PUBLICATION ETHICS & MALPRACTICE STATEMENT
Engineering Perspective is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics and takes all necessary measures to prevent any form of publication malpractice. This statement outlines the ethical standards that all parties involved in the publishing process, including authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, are expected to adhere to. This statement is based on the publication ethics guidelines published by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). It is our responsibility to publish original work that adds value to the intellectual community in the best possible form and to the highest possible standards. We hold our reviewers and authors to the same standards. Honesty, originality, and fair dealing on the part of authors, and fairness, objectivity, and confidentiality on the part of editors and reviewers are essential to achieving our goal. Engineering Perspective is committed to following best practices on ethical matters, errors, and retractions, and to providing a legal review if necessary. In case of any conflict, the COPE best practices guidelines are taken into account.
Ethical Oversight
Engineering Perspective requires all research to be conducted in accordance with applicable ethical standards, laws, regulations and institutional requirements. Authors are responsible for obtaining any required ethics committee approvals, research permits and other authorizations before the relevant research activities begin.
Research involving human participants, including surveys, questionnaires, interviews and user studies, or the use of human data or human-derived biological materials, must meet the applicable requirements for ethical review, informed consent and protection of privacy and confidentiality. Any formal exemption from ethical review must be documented by the relevant ethics committee or authorized institutional body.
Authors must obtain appropriate authorization to access and use confidential or restricted data and materials. Any unusual hazards associated with chemicals, materials, procedures or equipment must be clearly identified in the manuscript, together with the relevant safety precautions. Safety requirements and research ethics approval are distinct obligations; authors must comply with each where applicable.
Research involving animals as experimental or observational subjects is outside the scope of Engineering Perspective. Manuscripts reporting such research will not be considered for publication.
Intellectual Property
Engineering Perspective is committed to safeguarding intellectual property. It is the responsibility of authors, editors and reviewers to ensure this.
The authors certify that the submitted manuscript (and any supporting items) is their own intellectual property and that the copyright has not been transferred to others. They confirm that the manuscript contains no plagiarism, no fabrication, no falsification, no manipulated citations, and that it conforms to the authorship policies set out below. They also confirm that any third-party material is used in accordance with the applicable license or legal exception, or with permission from the rights holder where required. All manuscripts, revisions, drafts and galleys remain the intellectual property of the author(s). The copyright to the work is retained by the author(s). The authors retain the full right to modify, reshare, repost, or archive any version of their copyrighted work. Furthermore, the authors agree to keep all communications, comments, or reports between authors and reviewers or editors confidential. All review comments and reports remain the intellectual property of the reviewer or editor. Similarly, reviewers and editors agree to keep all manuscripts, revisions, drafts, and all communications, comments, or reports between authors and reviewers or editors confidential.
Conflicts of Interest: Disclosure and Management
A conflict of interest arises when a financial or non-financial interest could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, the conduct or reporting of research, peer review, editorial decisions or publication. Examples include employment, consultancies, patents, shareholdings, ownership, and relevant personal, academic, professional, political or religious interests.
At submission, the corresponding author includes a statement in the manuscript disclosing the relevant interests of all authors or stating that none exist. The statement is included in the published article. Authors promptly report any newly identified interests to the handling editor during assessment or to the Editor-in-Chief at acalam@gazi.edu.tr after publication.
Reviewers disclose relevant interests to the handling editor before accepting an invitation. Editors disclose relevant interests to the Editor-in-Chief before handling a manuscript. Both promptly report interests identified later. Reviewers and editors with a significant conflict recuse themselves from the assessment, and an authorised editor without a relevant conflict oversees the manuscript and makes editorial decisions.
The publisher reports relevant interests concerning the journal or the publisher to the Editor-in-Chief and discloses them on the journal website. Concerns involving the Editor-in-Chief or the publisher are referred for independent assessment under the journal’s Complaints and Appeals policy.
An editor without a relevant conflict assesses reports of undisclosed interests and seeks clarification from those involved. Before publication, the declaration is corrected where necessary, and any affected reviews or decisions are reassessed. After publication, the journal assesses the effect on the article and its peer review. It issues a correction where warranted and considers an Expression of Concern or retraction when the criteria in the relevant policy are met.
The journal follows COPE’s guidance on undisclosed author interests in submitted manuscripts and published articles.
