Bibliometric analysis of leadership styles

Year 2021, Volume: 35 Issue: 1, 161 - 189, 31.03.2021

Tuğba Gül Baynal Doğan , Sermed Doğan , Ebru Aykan

Abstract

Leadership concept is a research field that takes place in the literature as the area of interest of researchers from past to present. As a result of changes in organizations and employee expectations, the concept of leadership is constantly developing and different leadership styles enter the literature. Among these leadership styles, ethical leadership, visionary leadership, charismatic leadership, transformational leadership, servant leadership, transactional leadership and authentic leadership are frequently preferred in the literature. The aim of the study is to make a bibliometric analysis of the articles published in the international literature especially regarding these leadership styles, which have a tendency to increase since 2009, with various parameters. In accordance with this purpose, the articles published in SSCI, SCI-EXPANDED and A & HCI citation indexes on the Web of Science database between 1975 and 2020 were examined and the data obtained were mapped with VOSviewer 1.6.15 software version. As a result of the analysis, it was determined that the journal with the most articles on the mentioned leadership styles was "Leadership Quarterly", while the journal with the most citations was "Journal of Applied Psychology". In terms of the number of citations, Shamir, House and Arthur (1993) 's work was the most cited article, while the most cited researcher in the author co-citation network was Bass. The most used keyword within the scope of the articles examined is transformational leadership as well as it has been determined that this keyword has an intense relationship with transactional leadership. When the country-institutional cooperation is examined, the United States of America leads the countries and Erasmus University leads the institutions.

Keywords

Leadership, Leadership Styles, Bibliometric Analysis

Liderlik tarzlarının bibliyometrik analizi

Abstract

Liderlik kavramı geçmişten günümüze araştırmacıların ilgi alanı olarak literatürde yer bulan bir araştırma sahasıdır. Örgütlerde ve çalışan beklentilerinde yaşanan değişimler neticesinde liderlik kavramı sürekli gelişerek farklı liderlik tarzları literatüre girmektedir. Bu liderlik tarzlarından etik liderlik, vizyoner liderlik, karizmatik liderlik, dönüşümcü liderlik, hizmetkar liderlik, etkileşimci liderlik ve otantik liderlik literatürde sıklıkla kullanılmaktadır. Özellikle 2009 yılından bu yana artış eğilimi gösteren bu liderlik tarzları ile ilgili uluslararası alanyazında yayımlanan makalelerin çeşitli parametrelerle bibliyometrik bir analizini yapmak çalışmanın amacını oluşturmaktadır. Bu amaç doğrultusunda 1975-2020 yılları arasında Web of Science veri tabanı üzerinde SSCI, SCI-EXPANDED ve A&HCI atıf indekslerinde yayımlanmış makaleler incelenerek elde edilen veriler VOSviewer 1.6.6 yazılım versiyonu ile haritalandırılmıştır. Analiz sonucunda bahsi geçen liderlik tarzları ile ilgili en fazla makalenin yayımlandığı dergi “Leadership Quarterly” iken en fazla atıf alan dergi “Journal of Applied Psychology” dergisi olduğu tespit edilmiştir. Atıf sayısı bakımından Shamir, House ve Arthur (1993)’un çalışması en fazla atıf alan makale iken, yazar ortak atıf ağında en fazla alıntılanan araştırmacı Bass olmuştur. İncelenen makaleler kapsamında en fazla kullanılan anahtar kelime dönüşümcü liderlik olmakla birlikte bu anahtar kelimenin etkileşimci liderlik ile yoğun ilişki içinde olduğu saptanmıştır. Ülke kurum işbirliği incelendiğinde ise ülkelere Amerika Birleşik Devletleri, kurumlara ise Erasmus Üniversitesi öncülük etmektedir.

