Comparison of The Physical Fitness Parameters of Special Education Vocational School Students and Inclusion High School Students

Year 2024, Volume: 7 Issue: 3, 597 - 607, 25.05.2024

Mustafa Han , Şevval Akaydın , Atike Yılmaz , Serdar Koç

https://doi.org/10.33438/ijdshs.1436311

Abstract

This study compared the physical fitness parameters of intellectually disabled special education vocational school students with those of inclusive high school students using the causal comparison method. Participants consisted of 22 (15 male, 7 female) from Special Education Vocational School and 25 (20 male, 5 female) inclusion students receiving inclusive education at high school. A physical fitness form was used to collect data on body mass index (BMI), standing long jump, flexibility, right-hand reaction, left-hand reaction, leg strength, back strength, right-hand grip, left-hand grip, 30 m sprint, and push-ups. The T-test was applied to data exhibiting normal distribution, while the Mann-Whitney U test was used for data not normally distributed. Among the parameters showing normal distribution, there were significant differences between the two different student groups in the standing long jump, flexibility, left-hand reaction, leg strength, and right-left hand grip strength. Although a significant difference was observed in the right-hand reaction, no significant differences were detected for the other non-normally distributed parameters of BMI, back strength, 30-m sprint, and push-ups. Our results indicated that students with intellectual disability (ID) enrolled in inclusive education at the high school level performed better in all physical fitness tests conducted compared to their peers in special education vocational schools.

Keywords

Special education vocational school, inclusive education, intellectual disability, students with special needs, physical fitness.

Ethical Statement

No ethical violations were committed by the researchers during this research.

