Hybrid Technologies for Water Heating Applications: A Review

Abstract

The over-reliance on fossil resources necessitates the development of a sustainable energy system. Renewable energy and efficient hybrid water heating technologies are viable net-zero energy options. The economic benefits of these hybrid technologies offer a promising prospect for widespread adoption in developing countries as a means of increasing the hot water production. These hybrid technologies are becoming increasingly popular for domestic thermal applications in remote areas to compensate for energy shortages. This paper provides an overview of hybrid renewable water heating technologies with a focus on hybrid configurations, optimization techniques, mono-particle, and hybrid nanofluids and modelling. This paper also highlights the prospects for increasing the economic attractiveness and public acceptance of such systems.

Keywords

• Water Heating
• Hybrid Technology
• Optimization
• Heat Pump
• Nanofluids

References

1. [1] Jaziri, A., Boughamoura, J., Müller, B., Mezghani, F,. Tounsi, M., and Ismail, M., “A comprehensive review of Thermoelectric Generators: Technologies and common applications”, Energy Reports, 6:264–287, (2020).
2. [2] IEA,“Africa Energy Outlook 2019-World Energy Outlook special Report, Retrieved from www.iea.org/reports/africa-energy-outlook-2019” , Accessed: 17-January-2020, (2019).
3. [3] Rinaldi, F., Moghaddampoor, F., Najafi, B., and Marchesi, R., “Economic feasibility analysis and optimization of hybrid renewable energy systems for rural electrification in Peru”, Clean Technology Environment Policy, 23(3):731–748, (2021).
4. [4] Olabomi, R., Jaafar, A., and Musa, M., “The Potentials of Solar Thermal Technology for Sustainable Development in Nigeria” , International Journal Engineering and Technical Research., 3(7):181–186,( 2015).
5. [5] Fan, L., Liu, G.,Wang, F.,Geissen, V., Ritsema, C., and Tong, Y.,“Water use patterns and conservation in households of Wei River Basin” , Resources Conservation and Recycling, 74: 45–53, (2013).
6. [6] Love, J.,“The addition of heat pump electricity load profiles to GB electricity demand : Evidence from a heat pump field trial”, Applied Energy, 204:332–342, (2017).
7. [7] Lima, T., Dutra, J., Primo, A., Rohatgi, J., and Ochoa, A., “Solar water heating for a hospital laundry: A case study” , Solar Energy, 122: 737–748, (2015).
8. [8] Şerban, A., Bărbuţă-Mişu, N., Ciucescu, N., Paraschiv, S., and Paraschiv, S.,“Economic and environmental analysis of investing in solar water heating systems”, Sustainability, 8(12): 1286 (2016).

9. [9] Tazay, A., “Techno-Economic Feasibility Analysis of a Hybrid Renewable Energy Supply Options for University Buildings in Saudi Arabia”, Open Engineering, 11(1): 39–55, ( 2020).
10. [10] Donev, G., Van Sark, W., Blok, K., and Dintchev, O., “Solar water heating potential in South Africa in dynamic energy market conditions” , Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16(5): 3002–3013, (2012).
11. [11] IEA, “Space heating and water heating account for nearly two thirds of U.S. home energy use” , Retrieveed from: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=37433, Accessed:29-may-2021, (2021).
12. [12] Hohne, P., Kusakana, K., and Numbi, B., “Operation Cost Minimisation of Hybrid Solar/Electrical Water Heating Systems: Model Development”, Advanced Science Letters., 24(11): 8076–8080, (2018).
13. [13] Balke, E., Healy,W., and Ullah, T., “An assessment of efficient water heating options for an all-electric single family residence in a mixed-humid climate”, Energy and Buildings, 133: 371–380, (2016).
14. [14] Serale, G., Fiorentini, M., Capozzoli, A., Cooper, P., and Perino, M., “Formulation of a model predictive control algorithm to enhance the performance of a latent heat solar thermal system”, Energy Conversion and Management, 173(3): 438–449, (2018).
