International Carriage of Goods Contracts Defeated by Coronavirus: An Attempt to Identify Carrier’s Liability through Multinational Carriage of Goods Conventions

Abstract

Coronavirus (Covid-19), emerged not only as a health, social and commercial crisis, but also as a transport crisis. The initial reminiscence of the coronavirus chaos on the transport industry may have been the memory of people stranded on the Diamond Princess cruise ship when the vessel was quarantined for days. The Diamond Princess incident happened to be a bitter memory of coronavirus’s influence on passenger transport known by the whole world. On the other hand, the crisis freight transport industry experienced went rather behind closed doors. The decline in production was the main factor that led to the crisis in the international transportation market. The global measures taken to stop the spread of the virus resulted in decrease of production rates. In addition, certain animal species and food products were banned from export and import. The decrease in production and the export and import restrictions on products led to a decrease in the global movement of goods. Direct measures implemented over international freight transport also added to the already existing complexities. The closure of ports and state borders, the cessation of railway and airline activities negatively affected the conventional operation of transport vehicles. Labor restrictions and crew quarantine measures created delays in transportation processes. All in all, the measures related to Covid-19 had a direct, negative outcome for international carriage of goods contracts between shippers and carriers, which mostly resulted in delay or impossibility of delivery of goods. This article analyzes the precautionary measures taken by states in the course of the pandemic from the view of contracts of carriage of goods. Carrier’s liability will be set forth by virtue of the uniform law rules set up by multinational carriage of goods conventions.

Keywords

• COVID-19
• Coronavirus
• Transport
• Carriage of goods
• Conventions

References

1. Acar-Ünal Ö, ‘Covid-19 Virüsünün Sözleşmelere Etkisinin TBK MD. 138 Hükmü Çerçevesinde Değerlendirilmesi’ in Yusuf Çalışkan & Yeliz Bozkurt Gümrükçüoğlu and Others (eds) Koronavirüs Döneminde Güncel Hukuki Meseleler Sempozyumu Bildiri Tam Metin Kitabı (İBn HaLdun Üniversitesi YayınLarı, İstanBuL 2020) 285-330. google scholar
2. Akıncı Ş, ‘Covid-19’un Borç ilişkilerine ve Bazı Borçlar Hukuku Sözleşmelerine Etkisi’ (2020) 19(38) İstanbul Tic Üni Sos Bil Derg 62-103. google scholar
3. Arkan S, Demiryoluyla Yapılan Uluslararası Eşya Taşımaları (Banka ve Ticaret Hukuku Araştırma Enstitüsü Ankara 1987). google scholar
4. Berlingieri F, ‘A Comparative Analysis of The Hague-Visby Rules, the Hamburg Rules and the Rotterdam Rules’ https://www.uncitral. org/pdf/engLish/workinggroups /wg_3/BerLingieri _paper_comparing_RR_HamB_HVR.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
5. Bonomi A, ‘ArticLe 9: Overriding Mandatory Provisions’ in ULrich Magnus and Peter Mankowski (eds), European Commentaries on Private International Law II (ECPIL) (ECPIL) (Otto Schmidt CoLogne 2017) 599-660. google scholar
6. Bonomi A, Le Norme Imperative nel Diritto Internazionale Privato (SchuLthess Zurich 1998), (Imperative). google scholar
7. Cassar R, ‘EvoLution or DevoLution: Aviation Law and Practice After Covid-19’ (2020) 45 (SpeciaL Issue) Air & Space L 3-16. google scholar