References

• Akın, S., & O. Yüksel. (2016). The evaluation of athlete and non-athlete mentally retarded children’s dynamic balance level. Sports Perspective: Journal of Sports and Educational Sciences, 3(1), 33-40.
• Ariffin, N., Fariq, F., N, Hamzah., & N, Ahmad. (2020). Effects of circuit training on muscular strength and power, jumping height and body composition in ıntellectual disabilities ındividuals. Journal of Social Science and Humanities, 3(2), 14-24. [CrossRef]
• Ayan, S., E. Boyalı, M. Ergin, & M. Ulaş. (2019). An ınvestıgatıon of selected physıcal and basıc motor parameters of students wıth specıal needs ın terms of age and gender varıables. Journal of International Social Research, 12(62). Baltacı, G. (2016). Physical Fitness. In: Physiotherapy & Rehabilitation. Edited by A. A. Karaduman, Ö.T. Yılmaz, Ankara: Hipokrat Publisher.
• Battaglia, G., M. Alesi, M. Inguglia, M. Roccella, C. Caramazza, M. Bellafiore, & A. Palma. (2013). Soccer practice as an add-on treatment in the management of individuals with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Neuropsychiatric Disease And Treatment, 595-603. [PubMed]
• Baynard, T., K. H. Pitetti, M. Guerra, V. B. Unnithan, & B. Fernhall. (2008). Age-related changes in aerobic capacity in individuals with mental retardation: A 20-yr review. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 40(11), 1984-1989. [PubMed]
• Beilock, S. L., T. H. Carr, C. MacMahon, & J. L. Starkes. (2002). When paying attention becomes counterproductive: impact of divided versus skill-focused attention on novice and experienced performance of sensorimotor skills. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 8(1), 6. [CrossRef]
• Ben-Zaken, S., A. Eliakim, D. Nemet, & Y. Meckel. (2019). Genetic variability among power athletes: The stronger vs. the faster. The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 33(6), 1505-1511. [CrossRef]
• Berktaş, N. (2018). The evaluatıon physıcal fıtness on educatıon able mental retarded, prıvate class and ınclusıon students. Unpublished master's thesis, Anatolian University, Institute of Health Sciences, Department of Physical Education and Sports, Eskişehir.
• Bibro, M. A., & R. Żarów. (2021). The ınfluence of climbing activities on physical fitness of people with ıntellectual disabilities. International Journal of Disability. Development and Education, 70(4), 530-539. [CrossRef]
• Bossink, L. W., A. A. van der Putten, & C. Vlaskamp. (2017). Understanding low levels of physical activity in people with intellectual disabilities: A systematic review to identify barriers and facilitators. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 68, 95-110. [PubMed]
• Bouck, E.C. (2012). Secondary students with moderate/severe intellectual disability: Considerations of curriculum and post‐school outcomes from the National Longitudinal Transition Study‐2. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 56(12), 1175-1186. [PubMed]
• Bouck, E. C., & G. S. Joshi. (2016). Transition and students with mild intellectual disability: Findings from the National Longitudinal Transition Study–2. Career Development and Transition for Exceptional Individuals, 39(3), 154-163. [CrossRef]
• Byrnes, Z. (2012). Educational psychologists in the community: Supporting parents of children with Down syndrome through times of transition. Educational and Child Psychology, (29), 81–92. [CrossRef]
• Carmeli, E., M. Ayalon, S. Barchad, S. L. Sheklow, & A. Z. Reznick. (2002). Isokinetic leg strength of institutionalized older adults with mental retardation with and without Down's syndrome. Journal Of Strength And Conditioning Research, 16(2), 316-320. [PubMed]
• Carter, E. W., L. G. Sisco, Y. Chung, & T. L. Stanton-Chapman. (2010). Peer interactions of students with intellectual disabilities and/ or autism: A map of the intervention literature. Research and Practice for Persons with Severe Disabilities, 35(3-4), 63-79. [CrossRef]
• Cenikli, A., M. Dalkılıç, & K. A . Y. A. Metin. (2018). The effects of movement training applied for 16 weeks to the physical fitness levels of children with ıntellectual disability. International Journal of Sport Culture and Science, 6(3), 350-358.
• Chaiwanichsiri, D., Sanguanrungsirikul, S., & Suwannakul, W. (2000). Poor physical fitness of adolescents with mental retardation at Rajanukul School, Bangkok. Journal of the Medical Association of Thailand= Chotmaihet thangphaet, 83(11), 1387-1392. [PubMed]
