The Impact of a Semiotic Analysis Theory-Based Writing Activity on Students’ Writing Skills

Year 2016, Volume: 16 Issue: 63, 0 - 0, 15.04.2016

Tulay Sarar Kuzu

Abstract

Problem Statement: In entering the world intellectually and affectively
equipped, humans develop in a systemic way that encompasses both
thought and art education and in which written, oral, and visual texts are
important tools. In particular, visual literacy, which refers to the
interpretation of elements other than written text, including images,
symbols, shapes, and colors, has come into prominence through new
learning approaches that emphasize the importance of using numerous
stimuli. All texts convey a meaning and a message, which to comprehend
requires textual analysis, the different theories and methods of which vary
among various types of texts. As discussed in this article, the semiotic
analysis theory provides tools for textual analysis concerning the
dimensions of narrative discourse.
Purpose: This study aimed to determine how a writing lecture activity
based on semiotic analysis theory affects students’ writing skills. To that
end, cartoon caricatures were selected as visual texts for analysis.
Method: This experimental research based on pre- and post-tests was
conducted with a dependent group of 40 7th-grade students in a school
within Turkey’s Ministry of Education. Data collection involved having
each student develop two texts for caricature analysis: one prior to an
experiment based on the traditional approach, and the other after an
experiment based on the semiotic method. The differences between scores
received for each text by all students were analyzed. 

Findings: Results revealed that textual analysis based on the semiotic theory was more effective for the writing skills of students than the traditional writing method with respect to three areas of evaluation: understanding the subject, accessing the message, and multidimensional interpretation.
Conclusion and Recommendations: The findings suggest that the proposed method of semiotic analysis is an alternative to traditional methods used in Turkish-language courses that can enhance the effectiveness of learning and positively affect students’ creative-writing skills.
Keywords: Semiotic analysis theory, cartoon caricatures, writing education, writing skills