15. [15] Sangoi, J., and Ghisi, E., “Energy efficiency of water heating systems in single-family dwellings in Brazil” , Water , Switzerland, 11(5): 1068, (2019).
16. [16] Hohne, P., Kusakana, K. and Numbi, B., “Optimal energy management and economic analysis of a grid-connected hybrid solar water heating system : A case of Bloemfontein , South Africa”, Sustainable Energy and Technolology Assessments, 31:273–291,(2019).
17. [17] Sun, H, Li., and Zhang,Y., “Performance investigation of a combined solar thermal heat pump heating system”, Applied Thermal Engineering ,71(1): 460–468,( 2014).
18. [18] Maleki, A., Rosen, M., and Pourfayaz, F., “Optimal operation of a grid-connected hybrid renewable energy system for residential applications”, Sustainability, 9(8): 1314, (2017).
19. [19] Sawle, Y., Gupta, S., and Bohre, A., “PV-wind hybrid system: A review with case study”, Cogent Engineering, 3(1): 1189305, (2016).
20. [20] Mohamed, M., Eltamaly, A., and Alolah, A., “PSO-based smart grid application for sizing and optimization of hybrid renewable energy systems”, PLoS One, 11(8): e0159702, (2016).
21. [21] Torreglosa, J., García-Triviño, P., Fernández-Ramirez, L., and Jurado, F., “Control based on techno-economic optimization of renewable hybrid energy system for stand-alone applications” , Expert System. Application, 51:59–75,( 2016).
22. [22] Cheng, L.,Guo, B.,and Li, K.,“Design and Optimization of a Hybrid Energy System for Decentralized Heating”, Fluid Dynamics Material Processing, 17(1): 49–70, (2021).
23. [23] Khakimova, A., “Hybrid model predictive control for optimal energy management of a smart house” , Proceedings of the 15. IEEE International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering , Trento, Italy, (2015).
24. [24] Langer , L., and Volling, T., “An optimal home energy management system for modulating heat pumps and photovoltaic systems”, Applied Energy, 278:115661, (2020).
25. [25] Sichilalu, S., Tazvinga, H., and Xia, X., “Integrated energy management of grid-tied-PV-fuel cell hybrid system”, Energy Procedia , 103:111–116, (2016).
26. [26] Sichilalu, S., Mathaba, T., and Xia, X., “Optimal control of a wind–PV-hybrid powered heat pump water heater”, Applied. Energy, 185:1173–1184, (2017).
27. [27] Wanjiru, M., Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X., “Optimal control of heat pump water heater-instantaneous shower using integrated renewable-grid energy systems”, Applied Energy, 201: 332–342, (2017).
28. [28] Wanjiru, E., Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X., “Model predictive control of heat pump water heater-instantaneous shower powered with integrated renewable-grid energy systems”, Applied Energy, 204: 1333-1346, (2017).
29. [29] Wanjiru, E., Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X., “Optimal control of heat pump water heater-instantaneous shower using integrated renewable-grid energy systems”, Applied Energy, 201:. 332–342, ( 2017).
30. [30] Ko, M., Kim, S., Chung, H., and Jeon, C., “Multi-objective optimization design for a hybrid energy system using the genetic algorithm”, Energies, 8(4): 2924–2949, (2015).
31. [31] Zhang, W., Maleki, A., Birjandi, A., Alhuyi Nazari, M., and Mohammadi, O., “Discrete optimization algorithm for optimal design of a solar/wind/battery hybrid energy conversion scheme” , International Journal Low-Carbon Technology, 16(2): 326–340, (2021).
32. [32] Amer, M., Namaane, A., and Sirdi, N., “Optimization of hybrid renewable energy systems (HRES) using PSO for cost reduction”, Energy Procedia, 42: 318–327, (2013).