8. ChandLer G F III, ‘A Comparison of COGSA, The Hague/VisBy RuLes, and the HamBurg RuLes’ (1984) 15(2) J Mar L & Com 233-292. google scholar

9. CLarke M A, International Carriage of Goods by Road: CMR (6th edn, RoutLedge Oxon 2014). google scholar
10. CLarke M A and Yates D, Contracts of Carriage by Land and Air (LLP London/Singapore 2004). google scholar
11. Dempsey P S and MiLde M, International Air Carrier Liability: The Montreal Convention of 1999 (McGiLL University Centre for Research in Air & Space Law MontreaL 2005). google scholar Diamond QC A, ‘The Rotterdam RuLes’ (2009) 36 LMCLQ 445-536. google scholar
12. Diederiks-Verschoor I H P and Mendes de Leon P, An Introduction to Air Law (WoLters KLuwer ALphen aan den Rijn 2012). google scholar
13. Donovan J J, ‘The HamBurg RuLes: Why a New Convention on Carriage of Goods By Sea’ (1979) 4 (1) Mar Law 1-16. google scholar
14. Eckardt T, ‘InternationaL Conference 60 Years CMR’ in Wouter Verheyen (ed) CMR 60 Years: Time for Retirement or Future Proof? (Paris LegaL PuBLishers Zutphen 2017) 39-43. google scholar
15. EftestoL-WiLheLmsson E, ‘The Rotterdam RuLes in a European MuLtimodaL Context’ (2010) 16 J Int Mar L 274-288. google scholar
16. Erkan M, ‘MÖHUK Madde 31 BağLamında Türk Hukukunda Doğrudan UyguLanan KuraLLara Bakış’ (2011) 15(2) Gazi Uni Hukuk Fak Derg 81-121. Fan V Y and Jamison D T and Summers L H, ‘Pandemic Risk: How Large Are the Expected Losses?’ (2018) 96 BuLL WorLd HeaLth Organ 129-134. FLessner A and WiLderspin M, ‘Overriding Mandatory Provisions’ in Jürgen Basedow and GieseLa RühL and Franco Ferrari and Pedro de MigueL Asensio (eds) Encyclopedia of Private International Law I (Edward ELgar PuBLishing CheLtenham/Northampton 2017) 1330-1336. google scholar
17. Force R, ‘Comparison of The Hague, Hague-VisBy, and HamBurg RuLes: Much Ado ABout (?)’ (1995-1996) 70 (6) TuL L Rev 2051 2051-2090. google scholar
18. GLass D A, Freight Forwarding and Multimodal Transport Contracts (2nd edn, RoutLedge Oxon 2012). google scholar
19. GruBer A, ‘How ArticLe 17.2 of the CMR is Interpreted By the French Courts’ in Wouter Verheyen (ed) CMR 60 Years: Time for Retirement or Future Proof? (Paris LegaL PuBLishers Zutphen 2017) 37-39. google scholar
20. IvaLdi P, ‘Carriage of Goods By Sea’ in Jürgen Basedow and GieseLa RühL and Franco Ferrari and Pedro de MigueL Asensio (eds) Encyclopedia of Private International Law I (Edward ELgar PuBLishing CheLtenham/Northampton 2017) 262-269. google scholar
21. Kara H, Rotterdam Kuralları’na Göre Taşıyanın Zıya, Hasar veya Gecikmeden Kaynaklanan Zararlardan Sorumluluğu (LegaL İstanBuL 2014). google scholar
22. KatsiveLa M, ‘Overview of Ocean Carrier LiaBiLity Exceptions under the Rotterdam RuLes and the Hague-Hague/VisBy RuLes’ (2010) 40 Rev Gen 413-466. google scholar
23. Kolacz Marta K, ‘Country Report on ArticLe 17.2 CMR’ in Wouter Verheyen (ed) CMR 60 Years: Time for Retirement or Future Proof? (Paris Legal Publishers Zutphen 2017) 48-54. google scholar
24. de La Fayette Louise, ‘Date of Access to Ports in InternationaL Law’ (1996) 11 Int’L J Marine & CoastaL L, 1-22. google scholar
25. Mankowski P, ‘The Rotterdam RuLes-Scope of AppLication and Freedom of Contract’ (2010) 2 Eur J Com Cont L 9 9-21. google scholar
26. Marisam J, ‘LocaL Governance and Pandemics: Lessons from the 1918 FLu’ (2008) 85(3) U Det Mercy L Rev, 347-383. google scholar