Keywords

Liderlik, Liderlik Tarzları, Bibliyometrik Analiz

References

• Al, U. & Tonta, Y. (2004). Atıf analizi: Hacettepe Üniversitesi kütüphanecilik bölümü tezlerinde atıf yapılan kaynaklar, Bilgi Dünyası, 5(1), 19-47.
• Alilyyani, B., Wong, C. A., & Cummings, G. (2018). Antecedents, mediators, and outcomes of authentic leadership in healthcare: A systematic review. International Journal Of Nursing Studies, 83, 34-64.
• Alvesson, M., & Einola, K. (2019). Warning for excessive positivity: Authentic leadership and other traps in leadership studies. The Leadership Quarterly, 30(4), 383-395.
• Anderson, M. (2017). Transformational leadership in education: A review of existing literature. International Social Science Review, 93(1), 4.
• Andriani, S., Kesumawati, N., & Kristiawan, M. (2018). The influence of the transformational leadership and work motivation on teachers performance. International Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 7(7), 19-29.
• Arnold, K. A., Turner, N., Barling, J., Kelloway, E. K., & McKee, M. C. (2007). Transformational leadership and psychological well-being: the mediating role of meaningful work. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), 193.
• Aslan, Ş. (2019). Geçmişten Günümüze Liderlik Kuramları, 2. Baskı, Eğitim Yayınevi, Konya.
• Avolio, B.J. & Gardner, W.D. (2005). Authentic leadership development: Getting to the root of positive forms of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 16, 315-338.
• Avolio, B.J., Luthans, F. & Walumba, F.O. (2004). Authentic leadership: Theory building for veritable sustained performance. Working paper: Gallup Leadership Institute, University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
• Aykan, E. (2002). Girişimcilik ve girişimcilerin liderlik davranışları (Kayseri’de bir uygulama). Erciyes Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Kayseri.
• Bar-Llan, J. (2008). Informetrics at the beginning of the 21st century—A review. Journal of Informetrics, 2(1), 1–52.
• Bass, B.M. (1985a). Leadership: good, better, best. Organizational Dynamics, 13(3), 26-40.
• Bass, B. M. (1985b). Leadership and performance beyond expectation. New York, NY: Free Press.
• Bass, B. M. (1990a). Bass & Stogdill'shand book of leadership: Theory, research, and managerial applications. Third Edition, Simon and Schuster, NewYork.
• Bass, B. M. (1990b). From transactional to transformational leadership: Learning to share the vision. Organizational Dynamics, 18(3), 19-31.
• Bass, B. M., & Steidlmeier, P. (1999). Ethics, character, and authentic transformational leadership behavior. The Leadership Quarterly, 10(2), 181-217.
• Bass, B. M., Avolio, B. J., Jung, D. I., & Berson, Y. (2003). Predicting unit performance by assessing transformational and transactional leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(2), 207–218.
• Bayram, Ö. G. (1998). Atıf verisi (citationdata) ve enformetrik yasalar: Türk kütüphanecilik literatüründeki doktora tezleri üzerinde bir uygulama. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 12(1), 21-32.
• Bernarto, I., Bachtiar, D., Sudibjo, N., Suryawan, I. N., Purwanto, A., & Asbari, M. (2020). Effect of transformational leadership, perceived organizational support, job satisfaction toward life satisfaction: Evidences from indonesian teachers. International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology, 29(3), 5495 – 5503.
• Blau, P. M. (1964). Exchange and Power in Social Life. Transaction Publisher, New York.
• Brown, M., Trevino, L. & Harrison, D. (2005). Ethical leadership: a social learning perspective for construct development and testing. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 97, 117–134
• Brown, M.E. & Treviño, L.K. (2006). Ethical leadership: a review and future directions. The Leadership Quarterly, 17, 595–616.
• Buil, I., Martínez, E., & Matute, J. (2019). Transformational leadership and employee performance: The role of identification, engagement and proactive personality. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 77, 64-75.
• Burch, T. C., & Guarana, C. L. (2014). The comparative influences of transformational leadership and leader–member exchange on follower engagement. Journal of Leadership Studies, 8(3), 6-25.
• Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. Harper Torchbooks, 1st edition, New York.