Duties and Responsibilities of Editor-in-Chief & Section Editors
Objectivity & Confidentiality
The editor-in-chief and section editors of the journal are responsible for determining which manuscripts submitted to the journal should be published. In this process, the authors of the manuscript are not distinguished based on factors such as race, ethnicity, gender, religion or citizenship by the editors. The editors' decision to accept, revise or reject a manuscript for publication should be based on the manuscript's importance, originality and clarity, as well as the convenience of the study performed in the manuscript in relation to the journal's coverage.
It is the responsibility of the editor-in-chief and section editors to ensure that any information regarding a submitted manuscript is kept confidential and disclosed only to the corresponding author, reviewers/potential reviewers and publishing personnel. During the review process, editors must guarantee the confidentiality of all material submitted by authors.
Editorial Independence and Financial Separation
Engineering Perspective assesses manuscripts on their scientific quality, originality, ethical compliance and relevance to the journal’s scope. Acceptance and rejection decisions are made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorised editor with no relevant conflict of interest. The publisher does not participate in manuscript assessment, peer review or editorial decision-making.
Editors and journal staff receive no payments, bonuses or other compensation that depends on manuscript acceptance, the number of accepted manuscripts or acceptance rates.
Financial and administrative matters, including fee administration, invoicing, payment collection and fee-waiver decisions, are the responsibility of the publisher and are handled either directly or through an authorised financial or administrative representative. These duties are performed by persons outside the journal’s editorial team and Editorial Board who do not undertake manuscript assessment, peer review, copyediting, language editing or typesetting for the journal.
Financial procedures follow the journal’s published Price Policy. Authors’ ability to pay, payment status and eligibility for a fee waiver have no influence on scientific assessment or editorial decisions.
All enquiries concerning fees, invoices, payments, discounts and fee waivers are directed to Author Support, whose contact details are provided on the journal’s Contact page.
Conflicts of interest & Disclosure
Editors will not use any unpublished information disclosed in a submitted manuscript for their own research purposes without the author's explicit written consent. Information or ideas obtained by editors as a result of handling the manuscript will be kept confidential and not used for their personal advantage. Editors with a significant conflict of interest concerning a manuscript recuse themselves from its assessment, reviewer selection, and decision-making. If the Editor-in-Chief has such a conflict, including when they are an author or co-author, a designated subject editor with no relevant conflict of interest oversees the manuscript’s assessment and any peer review and makes the final editorial decision independently.
Editorial Procedures and Peer Review
For the peer-review process, the article will be assigned to at least two independent experts. Engineering Perspective uses single-blind peer review. Reviewers know the authors’ identities, while reviewers’ identities are kept confidential from the authors. The editors responsible for the review process know the reviewers’ identities. If there is no common decision as a result of the reviewer evaluations, the editor may send the article to new reviewers to receive additional evaluation reports.
Independent peer-review reports are obtained from experts outside the journal’s editorial office. Editorial Board members serving solely in an advisory capacity may be invited as reviewers if they meet the journal’s expertise, independence and conflict-of-interest requirements. Assessments provided by the Editor-in-Chief, subject editors or guest editors support editorial decision-making but do not replace the required independent peer-review reports. Potential reviewers suggested by the authors may also be considered. Reviewers must not have published with any of the co-authors in the past three years and must not work or collaborate with any institution of the co-authors of the currently submitted article.
You can check Editorial Procedures and Peer Review Process page for detailed information about editorial procedures and peer review processes.
Management of Unethical Behaviour(s)
The journal assesses reports of suspected misconduct concerning submitted manuscripts and published articles. For how to report a concern and how the journal assesses and follows up on reports, see “Handling Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct” below.
Duties and Responsibilities of Author(s)
Authorship of the Paper
Each listed author must have made a substantial contribution to the conception, design, conduct, analysis, or interpretation of the work, approved the final manuscript, and agreed to be accountable for the work and to help resolve any questions about its accuracy or integrity. The corresponding author confirms that all listed authors meet these criteria and have agreed to submission. For manuscripts with two or more authors, the CRediT Author Statement identifies each author’s contributions using the CRediT taxonomy. Other contributors may be recognised in the Acknowledgment section where appropriate.