27. Martin-Osante J M and Martinez-BaLmaseda A, ‘ResponsaBiLidad DeL Porteador Ferroviario Por IncumpLimiento: Fundamento y Supuestos’ in ALBerto Emperanza SoBejano and Andres RecaLde CasteLLs (eds) El Contrato de Transporte Internacional de Mercancias Por Ferrocarril (Thomson Civitas PampLona 2008) 177-218. google scholar
28. Mendes de Leon P, ‘NationaL Reflexes FoLLowing the Covid-19 OutBreak: Is Sovereignty Back in the Air?’ (2020) 45 (SpeciaL Issue) Air & Space L 17-38. google scholar
29. Messent A and GLass D A, Hill & Messent CMR: Contracts for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (2nd edn, London/New York/ HamBurg/Hong Kong 1995). google scholar
30. Montanari S, ‘EpidemioLogists have Been warning of a coronavirus outBreak for years and say that another pandemic wiLL happen again’ (Business Insider, 25 March 2020), https://www.Businessinsider.com/epidemioLogists-on-chances-of-future-coronavirus-outBreak-2020-3 Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
31. Moore J C, ‘The HamBurg RuLes’ (1978-1979) 10 J Mar L & Com 1-11. google scholar
32. MoLenaar E J, ‘Port State Jurisdiction: Toward Comprehensive, Mandatory and GLoBaL Coverage’ (2007) 38 (1-2) Ocean Dev & Int’L L 225-257. google scholar
33. Murray D E, ‘The HamBurg RuLes: A Comparative AnaLysis’ (1980) 12 Law Am 59-92. google scholar
34. Özdemir T, Uluslararası Eşya Taşıma Hukuku (Zıya ve/veya Hasar Sorumluluğu) (Vedat KitapçıLık İstanBuL 2006). google scholar
35. Rainey QC S, ‘Piracy and Contracts of Carriage by Sea’ in Baris Soyer and Andrew Tettenborn (eds) Carriage of Goods by Sea, Land and Air (RoutLedge Oxon/New York 2014) 3-24. google scholar
36. Sand P, ‘Container Shipping Industry Hard Hit By US Lockdown, BIMCO News and Trends’ (BIMCO, 12 June 2020), https://www.Bimco.org/ news/market_anaLysis/2020/202000611_ container_shipping_industry_hard_hit_By_us_Lockdown Date of Access 16 May 2021. google scholar
37. ScheLin J, ‘CMR Convention in a Law and Economics Perspective’ (CMR) (2016) 21(4) Unif L Rev 434-440. google scholar
38. ScheLin J, ‘CMR LiaBiLity in a Law & Economics Perspective’ (LiaBiLity) Stockholm Institute for Scandinavian Law 1957-2010 https://scan dinavianLaw.se/pdf/46-8.pdf Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
39. SchoenBaum T J, Admiralty and Maritime Law (6th edn, West St. PauL 2019). google scholar
40. Schwartz A A, ‘Contracts and Covid-19’ (2020) 73 Stan L Rev OnLine 48-60. google scholar
41. Scott B I and Others, ‘NationaL Aviation Law Responses to Covid-19’ (2020) 45 (SpeciaL Issue) Air & Space L 195-272. google scholar
42. Sykes A O, ‘Short SuppLy Conditions and the Law of InternationaL Trade: Economic Lessons from the Pandemic’ (2020) 114(4) Am J Int L 647-656. google scholar
43. TetLey W, ‘The HamBurg RuLes-A Commentary’ (1979) 4 LMCLQ 1-20. google scholar
44. Tompkins G N, Liability Rules Applicable to International Air Transportation as Developed by the Courts in the United States (WoLters KLuwer ALphen aan den Rijn 2010). google scholar
45. UnderhiLL S A and Austin N, ‘Steering through the Covid-19 Pandemic’, Maritime Risk InternationaL 2020 (Reedsmith, May 2020) https:// www.reedsmith.com/-/media/fiLes/ perspectives/2020/mri-2020-may-reed-smith-pp911.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
46. VuraL-ÇeLenk B, Application of Third Country Overriding Mandatory Rules-Analytical Comparison of Swiss, Turkish and EU Law (SchuLthess Zurich 2018). google scholar