• Choi, J. (2006). A motivational theory of charismatic leadership: Envisioning, empathy, and empowerment. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies,13(1), 24-43.
• Cobo, M. J., López‐Herrera, A. G., Herrera‐Viedma, E., & Herrera, F. (2011). Science mapping software tools: Review, analysis, and cooperative study among tools. Journal of the American Society for information Science and Technology, 62(7), 1382-1402.
• Cooley, C.H. (1902). Human Nature and Social Order. Scribners, NewYork.
• Çelik, S. (2019). Turizm alanında liderlik konusu ile ilgili hazırlanmış tezlere yönelik bibliyometrik bir analiz. Journal of Academic Value Studies, 5(4), 516-527.
• Datta, B. (2015). Assessing the effectiveness of authentic leadership. International Journal of Leadership Studies, 9(1), 62-75.
• Davutoğlu N. A. (2018a, Nisan). The perceptual effects of Industry 4.0 on transformational leadeship management (ss.1295-1302). Innovation and Global Issues in Social Sciences Congress Book.
• Davutoğlu, N. A. (2018b). Sanayi 4.0’ın Liderlik Ve İnsan Kaynakları Yönetimine Algısal Etkileri. Journal of Social And Humanities Sciences Research, 5(30), 4041-4048.
• Deichmann, D., & Stam, D. (2015). Leveraging transformational and transactional leadership to cultivate the generation of organization-focused ideas. The Leadership Quarterly, 26(2), 204-219.
• Den Hartog, D.N. (2015). Ethical Leadership. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 2:409–434.
• Dennis, R. S., & Bocarnea, M. (2005). Development of the servant leadership assessment instrument. Leadership & Organization Development Journal. 26(8), 600-615.
• Densten I. L. (2005). The relationship between visioning behaviours of leaders and follower burnout, British Journal of Management, 16, 105–118.
• Derin, N., Demirtaş, Ö. & Baynal Doğan, T. G. (2020). Vizyoner liderlik davranışlarının örgütsel destek aracılığıyla örgütsel vatandaşlık davranışları üzerindeki etkisi: psikolojik rahatlığın düzenleyici rolü. Pamukkale Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, 41, 550-562.
• Dirik, H.F. & İntepeler, S.Ş. (2019). Geçmişten günümüze otantik liderlik ve sağlık alanına yansımaları, Sağlık ve Hemşirelik Yönetimi Dergisi, 2(6), 164-170.
• Doğan, S., & Baynal Doğan, T. G. (2020). Uluslararası alanyazında sağlık turizmi alt bileşenleri üzerine bibliyometrik bir analiz. Hacettepe Sağlık İdaresi Dergisi, 23(4), 561-586.
• Duan, J., Li, C., Xu, Y., & Wu, C. H. (2017). Transformational leadership and employee voice behavior: A pygmalion mechanism. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 38(5), 650-670.
• Ebener, D. R., & O'Connell, D. J. (2010). How might servant leadership work?. Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 20(3), 315-335.
• Eva, N., Robin, M., Sendjaya, S., van Dierendonck, D., & Liden, R. C. (2019). Servant leadership: A systematic review and call for future research. The Leadership Quarterly, 30(1), 111-132.
• Ferch, S. R. (2020). Servant-leadership, forgiveness, and social justice. Voices of Servant-Leadership Series, 119.
• Gamarra, M. P., & Girotto, M. (2021). Ethical behavior in leadership: a bibliometric review of the last three decades. Ethics & Behavior, 1-23.
• Gardner, W. L., Cogliser, C. C., Davis, K. M., & Dickens, M. P. (2011). Authentic leadership: A review of the literature and research agenda. The Leadership Quarterly, 22(6), 1120-1145.
• Garfield, E. (Ed.). (1991). Journal citation reports. Institute for Scientific Information. Philadelphia.
• Garrigos-Simon, F.J., Narangajavana-Kaosiri, Y. & Lengua-Lengua, I. (2018). Tourism and sustainability: a bibliometric and visualization analysis. Sustainability, 10(6), 1-23.
• Gökkurt, Ö. (1997). “Citation” indeks ve “citation” analizi: enformetrik bir model enformetrik bir model çalışması [Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi]. Ankara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü.
• Grabo, A., Spisak, B. R., & van Vugt, M. (2017). Charisma as signal: An evolutionary perspective on charismatic leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 28(4), 473-485.
• Greenleaf, R. K. (2002). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. Paulist Press, New Jersey.
• Groves, K. S. (2006). Leader emotional expressivity visionary leadership, and organizational change. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 27(7), 566-583.