Change of Authorship
Requests to add or remove authors or change their order after submission must explain the reasons, provide relevant supporting documentation, and include written agreement from all listed authors and any authors being added or removed. All changes require editorial approval and must comply with the journal’s authorship criteria.
Authorship change requests should normally be submitted using the Authorship Change Request Form, including a separate agreement page signed by every current author and any author being added or removed. The corresponding author should submit the completed form and supporting documents confidentially to the handling editor or Editor-in-Chief. Submission of the form does not guarantee approval.
Changes after acceptance are considered only exceptionally, with adequate justification. A substantiated authorship error identified after publication may be addressed through a formal correction notice linked to the article.
Unresolved authorship disputes are referred to the relevant institution(s) for investigation; the journal does not adjudicate disputed contributions. Processing or publication may be paused pending resolution, where applicable. Institutional determinations may provide a basis for correcting authorship where the authors cannot reach agreement. Such cases are handled in accordance with COPE guidance on cooperation between research institutions and journals.
Originality and Plagiarism
The authors are responsible for the content, language and originality of the manuscript they submitted. The authors should assure that they have composed their original works entirely, and if the authors have used the study and/or words of other authors, that this has been conveniently cited or quoted. Plagiarism takes many forms varying from “passing off” someone´s paper as the authors’ own paper to copying or paraphrasing important parts of someone´s paper (without attribution), to claiming results from research performed by others. Plagiarism in all its forms comprises unethical publishing behaviour and is inadmissible. Before being sent a manuscript to reviewers, it is checked in terms of similarity by plagiarism tools to explore the plagiarism.
Plagiarism is not tolerated in Engineering Perspective. Plagiarism includes copying text, ideas, images, or data from another source, even from your own publications, without giving any credit to the original source.
Reuse of text that is copied from another source must be between quotes and the original source must be cited. If a study's design or the manuscript's structure or language has been inspired by previous works, these works must be explicitly cited.
All submissions are checked for plagiarism before peer review process using the industry standard software iThenticate. Please check the Plagiarism Policy page for more information.
Funding and Support
Engineering Perspective requires authors to disclose all financial and non-financial support for the research and manuscript preparation in a separate Funding and Support section before the references. Authors identify funding or supporting organisations and grant or project numbers, where applicable, and describe any equipment, materials or services provided as support.
If no funding was received, authors must state: “No funding was received for this study.” Any non-financial support must still be disclosed, where applicable.
Funders and supporters may also be thanked in the optional Acknowledgment section. Such thanks do not replace the required disclosures in the Funding and Support section.
Disclosure and conflicts of interest
All authors are required to disclose in their manuscript any financial and personal relationships with other individuals or organisations that could be viewed as inappropriately influencing the content of their work. All sources of financial support for the research and/or preparation of the article must be disclosed, as must the role of the sponsor(s), if any, in study design; in the collection, analysis, and interpretation of data; in the writing of the report; and in the decision to submit the article for publication. If the funding source(s) had no such involvement, this must be stated. The author must declare any competing interests in the manuscript.
Reporting standards
Authors of manuscript should present an accurate explanation of the study conducted and an objective discussion of its importance. Underlying data should be accurately given in the manuscript. A paper should include sufficient detail and references to allow other researchers to repeat the study. Tricky or knowingly imprecise statements form unethical behaviour and are unacceptable. Review and professional publication articles should also be precise, original and objective, and editorial opinion works should be described overtly as such.
Acknowledgment of sources
It is the responsibility of authors to ensure that they have properly acknowledged the work of others and to cite publications that have been influential in determining the nature of the reported work. Information obtained from third parties in confidence must not be used or reported without the source's explicit written permission. Similarly, information obtained in the course of providing confidential services, such as refereeing manuscripts or grant applications, must not be used or reported without the explicit written permission of the author(s) of the work involved in these services.
Data access & retention
Authors might be asked to ensure the raw data in connection with a paper for editorial review process, and should in any event be prepared to keep in such data for a moderate time after publication.
Multiple, redundant or concurrent publication
Manuscripts must not be under consideration by another journal and must not have been previously published as journal articles or full-text conference or symposium papers. Simultaneous submission to more than one journal is not permitted. Posting an author manuscript as a preprint does not, by itself, constitute prior publication or duplicate submission and is permitted under the journal’s Preprints policy.