• Cuesta-Vargas, A. I., & D. Pérez-Cruzado. (2014). Relationship between Barthel index with physical tests in adults with intellectual disabilities. Springerplus, 3(1), 1-6. [CrossRef]
• Çayır, Ç. (2019). The effect of different sports activities on the motor development of children aged 7-8 years. Master's thesis, Selcuk University, Institute of Health Sciences, Department of Physical Education and Sports, Konya.
• Demirci, H. (2009). The impact of flexibility studies on the mobility development of children with trainable intellectual disabilities. Master's thesis, Sakarya Üniversty, Institute of Social Sciences, Department of Physical Education and Sports Teaching, Sakaraya.
• Demirci, N., & P. Demirci. (2014). Analysıs of the attaınments gaıned by the students ın need of specıal educatıon durıng the course of games and physıcal actıvıtıes. İnönü University Journal of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, 1(1), 25-34.
• DiSalvo, C. A., & D. P. Oswald. (2002). Peer-mediated interventions to increase the social interaction of children with autism: Consideration of peer expectations. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 17(4), 198-207. [CrossRef]
• Fernhall, B., & K. H. Pitetti. (2000). Leg strength is related to endurance run performance in children and adolescents with mental retardation. Pediatric Exercise Science, 12(3), 324-333. [CrossRef]
• Fiori, F., G. Bravo, M. Parpinel, G. Messina, R. Malavolta, & S. Lazzer. (2020). Relationship between body mass index and physical fitness in Italian prepubertal schoolchildren. PloS one, 15(5), e0233362. [PubMed]
• Fox, J., R. Shores, D. Lindeman, & P. Strain. (1986). Maintaining social initiations of withdrawn handicapped and nonhandicapped preschoolers thorough a response-dependent fading tactic. Journal of Abnormal Child Psyhology, 14(3), 387-396. [PubMed]
• Frey, G. C., & B. Chow. (2006). Relationship between BMI, physical fitness, and motor skills in youth with mild intellectual disabilities. International Journal Of Obesity, 30(5), 861-867. [PubMed]
• Gallahue, D. L., Ozmun, J. C. & J. D. Goodway. (2014). Understanding Motor Development: Infants, Children, Adolescents, Adults. McGraw-Hill: New York.
• Giagazoglou, P., F. Arabatzi, E. Kellis, M. Liga, C. Karra, & I. Amiridis. (2013). Muscle reaction function of individuals with intellectual disabilities may be improved through therapeutic use of a horse. Research İn Developmental Disabilities, 34(9), 2442-2448. [PubMed]
• Goldstein, H., & S. Wickstrom. (1986). Peer intervention effects on communicative interaction among handicapped and nonhandicapped preschoolers. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 19(2), 209-214. [CrossRef]
• Guidetti, L., E. Franciosi, M. C. Gallotta, G. P. Emerenziani, & C. Baldari. (2010). Could sport specialization influence fitness and health of adults with mental retardation?. Research İn Developmental Disabilities, 31(5), 1070-1075. [PubMed]
• Gustavsson, A., C. Wendelborg, & J. Tøssebro. (2021). Educated for welfare services—The hidden curriculum of upper secondary school for students with intellectual disabilities. British Journal of Learning Disabilities, 49(4), 424-432. [CrossRef]
• Hartman, E., J. Smith, M. Westendorp, & C. Visscher. (2015). Development of physical fitness in children with intellectual disabilities. Journal Of İntellectual Disability Research, 59(5), 439-449. [PubMed]
• Hehir, T., T. Grindal, B. Freeman, R. Lamoreau, Y. Borquaye, & S. Burke. (2016). A summary of the evidence on ınclusive education. Abt Associates: Cambridge,
• İlhan, E. L., & O. K. Esentürk. (2015). Investigation of the some physical fitness parameters of mentally retarded children and their normally developed peers. Gazi Journal of Physical Education and Sports Sciences, 20(1-4), 11-17.
• Jouira, G., S. Srihi, F. Ben Waer, H. Rebai, & S. Sahli. (2022). Comparison of dynamic balance performances of adult runners with ıntellectual disability versus their sedentary peers. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 129(5), 1443-1457. [PubMed]
• Kargar, F., & S. Talebi. (2021). A comparative study on visual memory and reaction time in students with specific learn-ing disability and normal students. Journal of Learning Disabilities 10(2), 240-253. [CrossRef]
• Kodish, S., P. H. Kulinna, J. Martin, R. Pangrazi, & P. Darst. (2006). Determinants of physical activity in an inclusive setting. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 23(4), 390-409. [CrossRef]