• Gumusluoglu, L., & Ilsev, A. (2009). Transformational leadership, creativity, and organizational innovation. Journal of Business Research, 62(4), 461-473.
• Gürbüz, S. & Şahin, F. (2018). Sosyal Bilimlerde Araştırma Yöntemleri. Seçkin Yayıncılık, 5. Baskı, Ankara.
• Harter, S. (2002). Authenticity. Snyder C. R. & Lopez S. J. (Eds.). Handbook of Positive Psychology, (pp.382-394) .Oxford University Press, New York.
• Hoch, J. E.,Bommer, W. H., Dulebohn, J. H., & Wu, D. (2018). Do ethical, authentic, and servant leadership explain variance above and beyond transformational leadership? A meta-analysis. Journal of Management, 44(2), 501-529.
• Howell, J.M. & Avolıo, B.J. (1992). The ethics of charismatic leadership: submission or liberation?, Academy of Management Executive, 6(2), 43-54.
• Hsieh, C.C. & Wang, D.S. (2015). Does supervisor-perceived authentic leadership ınfluence employee work engagement through employee-perceived authentic leadership and employee trust?. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 26(18), 2329-2348.
• Imani, B., Mirezati, S.Z. & Saberi, M.K. (2019). A bibliometric analysis of ınternational journal of nursing studies (1963 – 2018), Library Philosophy and Practice, 1-14.
• Jensen, U. T., Andersen, L. B., Bro, L. L., Bøllingtoft, A., Eriksen, T. L. M., Holten, A. L., ... & Würtz, A. (2019). Conceptualizing and measuring transformational and transactional leadership. Administration & Society, 51(1), 3-33.
• Judge, T. A., & Piccolo, R. F. (2004). Transformational and transactional leadership: a meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Journal of applied psychology, 89(5), 755.
• Karakus, M. (2017). Bibliometric analysis of ethical leadership research in social sciences. Electronic International Journal of Education, Arts, and Science (EIJEAS), 3(7).
• Kearney, E., Shemla, M., van Knippenberg, D., & Scholz, F. A. (2019). A paradox perspective on the interactive effects of visionary and empowering leadership. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 155, 20-30.
• Kessler, M. M. (1963). Bibliographic coupling between scientific papers. American Documentation, 14(1), 10-25.
• Khalil, G. M., & Crawford, C. A. G. (2015). A bibliometric analysis of US-based research on the behavioral risk factor surveillance system. American journal of preventive medicine, 48(1), 50-57.
• Khan, N. (2017). Adaptive or transactional leadership in current higher education: A brief comparison. International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 18(3), 178-183.
• Le Blanc, P. M., González-Romá, V., & Wang, H. (2020). Charismatic leadership and work team innovative behavior: The role of team task interdependence and team potency. Journal of Business and Psychology, 1-14.
• Li, M., Lehto, X., & Li, H. (2020). 40 years of family tourism research: bibliometric analysis and remaining issues. Journal of China Tourism Research, 16:1, 1-22
• Luo, Y. J., Li, Y. P., Choi, J. N., & Du, J. (2020). Visionary leadership effectiveness: Moderating roles of power distance and middle-way thinking. Social Behavior and Personality: An İnternational Journal, 48(12), 1-12.
• Mayer, D. M., Aquino, K., Greenbaum, R. L., & Kuenzi, M. (2012). Who displays ethical leadership, and why does it matter? An examination of antecedents and consequences of ethical leadership. Academy of Management Journal, 55(1), 151-171.
• McClean, E., & Collins, C. J. (2019). Expanding the concept of fit in strategic human resource management: An examination of the relationship between human resource practices and charismatic leadership on organizational outcomes. Human Resource Management, 58(2), 187-202.
• McCleskey, J. A. (2014). Situational, transformational, and transactional leadership and leadership development. Journal of Business Studies Quarterly, 5(4), 117.
• Merigó, J. M., Blanco‐Mesa, F., Gil‐Lafuente, A. M., & Yager, R. R. (2017). Thirty years of the International Journal of Intelligent Systems: A bibliometric review. International Journal of Intelligent Systems, 32(5), 526-554.
• Merigó, J. M., Cancino, C. A., Coronado, F., & Urbano, D. (2016). Academic research in innovation: a country analysis. Scientometrics, 108(2), 559-593.
• Meslec, N., Curseu, P. L., Fodor, O. C., & Kenda, R. (2020). Effects of charismatic leadership and rewards on individual performance. The Leadership Quarterly, 31(6), 101423.