Principal errors in published studies
When an author corresponds to a significant error or inaccuracy in his/her own published work, it is the author´s obligation to notify swiftly the journal editor or publisher and cooperate with the editor to withdraw or correct the paper.
Ethics Approval, Research Approvals and Safety
Authors must conduct their research in accordance with applicable laws, regulations, institutional requirements and relevant disciplinary ethical standards. All required ethics approvals, research permits and other authorizations must be obtained before the activities to which they apply begin.
Research involving human participants, data or biological materials
Research involving human participants, including surveys, questionnaires, interviews, focus groups and user studies, as well as research using human data or human-derived biological materials, must comply with the applicable requirements for ethical review, informed consent and privacy protection.
Where ethics approval is required, the manuscript must identify the approving ethics committee and provide the approval date and reference number. Where a formal exemption or determination that ethical review is not required has been issued, authors must identify the responsible ethics committee or authorized institutional body and explain the documented basis for that decision. An unsupported statement by the authors that approval was unnecessary is insufficient.
Authors must describe how informed consent was obtained and how participants’ privacy and confidentiality were protected. Any formally approved waiver of informed consent must be reported separately from an exemption from ethics review. If the manuscript includes material from which a research participant could be identified, the authors must obtain that participant’s consent for publication. The manuscript’s “Ethics Approval and Informed Consent” section must state that this consent was obtained.
Other research approvals and permissions
Where the research requires approval or authorization from another competent body, authors must identify that body and report the relevant permit, approval or authorization details in the manuscript. This includes, where applicable, institutional biosafety approval, radiation authorization, permissions for regulated materials, and permits for fieldwork or sample collection. Such authorizations must not be described as research ethics committee approval unless they were issued in that capacity.
Authors must obtain appropriate authorization to access and use confidential, proprietary or restricted data and materials. Any restrictions affecting their use or disclosure must be respected and explained where relevant.
Hazards and safety precautions
Authors must clearly identify any unusual hazards associated with the chemicals, materials, procedures or equipment used in the research and describe the relevant safety precautions in the Methods section or an equivalent section. The use of hazardous materials or equipment does not, by itself, establish a requirement for research ethics committee approval; applicable safety approvals and regulatory requirements must nevertheless be met.
Reporting requirements
Manuscripts reporting research involving human participants, human data or human-derived biological materials must include a section entitled “Ethics Approval and Informed Consent” before the References. This section must report the applicable approval or documented exemption, consent arrangements and privacy safeguards. Relevant details must also be provided in the Methods section, where applicable.
For other studies requiring specific research approvals or permits, the relevant information must be reported in the Methods section or in a separate section entitled “Research Approvals and Permissions,” as appropriate.
Studies to which none of these ethics approval or research permission requirements apply are not required to include a separate ethics approval section or a “Not applicable” statement. This does not remove any applicable obligation to report hazards and safety precautions.
All applicable approval, exemption and permission documents must be uploaded to the submission system at the time of submission for editorial verification, as detailed under “Use of the Examples and Submission of Supporting Documents.” Editors may request additional information or clarification. All statements must accurately reflect the research conducted and must be retained in the published article, including its PDF version.
Relevant information should also be provided in the Methods section, where applicable.
Example 1 — Research with ethics committee approval
Use the following example when the study received ethics committee approval. Replace the bracketed text with accurate study-specific information and adapt the consent and confidentiality statements to the procedures actually followed.
Ethics Approval and Informed Consent
This study was approved by [full name of the ethics committee] (Approval Date: [DD Month YYYY]; Reference No.: [number]) before [specify the relevant research activities] began. Informed consent was obtained from participants through [describe the consent procedure] before their participation. Participation was voluntary, and participants were informed about the purpose and procedures of the study. Participants’ privacy and confidentiality were protected through [briefly describe the measures taken].
Example 2 — Research with a documented exemption or determination that ethical review was not required
Use the following example only when an ethics committee or authorized institutional body has formally documented the exemption or determination. Select the applicable wording and report the actual decision. The consent statement must reflect the study’s circumstances; if informed consent was formally waived, identify the approving body and explain the basis for that waiver.