33. [33] Waseem, M., Eftekhari, M., and Steffen,T., “Investigating the performance of a combined solar system with heat pump for houses”, Energy Building, 63:138–146, (2013).
34. [34] Mehrpooya, M., Hemmatabady, H., and Ahmadi, M., “Optimization of performance of Combined Solar Collector-Geothermal Heat Pump Systems to supply thermal load needed for heating greenhouses”, Energy Conversion and Management, 97: 382–392, (2015).
35. [35] Poppi, N., Sommerfeldt, C., Bales, H., Madani, H., and Lundqvist, P.,“Techno-economic review of solar heat pump systems for residential heating applications” , Renewenable and Sustainable Energy Review, 81: 22–32, (2018).
36. [36] Ibrahim, O., Fardoun, F., Younes, R., and Louahlia-gualous H., “Optimal management proposal for hybrid water heating system”, Energy and Buildings, 75: 342–357, (2014).
37. [37] Li, Y., and Kao,W., “Performance analysis and economic assessment of solar thermal and heat pump combisystems for subtropical and tropical region”, Solar Energy, 153: 301–316, (2017).
38. [38] Emmi, G., Zarrella, A., and De Carli M., “A heat pump coupled with photovoltaic thermal hybrid solar collectors : A case study of a multi-source energy system”, Energy Conversion and Management, 151: 386–399, (2017).
39. [39] Nasruddin, M., “Exergetic-Economic analysis and optimization of solar assisted heat pump using Multi-objective Genetic Algorithm”, Proceedings of the 2. International Conference on Tropical Renewable Energy (i-TREC), Bali, Indonesia, ( 2018).
40. [40] Hohne, P., Kusakana, K., and Numbi, B., “A review of water heating technologies : An application to the South African context”, Energy Reports, 5: 1–19, (2019).
41. [41] Sichilalu, S.,and Xia, X., “Optimal power dispatch of a grid tied-battery-photovoltaic system supplying heat pump water heaters ”, Energy Conversion and Management, 102: 81–91, (2015).
42. [42] Sichilalu, S., Tazvinga, H., and Xia, X., “Optimal control of a fuel cell/wind/PV/grid hybrid system with thermal heat pump load” , Solar Energy, 135: 59–69, (2016).
43. [43] Sichilalu,S., Xia, X., and Zhang, J., “Optimal scheduling strategy for a grid-connected photovoltaic system for heat pump water heaters”, Energy Procedia, 61: 1511–1514, (2014.
44. [44] Shan, F., Cao, L., and Fang, G., “Dynamic performances modeling of a photovoltaic-thermal collector with water heating in buildings”, Energy and Buildings, 66: 485-494, (2013).
45. [45] Li, H., and Yang, H., “Study on performance of solar assisted air source heat pump systems for hot water production in Hong Kong”, Applied Energy, 87(9): 2818–2825, (2010).
46. [46] Kjellson, E., " Solar Collectors Combined with Ground-Source Heat Pumps in Dwellings", (2009).
47. [47] Okubanjo, A., Ofualagba, G., and Oshevire, O.,“Model-based simulation of a solar thermal heat pump hyrid system for a smart house” , Science Forum, 21(1):1-11, (2021).
48. [48] Ren, H., Wu, Q., Gao, W., and Zhou, W., “Optimal operation of a grid-connected hybrid PV/fuel cell/battery energy system for residential applications”, Energy, 113: 702–712, (2016).
49. [49] Chen, H., Zhang, P., Jie, Y., Xiong, P., Xu, P., and. Zhai, H., “Performance study of heat-pipe solar photovoltaic/thermal heat pump system” , Applied Energy, 190:960–980, (2017).
50. [50] Wanjiru, E., Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X., “Optimal operation of integrated heat pump-instant water heaters with renewable energy” , Energy Procedia, 105: 2151–2156, (2017).
