Kültürel Irkçılık Bağlamında İslamofobi ve Antisemitizm İlişkisi

Yıl 2023, Cilt: 23 Sayı: 2, 499 - 522, 30.09.2023

Merve Ar

https://doi.org/10.33415/daad.1308798

Öz

Irkçılık, nefret, soykırım, yabancı düşmanlığı gibi tüm ayrımcılık biçimlerini içine alan tarihsel aşamalar “ötekileştirme” ile başlar. Tarih boyunca “öteki” üzerinden yükselme ve kimlik inşası oluşturma çabasında olan Batı medeniyeti Avrupa’nın özünü oluşturan değerler üzerinden, kendinden olmayan kültürlere “öteki” muamelesi yapmaktadır. Bu açıdan Batı medeniyetinin çok kültürlülüğü ve kendinden olmayanları ötekileştiren monolitik yapısı genelde yabancı düşmanlığına, özelde ise İslamofobiye sebep olmaktadır. İslamofobi kavramı tarihî, teolojik ve siyasi temelleri asla göz ardı edilmemekle birlikte özellikle ırkçılık ve kültürel ırkçılık bağlamında da yeniden değerlendirilmesi gereken bir kavram olarak karşımızda durmaktadır.
Bu çalışmamızda Müslümanların hem ötekileştirilmesi hem de şiddet ve terörle bağdaştırılmasının gerekçelerinden biri olarak gördüğümüz ırk ve ırkçılık anlayışı ve bu anlayışın en somut ürünü olan zenofobik tutum ve İslamofobinin ırkçılığın yeni bir kolu olan kültürel ırkçılık bağlamında değerlendirilip değerlendirilmeyeceği meselesi tartışılmıştır. Bununla birlikte bu öteki anlayışında zaman zaman Müslümanlar ile Yahudiler arasında kurulmaya çalışan bir ilişki söz konusu olduğu için son zamanlarda “İslamofobi yeni antisemitizm” midir sorusu gündeme getirilmektedir. Biz de çalışmamızın ilerleyen kısımlarında İslamofobi ve antisemitizm kavramlarının aynı düzlemde değerlendirilip değerlendirilemeyeceği meselesini müzakere ettik ve bu benzerliğin pratikte stratejik bir karşılığı olabilir mi sorusuna cevap aradık.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Dinler Tarihi, Irkçılık, Kültürel Irkçılık, Zenofobi, İslamofobi, Antisemitizm.

The Relationship Between Islamophobia and Antisemitism In The Context of Cultural Racism

Öz

Especially when it comes to concepts in the humanities, it is often necessary to go beyond the obvious. Because images are much more than meanings. Ideas gain repeatedly meaning with each cultural and historical experience that includes definition. Therefore, attention should be paid to the period in which the constructed concepts were created and under what conditions they became widespread. Racism, a key idea in daily discourse and sociological theory over the last fifty years, also implies a heavily negative moral and political connotation.
The process that prioritizes all forms of discrimination, such as racism, hatred, genocide, and xenophobia, begins with “othering.” Western civilization, which has been trying to strengthen and build identity through the "other" throughout history, treats cultures that are not itself as the "other" through the values that make up the essence of Europe. In this sense, the multiculturalism of Western civilization and its monotypic structure that excludes those who are not from it causes xenophobia in general and Islamophobia in particular. Historically, the term Islamophobia, which became very popular after the Twin Tower attacks on September 11, 2001, is new in terms of conceptualization. Still, the cultural, historical, and theological prejudices behind the term have a long history. For a certain period, a connection could not be established between racism and Islamophobia, which is rapidly increasing in the Western world since it is generally considered on a biological and racial basis in the classical sense. Whereas xenophobia is closely linked to racism, the newer/cultural features of racism perpetuate this hostility. In many cases, it is difficult to distinguish between racism and xenophobia as motivations for behavior. In this study, we have tried to address the concept of Islamophobia as a concept that should be re-evaluated, especially in the context of racism and cultural racism, while never ignoring the concept's historical, theological, and political foundations.
In our study, we also discussed the understanding of race and racism, which we see as one of the essential reasons for the marginalization of Muslims and their association with violence and terrorism, and the most concrete product of this understanding, xenophobic attitude and whether to evaluate Islamophobia in the context of cultural racism, a new branch of racism. However, in this understanding of the other, there is a relationship that tries to be established between Muslims and Jews from time to time. These contents have also spawned a debate on the possibilities and limitations of comparative approaches and analogies regarding the relationship between antisemitism and Islamophobia in public and academic debates. In this discussion, scientists from various fields started research to compare antisemitism and Islamophobia and reveal the similarities and differences between the two and raise multiple questions. For example, with the increasing fear/anti-Islam, hatred, and racism tendency in the Western world, especially in the Middle Ages and XX. How can a connection be established between the antisemitism experienced in the 21st century? Or, in other words, can Muslims today be seen as the new Jews of Europe? Therefore, one of the issues we discussed in the text is whether a similarity can be established between the discrimination Muslims face today and the anti-Semitism experienced, especially in the Middle Ages and its immediate aftermath.
Especially recently, there have been studies that evaluate Islamophobia individually in the context of cultural racism, both in the public and in the academic community. However, studies that evaluate Islamophobia and antisemitism together and deal with it in the context of cultural racism are relatively few. When we look at the discussions on the similarities and differences between the concepts of Islamophobia and antisemitism, some historical, theological, and conceptual explanations have been developed. As we have emphasized before, the images of "other understanding" and "racism" are placed in the axis of the debate. In general, most determinations that focus on hostility towards Jews and Muslims take shape on the axis of cultural racism. In the discussions held in this framework, the cultural differences of Muslims and Jews are brought to the fore, and the issue of foreignness to shared values is discussed. In the last part of our study, we examined whether Islamophobia and antisemitism could be evaluated on the same level. We tried to answer whether this similarity could have a strategic counterpart in practice.