• Konar, N., & A. Şanal. (2020). Investigation of the effects of physical activity, exercise and sport on anaerobic and coordination parameters of individuals with mild intellectual disabilities. International Journal of Sport, Exercise and Training Sciences, 6(1), 37-44. [CrossRef]
• Krause, S., R. Ware, L. McPherson, N. Lennox, & M. O’Callaghan. (2016). Obesity in adolescents with intellectual disability: Prevalence and associated characteristics. Obesity Research and Clinical Practice, 10(5), 520-530. [CrossRef]
• Lane, K. L., W. P. Oakes, E. W. Carter, & M. Messenger. (2015). Examining behavioral risk and academic performance for students transitioning from elementary to middle school. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 17(1), 39–49. [CrossRef]
• Lange, S. J., L. Kompaniyets, D. S. Freedman, E. M. Kraus, R. Porter, H. M. Blanck, & A. B. Goodman. (2021). Longitudinal trends in body mass ındex before and during the covıd-19 pandemic among persons aged 2-19 years - United States, 2018-2020. Morbidity And Mortality Weekly Report, 70(37), 1278–1283. [PubMed]
• Leaf, J. B., M. Taubman, S. Bloomfield, L. Palos-Rafuse, R. Leaf, J. Mc Eachin, & M. L. Oppenhaim. (2009). Increasing social skills and pro-social behavior for three children diagnosed with autism through the use of a reaching package. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, 3(1), 275-289. [CrossRef]
• LeCheminant, J. (2019). Comparison of standing long jump performance in young adults with and without autism spectrum disorder. Doctoral Dissertation, California State University, Institute of Health Sciences, Department of Kinesiology, California.
• Lightfoot, L., & C. Bond. (2013). An exploration of primary to secondary school transition planning for children with Down’s syndrome. Educational Psychology in Practice, 29(2), 163–179. [CrossRef]
• Logan, S. W., L. M. Barnett, J. D. Goodway, & D. F. Stodden. (2017). Comparison of performance on process-and product-oriented assessments of fundamental motor skills across childhood. Journal of Sports Sciences, 35(7), 634-641. [PubMed]
• Mandy, W., M. Murin, O. Baykaner, S. Staunton, J. Hellriegel, S. Anderson, & D. Skuse. (2015). The transition from primary to secondary school in mainstream education for children with autism spectrum disorder. Autism, 20(1), 4–13. [PubMed]
• Marshall, S., K. Goessling, R. Young, & A.Wozniak-Molnar. (2018). Researching the transition to high school for adolescents with a disability: Qualitative action-project method as an exemplar approach. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education, 66(4), 389-408. [PubMed]
• Mayda, M. H., O. Karakoc, & M. Ozdal. (2016). The Investigation of Some Physical, Physiological and Anthropometric Parameters of Visually Impaired and Non-Impaired a National Male Judoka. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 4(6), 192-198. [CrossRef]
• McQuilliam, S. J., D. R. Clark, R. M. Erskine, and T. E. Brownlee. 2020. Free-weight resistance training in youth athletes: a narrative review. Sports Medicine, 50(9), 1567-1580. [PubMed]
• Memisevic, H., & M. Djordjevic. (2018). Visual-motor integration in children with mild intellectual disability: A meta-analysis. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 125(4), 696-717. [PubMed]
• Morley, D., R. Bailey, J. Tan, & B. Cooke. (2005). Inclusive physical education: Teachers’ views of including pupils with special educational needs and/or disabilities in physical education. European Physical Education Review, 11(1), 84-107. [CrossRef]
• Mujea, A. M. (2014). The improvement of speed in mentally deficient pupils through the use of differentiated instruction in the physical education lesson. Procedia - Social And Behavioral Sciences, 117, 534-538. [CrossRef]
• Pan, C. Y. (2008). Objectively measured physical activity between children with autism spectrum disorders and children without disabilities during inclusive recess settings in Taiwan. Journal Of Autism And Developmental Disorders, 38(7), 1292-1301. [PubMed]
• Porretta, D. L., & Winnick, J. P. (2016). Adapted physical education and sport. Human Kinetics: Champaign.
• Rao, P.T., V. Guddattu, & J. M. Solomon. (2017). Response abilities of children with down syndrome and other intellectual developmental disorders. Exp Brain Res, 235(5), 1411-1427. [CrossRef]