51. [51] Bellos, E., and Tzivanidis, C., “Multi-objective optimization of a solar assisted heat pump-driven by hybrid PV ”, Applied Thermal Engineering, 149: 528-535, ( 2018).
52. [52] Herrando, M., and Markides, C., “Hybrid PV and solar-thermal systems for domestic heat and power provision in the UK : Techno-economic considerations” , Applied Energy, 161: 512–532, (2016).
53. [53] Panaras, G.,Mathioulakis, E., and Belessiotis,V., “Investigation of the performance of a combined solar thermal heat pump hot water system”, Solar Energy, 93: 169–182, (2013).
54. [54] Nema, P., Nema, R., and Rangnekar, S., “A current and future state of art development of hybrid energy system using wind and PV-solar: A review” , Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 13(8): 2096–2103, (2009).
55. [55] Gebrehiwot, K.,Mondal,M., Ringler, C., and Gebremeskel, A.,“Optimization and cost-benefit assessment of hybrid power systems for off-grid rural electrification in Ethiopia” , Energy, 177:234–246,( 2019).
56. [56] Skoplaki, E., and Palyvos, J., “On the temperature dependence of photovoltaic module electrical performance: A review of efficiency/power correlations”, Solar Energy, 83(5): 614–624, (2009).
57. [57] Mondal, M.,Bryan, E.,Ringler,C.,and Rosegrant, M.,“Ethiopian power sector development: Renewable based universal electricity access and export strategies”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 75: 11–20, (2017).
58. [58] Chen, H., and Polinder, H., “Optimization of multibrid permanent-magnet wind generator systems” , IEEE Transctions on Energy Conversion, 24(1): 82–92, (2009).
59. [59] Vaishak, S., and Bhale, P. V., “Photovoltaic/thermal-solar assisted heat pump system: Current status and future prospects,” Solar Energy, 189(3): 268–284, (2019).
60. [60] Zhang, S., Zhang, K.,Li, X., Li, Y., and Zhang, X., “Study on performance of storage tanks in solar water heater system in charge and discharge progress”, Energy Procedia, 48: 384–393, (2014).
61. [61] Hong, T., Koo, C., Kwak, T., and Park, H., “An economic and environmental assessment for selecting the optimum new renewable energy system for educational facility”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 29: 286–300, (2014).
62. [62] Okubanjo, A,A., Godswill, O., and Patrick, O., “Cost Optimization of Hybrid Solar/ Heat Pump Water Heating System : Model Formulation” , Proceedings of the 2022 IEEE Nigeria 4th International Conference on Disruptive Technologies for Sustainable Development (NIGERCON), Nigeria, Abuja,(2022).
63. [63] Xu, G., Zhang, X., Deng, S., and Yang, L., “ Operating Characteristics of a Photovoltaic/ Thermal Integrated Heat Pump System”, Proceedings of the 8. International Conference on Regfigeration and Air Conditioning, Purdue, United State, (2018).
64. [64] Mahajan, A., Leyffer, S., Linderoth, J., Luedtke, J., and Munson, T., “A review and comparison of solvers for convex MINLP” , Optimization and Engineering, 13(2): 301–338, (2021).
65. [65] Kronqvist, D. E. Bernal, A. Lundell, and I. E. Grossmann, A review and comparison of solvers for convex MINLP", 20(2): 397-455, ( 2019).
66. [66] Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X.,“Optimal power dispatch of a grid tied-battery-photovoltaic system supplying heat pump water heaters”, Energy Conversion and Management, 102: 81-91, (2015).
67. [67] Nualboonrueng, T., Ueda, Y., Hırayama, K., and Akısawa, A.,“A simulation of the performance of PVthermal（PVT) systems for residential application in Tokyo”, Journal of JSES, 38(2): 37–46 , (2012).
68. [68] Katoch, S., Chauhan, S., and Kumar, A., " A review on genetic algorithm: past, present, and future", Multimedia Tools and Applications, 80(5): 8091-81262, (2021).
