COLONIAL BOUNDARIES OF AFRICA: THE CASE OF ETHIOPIA’S BOUNDARY WITH SUDAN

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to study the merits and the demerits of colonial boundaries in Africa by using the Ethiopia-Sudan boundary as a case study. The paper tries to examine how the existing boundary between the two countries came into being in the early 20th century. The present-day boundary between Ethiopia and Sudan is principally the result of the 1902 and 1907 Anglo-Ethiopian delimitation treaties which were demarcated in 1903 and 1909 respectively. At present, there is confusion and controversy in Ethiopia, particularly, after the exposure of the alleged “secret” re-demarcation deal between the current governments of Ethiopia and Sudan that resulted, according to various media reports, in the ceding of huge Ethiopian border land to Sudan along their common border. This paper explores the historical background of the boundary conflict and gives an insight to the current boundary problem between Ethiopia and Sudan

Keywords

• Africa, Anglo-Abyssinia, Boundary, Ethiopia, Haile Selassie I, Major Charles Gwynn, Menelik II, Sudan

References

1. (1) The Ethiopian emperor who initiated the re-unification process of the country. He ruled the country from 1855 to 1868 and died fighting against the British at Maqdalla in 1868.
2. (2) OLF (Oromo Liberation Front); EPPF (Ethiopian Peoples Patriotic Front) (3) It was Stephen Jones who outlined the “traditional” four stages of boundary making in 1945. However, as Pratt (2006) noted the four stages (i.e.delimitation, demarcation, maintenance and management) should not be seen as totally independent processes. In many cases they overlap.
3. (4) On the other hand, Prescott (1979) identifies only three stages in boundary making: allocation, delimitation and demarcation.
4. (5) Ron Adler calls the politicians and their advisers as “boundary architects” and the technical specialists as “boundary engineers” (Blake 1995: 45).
5. (6) As stated elsewhere in this paper, Charles Gwynn who delimited and demarcated Ethiopia’s border with Sudan was employed by the Royal Engineers Officers. (7) Blake (1995: 46) argues that “agreements are.......perfectly valid without demarcation.”
6. (8) As Rushworth (1997:61) emphasized “delimitation” requires the arts of diplomacy, while “demarcation” is a mechanical process. In short, delimitation is drawing a line on the map while demarcation is drawing a line on the ground.
7. (9) This is particularly true in poor countries like Ethiopia and Sudan. (10) Loisel (2004: 4) argues that in 1990 almost 87% of African borders were inherited from colonial era.
8. (11) Foucher (1991: 202) claimed that by 1991, 41% of African border had never been demarcated.

9. (12) On the other hand, Asiwaju and Nugent (1993) criticized the perception that claims African ethnic conflicts are caused by irrational colonial boundaries.
10. (13) This means, according to Griggs (1997: 64), after independence African countries agreed to stick with colonial boundaries which were the result of the Berlin Conference. Herbst (1989: 673) argues: “there is widespread agreement that the boundaries are arbitrary, yet the vast majority of them have remained virtually untouched since the late 1800’s, when they were first demarcated.” The only two exceptions are Eritrea and the Western Sahara.
11. (14) Griggs (1997: 66) argues that African colonial boundaries are also the causes for high economic costs. That is to say, due to border disputes African countries purchase armaments and sometimes the expense is equivalent to the foreign aid they are receiving.
12. (15) E.g., the relation between the ancient Axumite Kingdom of Ethiopia and the Meroe Kingdom of Sudan. (16) Egypt annexed Sudan in 1821-1822.
13. (17) Named after their leader Muhammad Ahmad (“Mahdi”) who later ruled Sudan from June 1881 to June 1885 by expelling the Anglo-Egyptian forces.
14. (18) The Mahdists successfully expelled the Egyptians from Sudan and occupied Khartoum in 1885.
15. (19) Khalifa Abdallah succeeded Mahdi and ruled Sudan from June 1885 to September 1898.
