Importance Of Zoning for Vertical Circulation Planning of Densely Populated Buildings: A Simulation Based Approach for Elevator Traffic Analyses

Abstract

Elevator systems are essential in multi-story buildings, affecting circulation, travel time, and user comfort. Traditional design methods, based on mathematical calculations, provide initial estimates of elevator numbers and capacities by considering basic operational criteria. However, these methods cannot fully capture dynamic passenger flows and temporal variations in demand. Dynamic simulation-based elevator traffic analysis, on the other hand, allows for more comprehensive evaluation of elevator operations and enables testing of alternative zoning scenarios. In this study, a dynamic simulation-based analysis is applied as a case study for a hospital outpatient building. Different zoning strategies are implemented for elevator groups to evaluate their effect on system performance. Performance criteria, including Average Waiting Time (AWT), Average Time To Destination (ATTD), and Interval (INT), are assessed across different zoning scenarios and compared with values commonly reported in the literature. The results highlight the potential of zoning to improve elevator performance, including passenger handling, waiting times, and travel efficiency. Especially in buildings where physical modifications are difficult, the combination of simulation-based analysis and carefully designed zoning strategies can reveal the potential for enhancing operational performance and optimizing elevator efficiency within existing physical constraints.

Keywords

• Elevator traffic analysis
• Elevator traffic analysis for hospitals
• Use of simulation
• Zoning

References

1. [1] Batosalem, A. C., Gaba, J. M. B., Ngo, J. B. O., Ticug, J. R. G., and Ngo, C. A. M., “Static Zoning Division Elevator Traffic Simulation Using Agent-Based Modeling”, in 2019 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC), 145-156, (2019). DOI: 10.1109/WSC40007.2019.9004761
2. [2] Sarı, A., Düşey Sirkülasyon Araçları Merdivenler, YEM Kitabevi, İstanbul, (2019).
3. [3] Siikonen, M., “Planning and Control Models for Elevators in High Rise Building”, Ph.D. Thesis, Helsinki University of Technology, (1997).
4. [4] CIBSE, Transportation Systems in Buildings: CIBSE Guide D: 2015, 5th ed., CIBSE, (2015).
5. [5] Peters, R., Smith, R., and Evans, E., “The appraisal of lift passenger demand in modern office buildings”, Building Services Engineering Research and Technology, 32(2): 159-170, (2011). DOI: 10.1177/0143624410385378
6. [6] Smith, R., “Traffic Analysis Based on The Up Peak Round Trip Time Method. Why It Works and How It Can Be Improved”, in Proceedings of the 2nd Symposium on Lift and Escalator Technologies, 93-103, (2012).
7. [7] Barney, G., and Peters, R., “The Evolution of Lift Traffic Design from Human to Expert System”, in 9th Symposium on Lift & Escalator Technologies, 219-234, (2018).
8. [8] Barney, G., and Al-Sharif, L., Elevator Traffic Handbook: Theory and Practice, 1st ed., Routledge, London, (2003).