Ethics Approval and Informed Consent
The [full name of the ethics committee or authorized institutional body] determined that [this study was exempt from ethical review / ethical review was not required] because [state the documented reason] (Decision Date: [DD Month YYYY]; Reference No.: [if available]). [Describe how informed consent was obtained, or identify and explain a separately approved waiver of informed consent, as applicable.] Participants’ privacy and confidentiality were protected through [briefly describe the measures taken].
Other research approvals and permissions
Research may require approvals or permissions other than research ethics committee approval. Depending on the study and applicable requirements, these may include institutional biosafety approval, radiation authorization, permission to use regulated materials, or permits for fieldwork or sample collection.
Where such authorization is required, authors must identify the competent body and report the relevant approval or permit details in the Methods section or in a separate section entitled “Research Approvals and Permissions,” as appropriate. These authorizations must not be described as ethics committee approval unless they were issued in that capacity.
Example 3 — Research requiring other approvals or permissions
Use the following example only when a specific research approval, permit or authorization was required. Identify the activity covered and the issuing body. If several authorizations were required, report each separately.
Research Approvals and Permissions
Authorization for [specify the activity, material or research procedure] was obtained from [full name of the competent body] before the relevant activities began (Authorization Date: [DD Month YYYY]; Permit/Reference No.: [number]). The research was conducted in accordance with [identify the applicable requirements and authorization conditions].
Hazards and safety precautions
The use of chemicals, materials, procedures or equipment presenting unusual hazards must be explained in the Methods section or an equivalent section, together with the relevant safety precautions. Such hazards do not, by themselves, establish a requirement for research ethics committee approval. Authors must nevertheless obtain any safety-related authorizations required by applicable regulations or institutional rules.
When a separate statement is not required
Studies that do not involve human participants, human data or human-derived biological materials, and do not require specific ethics approvals or research permissions, are not required to include either of the sections described above. A “Not applicable” statement is not required.
For example, purely numerical simulations, theoretical analyses and standard engineering laboratory tests generally do not require a separate ethics approval statement unless the particular research activities, materials, data or applicable regulations introduce an approval or permission requirement. Any relevant hazards and safety precautions must still be reported.
Use of the examples and supporting documentation
The examples are provided as guidance and must be adapted to the actual study. Authors must include only the statements applicable to their research, remove all instructional text and placeholders, and ensure that every declaration accurately reflects the research procedures and supporting documentation.
Where ethics committee approval is required, authors must upload the approval document to the journal’s submission system at the time of submission and submit it to the handling editor for verification. Where a formal exemption from ethical review or a determination that ethical review is not required has been issued, the corresponding official document must be uploaded and submitted in the same manner. Any separately granted waiver of informed consent must also be supported by the relevant official documentation.
Where the study requires other research approvals, permits or authorizations, authors must also upload the relevant documents to the submission system and submit them to the handling editor. These may include institutional biosafety approvals, radiation authorizations, fieldwork or sample collection permits, and permissions to access or use restricted data or materials, as applicable.
Supporting documents must be submitted as separate files designated for editorial review and must not be included as publicly accessible supplementary material. Unnecessary personal information must be removed without obscuring the information needed to verify the issuing body, the study covered, the decision date, the reference number and any relevant conditions.
The information reported in the manuscript must be consistent with the submitted documents. Manuscripts requiring such documentation will not proceed to peer review until the necessary documents have been provided and verified by the editor. The editor may request additional information or clarification where necessary.
The relevant ethics approval, exemption, informed consent and research permission statements must remain in the published article, including its PDF version. Studies for which these requirements do not apply are not required to submit such documents or include a separate “Not applicable” statement.
Scope exclusion
Research involving animals as experimental or observational subjects is outside the scope of Engineering Perspective. Manuscripts reporting such research will not be considered for publication.
Duties and Responsibilities of Reviewers
Engineering Perspective has an obligation to provide transparent policies for peer review, and reviewers have an obligation to conduct reviews in an ethical and accountable manner. The peer review process often depends on the trust and voluntary participation of the academic community, and peer reviewers, who play a central and critical role in the review process, must act responsibly and ethically. Open communication between the journal and reviewers is essential to facilitate consistent, fair, and timely reviews. If you have no previous experience with peer review, we strongly recommend that you review COPE’s ethics guidance on peer review.