47. Yancey B W, ‘Carriage of Goods: Hague, Cogsa, VisBy, and HamBurg’ (1982-1983) 57(5) TuL L Rev 1238-1259. google scholar
48. YazıcıoğLu E, Hamburg Kuralları’na Göre Taşıyanın Sorumluluğu (Beta İstanBuL 2000). google scholar
49. ‘Action Cargo: Covid-19’ (IATA) https://www.iata.org/en/programs/cargo/> Date of Access 7 May 2021. google scholar
50. ‘Chairman of the American Trucking Associations in The State of Transportation and CriticaL Infrastructure: Examining the Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic’ (IRU 3 June 2020) https://www.iru.org/resources/iru-LiBrary/statement-r-guiLLot-chairman-ata> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
51. ‘Container ImBaLances and Covid-19: Freight Forwarders’ RoLe in Finding SoLutions to the ProBLems of Today’ FIATA Beyond COVID-19 (FIATA 29 ApriL 2020), https://fiata.com/Beyond-covid-19/cargo/sea-freight.htmL> Date of Access 16 May 2021. google scholar
52. ‘Coronavirus: CLuB Cover and Contracts of Carriage’ (The Swedish Club 30 ApriL 2020) https://www.swedishcLuB.com/media_upLoad/ fiLes/Corona%20virus%20COVID%2019/Coronavirus%20Cover%20and%20Contracts%20of%20Carriage%20Scenarios%20TSC.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
53. ‘COVID-19-Air Cargo Operations’ (IATA) https://tact.iata.org/covid-19/country> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
54. ‘Covid-19-Cargo Entry Point’ (Logistic Clusters 30 March 2020) https://LogcLuster.org/ sites/defauLt/fiLes / google scholar
55. Logistics_cLuster_covid-19_cargo_entry_points_up dates_200330.pdf> Date of Access 20 May 2021. google scholar
56. ‘Covid-19: GLoBaL ImpLications for Charterparties’ (Norten Rose Fulbright March 2020) https://www.nortonrosefuLBright.com/en-au/ knowLedge/puBLications/178f0135/covid-19-gLoBaL-impLications-for-charterparties> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
57. ‘Covid-19 Task Force, Management of Covid-19: First Estimation of the GLoBaL Economic Impact of Covid-19 on RaiL Transport’ (UIC JuLy 2020) https://uic.org/IMG/pdf/economic_impact_v2.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
58. ‘Covid-19 Task Force, RaiLsiLience: How the RaiL Sector Fought Covid-19 During Lockdowns’ (UIC May 2020) https://uic.org/IMG/pdf/ raiLsiLience how_the_raiL_sector_ fought_covid-19_during_Lockdowns. pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
59. ‘Covid-19 Transport Brief: GLoBaL Container Shipping and the Coronavirus Crisis’, FIATA Beyond COVID-19 (FIATA 11 May 2020) https:// fiata.com/Beyond-covid-19/practicaL-resources/Latest-deveLopments.htmL> Date of Access 20 May 2021. google scholar
60. ‘Crew Changes: A Humanitarian, Safety and Economic Crisis’ (IMO Media Centre-Hot Topics) https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/ HotTopics/Pages/FAQ-on-crew-changes-and-repatriation-of-seafarers.aspx> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
61. ‘Effects of NoveL Coronavirus (Covid-19) on CiviL Aviation: Economic Impact AnaLysis, ICAO Economic DeveLopment’ (ICAO 30 DecemBer 2020) https://www.icao.int/sustain aBiLity/Documents/COVID-19/ICAO _Coronavirus_Econ_Impact.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
62. ‘Export ProhiBitions and Restrictions Information Note’ (World Trade Organization 23 ApriL 2020) https://www.wto.org/engLish/tratop_ e/covid 19_e/export_prohiBitions_report_e.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