16. (20) According to Abdussamad (1999), “Towards the end of the nineteenth century, the Ethiopian empire incorporated the north western border enclaves of
17. Bela-Shangul and Gumuz into greater Ethiopia.” (21) Major Charles Gwynn (Later Major General) was born in Ireland in 1870. In , he was commissioned in the Royal Engineers. He joined the geographical section of the Intelligence Branch of the war office from 1897 to 1901. Until 1904 he undertook survey work in the Sudan. He was awarded his CMG for conducting the survey determining the border between Ethiopia and Sudan He died in 1963 in Dublin, Ireland (Long 1983).
18. (22) Gwynn uses the terms “Abyssinia” and “Abyssinians” throughout his article. (23) This is because either the Europeans were not affordable or the Ethiopians were not ready to trust them (Gwynn 1937: 150).
19. (24) The forces of Khalifa were able to push the British forces towards Gedaref and Gallabat provinces and Blue Nile and Sobat rivers (Gwynn 1937: 151)
20. (25) Named after the head of the delegation, James Rennell Rodd. (26) By that time, the British themselves had no clear information about the Ethiopia-Sudan border areas. According to Gwynn (1937: 150-151), “to take the case of the Sudan; the maps in much of the frontier regions were blank, and other parts were out of date-nor could the Abyssinians supply reliable information”.
21. (27) As I stated earlier, the Dervishes defeated the Anglo-Egyptian forces in and drove them from cities like Khartoum. However, in July 1894, the Italians under General Baratieri expanded their holding from Massawa and conquered Kassala from the Dervishes. When the Italians were defeated by
22. Menelik of Ethiopia in 1896 at Adwa, they were not in a position to maintain their forces in Kassala though the post Adwa peace agreement between Ethiopia and Italy allow the latter to keep its military presence in the Kassala area (The New
23. York Times 21 December 1897). In the mean time, the Dervishes besieged the Italian forces at Kassala in March 1896. Unable to resist the pressure, the Italians decided to evacuate from Kassala, and the Anglo-Ethiopian forces rapidly occupied Kassala. The British used Kassala as a launching pad to counter-attack the Dervishes who fortified themselves in Khartoum (The New
24. York Times 21 December 1897).
25. (28) Captain Bright had previously conducted an expedition from East Africa to the northern end of Lake Rudolf (29) Elaboration is mine (30) In the following years, some of the communities resisted the British’s attempt to put them in Sudan. One of the leaders of the resistance was Ibrahim Wad Mahmud. Then, the British sent an army to crush the resistance and hanged Ibrahim Wad Mahmud in Khartoum (See Gwynn 1937: 154).
26. (31) As testified by Mburu (2003:20) “Addis Ababa renounced Britain’s attempt to rectify this border through a survey by Major Charles Gwynn (Royal
27. Engineers) in August 1908 for excluding Ethiopian surveyors.”
28. (32) The preliminary survey of the Kenya-Ethiopia boundary was earlier carried out by Captain P. Maud R.E., in the winter of 1902-1903. He surveyed the area between the Dawa River and Lake Rudolf (Gwynn 1937: 159).
29. (33) Emperor Menelik’s illness was a great concern for the British as clearly seen in the British newspapers. The New York Times reported the health condition of the Emperor on almost regular basis (See: New York Times 9 January 1992; 30 January 1909; 2 November 1909; 1 December 1906; 23
30. December 1906; 25 May 1910; 22 February 1910; 29 March 1910; 31 October ; 12 January 1910; 2 April 1910; 19 December 1909).
31. (34) One of the causes for the conflict between Ethiopia and Sudan was a boundary problem. In order to properly study his country’s boundary problem with Sudan Haile Selassie established two inquiry committees at different times. (35) VOA (05 June 2008) reported that, “The news of a boundary settlement shocked many Ethiopians, who consider the ceded Ethiopian land to be historically and culturally theirs.”
32. ABBINK, JON (2003): “Badme and the Ethio-Eritrean border: The challenge of demarcation in the post-war period”. Africa [Rome] LVIII, (2) (Jun): 219-31.