Disclosure & conflict of interest
It is imperative that you declare all potential competing or conflicting interests. Should you be uncertain as to whether a potential competing interest may impede your ability to conduct a review, please do not hesitate to raise it. A competing interest may be personal, financial, intellectual, professional, political or religious in nature. If you are currently employed at the same institution as any of the authors or have recently (within the last three years) been a mentor, mentee, close collaborator or co-grantee, you should refrain from accepting a review. Furthermore, you should not agree to review a manuscript simply for the purpose of seeing it, without the intention of submitting a review. Similarly, you should not agree to review a manuscript that is substantially similar to one you have prepared or reviewed in another journal.
Obeying the Timeline
It is courteous to respond to an invitation to peer review within a reasonable time frame, even if you are unable to undertake the review. If you have been authorised to review a particular manuscript, you should only accept the review if you are able to return it within the proposed or mutually agreed timeframe. Should your circumstances change and you be unable to fulfil your original agreement or require an extension, you are required to inform the journal immediately. If you are unable to review, it is advisable to suggest alternative reviewers, if relevant, based on their expertise and without any personal considerations or intention to receive a particular result (positive or negative).
Contribution, Confidentiality, Objectivity and Accountability Standarts
Reviewers are the main members contributing to the quality of the journal being a peer reviewed one. Please note that the editor requests a fair, honest and unbiased assessment of the manuscript's strengths and weaknesses. The Engineering Perspective manuscript evaluation form enables reviewers to provide feedback to the authors and submit confidential comments to the editor, which will not be visible to the authors. Engineering Perspective also requests a recommendation for acceptance, minor revision, major revision or rejection. Any recommendation must be consistent with the comments provided in the review. If you have not yet had the opportunity to review the entire article, please indicate which aspects you have evaluated. It is important to ensure that your comments and suggestions to the editor are consistent with your report to the authors. The majority of feedback should be included in the report that the authors will see. Confidential comments to the editor should not contain any defamatory or unfounded accusations, as the authors will not see your comments. Please note that the editors of Engineering Perspective will be sensitive to this and have the right to disregard inconsistent, contradictory and subjective referee reports and to invite new referees if necessary.
The reviewers who feel unqualified to review the received manuscript must swiftly notify the editor and reject to review that manuscript. Reviewers prepare their reports personally and remain responsible for their assessments and recommendations. All manuscripts and review materials are treated as confidential. Reviewers must not contact authors directly about the manuscript or its review; communication is conducted through the handling editor. Reviewers must obtain prior approval from the handling editor before involving another person in the review. Any approved contributor must be identified to the editor, formally assigned to the review process and subject to the same confidentiality and conflict-of-interest requirements. Confidential material must not be shared with anyone who has not been authorised and assigned to participate. It is imperative that you refrain from making any disparaging or unjustified criticisms of the work of any competitor mentioned in the manuscript. Do not suggest that authors add citations to your (or an associate's) work solely to increase the number of citations or to increase the visibility of your or an associate's work. Instead, suggestions should be based on valid academic or technological reasons. Do not intentionally extend the review period by delaying the submission of your review or requesting superfluous supplementary information from the journal or the author.
Action in Suspicion of Ethics Violations
Should you become aware of any irregularities in research and publication ethics, please report them to chief editor of the Engineering Perspective. For instance, you may have reservations that improper conduct has taken place during the writing and submission of research or a manuscript, or you may observe notable similarities between the manuscript and a simultaneous submission to another journal or a published article. In the event of these or any other ethical concerns, please contact the editor directly and refrain from conducting your own investigation. While it is acceptable to collaborate with the journal in a confidential manner, you should not conduct further research unless the journal requests additional information or advice.
Data Sharing and Reproducibility
Engineering Perspective encourages authors to share the data, code and other materials needed to verify and reproduce their findings. Data sharing is voluntary. When authors share data in a suitable repository, they are encouraged to cite the datasets in the reference list and include a DOI or another persistent identifier where available.
All original research and review articles must include a Data Availability statement before the References at submission. The statement is included in the published article and describes whether and how the data supporting the findings are available. If access is restricted, authors must explain the restriction and describe any permitted route and conditions for access. Authors who choose not to share their data may state that choice without giving a reason. If no datasets were generated or analyzed, authors must state this explicitly.
