya XIII (2010) 29-63.
54. Dillon 2002 M. Dillon, Girls and Women in Classical Greek Religion. London – New York 2002.
55. Dmitriev 2005 S. Dmitriev, City Government in Hellenistic and Roman Asia Minor. Oxford 2005.
56. Edelstein – Edelstein 1998 E. J. Edelstein – L. Edelstein, Asclepius: Collection and Interpretation of the Testimonies I-II. London 1998.
57. Erzen 1953 A. Erzen, “Ay Tanrısı Men’in Adı ve Mensei Hakkında”. Belleten XVII/65 (1953) 1-14.
58. Eshleman 2012 K. Eshleman, The Social World of Intellectuals in the Roman Empire: Sophists, Philosophers, and Christians. Cambridge 2012.
59. Foley 1993 H. P. Foley, The Homeric Hymn to Demeter Translation, Commentary and Interpritive Essays. New Jersey 1993.
60. Fontenrose 1988 J. E. Fontenrose, Didyma: Apollo's Oracle, Cult, and Companions. London 1988.
61. Frei 1990 P. Frei, “Die Götterkulte Lykiens in der Kaiserzeit”. ANRW II 18/3 (1990) 1729-1864.
62. Friesen 1993 S. J. Friesen, Twice Neokoros, Ephesus, Asia and the Cult of the Flavian Imperial Family. Leiden-New York-Köln 1993.
63. Gleason 1995 M. W. Gleason, Making Men, Sophists and Self-Presentation in Ancient Rome. Princeton 1995.
64. Goldhill 2001 S. Goldhill, Being Greek under Rome, Cultural Identity, the Second Sophistic and the Development of Empire. Cambridge 2001.
65. Göktürk 2000 M. T. Göktürk, “Nümizmatik, Dionysos Kültü ve Şarap Kültürü”. Anadolu Medeniyetleri Müzesi 1999 Yıllığı (2000) 129-153.
66. Guen 2001 B. Le Guen, Les Associations de Technites Dionysiaques à l’Époque Hellénistique I, Corpus Documentaire. Paris 2001.
67. Gürdal 2007 T. Gürdal, Anadolu'da Apollon Kültü. Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi, Ankara Üniversitesi, Ankara 2007.
68. Haake 2008 M. Haake, “Philosopher and Priest: The Image of the Intellectual and the Social Practice of the Elites in the Eastern Roman Empire”. Eds. B. Dignas – K. Trampedach, Practitioners of the Divine: Greek Priests and Religious Officials from Homer to Heliodorus. Harvard University (2008) 145-165.
69. Harrison 2012 J. R. Harrison, “A “worthy” neopoios thanks Artemis”. Eds. S. R. Llewelyn, James R Harrison, E. J. Bridge, A Review of the Greek and Other Inscriptions and Papyri Published between 1988 and 1992, New Documents Illustrating Early Christianity. Vol. 10. Australia-USA (2012) 48-54.
70. Hazlitt 1851 W. Hazlitt, The Classical Gazetteer: A Dictionary of Ancient Geography. London 1851.
71. Head 1897 B. V. Head, British Museum Catalogue of Greek Coins of Caria and Islands. London 1897.
72. Heath 1996 M. Heath, “The Family of Minucianus”. ZPE 113 (1996) 66-70.
73. Herda 2006 A. Herda, Der Apollon-Delphinios-Kult in Milet und die Neujahrsprozession nach Didyma: Ein neuer Kommentar der sog. Molpoi-Satzung. Mainz am Rhein 2006.
74. Hoff 2011 R. von den Hoff, “New Research in Aizanoi 2007–2009”. Ed. A. N. Bilgen, Archaeological research in Western Central Anatolia. The IIIrd International Symposium of Archaeology. Kütahya 8-9 March 2010. Kütahya (2011) 122-139.
75. I. Aphrodisias D. F. McCabe, Aphrodisias Inscriptions. Princeton 1991.
76. I. Asklepieion C. Habicht, Altertümer von Pergamon: Die Inschriften des Asklepieions, 8/3. Berlin 1969.
77. I. Didyma D. F. McCabe, Didyma Inscriptions. Princeton 1985.
78. I. Eleusis K. Clinton, Eleusis: The Inscriptions on Stone. Athens 2005-2008.
79. I. Ephesos D. F. McCabe, Ephesos Inscriptions. Princeton 1991.
80. I. Pergamon I M. Fränkel, Altertümer von Pergamon: Die Inschriften von Pergamon, 8/1- 2. Vol. 1, nos. 1-250. Berlin 1890-1895.