33. ABBINK, J (1998): “Briefing: The Eritrean-Ethiopian Border Dispute”, African Affairs 97(389), 551-565.
34. ABDUSSAMAD H. AHMAD (1999): “Trading in Slaves in Bela-Shangul and Gumuz, Ethiopia: Border-Enclaves in History 1897-1938”, In: The Journal of African History, 40, pp. 433-446.
35. AGHEMELO, A. T., AND S. IBHASEBHOR (2006): Colonialism as a Source of
36. Boundary Dispute and Conflict among African States: The World Court Judgment on the Bakassi Peninsula and its Implications for Nigeria, Journal of Social Sciences. 13(3): 177-181. AJALA, ADEKUNLE (1983): “The Nature of African Boundaries.” Afrika Spectrum, 18: 177-188.
37. AKIHIRO, IWASHITA (2005): “An Inquiry for New Thinking on the Border
38. Dispute: Backgrounds of “Historic Success” for the Sino-Russian Negotiations”, in: Siberia and the Russian Far East in the 21st Century: Partners in the “Community of Asia”, (Iwashita A. Akihiro (Ed.), vol. 1, Chapter 6, pp. 95-115. ADLER, R. (1995): ‘Positioning and Mapping International Land Boundaries.’ In:
39. Boundary and Territory Briefing, Clive Schofield and Peter Hocknell (Eds.), International Boundaries Research Unit, Durham: University of Durham, vol. 2, No.1, pp. 1-40. ANDERSON, MALCOLM (1996): Frontiers: territory and state formation in the modern world. Cambridge: Polity Press. http://www.issi.org.pk/journal/2004_files/no_2/article/7a.htm, (Retrieved on April 2008).
40. ARABIC NEWS.COM (7-3-2003): “Sudan, Ethiopia end border dispute.” http://www.arabicnews.com/ansub/Daily/Day/030703/2003070305.html, (Retrieved on 6/29/2008).
41. ASIWAJU, A.I. (1984): “Artificial Boundaries.” Inaugural Address, University of
42. Lagos: Lagos, 12 December. ASIWAJU, A.I. (1985): “The Conceptual Framework.” In: Partitioned Africans, ed. A. I. Asiwaju. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1-18.
43. ASIWAJU, A. I., PAUL NUGENT (1993):. « The Paradox of African Boundaries.
44. » in African Boundaries: Barriers, Conduits and Opportunities. A. I. Asiwaju and Paul Nugent (eds.) London: Pinter. ATZILI, BOAZ (2004): Good Fences Can Make Bad Neighbors: State
45. Weakness, Border Fixity, and the War in Congo. A Paper prepared for delivery at the International Studies Association conference in Montreal, Canada, March 20, 2004.
46. BACH, DANIEL (Ed.). (1999): Regionalisation in Africa: Integration and Disintegration. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
47. BAHRU ZEWDE (2002): A History of Modern Ethiopia 1855–1991. Addis
48. Ababa.Addis Ababa University Press, 2nd edition. BARBOUR, K.M. (1961): “A Geographical Analysis of Boundaries in Inter
49. Tropical Africa.” In: Essays on African Population, ed. K.M. Barbour and R.M. Prothero. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 303-323. BELLO, ADEBAYO (1995): “The Boundaries Must Change.” West Africa, 10 April: 546.
50. BERRY, L, (1968): The Sudan’s Contact with East Africa, International
51. Conference on Sudan in Africa, University of Khartoum- Faculty of Arts Sudan Research Unit. BENTSI-ENCHILL, KWAMENA (1976): “The Traditional Legal Systems of
52. Africa,” Property and Trust, vol. 6, International Encyclopedia of Comparative Law. Tubingen, Germany: J. C. B. Mohr, 2-38. BLAKE, GERALD (April 1995): “The Depiction of International Boundaries on
53. Topographic Maps,” IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin. BOUQUET, CHRISTIAN (2003): Artificiality of the borders in sub-Saharan
54. Africa. Cahiers d'Outre-Mer 56, (222) (Apr-Jun): 181-98. BRAMBILLA, CHIARA (n.d): Borders and Identity: The Cartographic Invention of the Ghana/Togo Boundary and the Ewe Identity. Università degli Studi di Bergamo. BROWN, HARRY (October 1994): The Iraq-Kuwait Boundary Dispute: Historical