The journal encourages authors to follow the FAIR Principles for research data and the CARE Principles where Indigenous data are involved. Authors are encouraged to follow reporting guidelines appropriate to their study design, such as PRISMA for systematic reviews, and to register studies or protocols where this is standard practice in their field.
Complaints and Appeals
Complaints may concern the journal’s procedures, publication ethics, staff, Editorial Board, or Publisher. Appeals are requests by authors to reconsider an editorial decision.
Complaints and appeals should be submitted to the Editor-in-Chief at acalam@gazi.edu.tr . Requests should identify the manuscript or article, where applicable, describe the concern, and provide supporting evidence. Appeals must explain the scientific, factual, or procedural grounds for reconsideration and address the reasons given for the original decision.
Receipt is acknowledged, and an initial assessment determines the appropriate handling of the case. Relevant parties may be asked to respond or provide additional information. Independent expert advice may be obtained where necessary.
Complaints are assessed by a person with appropriate responsibility and no relevant conflict of interest. A person whose conduct is the subject of a complaint must not determine its outcome. Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief or Publisher are referred to an independent editor, Editorial Board member, or external adviser.
Appeals are assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. Possible outcomes include upholding the original decision, obtaining further review, or reconsidering the manuscript. Reconsideration does not guarantee acceptance. Final manuscript decisions remain the responsibility of an editor without a relevant conflict of interest.
The outcome and reasons are communicated to the complainant or appellant, subject to confidentiality requirements. Updates are provided if the assessment is prolonged.
Confidentiality is protected as far as possible, consistent with a fair assessment and necessary communication with relevant parties. Anonymous concerns are considered when sufficient information is available for assessment. Allegations of research misconduct are handled under the corresponding section of this policy.
Post-publication Discussion and Correspondence
Engineering Perspective welcomes evidence-based scientific comments, questions and criticisms concerning published articles. Correspondence should be sent to the Editor-in-Chief at acalam@gazi.edu.tr, identifying the article and its DOI or publication link, explaining the points raised, and providing supporting references or evidence where applicable. Correspondents should disclose any relevant competing interests.
Comments are assessed on their scientific substance. The authors of the article are normally invited to respond, and independent expert advice may be sought where necessary.
Substantive correspondence and author responses may be considered for publication following editorial assessment and with the contributors’ agreement. Published correspondence will identify and link to the relevant article.
Allegations of misconduct and issues requiring a correction, an Expression of Concern or retraction are handled under the corresponding sections of this policy.
Handling Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct
Anyone may report suspected misconduct concerning a submitted manuscript or published article to the Editor-in-Chief at acalam@gazi.edu.tr. Concerns may include fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, citation manipulation or manipulation of peer review. Reports should identify the manuscript or article, describe the concern and include any supporting evidence available. The journal considers anonymous reports when they contain enough information for assessment and protects the identity of the person raising the concern as far as possible.
An editor without a relevant conflict of interest assesses the report. Where further inquiry is warranted, the editor seeks a response from the parties concerned and may obtain independent expert advice. Cases involving the Editor-in-Chief or the publisher are referred for independent assessment under the journal’s Complaints and Appeals policy.
Where appropriate, the journal contacts the relevant research institution, shares information needed for its inquiry and considers its findings. The journal remains responsible for decisions concerning the manuscript and the published record.
Before publication, the editor may pause processing while the concern is assessed. The journal rejects a manuscript if misconduct is substantiated. After publication, the journal may issue a correction, an Expression of Concern or a retraction under the applicable policy. Where contact details are available, the journal acknowledges receipt and communicates the outcome to the person who raised the concern, subject to confidentiality.
The journal follows COPE guidance on responding to concerns raised directly and cooperation with research institutions.
Engineering Perspective maintains the integrity of the published record through transparent corrections and editorial notices. Articles affected by errors or misconduct ordinarily remain accessible, with any correction, Expression of Concern or retraction clearly linked to the original publication. Removal of published content is considered only in the exceptional circumstances specified in the journal’s policy on article removal or replacement.
