Prioritization of upcycling and recycling applications for the management of waste printed circuit boards by using S-LCA and MCDM

Abstract

In this study, the upcycling and recycling applications for the management of waste printed circuit boards (PCBs) were compared through the sequential application of Streamlined Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA) and Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques. Upcycling applications were determined as gold, copper-tin alloy, lead, copper recovery and activated carbon production. And, portland cement, aggregate, sawdust, fiberglass and styrene butadiene rubber (SBR) productions were taken account as recycling applications. At the S-LCA stage, CML-IA baseline and ReCiPe 2016 methods were used for the characterization. For the MCDM study, environmental, technical and economic criteria were determined. Remarkable characterization results of S-LCA were used as the environmental criteria of MCDM. The Entropy method was used for the weighting of the criteria. TOPSIS method was used to compare the alternatives based on weighted criteria. S-LCA study shows that impact categories of Abiotic Depletion Potential (element basis), Total Ecotoxicity Potential and Human Toxicity Potential are the major impact categories. MCDM study shows that the gold recovery (0.9845) as an upcycling application and SBR production (0.7361) as a recycling application have been determined as the first applications to be applied to waste PCBs in terms of environmental, technical and economic aspects.

Keywords

• Life cycle assessment
• Multi-criteria decision methods
• Printed circuit board
• Recycling
• Upcycling

References

1. W. Zhao, J. Xu, W. Fei, Z. Liu, W. He and G. Li, “The reuse of electronic components from waste printed circuit boards: A critical review,” Environmental Science: Advances., 2, 196-214, 2023.
2. J.Van Yken, K.Y. Cheng, N.J. Boxall, A.N. Nikoloski, N. Moheimani, M. Valix, M., ... and A.H. Kaksonen, “Potential of metals leaching from printed circuit boards with biological and chemical lixiviants,” Hydrometallurgy, 196, 105433, 2020.
3. Y.Zhu, B. Li, Y. Wei, S. Zhou and H. Wang, “Recycling potential of waste printed circuit boards using pyrolysis: Status quo and perspectives,” Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 173, 437-451, 2023.
4. J. Chen, J. He, L. Zhu, Q. Yao, Y. Sun, C. Guo, B. Yang, “Efficient recovery of valuable metals from waste printed circuit boards via ultrasound-enhanced flotation,” Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 169, 869-878, 2023.
5. L. Ali, H.A. Mousa, M. Al-Harahsheh, S. Al-Zuhair, B. Abu-Jdayil, M. Al-Marzouqi and M.Altarawneh, “Removal of bromine from the non-metallic fraction in printed circuit board via its co-pyrolysis with alümina,” Waste Management, 137, 283-293, 2022.
6. M.Y.Khalid, Z.U. Arif, W. Ahmed and H. Arshad, “Recent trends in recycling and reusing techniques of different plastic polymers and their composite materials,” Sustainable Materials and Technologies, 31, e00382, 2022.
7. H. Jung, G. Shin, H. Kwak, L.T. Hao, J. Jegal, H.J. Kim and D.X. Oh, “Review of polymer technologies for improving the recycling and upcycling efficiency of plastic waste,” Chemosphere, 138089, 2023.
8. K.M. Wyss, B. Deng and J.M. Tour, “Upcycling and urban mining for nanomaterial synthesis,” Nano Today, 49, 101781, 2023.

9. S. Yi, H. Lee, J. Lee and W. Kim, “Upcycling strategies for waste electronic and electrical equipment based on material flow analysis,” Environmental Engineering Research, 24(1), 74-81, 2019.
10. L.H. Xavier, M. Ottoni and L.P.P. Abreu, “A comprehensive review of urban mining and the value recovery from e-waste materials,” Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 190, 106840, 2023.
11. G.Martinez-Ballesteros, J.L.Valenzuela-Garcia, A. Gomez-Alvarez, M.A.Encinas-Romero, F.A. Mejia-Zamudio and A.D.J. Rosas-Durazo, “Base metals extraction from printed circuit boards by pressure acid leaching,” Minerals, 13(1), 98, 2023.