81. I. Pergamon II M. Fränkel, Altertümer von Pergamon: Die Inschriften von Pergamon, 8/1- 2. Vol. 2, nos. 251-1334. Berlin 1890-1895.
82. I. Perge S. Şahin, Die Inschriften von Perge. Bonn 1999.
83. I. Sardis W. H. Buckler – D. M. Robinson, Sardis, VII. Greek and Latin Inscriptions, Part I. Leiden 1932.
84. I. Smyrna II G. Petzl, Die Inschriften von SmyrnaII/1. Bonn 1987.
85. IG Inscriptiones Graecae.
86. IGR Inscriptiones Graecae ad res Romanas pertinentes.
87. Janiszewski et al. 2015 P. Janiszewski, K. Stebnicka – E. Szabat, Prosopography of Greek Rhetors and Sophists of the Roman Empire. Oxford 2015.
88. Johnson 1943 A. C. Johnson, “Review”. AJA 47/2 (1943) 256-257.
89. Jones 1966 A. H. M. Jones, The Greek City from Alexander to Justinianus. Oxford 1966.
90. Jones 1980 C. P. Jones, “Prosopographical Notes on the Second Sophistic”. GRBS 21 (1980) 373-380.
91. Jones 1983 C. P. Jones, “Diotrephes of Antioch”. Chiron 13 (1983) 369-80.
92. Jones 1990a C. P. Jones, “A new Lycian dossier establishing an artistic contest and festivals in the reign of Hadrian”. JRA 3 (1990) 484-488.
93. Jones 1990b C. P. Jones, “Heracles at Smyrna”. AJN2 (1990) 65-76.
94. Kerényi 1967 K. Kerényi, Eleusis: Archetypal Image of Mother and Daughter. London 1967.
95. Klöckner 2012 A. Klöckner, “Tradition – Repräsentation – Distinktion. Eine Fallstudie zu Reliefweihungen Von Priestern im späthellenistischen und römischen Attika”. Eds. M. Horster – A. Klöckner, Civic Priests: Cult Personnel in Athens from the Hellenistic Period to Late Antiquity. Berlin - Boson (2012) 27-66.
96. König 2005 J. König, Athletics and Literature in the Roman Empire. Cambridge 2005.
97. Kuhn 2014 A. B. Kuhn, “The chrysophoria in the Cities of Greece and Asia Minor in the Hellenistic and Roman Periods”. Tyche 29 (2014) 51-87.
98. Landfester 2007 M. Landfester, “Philostratos”. DNP Supplement 2 (2007) 460-463.
99. Lane 1964 E. N. Lane, “A Re-Study of the God Men, Part 1: The Epigraphic and Scuptural Evidence”. Berytus 15 (1964) 5-58.
100. Lane 1971 E. N. Lane, Corpus Monumentorum Religionis Dei Menis I: The Monuments and Inscriptions. Leiden 1971.
101. Lane 1975 E. N. Lane, Corpus Monumentorum Religionis Dei Menis II: The Coins and Gems. Leiden 1975.
102. Lane 1976 E. N. Lane, Corpus Monumentorum Religionis Dei Menis III: Interpretations and Testimonia. Leiden 1976.
103. Lane 1978 E. N. Lane, Corpus Monumentorum Religionis Dei Menis IV: Suplementary Men Inscriptions from Pisidia. Leiden 1978.
104. Lüders 1873 O. Lüders, Die Dionysischen Künstler. Berlin 1873.
105. Magie 1950 D. Magie, Roman Rule in Asia Minor. Princeton 1950.
106. Maischberger 2014 M. Maischberger, “Tiyatro Kompleksi ve Dionysos Tapınağı”. Eds. F. Pirson – A. Scholl, Anadolu’da Hellenistik Bir Başkent: Pergamon. İstanbul (2014) 288-299.
107. Malay 2005 H. Malay, “Anadolu’da Antik Dönem’de İnanç İstismarı: İtiraf Yazıları”. Toplumsal Tarih 13 (2005) 52-59.
108. MAMA Monumenta Asiae Minoris Antiqua. MDAI (A) Mitteilungen des deutschen archäologischen Instituts. Athenische Abteilung Berlin.
109. Mellor 1975 R. Mellor, ΘΕΑ ΡΩΜΝ: The Worship of the Goddess Roma in the Greek World. Göttingen 1975.
110. Mellor 1981 R. Mellor, “The Goddess Roma”. ANRW II. 17/2 (1981) 950-1030. Merkelbach 1985 R. Merkelbach, “Eine Inschrift des Weltverbandes der Dionysischien Technitai”. ZPE 58 (1979) 136-138.