Anahtar Kelimeler

History of Religions, Race, Racism, Cultural Racism, Xenophobia, Islamophobia, Antisemitism

.

Öz

The process that prioritizes all forms of discrimination such as racism, hatred, genocide and xenophobia begins with “othering”. Western civilization, which has been trying to strengthen and build identity through the "other" throughout history, treats cultures that are not itself as the "other" through the values that make up the essence of Europe. In this sense, the multiculturalism of Western civilization and its monotypic structure that excludes those who are not from it causes xenophobia in general and Islamophobia in particular. In this understanding of the other, there is a relationship that tries to be established between Muslims and Jews from time to time. From this point of view, in our study, we will focus on the question of whether we can explain Islamophobia with the concept of racism or cultural racism by first discussing the basic concepts of racism. In addition, we will also discuss whether the concepts of Islamophobia and antisemitism can be evaluated on the same level, especially in the context of racism.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Dinler Tarihi, Irkçılık, Kültürel Irkçılık, Zenofobi, İslamofobi, Antisemitizm

Kaynakça

• Ahmed, Nazir. “Islamophobia and Antisemitism.” European Judaism: A Journal for the New Europe 37/ 1 (2004), 124-127.
• Allen, Chris. “Justifying Islamophobia: A post-9/11 Consideration of the European Union and British Context”. American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 21/3,(2004), 1-25.
• Balibar, Etinne – Wallerstein, Immanuel. Irk Ulus Sınıf: Belirsiz Kimlikler. çev. Nazlı Ökten. İstanbul: Metis Yayınları, 2000.
• Barın, Hilal. İslamofobi ve DAEŞ. İstanbul: Tezkire Yayıncılık, 2016.
• Bayraklı, Enes-Güngörmez, Oğuz. “İslamofobi ve Anti-Semitizm Karşılaştırmalarını Anlamlandırmak: Kapsamlı Bir Literatür Değerlendirmesi”. Muhafazakâr Düşünce 53/1 (2018), 119-148.
• Beçene, Maruf ed. “Zenofobi Nedir?, Belirtileri Nelerdir?”, (01.06.2012) http://www.aktuelpsikoloji.com/zenofobi-nedir-belirtileri-nelerdir-11590h.htm
• Berezin, Mabel. ” Xenophobia and the New Nationalisms,” The Sage Handbook of Nations and Nationalism, Gerard Delanty and Krishna Kumar. ed. London: Sage Publications, 2006.
• Budak, Selçuk. Psikoloji Sözlüğü. Ankara: Bilim ve Sanat Yayınları, 2009.
• Canatan, Kadir. “İslamofobi ve Anti-İslamizm: Kavramsal ve Tarihsel Yaklaşım”. Batı Dünyasında İslamofobi ve Anti-İslamizm. ed. Kadir Canatan- Özcan Hıdır. Ankara: Eski Yeni Yayınları, 2007.
• Crush, Jonathan – Ramachandran. Sujata “Xenophobia, International Migration, and Human Development”. Human Development Research Paper, 47 (2009).
• Çakaş, Caner Övsan. “Avrupa Toplumunda Irkçılığın İki Yüzü: Antisemitizm ve İslamofobi Arasındaki Benzerliklerin ve Farklılıkların Karşılaştırmalı Analizi”. Akademik İzdüşüm Dergisi, 4/2 (2019), 222-252.
• Dobkowski, Michael. “Islamophobia and Anti-Semitism”. Cross Currents 65/3(2015), 321-333.
• Ertaş, Suphi. İslamofobi. İstanbul: Cinius Yayınları, 2017.
• Fekete, Liz. A Suitable Enemy: Racism, Migration and Islamophobia in Europe.New York: Pluto Press, 2009.
• Frederickson G.M. Race: The History of an Idea. Princedon and Oxford: Princetton University Press, 2002.