63. ‘G20 Trade and Investment Ministerial Statement’ (G20 Information Centre 30 March 2020) http://www.g20.utoronto.ca/2020/2020-g20-trade-0330.htmL> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
64. ‘How Covid-19 is Changing the WorLd: A StatisticaL Perspective’, Committee for the Coordination of StatisticaL Activities (World Trade Organization May 2020) https://www. wto.org/engLish/tratop_e/covid19_e/ccsa_puBLication_e.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
65. ‘Invoking Force Majeure in the Covid-19 Crisis: Some PracticaL Tips, FIATA Beyond COVID-19’ (FIATA 30 March 2020) https://fiata.com/ Beyond-covid-19/practicaL-resources /fiata-documents.htmL> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
66. ‘Joint Statement on the ContriBution of InternationaL Trade and SuppLy Chains to a SustainaBLe Socio-Economic Recovery in Covid-19 Times By UNCTAD/IMO/UNECA/ UNECE/UNECLAC/UNESCAP/UNESCWA/UNCTAD’ (UNCTAD 17 SeptemBer 2020) https://unctad.org/ system/fiLes/information-document/IMO-UNCTAD-2020-statement _en.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
67. ‘Maintaining the FLow of Goods is EssentiaL Work in the BattLe Against Covid-19’ World Shipping Council Industry Issues Corona Virus COVID-19 (World Shipping Council) https://www.worLdshipping.org/ industry-issues/coronavirus-covid19/maintaining-flow-of-goods-covid19> Date of Access 10 May 2024. google scholar
68. ‘Repatriation of Stranded Seafarers Necessary for GLoBaL Trade’ FIATA Beyond COVID-19 (FIATA 22 June 2020) http://fiata.com/ index.php? id=840&cHash=FIATA_Statement_ Seafarers_June_2020> Date of Access 10 May 2024. google scholar
69. ‘Standards, ReguLations and Covid-19-What Actions Taken By WTO MemBers?’ (World Trade Organization 4 DecemBer 2020) https://www. wto.org/engLish/tratop_e/covid19_e/ standards_report_e.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
70. ‘The ChaLLenge of HandLing Airfreight Capacities in Covid-19 and Beyond, FIATA Beyond COVID-19 (FIATA 25 May 2020)’ https://fiata.com/ Beyond-covid-19/cargo/air-freight. htmL> Date of Access 10 May 2024. google scholar
71. Travaux Preparatoires of the Hague RuLes and of the Hague-VisBy RuLes, Comite Maritime InternationaL 411 https://comitemaritime.org/ wp-content/upLoads/2018/05/Travaux-Preparatoires-of-the-Hagu e-RuLes-and-of-the-Hague-VisBy-RuLes.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
72. ‘UNCTAD Review of Maritime Transport 2020’ (UNCTAD) https://unctad.org/system/ fiLes/officiaL-document/rmt2020_en.pdf> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
73. ‘UNECE/IRU FLyer-Recommendation for Border Crossings During Covid-19’ (UNECE/IRU 27 ApriL 2020) https://www.iru.org/resources/ iru-LiBrary/Border-crossings-age-covid-19> Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
74. Commercial Union Insurance Company v Alitalia Airlines 347 F 3d 448 457-71 (2nd Cir 2003). google scholar
75. Jaycees Patou Inc v Pier Air International Ltd 714 F Supp 81 82-5 (SDNY 1989). google scholar
76. Magnus Electronics Inc v Royal Bank of Canada 611 F Supp 436 440-9 (ND ILL 1985). google scholar
77. Victoria Sales Corp v Emery Air Freight Inc 917 F 2d 705 706-12 (2nd Cir 1990). google scholar
78. Yargıtay 11 HD, 2018/1829, 2019/7402, 21.11.2019, http://www.kazanci.com Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar
79. Yargıtay 11 HD, 2019/1522, 2020/4343, 21.10.2020 http://www.kazanci.com Date of Access 10 OctoBer 2024. google scholar