55. Background and the UN Decisions of 1992 and 1993,” IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin.
56. BROWNLIE, IAN (1979): African Boundaries: A Legal and Diplomatic
57. Encyclopedia. London: C. Hurst and Company. CAFLISCH, LUCIUS (2006): “A Typology pf Borders,” International Symposium on Land and River Boundary Demarcation and Maintenance in Support of
58. Borderland Development Bangkok, 7-9 November 2006.
59. CLAPHAM, CHRISTOPHER (1996): Africa and the International System.
60. Cambridge: Cambridge University. DAVIDSON, BASIL (1992): The Black Man’s Burden: Africa and the Curse of the Nation-State. New York: Times Books.
61. DECAPUA, JOE (11 June 2008): “Djibouti-Eritrean Clash Called Minor Incident,
62. But Adds to Regional Volatility,” VOA. DEUTSCHE WELLE (08-05-2008): “Sudan keethiopia meret silemagnetua”
63. (“About Sudanese Acquisition of Land from Ethiopia” DFID (Department for International Development) (October 2001): “The causes of conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa: Framework Document” Foreign and Commonwealth Office; London.
64. DZUREK, DANIEL J. (Spring 1996): Eritrea-Yemen Dispute over the Hanish
65. Islands,IBRU, Boundary and Security Bulletin. DZUREK, DANIEL J. (Spring 1999): “Gulf of Guinea Boundary Disputes” IBRU
66. Boundary and Security Bulletin. DZUREK, DANIEL J. (Winter 1999-2000): “What Makes Some Boundary
67. Disputes Important?” IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, 83-95. ENGLEBERT, PIERRE, STACY TARANGO AND MATTHEW CARTER (February 2001): “Dismemberment and Suffocation: A Contribution to the Debate on African Boundaries.” http://www.politics.pomona.edu/penglebert/borders_FINAL.pdf, (Retrieved on 6 September 2008) Pomona College.
68. ENGLUND, H. (2003): From war to peace on the Mozambique Malawi borderland. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 9, (2) (Jun): 361-2.
69. FIELDING, MARGARET (Spring 1999): Bad Times in Badme: Bitter Warfare
70. Continues Along the Eritrea-Ethiopia Border. IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin. FOUCHER, MICHEL (1991): Fronts et frontières. Un tour du monde géopolitique. Paris: Fayard. Griffiths, Ieuan (1996): “Permeable Boundaries in
71. Africa.” In African Boundaries, ed. Paul Nugent and A.I. Asiwaju. London: Pinter, 83. GRIGGS, R. A. (1995b): ‘African Boundaries –Reconsidered,’ Internationales Afrikaforum, 31, 1: 56-62.
72. GRIGGS, R. A. (1994): ‘Boundaries for a New Africa,’ Track Two, 3, 4: 9-12, December 1994.
73. GRIGGS, R. A. (1995a): ‘Boundaries and War in Africa in 1995,’ IBRU
74. Boundary and Security Bulletin, 3, 1: 77-80. GRIGGS, RICHARD A. (Summer 1997): The Boundaries of an African
75. Renaissance. IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, pp. 64-68. GWYNN, CHARLES (1937): “The Frontiers of Abyssinia: A Retrospect”, In:
76. African Affairs, XXXVI, 150-161. HERBST, JEFFREY (2000): States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
77. HERBST, JEFFERY (1989):“The Creation and Maintenance of National
78. Boundaries in Africa.” International Organization 43, no. 4 (Autumn 1989): 673.
79. HOILE, DAVID (May 2002): The European-Sudanese Public Affairs Council
80. “The Search for Peace in the Sudan: A Chronology of the Sudanese Peace Process 1989-2001” The European-Sudanese Public Affairs Council, London.