• Ruijs, N. M., I. Van der Veen, & T. T. Peetsma. (2010). Inclusive education and students without special educational needs. Educational Research, 52(4), 351-390. [CrossRef]
• Sansi, A., & D. Özer. (2019). Examination of physical fitness levels of young people with down syndrome by comparing typical development peers. Gaziantep University Journal of Sport Sciences, 4(4), 491-503. [CrossRef]
• Schalock, R. L., R. Luckasson, & M. J. Tassé. (2021). An overview of ıntellectual disability: definition, diagnosis, classification, and systems of supports. American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, 126(6), 439-442. [CrossRef]
• Senturk, Y., B. Kirmizigil, & E. H. Tuzun. (2021). Effects of clinical pilates on the fitness in people with children with disabilities: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Comparative Effectiveness Research, 10(5), 409-422. [CrossRef]
• Shilpa, I., & V. Reeta. (2012). The effect of a ten-week physical education training programme on mentally retarded children. Asian Man (The)-An International Journa, 6(2), 166-170. [CrossRef]
• Skowronski, W., M. Horvat, J. Nocera, G. Roswal, & R. Croce. (2009). Eurofit special: European fitness battery score variation among individuals with intellectual disabilities. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 26(1), 54- 67. [PubMed]
• Suchomel, T. J., S. Nimphius, C. R. Bellon, W. G. Hornsby, and M. H. Stone. 2021. Training for muscular strength: methods for monitoring and adjusting training intensity. Sports Medicine, 51(10), 2051-2066. [PubMed]
• Szabó, E., N. Erdei, & S. Bene. (2015). A comparative study of the physical development and motor performance of mentally non-handicapped children and children with intellectual and development disabilities. Acta Physiologica Hungarica, 102(3), 311-323. [PubMed]
• Şenlik, M. K., & E. Atılgan. (2019). The effect of regular exercise program on motor skills in adolescents with mild mental retardation. Journal of Exercise Therapy and Rehabilitation, 6(3), 140-148. [CrossRef]
• Tomaz, R. V. V., V. D. A. Santos, L. R. D. Silva de Avó, C. M. R. Germano, & D. G. Melo. (2017). Impacto da deficiência intelectual moderada na dinâmica e na qualidade de vida familiar: um estudo clínico-qualitativo. Cadernos de Saúde Pública, 33(11), e00096016.
• Top, E. (2015). Examination of the effect of 12 weeks of swimming exercise on the physical fitness levels of individuals with intellectual disabilities. Doctoral Thesis, Dumlupınar University, Institute of Social Sciences, Department of Physical Education and Sports Teaching, Kütahya.
• Top, E. (2021). Fine motor skills and attention level of individuals with mild intellectual disability getting education in inclusive classrooms and special education schools. International Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 69(2), 248-255. [PubMed]
• Turna, B., B. Erdem, & E. Aslan. (2019). Comparison of some physical parameters of ındividuals with and without mental retardation. Mediterranean Journal of Sport Sciences, 2(2), 175-183.
• Turner, S., A. Alborz, & V. Gayle. (2008). Predictors of academic attainments of young people with Down’s syndrome. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 52, 380–392. [PubMed]
• Uçan, İ., Y. Buzdağlı, & E. Ağgön. (2018). research of the effect of physıcal fıtness on sports ın chıldren. Ataturk University Journal of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, 20(3), 1-11.
• Vargas, A. C., D. P. Cruzado, & A. R. Moya. (2022). Relationship between quality of life and physical fitness in adults with intellectual disabilities. Advances in Mental Health and Intellectual Disabilities, 16(1), 44-52. [CrossRef]
• Wendelborg, C., A. M. Kittelsaa, & S. E. Wik. (2017). Overgang skole arbeitsliv for elever med utviklingshemming: Trondheim: Rapport. NTNU Samfunnsforskning. 1-186.
• Winnick, J. P., & Short, F. X. (2014). Brockport physical fitness test manual: a health-related assessment for youngsters with disabilities. Canada: Human Kinetic, 1-67.
• World Health Organization. (2007). A Safer Future - Global Public Health Security in the 21st Century. (p. 1-96) America: Paho Publications.
• Yildirim, N. Ü., F. Erbahçeci, N. Ergun, K. H. Pitetti, & M. W. Beets. (2010). The Effect of Physical Fitness Training on Reaction Time in Youth with Intellectual Disabilities. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 111(1), 178-186. [PubMed]