Article Retraction
Engineering Perspective is committed to upholding the integrity of the scholarly record. In some instances, it may be necessary to retract articles. The following COPE criterias explained in COPE Retraction Guidline will be used to determine whether an article should be retracted:
>There are clear evidence that the findings are unreliable, either as a result of major error (eg, miscalculation or experimental error), or as a result of fabrication (eg, of data) or falsification (eg, image manipulation)
>It constitutes plagiarism
>The findings have previously been published elsewhere without proper attribution to previous sources or disclosure to the editor, permission to republish, or justification (ie, cases of redundant publication)
>It contains material or data without authorisation for use
>Copyright has been infringed or there is some other serious legal issue (eg, libel, privacy)
>It reports unethical research
>It has been published solely on the basis of a compromised or manipulated peer review process
>The author(s) failed to disclose a major competing interest (aka, conflict of interest) that, in the view of the editor, would have unduly affected interpretations of the work or recommendations by editors and peer reviewers.
Editor follows these steps in any case of possible retraction;
1. The journal editor is alerted to an article that may require retraction.
2. The journal editor should follow the recommended procedure, as outlined by COPE, which includes evaluating a response from the author of the article in question.
3. Prior to taking any action, the editor collates all the relevant findings. An additional Ethics Advisory Board may be constituted from the Editorial Board of the Journal. This step is intended to guarantee a uniform approach in line with industry best practices.
4. The final decision regarding retraction is then communicated to the author.
5. The journal promptly publishes a freely accessible notice labelled “Retraction”. The notice identifies the original article by title and author names, links to its DOI or DergiPark page, and states who is retracting the article and why.
Please note that while authors may retain copyright for an article, this does not automatically entitle them to retract it after publication. The integrity of the published scientific record is of paramount importance, and COPE's Retraction Guidelines still apply in such cases.
Expressions of Concern
Engineering Perspective may publish an Expression of Concern when significant and credible concerns about the reliability of a published article cannot be resolved promptly and the available evidence does not yet support a definitive editorial decision. This may occur while an investigation is ongoing or further information is awaited. An authorship dispute alone does not normally warrant an Expression of Concern.
The notice will be clearly labelled, freely accessible, and linked to the original article, with a corresponding link from the article to the notice. It will identify the article and explain the reasons for concern objectively. An Expression of Concern does not, by itself, establish misconduct.
The journal will review the notice when relevant new evidence becomes available and publish an appropriate follow-up explaining whether the concerns have been resolved or whether a correction or retraction is required. Where the concerns remain unresolved, the notice may remain in place. Such cases are handled in accordance with COPE guidance on Expressions of Concern.
Article Correction
Once an article has been accepted for publication, Engineering Perspective will send it to the author for a final check. It is of the utmost importance that authors exercise the utmost care when proofreading.
Errors identified after publication are assessed and, where necessary, addressed through a separate correction article that clearly identifies the original publication and includes a link to its DOI or DergiPark page. Engineering Perspective may issue a correction in the event that a minor section of a generally reliable publication contains erroneous data or information that is misleading, particularly if this is due to an honest mistake, if the author or contributor list contains errors, such as the omission of a deserving author or the inclusion of someone who does not meet authorship criteria, we will take appropriate action.
A publisher correction (erratum) is issued to notify readers of an important error made by publishing/journal staff. This is usually a production error that has a negative impact on the publication record, the scientific integrity of the article, or the reputation of the authors or the journal.
An author correction (corrigendum) is issued to notify readers of an important error made by the authors which has a negative impact on the publication record, the scientific integrity of the article, or the reputation of the authors or the journal.
Addendum: an additional contribution from the authors to clarify inconsistencies, expand existing work, or otherwise explain or update information in the main article.
The decision as to whether a correction should be issued is made by the Editor(s) of a journal, sometimes with input from reviewers or editorial board members. Handling editors will contact the authors of the paper in question with a request for clarification. However, the final decision regarding the necessity of a correction and, if so, the type of correction, rests with the editors.
Article Removal or Replacement
In exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to remove a published article from our online platform. Such action will only be taken in cases where an article is clearly defamatory, infringes the legal rights of others, or is the subject of a court order. It may also be taken in cases where the article poses a serious health risk. In such instances, while the metadata (i.e. title and author information) of the article will be retained, the text will be replaced with a screen indicating that the article has been removed for legal reasons.
In cases where an article may pose a serious health risk, the authors of the original paper may choose to retract the flawed original and replace it with a corrected version. In such instances, the standard procedures for retraction will be followed, with the exception that the retraction notice will include a link to the corrected, republished article, along with a history of the document.