81. Hoyle, Peggy (Autumn 2000): Somaliland: Passing the Statehood Test? IBRU
82. Boundary and Security Bulletin. ICG (4 April 2002): Central Asia: Border Disputes and Conflict Potential, ICG
83. Asia Report N° 33, Osh/Brussels. JACKSON, ROBERT H. AND CARL G. ROSEBERG (1982): “Why Africa’s
84. Weak States Persist: The Empirical and the Juridical in Statehood.” World Politics 35: 1-24. JONES, S. B. (1945): Boundary Making, Washington: Carnegie Foundation for International Peace.
85. KAPIL, RAVI L. (1966): “On the conflict potential of Inherited Boundaries in
86. Africa”, World Politics, 18 (4), 656-673. KORNPROBST, M. (2002): “The Management of Border Disputes in African
87. Regional Sub-Systems Comparing West Africa and the Horn of Africa”, The Journal o Modern African Studies, 40, pp. 369-393. KONINGS, PIET (2005): The anglophone cameroon-nigeria boundary:
88. Opportunities and conflicts. African Affairs 104, (415) (Apr): 275-301. KORKOR, FRANCIS O. (2001): The Surveyor and the Boundary:
89. A Spatial Odyssey : 42nd Australian Surveyors Congress. http://www.isaust.org.au/innovation/2001-Spatial_Odyssey/pdf/korkor.pdf,
90. (Retrieved on 6 September 2008).
91. KROMM, DAVID K. (1967): “Irrendentism in Africa: The Somali-Kenya
92. Boundary Dispute”, Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science, 70(3), 365. KRUKOSKI, WILSON R.M. (n.d):‘Frontiers and Boundaries’, (Translated by Jose A. Krukoski), (Retrieved on June 2008).
93. KUM, JOSEPH M. (1993): “The Central African Subregion.” Disarmament:
94. Workshop on the Role of Border Problems in African Peace and Security. New York: United Nations, 1993, 49-71.
95. KWIATKOWSKA, BARBARA (2001): The Eritrea/Yemen Arbitration: Landmark
96. Progress In The Acquisition of Territorial Sovereignty and Equitable Maritime Boundary Delimitation. Ocean Development and International Law, 32(1). LENTZ, CAROLA (2003): 'This is Ghanaian territory ' land conflicts on a West
97. African border. American Ethnologist 30, (2) (May): 273-89. LOISEL, SÉBASTIEN (2004): The European Union and African Border
98. Conflicts: Assessing the Impact of Development Cooperation. UACES Student Forum Regional Conference, Cambridge, May 7th 2004.
99. LONG, GAVIN (1983):'Gwynn, Sir Charles William (1870 - 1963)', Australian
100. Dictionary of Biography, Volume 9, Melbourne University Press, pp 146-147. MAYALL, JAMES (1973): “The Malawi-Tanzania Boundary Dispute” The Journal of Modern African Studies, 11 (4), 611-628.
101. MBURU, NENE (22 March 2003): “Delimitation of the Elastic Ilemi Triangle:
102. Pastoral conflicts and official Indifference in the Horn of Africa.” African Studies Quarterly, vol.7. MILES, WILLIAM F.S. (1994): Hausaland Divided: Colonialism and Independence in Nigeria and Niger. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
103. MWAURA, PETER (16 July 2005): “Kenya’s Claim over Sudan, Ethiopia border
104. Triangle Precarious,” The Daily Nation. MUGABI, FRANK (13 May 2008): “Uganda: Congo Yet to Leave Disputed
105. Area”, New Vision (Kampala). Retrieved from <:http://allafrica.com/stories/200805140091.html> (Retrieved on 6/17/2008).
106. THE NEW YORK TIMES (17 February 1888): “A battle in Abyssinia.”
107. THE NEW YORK TIMES (22 February 1910): “Accused by Menelik’s Wife.”
108. THE NEW YORK TIMES (7 March 1897): Britain’s aim in Abyssinia.”
109. THE NEW YORK TIMES (28 September 1897): “British to occupy Kassala: Italy completed Arrangements for ceding the Abyssinian Town.”
110. THE NEW YORK TIMES (12 January 1898): “British Treaty with Menelik:
111. Frontier Rectification Promised when the Khalifa is Subdued.” THE NEW YORK TIMES (21 July 2008): “China says Russia will return disputed border land.”