69. [69] Mayer, M., Szilágyi, A., and Gróf, G., “Environmental and economic multi-objective optimization of a household level hybrid renewable energy system by genetic algorithm”, Applied Energy, 269: 115058, (2020).
70. [70] Liu, C.,Wang, Z., Han, W., Kang, Q., and Liu, M., “Optimization of a Heat Pump-enhanced Solar Multifunctional Heating System Using Genetic Algorithm” Proceedings of the 23. International Conference on Concentrating Solar Power and Chemical Energy Systems , Daegu, South Korea, (2020).
71. [71] Soltani, M., Farzanehkhameneh, P., Moradi Kashkooli, F., Al-Haq, A., and Nathwani,J., “Optimization and energy assessment of geothermal heat exchangers for different circulating fluids” , Energy Conversion and Management, 228: 113733,( 2021).
72. [72] Starke, R., Cardemil, J., and Colle, S., “Multi-objective optimization of a solar-assisted heat pump for swimming pool heating using genetic algorithm”, Applied Thermal Engineering, 142: 118–126, (2018).
73. [73] Javed, S., and Ma, T.,“Techno-economic assessment of a hybrid solar-wind-battery system with genetic algorithm”, Energy Procedia ,158: 6384–6392, (2019).
74. [74] Miglani, S., Orehounig, K., and Carmeliet, J., “Design and optimization of a hybrid solar ground source heat pump with seasonal regeneration”, Energy Procedia , 122: 1015–1020, ( 2017).
75. [75] Atia, D., Fahmy, F., Ahmed, N., and Dorrah, H., “Optimal sizing of a solar water heating system based on a genetic algorithm for an aquaculture system”, Mathematical Compututer Modelling, 55(3):1436–1449, (2012).
76. [76] Wang, D.,Tan, D.,and Liu, L., “Particle swarm optimization algorithm: an overview”, Soft Computing, 22(2): 387–408, (2018).
77. [77] Makhdoomi, S., and Askarzadeh, A., “Optimizing operation of a photovoltaic/diesel generator hybrid energy system with pumped hydro storage by a modified crow search algorithm”, Journal of Energy Storage, 27(3): 101040, (2020).
78. [78] Sahu, A., Panigrahi, S.,and Pattnaik, S.,“Fast Convergence Particle Swarm Optimization for Functions Optimization”, Procedia Technology, 4: 319–324, (2012).
79. [79] Yoshida, Y., “Optimization of Residential PV and Water Heating System ’s Configration and Operation Using Multi-Objective Particle Swarm Optimization”, 2: 2–6,(2016).
80. [80] Ma, R., Yu, N., and Hu, J., “Application of Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm in the Heating System Planning Problem” , Handbook of Neural Computation, 2013: 571-579, (2017).
81. [81] Perrigot, A., “Technical economic analysis of PV-driven electricity and cold cogeneration systems using Particle Swarm Optimization algorithm ”, 211: 119009, (2020).
82. [82] Sim, M., Suh, D., and Otto, M., “Multi-Objective Particle Swarm Optimization-Based Decision Support Model for Integrating Renewable Energy Systems in a Korean Campus Building,” Sustainability, 3(15): 8660, (2021).
83. [83] Dada, E., Joseph, F., Oyewola, D., Fadele, A., Chiroma, H., and Abdulhamid, S., “Application of Grey Wolf Optimization Algorithm: Recent Trends, Issues, and Possible Horizons”, Gazı University Journal of Science, 35(1): 1-21, (2021).
84. [84] Chicco, G., and Mazza, A., “Metaheuristic optimization of power and energy systems: Underlying principles and main issues of the ‘rush to heuristics” , Energies, 13(19): 5097, (2020).
85. [85] Mohammad Zadeh, P., Sokhansefat, T., Kasaeian, A., Kowsary, F., and Akbarzadeh, A., “Hybrid optimization algorithm for thermal analysis in a solar parabolic trough collector based on nanofluid” , Energy, 82: 857–864, (2015).