• Mihelic, K. K., Lipicnik, B., & Tekavcic, M. (2010). Ethical leadership. International Journal of Management & Information Systems (IJMIS), 14(5), 31-42.
• Mittal, R., & Dorfman, P. W. (2012). Servant leadership across cultures. Journal of World Business, 47(4), 555-570.
• Mulet-Forteza, C., Martorell-Cunill, O., Merigó, J .M., Genovart-Balaguer, J. & Mauleon-Mendez, E. (2018). Twenty five years of the journal of travel & tourism marketing: a bibliometric ranking. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 35(9), 1201-1221.
• Najam, U., & Mustamil, N. (2020). Servant leadership: A bibliometric Review. International Journal of Organizational Leadership, 9(3), 138-155.
• Niñerola, A., Sánchez-Rebull, M. V., & Hernández-Lara, A. B. (2019). Tourism research on sustainability: A bibliometric analysis. Sustainability, 11(5), 1377.
• Nwachukwu, C., Chladkova, H., Zufan, P., & Olatunji, F. (2017). Visionary leadership and its relationship to corporate social performance. Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research, 3(4), 1302-1311.
• Nwankwo, S. & Richardson B. (1996). Quality management through visionary leadership, Managing Service Quality: An International Journal, 6(4), 44-47.
• Osareh, F. (1996). Bibliometrics, citation analysis and co-citation analysis: A review of literature I. Libri, 46(3), 149-158.
• Özel, Ç. H., & Kozak, N. (2012). Turizm pazarlaması alanının bibliyometrik profili (2000-2010) ve bir atıf analizi çalışması. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 26(4), 715-733.
• Parris, D. L., & Peachey, J. W. (2013). A systematic literature review of servant leadership theory in organizational contexts. Journal of Business Ethics, 113(3), 377-393.
• Pillai, R., Schriesheim, C. A. & Williams, E. S. (1999). Fairness perceptions and trust as mediators for transformational and transactional leadership: A two-sample study. Journal of Management, 25(6), 897-933.
• Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., Moorman, R. H., & Fetter, R. (1990). Transformational leader behaviors and their effects on followers' trust in leader, satisfaction, and organizational citizenship behaviors. The Leadership Quarterly, 1(2), 107-142.
• Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., Lee, J. Y., & Podsakoff, N. P. (2003). Common method biases in behavioral research: a critical review of the literature and recommended remedies. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(5), 879.
• Prestiadi, D., Zulkarnain, W., & Sumarsono, R. B. (2019, December). Visionary leadership in total quality management: efforts to improve the quality of education in the industrial revolution 4.0. In The 4th International Conference on Education and Management (COEMA 2019) (pp. 202-206). Atlantis Press.
• Purwanto, A., Bernarto, I., Asbari, M., Wijayanti, L. M., & Hyun, C. C. (2020). Effect of transformational and transactional leadership style on public health centre performance. Journal of Research in Business, Economics, and Education, 2(1), 304-314.
• Qasim, M., Rizvi, T. H., & Irshad, M. (2020). Impact of ethical leadership on task performance and organizational citizenship behavior: moderating role of ıslamic work ethics. Journal of Management and Research, 7(2), 166-193.
• Qiu, H. & Chen, Y.F. (2009). Bibliometric analysis of biological ınvasions research during the period of 1991 to 2007. Scientometrics, 81(3), 601-610.
• Russell, R. F. (2001). The role of values in servant leadership. Leadership & Organization Development Journal. 22(2), 76-84.
• Russell, R. F., & Stone, A. G. (2002). A review of servant leadership attributes: Developing a practical model. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 23(3), 145-157.
• Samul, J. (2020). The Research Topics of Leadership: Bibliometric Analysis from 1923 to 2019. International Journal of Educational Leadership and Management, 8(2), 116-143.
• Sendjaya, S., & Sarros, J. C. (2002). Servant leadership: Its origin, development, and application in organizations. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 9(2), 57-64.
• Shamir, B., House, R. J., & Arthur, M. B. (1993). The motivational effects of charismatic leadership: A self-concept based theory. Organization Science, 4(4), 577-594.
• Shanti, C. M., Gunawan, I., & Sobri, A. Y. (2020, December). Relationship of school visionary leadership and organizational climate with teacher performance. In 1st International Conference on Information Technology and Education (ICITE 2020) (pp. 624-629). Atlantis Press.