112. THE NEW YORK TIMES (31 October 1909): “Expect Menelik to die.”
113. THE NEW YORK TIMES (4 April 1889): “King John Reported Dead.”
114. THE NEW YORK TIMES (4 May 1889): “King John’s Death.”
115. THE NEW YORK TIMES (25 September 1898): “Menelik and His Empire: Wise and peaceful Monarch.”
116. THE NEW YORK TIMES (29 March 1910): “King Menelik not dead.”
117. THE NEW YORK TIMES (1 December 1906): “King Menelik Seriously ill.”
118. THE NEW YORK TIMES (2 November 1909): “Menelik is Daying”
119. THE NEW YORK TIMES (9 January 1912): “Menelik is Paralized.”
120. THE NEW YORK TIMES (2 April 1910): “Menelik may be alive.”
121. THE NEW YORK TIMES (19 December 1909): “Hears Menelik is Dead.”
122. THE NEW YORK TIMES (23 December 1906): “Menelik Again ill.”
123. THE NEW YORK TIMES (6 September 1910): “Menelik again rallies.”
124. THE NEW YORK TIMES (23 January 1898): “Menelik Mobilizing his army:
125. Explanation Given for the Rush of British Troops to Egypt.” THE NEW YORK TIMES (30 January 1909): “Menelik really ill.”
126. THE NEW YORK TIMES (23 May 1897): “Menelik to help the Dervishes.”
127. THE NEW YORK TIMES (12 January 1910): “Menelik Reported Dead.”
128. THE NEW YORK TIMES (25 May 1910): “Menelik reported dying.”
129. THE NEW YORK TIMES (21 December 1897): “Ready to Transfer Kassala.”
130. THE NEW YORK TIMES (20 February 1888): “The Abyssinian Defeat”.
131. THE NEW YORK TIMES (16 January 1902): “To explore the Sobat region:
132. W.Fitz Hugh Whitehouse, Jr., and Lord Hindlip Going to Abyssinia.” THE NEW YORK TIMES (22 September 1897): “Treaty with Mahdi: King
133. Melelik’s frontier Guaranteed by Great Britain and the Mahdi, according to the Figaro.” THE NEW YORK TIMES (25 July 1884): “With the King of Abyssinia.”
134. NKIWANE, SOLOMON M. (1993): “Southern Africa.” Disarmament: Workshop on the Role of Border Problems in African Peace and Security. New York: United Nations, 29-37.
135. NORDQUIST, KJELL-AKE (2002): Boundary Conflicts and Preventive
136. Diplomacy, Chapter 2, Carnegie Commission on preventive Deadly conflict. (Retrieved on 5 September 2008).
137. NUGENT, P. AND ASIWAJU, A. I. (1996): African boundaries: Barriers, conduits and opportunities. London: Pinter.
138. NUGENT, PAUL (1996): “Arbitrary Lines and the People’s Minds: A Dissenting
139. View on Colonial Boundaries inWest Africa.” In: African Boundaries, ed. Paul Nugent and A.I. Asiwaju. London: Pinter, 35-67. NUGENT, PAUL AND A.I. ASIWAJU (1996): “Introduction: The Paradox of
140. African Boundaries.” In: African Boundaries, ed. Paul Nugent and A.I. Asiwaju. London: Pinter, 1-17. ODUGBEMI, SINA (1995): “Consensus and Stability.” West Africa. 3 April: 501
141. ODUNTAN, GBENGA (2006): The demarcation of straddling villages in accordance with the International court of justice jurisprudence: The Cameroon - Nigeria experience. Chinese Journal of International Law 5, (1) (Mar): 79-114.
142. OTTAWAY, MARINA (1999): “Keep Out of Africa.” Financial Times. 25 February.
143. ÖZCAN, MESUT (2002): “Border Concept and Turkey-Iraq Border,” Turkish
144. Review of Middle East Studies, no.13, pp.41-85. PEARCE, JUSTIN (May-June 2000): Facts on the Ground: War and Peace in the Horn of Africa, IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin.