86. [86] El Sehiemy, R., Selim, F., Bentouati, B., and Abido, M., “A novel multi-objective hybrid particle swarm and salp optimization algorithm for technical-economical-environmental operation in power systems”, Energy, 193: 116817, (2020).
87. [87] Neshat, M., and Sepidname, G.,“A new hybrid optimization method inspired from swarm intelligence: Fuzzy adaptive swallow swarm optimization algorithm (FASSO)”, Egyptian Informatics Journal, 16(3): 339–350, (2015).
88. [88] Lahiri, S.,and Khalfe,N., “Hybrid particle swarm optimization and ant colony optimization technique for the optimal design of shell and tube heat exchangers” , Chemical Product and Process Modeling, 10(2): 81–96, (2015).
89. [89] Khan, A., Hizam, H., Bin, N., Wahab, A., and Othman, M., “Optimal power flow using hybrid firefly and particle swarm optimization algorithm”, PLoS One, 15(8): 1–21, (2020).
90. [90] Arslan, G., and Yaman, K.,“The Optimization of Solar Water Heating System Using Hybrid Algorithm (PSO/HJ) for Different Locations of Turkey” , Uluslararası Muhendislik Arastirma ve Gelistirme Dergisi, 1: 73-8273–82, (2017).
91. [91] Wu, M., Bao, Y, Q., Zhang, J., and Ji, T., “Multi-objective optimization for electric water heater using mixed integer linear programming”, Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy, 7(5): 1256–1266,(2019).
92. [92] Jamali, B., Rasekh, M., Jamadi, F., Gandomkar, R., and Makiabadi, F., “Using PSO-GA algorithm for training artificial neural network to forecast solar space heating system parameters" , Appied Thermal Engineering, 147: 647–660, (2019).
93. [93] Wong, K. ,and De Leon, O., “Applications of nanofluids: Current and future”, Advances in Mechnical Engineering, 2: 1-11, (2020).
94. [94] Olfian, H., Ajarostaghi,S., and Ebrahimnataj, M., “Development on evacuated tube solar collectors: A review of the last decade results of using nanofluids”, Solar Energy, 211(2): 265–282, (2020).
95. [95] Farhana, K., Kadirgama, K., Rahmam, M., Ramasamy, D., Noor, M., and Najafi, G.,, “Improvement in the performance of solar collectors with nanofluids — A state-of-the-art review”, Nano-Structures and Nano-Objects, 18: 100276, (2019).
96. [96] Jamil, F., and Ali, H., "Applications of hybrid nanofluids in different fields", 1: 215-254, Elsevier, (2020).
97. [97] Shah, T., and Ali, H., “Applications of hybrid nanofluids in solar energy, practical limitations and challenges: A critical review”, Solar Energy,183(2): 173–203, (2019).
98. [98] Harrabi, L., Hamdi, M., and Hazami, M., “Long-Term Performances and Technoeconomic and Environmental Assessment of Al2O3/Water and MWCNT/Oil Nanofluids in Three Solar Collector Technologies”, Journal of Nanomaterials, 2021: 1-18, ( 2021).
99. [99] Younis, A., Onsa, M., Alhorr, Y., and Elsarrag, E., “The Influence of Al2O3- ZnO-H2O Nanofluid on the Thermodynamic Performance of Photovoltaic- Thermal Hybrid Solar Collector System”, Innovative Energy and Resarch, 7(1): 1–8, (2018).
100. [100] Javadi, H., Urchueguia, J.,Ajarostaghi, S., and Badenes, B., “Impact of employing hybrid nanofluids as heat carrier fluid on the thermal performance of a borehole heat exchanger”, Energies, 14(10): 1–26, (2021).