• Funke, Hajo. “Europe at the Threshold: Fairness or Fortress? Racism, Public Policy and Antiracist Concepts”. United Nations Institute for Social Development, Conference Paper, Durban, South Africa, 3-5 September (2001).
• Geisser, Vincent. İslamofobi. İzmir: Mavi Ufuklar Yayınları, 2010.
• Göknel, Ergun. Öteki’den Düşman’a. İstanbul: Kanes Yayınları, 2015.
• Gürkan, Salime Leyla. Yahudilik. İstanbul: İsam Yayınları, 2008.
• Hafez, Farid. “Comparing anti-Semitism and Islamophobia: The state of the field.” Islamophobia Studies Journal 3/ 2 (2016), 16-34.
• Hıdır, Özcan. "İslamofobi-Irkçılık- “Kültürel Irkçılık” İlişkisi". Ombudsman Akademik / 7 (Aralık 2017), 23-49.
• Jacquard, Albert. The Genetic Structure of Populations.Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1974
• Kalmar, Ivan. “İslamofobi Yeni Antisemitizm midir”. Analiz, Seta, 233 (Nisan 2018)
• Keneş, Hatice Çoban. “İdeolojik Bir İnşa Olarak Yeni Irkçılık: Günümüz Irkçılığını Tartışmak, Anlamak, Adlandırmak”. Ayrımcılığın Yüzleri. Ülkü Doğanay der. (2018) http://www.ihop.org.tr/wp- content/uploads/2018/10/Ayrimcilik_yuzleri.pdf, (15.06.2019).
• Lean, Nathan. The Islamophobia Industry: How The Right Manufactures Fear of Muslims. London: Pluto Press, 2012.
• Lewis, Bernard.“The New Anti-Semitism.” The American Scholar 75/1 (2006), 25-36.
• Maira, Sunaina. “İslamofobi ve Teröre Karşı Savaş: Gençlik, Vatandaşlık ve Uyuşmazlık”. İslamofobi: 21.Yüzyılda Çoğulculuk Sorunu. ed. John L. Esposito - İbrahim Kalın. çev. İsmail Eriş. İstanbul: İnsan Yayınları, 2015.
• Meer, Nasar. “Semantics, scales and solidarities in the study of antisemitism and Islamophobia”. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 36/ 3 (2013), 500-515.
• Memni, Albert. Racism. London: Minesota University Press, 2000.
• Miles, Robert – Brown, Malcolm. Racism. New York: Routledge, 1989.
• Miles, Robert. Racism After ‘Race Relations. London and New York: Routledge, 2001.
• Okumuş, Ejder. “ABD’de İslamofobi ve Anti-İslamizm: 11 Eylül Öncesi ve Sonrası”. Batı Dünyasında İslamofobi ve Anti-İslamizm. ed. Kadir Canatan ve Özcan Hıdır. Ankara: Eski Yeni Yayınları, 2007.
• Olgun, Hakan. “Tarihsel Bir Kurgu Ürünü Olarak İslamofobya”. Diyanet İlmi Dergi. 44/3 (2008), 32.
• Reisigl, Martin – Wodak, Ruth. Discourse and Discrimination: Rhetoric of Racism and Antisemitism. London: Routledge, 2001.
• Renton James – Gindley, Ben. ed. Antisemitism and Islamophobia in Europe; A Shared Story. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017.
• Salaita, Steven. Anti-Arab Racism in the USA: Where it Comes From and What it Means for Politics Today. London: Pluto Press, 2006.
• Smedley, Audrey - Brian D. Race in North America: Origin and Evolution of a Worldview. Westview Press, 2011.
• Taguieff, Pierre-Andre. The Force of Prejudice: On Racism and Its Doubles. trans. Hassan Melehy. Minneapolis, London: University of Minnesota Press, 2001.
• Vorster, J.M. “Racism, Xenophobia and Human Rights”. The Ecumenical Review 54/ 3, (2002), 296-312.
• Wieviorka, Michel. “Irk, Kültür ve Toplum: Fransızların Müslümanlarla Yaşadığı Tecrübeler”, Müslüman Avrupa ya da Avro-İslam. çev. Zehra Savan. haz. Nezar Alsayyad ve Manuel Castells. İstanbul: Everest Yayınları, 2004.
• Wodak, Ruth - Reisigl, Martin.“Discourse and Racism: European Perspectives”. Annual Review of Anthropology, 28 (1999), 174-199.