111. Merkelbach 1988 M. Merkelbach, Die Hirten des Dionysos: Die Dionysos-Mysterien der römischen Kaiserzeit und der bukolische Roman des Longus. Stuttgart 1988.
112. Merker 2000 G. S. Merker, The Sanctuary of Demeter and Kore: Terracotta Figurines of the Classical, Hellenistic, and Roman Periods. Princeton-New Jersey 2000.
113. Meyer 1987 M. W. Meyer, The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook of Sacred Texts. Philadelphia 1987.
114. Müller 1989 H. Müller, “Ein neues hellenistisches Weihepigramm aus Pergamon”. Chiron 19 (1989) 499-553.
115. Nilsson 1957 M. P. Nilsson, The Dionysiac Mysteries of the Hellenistic and Roman Age. New York 1957.
116. O'Brien-Moore 1942 A. O’Brien-Moore, “M. Tullius Cratippus, Priest of Rome”. YClS 8 (1942) 23-50.
117. Ohlemutz 1940 E. Ohlemutz, Die Kulte und Heiligtümer der Götter in Pergamon. Würzburg 1940.
118. Oliver 1950 J. H. Oliver, The Athenian Expounders of the Sacred and Ancestral Law. Baltimore 1950.
119. Oliver 1967 J. H. Oliver, “The Sacred Gerusia and the Emperor’s Consilium”. Hesperia 36 (1967) 329-335
120. Oliver 1970 J. H. Oliver, Marcus Aurelius: Aspects of Civic and Cultural Policy in the East. Princeton 1970.
121. Otto 1965 W. F. Otto, Dionysus: Myth and Cult. Bloomington-London 1965.
122. Özlem-Aytaçlar 2006 P. Özlem Aytaçlar, Yazıtlar ve Antik Kaynaklar Işığında Batı Anadolu’da Entelektüeller. İstanbul 2006.
123. Öztürk 2010 B. Öztürk, Roma İmparatorluk Çağı Küçükasyası’nda Dionysos Kültü. İstanbul 2010.
124. Paz de Hoz 1999 M. Paz de Hoz, Die lydischen Kulte im Lichte der griechischen Inschrifte. Bonn 1999.
125. Petzl – Schwertheim 2006 G. Petzl – E. Schwertheim, Hadrian und die dionysischen Künstler. Drei in Alexandria Troas neugefundene Briefe des Kaisers an die Künstler – Vereinigung. Bonn 2006.
126. PIR Prosopographia Imperii Romani. Price 1984 S. R. F. Price, Rituals and Power: The Roman Imperial Cult in Asia Minor. Cambridge 1984.
127. Puech 2002 B. Puech, Orateurs et Sophistes Grecs Dans Les Inscriptions D’époque Impériale. Paris 2002.
128. Quant 1912 G. Quant, De Baccho ab Alexandri aetate in Asia Minore culto. Halenses 1912.
129. Radt 1999 W. Radt, Pergamon: Geschichte und Bauten einer antiken Metropole. Darmstadt 1999.
130. Ramsay 1916 W. M. Ramsay, “Colonia Caesarea (Pisidian Antioch) in the Augustan Age”. JRS VI (1916) 83-134.
131. Rehm 1958 R. Rehm, Didyma II: Die Inschriften. Berlin 1958.
132. Reynolds 1981 J. Reynolds, “New Evidence for Imperial Cult in Julio – Claudian Aphrodisias”. ZPE 43 (1981) 317-327.
133. Reynolds 1982 J. Reynolds, Aphrodisias and Rome: Documents from the Excavation of the Theatre at Aphrodisias Conducted by Kenan T. Erim, together with some related texts. London 1982.
134. Reynolds 1991 J. Reynolds, “Epigraphic Evidence for the Construction of the Theatre: 1st c. B.C. to mid. 3rd c. A.D.”. Eds. R. R. R. Smith – K. T. Erim, Aphrodisias Papers 2: The Theatre, a Sculptor’s Workshop, Philosophers, and Cointypes. Ann Arbor (1991) 15-28.
135. Rigsby 1996 K. J. Rigsby, Asylia: Territorial Inviolability in the Hellenistic World. Los Angeles-London 1996.
136. Robert – Robert 1954 J. Robert – L. Robert, La Carie II: Histoire et géographie historique avec le recueil des inscriptions antiques. Tome II. Paris 1954.