101. [101] Wole-Osho, I., Adun, H., Adedeji, M., Okonkwo, E., Kavaz, D., and Dagbasi, M., “Effect of hybrid nanofluids mixture ratio on the performance of a photovoltaic thermal collector”, International of Journal of Energy Research, 44(11): 9064–9081, (2020).
102. [102] Yıldırım, E., and Yurddaş, A., “Assessments of thermal performance of hybrid and mono nanofluid U-tube solar collector system”, Renewable Energy, 171: 1079–1096, ( 2021).
103. [103] Okonkwo, E., Wole-Osho, I., Kavaz, D., Abid, M., and Al-Ansari, T., “Thermodynamic evaluation and optimization of a flat plate collector operating with alumina and iron mono and hybrid nanofluids”, Sustainable Energy Technology and Assessments, 37(1): 100636, (2020).
104. [104] Verma, A., Tiwari, K., Tiwari, S., and Chauhan, D., “Performance analysis of hybrid nanofluids in flat plate solar collector as an advanced working fluid”, Solar Energy, 167(1): 231–241, (2018).
105. [105] Tahat, M., and Benim, A., “Experimental Analysis on Thermophysical Properties of Al2O3/CuO Hybrid Nano Fluid with its Effects on Flat Plate Solar Collector”, Defect Diffusion Forum, 374: 148–156, (2017).
106. [106] Huang, W., and Marefati, M., “Energy, exergy, environmental and economic comparison of various solar thermal systems using water and Thermia Oil B base fluids, and CuO and Al2O3 nanofluids”, Energy Reports, 6: 2919–2947, (2020).
107. [107] Farajzadeh, E., Movahed, S., and Hosseini, R., “Experimental and numerical investigations on the effect of Al2O3/TiO2/H2O nanofluids on thermal efficiency of the flat plate solar collector”, Renewable Energy, 118: 122–130, (2018).
108. [108] Abid, M., Khan, M., Ratlamwala, T., Malik, M., Ali, H., and Cheok, Q.,“Thermodynamic analysis and comparison of different absorption cycles driven by evacuated tube solar collector utilizing hybrid nanofluids”, Energy Conversion and Management, 246: 114673, (2021).
109. [109] Rashid, H., Sultan, K., and Anead, H., “Thermal Performance of an Evacuated-Tube Solar Collector Using Nanofluids and an Electrical Curtain Controlled by an Artificial Intelligence Technique”, Engineering and Technology Journal, 40(2): 8–19, (2022).
110. [110] Kaya, H., Alkasem, M., and Arslan, K., “Effect of nanoparticle shape of Al 2 O 3 / Pure Water nano fl uid on evacuated U-Tube solar collector efficiency”, Renewable Energy, 162: 267–284, (2020).
111. [111] Sani, F., Pourfallah, M., and Gholinia, M.,“The effect of MoS2–Ag/ H2O hybrid nanofluid on improving the performance of a solar collector by placing wavy strips in the absorber tube”, Case Studies in Thermal Engineering, 30(1): 101750, (2022).
112. [112] Minea, A., and El-Maghlany, W., “Influence of hybrid nanofluids on the performance of parabolic trough collectors in solar thermal systems: Recent findings and numerical comparison”, Renewable Energy, 120: 350–364, (2018).
113. [113] Al-Oran, O., and Lezsovits, F., “A hybrid nanofluid of alumina and tungsten oxide for performance enhancement of a parabolic trough collector under the weather conditions of budapest”, Applied Science, 11(11): 4946, (2021).
114. [114] Farooq, M., Farhan, M., Ahmad, G., Tahir,Z., Usman, M., Sultan, M., Hanif, M., Imran, M., Anwar, S., El-Sherbeeny, A., and Shakir, M., “Thermal performance enhancement of nanofluids based parabolic trough solar collector ( NPTSC ) for sustainable environment”, Alexandria Engineering Journal, 61(11): 8943-9853, (2022).
