Volume: 4 Issue: 8 , 8/31/22

Year: 2022

Research Article

Research Article

3. Köhne Ark Sarayı 1686-1688

Systematic Reviews and Meta Analysis

Systematic Reviews and Meta Analysis

1. Kazakistan ve Türkiye Arasındaki Dış Ticaret

Translation

Book Review

Volga- Ural and Turkestan regions played important roles in history. The regions are on Silk Road from the east to west, Fur Trade Road from north to south, Spice Road from south to North and were not only an important trading place in history but also a meeting point of cultures, languages and religions. From this aspect, the regions hosted many empires and cultures. The aim of IJVUTS is to present international level of informations about the region that is components to and in interaction with each other to academic community neoterically. 

The journal is published on February and September, twice a year.
The journal has to follow publication schedule.
Double-blind systematic review is applied in the journal.
Social and human studies about Volga-Ural and Turkestan regions is published in the journal.
Studies which was published in other publication before is rejected by editor. A paper was presented in a conference or symposium must be stated in the paper.
After uploading a paper, researcher is informed by an e-mail about that the paper is sent to the journal. If this e-mail isn’t sent, the paper must be uploaded to journal again.
Papers must be proper to “Scientific Ethical Rules” of YÖK. Authors are responsible for papers that is not proper to ethical rules.
If papers sent to IJVUTS had been rejected by another journal before, this situation must be stated to the editor or an assistant editor.
Authors must reload papers editing it in accordance with prior reviews and referee reports in 10 days at the latest.
Papers are uploaded by authors. Editor views the papers and makes a prior review. This examination is not an content examination. Two expert referees examine contents and decide if papers could be published or not. If papers must be edited, referees state these points on their reports and then send them to the editor. Editor send referee reports to authors by using system. Authors must definitely apply editings take part in referee reports. Papers aren’t edited in accordance with referee reports at the appointed time are rejected by editor.
“Publishing Consultative Comitee” of the journal is being updated consistently, Arbitration Comitee is being enlarged.

For the template Click here
for the Copyright Form Click here


Articles should be written in the following format and according to the stated technical rules.

Title: Maximum 12 words summarizing the topic, Times New Roman, 14 fonts, bold, centered and only first letters are capital.
Author(s) information: No information about the author(s) (name, institution etc.) should not be included on the manuscript. However, after the approval of the manuscript, when a file is sent to the author to add information such as the name(s) and contact information, the following conditions should be taken into consideration: The name(s) and surname(s) of the author(s) need to be written clearly under the title, centered, in “Times New Roman”, “12 fonts”, bold and with a line spacing. The title(s) of the author(s), affiliated institute(s) and contact information should be written as (*) foot note, in “Times New Roman”, “10 fonts” with 1 line spacing.
Abstract: Turkish and English abstracts giving general information about the article need to be written. The length of the abstracts should be at least 150 and at most 250 words. Turkish abstract and English abstract should be written in “Times New Roman”, “10 fonts” and with 1 line spacing. Within the abstract, the purpose, method, main findings and general result of the article should be introduced.
Key Words: In this section, minimum 3 and maximum 7 key words need to be written. Key Words should be written in “Times New Roman” and “10 fonts”.
Main Sections: They should be written in “Times New Roman”, “12 fonts” and with 1.5 line spacing.
Introduction: It includes information about the purpose, significance, conceptual – theoretical framework and study in general.
Method: It gives information about the method and the process followed in the study.
Findings: It is the main section in which the collected data and findings are discussed.
Result: It is section where the conclusion reached through findings is presented.
Discussion: It is the section referring to similar studies about the same topic and discussions in literature.
Suggestions: It includes the suggestions made in light of the findings and discussions.
Note: The sequencing of the main sections may vary depending on the field and type (theoretical, empirical etc.) of the study; however, inclusion of method, discussion and suggestions sections is an obligation for empirical studies.

Referencing:
Both in-text referencing and list of references at the end should be organized according to APA 6 style.

In-text referencing

If there is a general reference within the text and reference is made to the whole text, it is enough to write surname, year.
Example: Yavuz, 2013

If there is a citation made from a certain page, then it is written as follows (Arpacı and Kuyu, 2010, s. 72), (Arpacı, Kuyu and Huysuz, 2000, s. 12-13).
In the sequencing of the citations within a parenthesis, alphabetical order is followed.
Example: (Arpacı, 2013; Arpacı and Kuyu, 2010, s. 15; Karman, 2000; Zengin, Warrant, Güner, Aykut and Karpat, 2013)

The studies of the same writer with the same publication year should be written as follows; Turgut, 2009a and Turgut 2009b.
If the number of authors is between three and five, in the first citation, the surnames of all the others need to be written and in the following citation of the same source, only the surname of the first writer needs to be written.
Example: In the first citation (Kejanlıoğlu, Adaklı and Çelenk, 2004); in the following citations (Kejanlıoğlu et al., 2004).

In articles having six or more authors, in the first citation, only the surname of the first author is written.
Example: (Abisel et al., 2005).

If there is a double citation, the following format is followed;
Example: (Sancar cited in Zizek, 2009). While Sancar (2009) is included in the list of references with all the related information, Zizek is not given in the list of references.

Abbreviations are given in a parenthesis when given for the first time, then not given in the parenthesis.
Example: The first citation within the text is shown as Milli Eğitim Bakanlığı (MEB, 2012), the first citation within a parenthesis is shown as (Milli Eğitim Bakanlığı [MEB], 2012).