9. [9] Hakonen, H., and Siikonen, M., “Elevator Traffic Simulation Procedure”, Elevator Technology 17, Proc. of Elevcon 2008, Thessaloniki, 131-141, (2008).
10. [10] Peters, R., and Sung, C. M., “Beyond the Up Peak”, in ELEVCON BERLIN 2000, (2000).
11. [11] Peters, R., “Improvements to the Up Peak Round Trip Time Calculation”, International Journal of Elevator Engineers, 3(1), (2000).
12. [12] Ruokokoski, M., Sorsa, J., and Siikonen, M., “A Systematic Methodology for Analysing Zoning Options for a Building Using Dynamic Programming”, in 9th Symposium on Lift & Escalator Technologies, 9(1): 17-29, (2018).
13. [13] TMMOB, Asansör Avan Projesi Hazırlama Teknik Esasları, TMMOB, İzmir, (2020).
14. [14] Siikonen, M., Susi, T., and Hakonen, H., “Passenger Traffic Flow Simulation in Tall Buildings”, Elevator World 2001, 49: 117-123, (2001).
15. [15] Cortés, P., Muñuzuri, J., and Onieva, L., “Design and Analysis of a Tool for Planning and Simulating Dynamic Vertical Transport”, Simulation, 82(4): 255-274, (2006). DOI: 10.1177/0037549706066986
16. [16] Çiflikli, C., and Tartan, E. Ö., “Grup Asansör Sistemleri Simülasyonu”, Mühendis ve Makina, 59(693): 1-18, (2018).
17. [17] Peters, R., and Smith, R., “Designing Elevator Installations Using Modern Estimates of Passenger Demand”, in ELEVCON LUZERNE 2010, (2010).
18. [18] Chu, C., Lin, C., and Lam, S., “Hospital lift system simulator: A performance evaluator-predictor”, European Journal of Operational Research, 1(146): 156-180, (2003). DOI: 10.1016/S0377-2217(02)00203-5
19. [19] Çiflikli, C., and Tartan, E. Ö., “Asansör Dağıtım Yöntemlerinin İncelenmesi İçin Bir Yazılım Geliştirilmesi”, Elevator Symposium, Izmir (2016).
20. [20] Adak, M. F., “Bir Asansör Simülatörü Tasarımı ve Trafik Türünün Veri Madenciliğiyle Belirlenmesi”, MSc. Thesis, Kocaeli University, (2012).
21. [21] Peters, R., “Simulation for Control System Design and Traffic Analysis”, in ELEVCON ZURICH 1998, (1998).
22. [22] https://www.peters-research.com, Access date: 21.06.2021.
23. [23] So, A., and Al-Sharif, L., “Calculation of the elevator round-trip time under destination group control using offline batch allocations and real-time allocations”, Journal of Building Engineering, 22: 549-561, (2019). DOI: 10.1016/j.jobe.2019.01.013
24. [24] Peters, R., “Understanding the Benefits and Limitations of Destination Dispatch”, in ELEVCON HELSINKI 2006, (2006).
25. [25] Al-Sharif, L., Al Sukkar, G. M., Hakouz, A., and Al-Shamayleh, N., “Towards a Systematic Methodology for the Design of Elevator Traffic Systems in High Rise Building”, 6th Symposium on Lift and Escalator Technologies, Northampton, (2016).
26. [26] Jonathan, W.C. Ng. and Carrie K. Y. “Planning the Capacity of a Hospital Lift System”, 16(5): (2016).
27. [27] Zou, B., Lu, C., & Li, Y. (2020). “Simulation of a hospital evacuation including wheelchairs based on modified cellular automata”, Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory, 99, (2020). DOI: 10.1016/j.simpat.2019.102018
28. [28] Wang, J., Luo, Y., Zhou, X., Zhao, W., Lei, Y., and Xie, W. “Impact of assistance behavior on evacuation efficiency in high-rise hospital inpatient buildings: An agent-based simulation study”, Journal of Building Engineering, 112, (2025). DOI: 10.1016/j.jobe.2025.113780
29. [29] Adler, R., Vertical Transportation for Buildings, American Elsevier Publishing Company Inc., New York, (1970).
30. [30] Barney, G., Health Technical Memorandum 08-02 Lifts, 2016 Edition, Department of Health, (2016).
31. [31] Siikonen, M., and Suihkonen, K., “People Flow and Automated Transportation with Hospital Elevators”, Business Briefing: Hospital Engineering & Facilities Management, (2005).
32. [32] Department of Health, Health Building Note 00-04: Circulation and Communication Spaces, Department of Health and Social Care, (2013).
33. [33] T.C. Sağlık Bakanlığı, Türkiye Sağlık Yapıları Asgari Tasarım Standartları 2010 Yılı Kılavuzu, (2010).
34. [34] https://hastane.gazi.edu.tr/tr/hakkimizda/tarihce, Access date: 21.06.2021.
35. [35] Başdemir, H., “Binaların Yangın Yönetmeliğinin Ulusal Yangın Yönetmeliğine Göre Analiz Edilebilmesine Yönelik Bilgisayara Dayalı Bir Model Önerisi”, Ph.D. Thesis, Gazi University, (2010).
36. [36] Muslu, M. S., “İç Mekan Tasarımında Fiziksel Çevre Faktörlerinin Kullanıcı Memnuniyetine Etkisi; Gazi Hastanesi Çocuk Polikliniği Bekleme Holü Örneği”, MSc. Thesis, Gazi University, (2005).
37. [37] Gazi University, Gazi Üniversitesi 2019 Yılı İdari Faaliyet Raporu, Ankara, (2020).
38. [38] https://hastane.gazi.edu.tr/tr/bolumler, Access date: 21.06.2021.