Yunan Ulusal Kimliğinin Oluşumu Sürecinde İçsel ve Dışsal Parametrelerin Analizi

Year 2006, Volume: 46 Issue: 1, 53 - 78, 01.01.2006

Ferhat Pirinççi

Abstract

Yunanistan günümüzde, Yunan kimliği ekseninde dil, etnik köken, tarih, din ve kültür gibi değerleri ile 1830’da kurulan Yunan devletinden oldukça farklı bir siyasal kültüre ve toplumsal yapıya sahip olmuştur. Yunan devletindeki teritoryal genişlemenin yanı sıra Yunan bilincinde yaşanan değişim/dönüşüm, hem süreç hem de anlam itibariyle kendine özgü bir ulus inşa süreci ile ilişkilidir. İster içsel ve dışsal unsurların etkileşimi isterse de ulusal güçlerin yeni değer yaratma süreci açısından bakılsın, Yunan ulus inşa sürecinin gerek düşünsel gerekse eylemsel boyuttaki gelişimi büyük oranda dışsal değişkenlerin etkisi altında gerçekleşmiştir. Bu bağlamda, çalışmada Yunan ulusçuluğunun bir devlete dönüşmesinden önceki periyotta içsel ve dışsal boyut irdelendikten sonra, Yunan devletinin kurulmasıyla ulus inşası çerçevesinde şekillenen Yunan ulusal kimliği ve bu kimliği etkileyen parametreler içsel ve dışsal unsurlarıyla analiz edilecektir.

Keywords

Helen, Yunanistan, Yunan Ulusal Kimliği, Megali İdea, Türk-Yunan İlişkileri

Analyze of Internal and External Parameters in the Process of Greek National Identity Formation

Abstract

With her values as language, ethnic root, history, religion and culture in the axis of Greek identity, contemporary Greece has a very different political culture and social structure than the Greek state founded in 1830. Besides the territorial expansion of Greek state, the change/transformation occurred in Greek consciousness is closely related with a sui generis nation building process. Whether the interaction of internal and external elements or creation of new values by national powers regarded; the progress of Greek nation building process in theoretical and practical dimensions, is heavily influenced by external factors. In this context, after examining the dynamics of Greek nationalism in the era of pre-Greek state; the article will analyze the internal and external parameters of Greek national identity which have shaped in the frame of Greek nation building process.