115. [115] Adun, H., Adedeji, M., Dagbasi, M., Bamisile, O., Senol, M., and Kumar, R., “A numerical and exergy analysis of the effect of ternary nanofluid on performance of Photovoltaic thermal collecto”, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 145(3): 1413–1429, (2021).
116. [116] Karaaslan, I., and Menlik, T., “Numerical study of a photovoltaic thermal ( PV / T ) system using mono and hybrid nanoflui”, Solar Energy, 224(3): 1260–1270, (2021).
117. [117] Han, X., Chen, X., Wang, Q., Alelyani, S, M.,and Qu, J., “Investigation of CoSO4-based Ag nanofluids as spectral beam splitters for hybrid PV/T applications”, Solar Energy, 177(4): 387–394, (2019).
118. [118] Wole-osho, I., Okonkwo, E., Abbasoglu, S., and Kavaz, D., “Nanofluids in Solar Thermal Collectors : Review and Limitations”, International Journal of Thermophysics, 41(11): 1-74, (2020).
119. [119] Rasheed, T., Hussain, T., Anwar, M., Ali, J., Rizwan, K., Bilal, M., Alshammari, F., Alwadai, N., and Almuslem, A., “Hybrid Nanofluids as Renewable and Sustainable Colloidal Suspensions for Potential Photovoltaic/Thermal and Solar Energy Applications”, Frontiers in Chemistry, 9(4): 1–20, (2021).
120. [120] Kumar, A., Sharma, M., Thakur, P., Thakur, V., Rahatekar, S., and Kumar, R., “A review on exergy analysis of solar parabolic collectors”, Solar Energy, 197(1): 411–432, (2020).
121. [121] Naicker, S., Solar Water Heating: “Reducing the Barriers. Master’s Thesis, University of Kwazulu- Natal”, 5 :10–58, (2010).
122. [122] Veeraboina, P., Ratnam, G., “Analysis of the opportunities and challenges of solar water heating system (SWHS) in India: Estimates from the energy audit surveys and review”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Review, 16: 668–676, (2012).
123. [123] Djordkevic, S., Baverstock, G., Walker, E.,Urmee, T, . “Identification of the barriers for the slow uptake of solar water heaters in Australia”. Proceedings of the 52. Annual Conference of the Australian Solar Energy Society, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, (2014). [124] Urban, F., Geall, S., Wang, Y., “Solar PV and solar water heaters in China: Different pathways to low carbon energy”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Review, 64: 531–542, (2016).
124. [125] Naicker, S., Solar Water Heating: “Reducing the Barriers. Master’s Thesis, University of Kwazulu- Natal” , 5:10–58, (2010).
125. [126] Strbac, G., “Demand side management: Benefits and challenges”, Energy Policy, 36: 12, 4419–4426, (2008).
126. [127] Khakimova, A., “Hybrid model predictive control for optimal energy management of a smart house,” Proceedings of the IEEE 15 International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering (EEEIC), Rome, Itay, (2015).
127. [128] Wanjiru, M., Sichilalu, S., and Xia, X., “Optimal Operation of Integrated Heat Pump-instant Water Heaters with Renewable Energy”, Energy Procedia, 105: 2151–2156, ( 2017).
128. [129] Liu, C., and Rao, Z., “Challenges in various thermal energy storage technologies”, Science Bulletin, 62(4): 231–233, (2017).
129. [130] Shukla, A., Buddhi, D., Sawhney, R., “Solar water heaters with phase change material thermal energy storage medium: A review”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Review, 13: 2119–2125, (2019).
130. [131] Deng, J., Furbo, S., Kong, W.,Fan, J., “Thermal performance assessment and improvement of a solar domestic hot water tank with PCM in the mantle”, Energy in Buildings, 172:10–21, (2018).
131. [132] Manoj P., Mylsamy, K., “Experimental investigation of solar water heater integrated with a nanocomposite phase change material”, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 136: 121–132, (2019).