• Sinkovics, N. (2016). Enhancing the foundations for theorising through bibliometric mapping. International Marketing Review, 33(3), 327-350.
• Smith L. C. (1981). Citation analysis. Library Trends, 30(1): 83-106.
• Sözen Şahne, B. & Şar, S. (2015). Liderlik kavramının tarihçesi ve Türkiye’de ilaç endüstrisinde liderliğin önemi. Marmara Pharmaceutical Journal, 19:109-115.
• Stouten, J., Van Dijke, M., & De Cremer, D. (2012). Ethical leadership an overview and future perspectives. Journal of Personnel Psychology, 11(1), 1–6.
• Supriyadi, D., Syafitri, L. N. H., Widodo, S. F. A., Wahidi, R., Arinta, Y. N., Nabhan, F., ... & Cahyono, Y. (2020). Innovation and authentic leadership of Islamıc Unıversıty lectures in faculty pharmacy faculty: what is the role of psychological capital?. Systematic Reviews in Pharmacy, 11(8), 383-393.
• Tal, D., & Gordon, A. (2016). Leadership of the present, current theories of multiple involvements: A bibliometric analysis. Scientometrics, 107(1), 259-269.
• Taylor, C. M., Cornelius, C. J., & Colvin, K. (2014). Visionary leadership and its relationship to organizational effectiveness. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 35(6), 566-583.
• Tims, M., Bakker, A. B., & Xanthopoulou, D. (2011). Do transformational leaders enhance their followers' Daily work engagement?. The Leadership Quarterly, 22(1), 121-131.
• Tracey, J. B., & Hinkin, T. R. (1998). Transformational leadership or effective managerial practices?. Group & Organization Management, 23(3), 220-236.
• Tuan, L. T., & Thao, V. T. (2018). Charismatic leadership and public service recovery performance. Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 36(1), 108-123.
• van Dierendonck, D. (2011). Servant leadership: A review and synthesis. Journal of management, 37(4), 1228-1261.
• Van Eck, N. J., & Waltman, L. (2010). Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics, 84(2), 523-538.
• Van Eck, N. J., Waltman, L., Dekker, R., & van den Berg, J. (2010). A comparison of two techniques for bibliometric mapping: Multidimensional scaling and VOS. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 61(12), 2405-2416.
• van Knippenberg, D., Van Dick, R. & Tavares, S. (2007). Social identity and social exchange: identification, support and with drawal from the job. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 37(3), 457–477.
• Vogel, B., Reichard, R. J., Batistič, S., & Černe, M. (2020). A bibliometric review of the leadership development field: How we got here, where we are, and where we are headed. The Leadership Quarterly, 101381.
• Wang, B., Pan, S. Y., Ke, R. Y., Wang, K. & Wei, Y. M. (2014). An overview of climate change vulnerability: a bibliometric analysis based on web of science database. Natural Hazards, 74(3), 1649-1666.
• Wolcott, H. F. (1994). Transforming qualitative data: description, analysis and interpretation. Thousand Oaks, SAGE, London.
• Xiao, H. & Smith, S.L.J. (2006). The maturation of tourism research: evidence from a content analysis, Tourism Analysis, 10(4), 335-348.
• Yang, L., Chen, Z., Liu, T., Gong, Z., Yu, Y. & Wang, J. (2013). Global trends of solid waste research from 1997 to 2011 by using bibliometric analysis. Scientometrics, 96(1), 133-146.
• Yekeler, K. (2015).Dönüştürücü liderlik davranışlarının örgütsel bağlılığa etkisinde etkileşimci liderlik davranışlarının rolü, Atatürk Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Doktora Tezi, Erzurum.
• Yıldırım, A. ve Şimşek, H. (2013). Sosyal bilimlerde nitel araştırma yöntemleri. Genişletilmiş 9. Baskı, Seçkin Yayıncılık, Ankara.
• Yıldız, T., & Aykanat, Z. (2016). Yönetim ve organizasyon alanındaki liderlik çalışmalarının gelişiminin bibliyometrik analiz yöntemiyle incelenmesi (ss.120-130). 15. Ulusal İşletmecilik Kongresi, İstanbul.
• Yukl, G., Mahsud, R., Hassan, S., & Prussia, G. E. (2013). An improved measure of ethical leadership. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 20(1), 38-48.
• Zhu, W., Avolio, B. J., & Walumbwa, F. O. (2009). Moderating role of follower characteristics with transformational leadership and follower work engagement. Group & Organization Management, 34(5), 590-619.
• Zou, X., Yue, W.L. & Vu, H.L. (2018). Visualization and analysis of mapping knowledge domain of road safety studies. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 118, 131-145.