145. PERRY, ALAN (Summer 2000): Caprivi Strip: World Court Awards Island To
146. Botswana: International Court of Justice Case concerning Kasikili/Sedudu Island (Botswana/Namibia). IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, pp.80-87. PRATT, MARTIN (2006): A terminal crisis? Examining the breakdown of the Eritrea - Ethiopia Boundary Dispute Resolution process. Conflict Management and Peace Science 23, (4) (winter): 329-41.
147. PRESCOTT V. (1979): ‘Africa’s Boundary Problems’, Optima, 28, 1.
148. PRESCOTT, J.R.V. (1987): Political Frontiers and Boundaries, London: Allen and Unwin.
149. RANKIN, KJ AND R SCHOFIELD (2004): “The Troubled Historiography of
150. Classical Boundary Terminology,” Mapping Frontiers, Plotting Pathways: Ancillary Paper, No. 2. RUBENSON, SECEN (1976): The Survival of Ethiopian Independence, London.
151. RUSHWORTH, DENNIS (Spring 1997): “Mapping in Support of Frontier
152. Arbitration: Delimitation and Demarcation.” IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, pp.61-64. SAMBANIS, NICHOLAS (1999): “Partition as a Solution to Ethnic War: An
153. Empirical Critique of the Theoretical Literature.” World Politics 52: 437-483. SANDERSON, G.N. (1969): Conflict and Cooperation between Ethiopia and the Mahdist State, In Sudan Notes and Records, Vol. 50, Khartoum.
154. SAUTTER, GILLES (1982): “Quelques réflexions sur les frontières africaines” in
155. Catherine Coquery-Vidrovitch (Ed.). Problèmes frontières dans le Tiers-Monde. Paris: Université de Paris. SHAW, MALCOLM (1997): “People, Territorialism and Boundaries”, In:
156. European Journal of International Law, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 478-507. SMITH, BARRY (1995):‘On Drawing Lines on a Map’, A. U. Frank, W. Kuhn and D. M. Mark (eds.), Spatial Information Theory. Proceedings of COSIT '95,
157. Berlin/Heidelberg/Vienna/New York/London/Tokyo: Springer Verlag, 1995, 475–
158. SODEINDE, OLALEKAN RASHEED (2001): Boundary Conflict Resolution through the Spatial Analysis of Social, Commercial and Cultural Interaction of
159. People Leaving Along Boundary Area. International Conference on Spatial Information for Sustainable Development, Nairobi, Kenya, 2–5 October 2001.
160. SUDAN TRIBUNE (4 July 2007): “Eastern Sudan farmers get back disputed land from Ethiopia.”
161. TIME (3 July 1995): “Sudan Threatens to Block the Nile.”
162. TOUVAL, SAADIA (1969): “The Sources of Status Quo and Irredentist Policies.”
163. In African Boundary Problems, ed. Carl Gosta Widstrand. Uppsala: The Scandinavian Institute of African Studies, 101-118. UNHCR (16 January 2006): Sudan Operations: Sudan/Chad Situation update
164. VOA (05 June 2008): “Border Demarcation with Sudan Caused Anger in Ethiopia.”
165. VOA (11 June 2008): “Djibouti Says Two Dead in Eritrea Border Clash.”
166. WEMBOU, MICHEL-CYR D. (1994): “The OAU and International Law.” In: The Organization of African Unity after Thirty Years, (ed.) Yassin El-Ayouty, London: Praeger.
167. WESTING, ARTHUR H. (1996): “The Eritrean-Yemeni Conflict over the Hanish
168. Archipelogo: Toward a Resolution Favoring Peace and Nature”, Security Dialogue 27(2), 201-206. YACOB ARSANO (2007): Ethiopia and the Nile Dilemmas of National and Regional Hydropolitics. Center for Security Studies, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich.
169. YOUNG, CRAWFORD (1996): “The Impossible Necessity of Nigeria: A Struggle for Nationhood,” Foreign Affairs, November/December, 75(6):139-143.
170. YOUNG, JOHN (2007): “Armed Groups along Sudan’s Eastern Frontier: An
171. Overview and Analysis,” Small Arms Survey, Graduate Institute of International Studies, Geneva