137. Robert – Robert 1971 J. Robert – L. Robert, Bulletin épigraphique. Revue des Études Grecques.
138. Tome 84/401-403 (1971) 397-540.
139. Robert 1960 L. Robert, “Inscriptions de Didymes et de Milet”. Hellenica XI/XII (1960) 449-489.
140. Robert 1966 L. Robert, “Inscriptions d’Aphrodisias”. Antiquité Classique 36/2 (1966) 377-432.
141. Robert 1969 L. Robert, Laodicée du Lycos: Le Nymphée, Campagnes (1961-1963). Paris 1969.
142. Rogers – Peppler 1944 R. S. Rogers – C. W. Peppler, “Review: Yale Classical Studies by Austin M. Harmon and Alfred R. Bellinger”. AJPh 65/3 (1944) 287-289.
143. Roueché 1993 C. Roueché, Performers and Partisans at Aphrodisias in the Roman and Late Roman Periods. London 1993.
144. Sandy 1997 G. Sandy, The Greek World Of Apuleius and The Second Sophistic. LeidenNew York-Köln 1997.
145. Sarıkaya 2012 S. Sarıkaya, “Asylia: Tarihsel Gelişimi”. Eds. A. V. Çelgin – N. E. Akyürek Şahin, Akron 2: Eskiçağ Yazıları 2. İstanbul (2012) 67-91.
146. Schissel 1926 O. Schissel, “Die Familie des Minukianos”. Klio 21 (1926) 361-373.
147. Schulthess 1935 O. Schulthess, “Neopoioi”. RE XVI (1935) 2433-2439.
148. Schwandner 1990 E.-L. Schwandner, “Beobachtungen zur hellenistischen Tempelarchitektur in Pergamon”. Eds. W. Hoepfner – E.-L. Schwandner, Hermogenes und die hochhellenistische Architektur. Mainz am Rhein (1990) 80-102.
149. Schwarzer 2014 H. Schwarzer, “Attaloslar ve Hükümdar Kültü”. Eds. F. Pirson –A. Scholl, Anadolu’da Hellenistik Bir Başkent: Pergamon. İstanbul (2014) 404-419.
150. SEG Supplementum Epigraphicum Graecum.
151. Sheppard 1981 A. R. R. Sheppard, “R.E.C.A.M. Notes and Studies No. 7: Inscriptions from Ușak, Denizli and Hisar Köy”. AS 3 (1981) 19-27.
152. Sherk 1988 R. Sherk, The Roman Empire: Augustus to Hadrian. Cambridge 1998.
153. SIG Sylloge Inscriptionum Graecarum.
154. Smith 1993 M. F. Smith, The Epicurean Inscription, Diogenes of Oinoanda. Napoli 1993.
155. Sokolowski 1973 F. Sokolowski, “On the New Pergamene Lex Sacra”. GRBS 14 (1973) 407- 413.
156. Sokolowski 1979 F. Sokolowski, “Τὰ ἔνπυρα: On the Mysteries in the Lydian and Phrygian Cults”. ZPE 34 (1979) 65-69.
157. Solmsen 1940 F. Solmsen, “Some Works of Philostratos the Elder”. TAPhA 71 (1940) 556-572.
158. Stebnicka 2006 K. Stebnicka, “Die Münzen der Sophisten und Rhetoren aus der Zeit der zweiten Sophistik”. Palamedes 1 (2000) 167-184.
159. Stevenson 2001 G. Stevenson, Power and Place: Temple and Identity in the Book of Revelation. Berlin-New York 2001.
160. Swain 1996 S. Swain, Hellenism and Empire: Language, Classicism, and Power in the Greek World AD 50–250. Oxford 1996.
161. Şahin 2015 S. Şahin, “Lykiarkes Sorunu”. Eds. A. V. Çelgin – N. E. Akyürek-Şahin, Akron 10: Eskiçağ Yazıları 8. İstanbul (2015) 1-26.
162. TAM Tituli Asiae Minoris.
163. Todd 1944 O. J. Todd, “Review”. CPh 39/1 (1944) 61-63.
164. Türkan 2012 A. Türkan, “Men, Mensis, Moon/Ay Tanrı Men, Özellikleri ve Kültü”. Eds. A. Sina – T. Yiğit, Ömer Çapar’a Armağan. Ankara (2012) 333-348.
165. Whitmarsh 2005 T. Whitmarsh, The Second Sophistic. Oxford 2005.
166. Wickkiser 2008 B. L. Wickkiser, Asklepios, Medicine, and the Politics of Healing in FifthCentury Greece. Baltimore 2008.
167. Wörrle 1990 M. Wörrle, “Inschriften von Herakleia am Latmos II. Das Priestertum der Athena Latmia”. Chiron 20 (1990) 19-58.
168. Yurtsever 2015 A. Yurtsever, “Neokoros Düşüncesinin Kökeni ve Gelişimi: Tanrı, Kutsal Krallık ve Yönetici İlişkisi”. AUSBD15/2 (2015) 1-16.