Keywords

Hellen, Greece, Greek National Identity, Megali Idea, Turkish-Greek Relations

References

• ANDREOPOULOS, George. (1981). “State and Irredentism: Some Reflexions on the Case of Greece”, The Historical Journal. 24(4), 949- 959.
• ARMAOĞLU, Fahir. (1999). 19. Yüzyıl Siyasi Tarihi (1789-1914). Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları.
• ARNAKIS, G. Georgiades. (1952). “The Greek Church of Constantinople and the Otoman Empire”, The Journal of Modern History, 24(3), 235- 250. BBC. (2004). http://www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/europe/story/2004/11/printable/041125_gi scard-turkey.shtml, (e.t. 29/11/ 2004).
• BLACKSBURG, Seth. (2000). “Greek Irredentist Claims to Asia Minor”, http://ase.tufts.edu/hemispheres/seth_blacksburg_2000.htm, (e.t. 08/09/2004)
• BOZOS, Stavros. (2004). “Neoclassicism, Modernity and the ‘Masses’: National Identity Issues in 19. Century Athens”, http://www.esh.ed.ac.uk/urban_history/text/BozosS13.doc, (e.t. 20/10/2004), 1-8.
• CHRYSOLORAS, Nikos. (2003). “Why Orthodoxy? Religion and Nationalism in Greek Political Culture”. The LSE Hellenic Observatory 1 st LSE PhD Symposium on Modern Greece, LSE, 21 June 2003,http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/hellenicObservatory/pdf/NicosCh rysoloras1stLSESymposiumPaper.pdf
• CHRYSOLORAS, Nikos. (2004a). “Orthodoxy and Greek National Identity: An Analysis of Greek Nationalism in Light of A. D. Smith’s Theoretical Framework”. http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/kokkalis/GSW7/GSW%206/Nikos%20Chr ysoloras%20Paper.pdf, (E.T. 10/09/2004).
• CHRYSOLORAS, Nikos. (2004b). “Religion and Nationalism in Greece”, Second Pan-European Conference Standing Group on EU Politics. Bologna, 24-26 June 2004.
• CLOGG, Richard. (1976). The Movement for Grek Independence 1770- 1821: A Collection of Documents. London: McMillan Publications..
• CLOGG, Richard. (1997). Modern Yunanistan Tarihi. (Çev. Dilek Şendil), İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları.
• CRAWLEY, C.W. (1929) “Anglo-Russian Relations 1815-40”. Cambridge Historical Journal, 3 (1), 47-73.
• DAĞI, Zeynep. (2002). Kimlik, Milliyetçilik ve Dış Politika: Rusya’nın Dönüşümü. İstanbul Boyut Kitapları.
• DAKIN, Douglas. (1973). The Greek Struggle for Independence 1821-1833. California: University of California Press.
• DEKMENJIAN, R.H. (1968). “Soviet-Turkish Relations and Politics in the Armenian SSR”, Soviet Studies. 19(4), 510-525.
• GÜREL, Şükrü S. (1993). Tarihsel Boyut İçinde Türk-Yunan İlişkileri (1821-1993), Ümit Yayıncılık, Ankara.
• HERACLIDES, Alexis. (2002). Yunanistan ve “Doğudan Gelen Tehlike Türkiye: Türk-Yunan İlişkilerinde Çıkmazlar ve Çözüm Yolları. (Çev. Mihalis Vasilyadis ve Herkül Milas), İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları.
• KATSIADAKIS, Helen Gardikas. (1995). Greece and the Balkan Imbroglio: Greek Foreign Policy, 1911-1913. Athens: Syllogos Pros Diadosin Ophelimon Biblion.
• KOSTIS, Kostas P. (2002). “The Formation of the State in Greece, 1830- 1914”, (ed. Marco Dogo and Guido Franzinetti). Disrupting and Reshaping: Early Stages of Nation-Building in the Balkans. Longo: Ravenna Pub. (47-64).
• LIAKOS, Antonis. (2001). “The Construction of National Time: The Making of the Modern Greek Historical Imagination”, Mediterranean Historical Review, 16(1), 27-42.
• LIEDERMAN, Lina. Molokotos (October 2003). “Identity Crisis: Greece, Orthodoxy and the European Union”, Journal of Contemporary Religion. 18( 3), 291-315.
• MILLAS, Hercules. (2004). The Imagined ‘Other’ as National Identity: Greeks and Turks. EC Representation NGO Support Team (Euromed): Civil Society Development Program .
• MİLLAS, Herkül. (1999). Yunan Ulusunun Doğuşu. 2. Baskı, İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları.
• MONTGOMERY A.E. (1972). “The Making the Treaty of Sevres of 10 August 1920”, The Historical Journal. 15(1), 775-787.
• MORIN, Edgar. (1988). Avrupa’yı Düşünmek. (Çev.: Şirin Tekeli), İstanbul: Afa Yayınları.
• PAPACOSMA, Victor S. (1977). The Military in Greek Politics: The 1909 Coup D’état. Ohio: Kent University Press.
• PAPPAS, Paul Constantine. (1985). The United States and the Greek War for Independence: 1821-1828. New York: Columbia University Press. Parliament of Greece. (2004). http://www.parliament.gr/english/politeuma/ default.asp, (e.t. 18/10/2004).
• PREVELAKIS, Nicolas. “The Spirit of Greek Nationalism: The Greek Case in the Light of Greenfield’s Conceptual Framework”, http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/hellenicObservatory/pdf/symposiumPa personline /N.Prevelakis.paper.pdf, (e.t. 25/10/2004).
• SKRINIS, Stavros. (2003). “Nation-State Building Process and Cultural Diversity”, MigPol-Project: Greece. Overview about Immigration, Integration, and Refugee- Protection Politics in all Member States of the European Union.
• ŞAHİN, M. Süreyya. (1996). Fener Patrikhanesi ve Türkiye. İstanbul: Ötüken Yayınları.
• VAN EVERA, Stephen. (1994). “Hypotheses on Nationalism and War”, International Security, 18(4), 5-39.
• VEREMIS, Thanos. (1997). The Military in Greek Politics: From Independence to Democracy. London: Hurst&Company.
• VOLKAN, Vamık D. ; Itzkowitz, Norman. (1994). Turks and Greeks: Neighbours in Conflict, Cambridgeshire: The Eothen Press.
• VUCINICH, Wayne S. (1962). “The Nature of Balkan Society Under Otoman Rule”, Slavic Review, 21 (4), 597-616.
• WOODHOUSE, C. M. (1952). The Greek War of Independence: Its Historical Settings. New York: Longmans&Green and Company.
• XANTHOS, Emmanouil. (1976). “The Memoirs of Emmanouil Xanthos, A Founder Member of Philiki Etairia”. (ed. Richard Clogg), The Movement for Greek Independence 1770-1821: A Collection of Documents. London: McMillan Publications. (182-200).