If not necessary, footnote should not be used. If it is necessary, then it should used as follows; (Surname, Publication Date: Page Number)
Direct quotations are written within “”. If the direct quotation is longer than 40 words, then it should be written without using “” as a separate paragraph, indented and in 10 fonts. 

International Journal of Volga - Ural and Turkestan Studies (IJVUTS) accepts articles in Turkish, English, German and French. 
Articles written in different languages but having a special importance in their fields will be sent to reviewers if approved by the absolute majority of the publication board.
IJVUTS is a journal published electronically. The whole volume of the journal or PDF formats of the articles are available free of charge. Therefore, hardcopy of the journal is not sent to writers or third parties.
All the scientific and legal responsibilities of the articles are taken by the author. In this regard, our journal cannot be put under any obligation. The authors sending their manuscripts to the journal are regarded to accept and acknowledge this.
IJVUTS does not accept articles published or sent for revival anywhere else. The authors subscribing to the internet site of the journal and uploading their manuscripts are considered to accept this beforehand. In this regard, our journal acts based on the author’s statement and the author is under the obligation of making declaration of the truth. If the opposite is detected, every legal, scientific and ethical responsibility is taken by the author.
The manuscripts uploaded into the system of the journal are sent to two reviewers to be evaluated. If two of the reviewers approve it, the article proceeds through the process of publication. If both of the reviewers refute the article, the article cannot be published. If one of the reviewers approves but the other refutes, the manuscript is sent to third reviewer and based on the evaluation of the third reviewer, decision is made.
Appointment of reviewers, their works and evaluation processes are kept secret. Which reviewers evaluate which manuscripts is only known by the publication board and editors of the journal. In this regard, no information is given to authors. (For Review Forms)
Reviewers can require corrections for manuscripts they have reviewed. These corrections can be large-scale or small-scale corrections. Two chances are given to authors for the corrections. For each of these corrections, time given to the author cannot be more than 15 days. The articles that cannot be corrected within due time are refuted.
If any study that was presented as a thesis, paper, poster etc. anywhere previously was turned into a manuscript and uploaded to the system of the journal, information about the prior presentation of the article should be given in the first page of the article in the form of footnote. If this is not done, the author is viewed to have committed “ethical violation”.
Copyrights of the articles uploaded to the system of the journal are delivered to the journal. No signature or confirmation is required from the author for this operation. No fee is paid to the author for the publication of the article.
Maximum effort is invested for the fastest review of the article uploaded to the system of the journal. The author is informed about whether the article is accepted for the publication or not within 10 weeks on average after the uploading of the article into the system over the system. The author cannot withdraw his/her article before the end of this period.
The corresponding author of the co-authored articles will be the one uploading the article into the system, no contact is made with the other author(s) and except for the corresponding author, no one is informed about the process.
IJVUTS is issued twice per-year in April and October. This may change depending on the publication system of the journal, review process and technical issues. The journal does not assume any responsibility for any change that can occur at the time of publication.
In articles written in Turkish, an extended abstract with the length of 700-1500 words written in English is required. This extended abstract section should include purpose, content, short literature review, method, findings and results.
IJVUTS has a right to directly publish any article uploaded into the system or sent for publication, place it into the line of articles waiting for publication, put it into the process of publication after corrections are done or refute it. Authors are regarded to know and acknowledge this. In this regard, they cannot start any initiative to put the journal under pressure and make any request.
We have a policy of screening for plagiarism.

The International Journal of Volga - Ural and Turkestan Studies does not charge any fee for article submission, evaluation and publication stages. Articles are published for free. / Uluslararası İdil - Ural ve Türkistan Araştırmaları Dergisi, makale gönderme, değerlendirme ve yayın aşamalarında ücret talep etmemektedir. Makaleler ücretsiz olarak yayınlanmaktadır.

Editor in Chief

South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, North-West (Kipczak) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, North-East (Altai, Khakas, Tuva, Sakha/Yakut) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Dialectology, Comparative Language Studies, Linguistics, Sociolinguistics, Asian Language, Literature and Culture

Managing Editor

Selahittin Tolkun
Prof. Dr. Selahittin TOLKUN Anadolu University, Faculty of Letters, Department of Turkish Language and Literature, Eskişehir, Türkiye Web
South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, South-East (Latest Uyghur/Uzbek) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, North-West (Kipczak) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Dialectology, Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan), Historical North East Turkish Language (Khwarezm, Kipchak, Chagatai), New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye)

Co-Editor

Gıyas Şüküroğlu
Asst. Prof. Dr. Gıyas ŞÜKÜROĞLU ANKARA SOSYAL BİLİMLER ÜNİVERSİTESİ Web
Studies of the Turkic World, Turkish Society and Community

Production Editor

Saffet Alp Yılmaz
Doctoral Saffet Alp YILMAZ Azerbaycan Milli Bilimler Akademisi
Turkish Language and Literature, Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan)

Layout Editor

Serkan Yüksel
Res. Assist. Serkan YÜKSEL Burdur Mehmet Akif Ersoy Üniversitesi
Modern Turkic Languages and Literatures, North-East (Altai, Khakas, Tuva, Sakha/Yakut) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Turkish Language and Literature, New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye)

Copy Editor

Tuğçe Burcu Demir
Doctoral Tuğçe Burcu DEMİR ERCİYES ÜNİVERSİTESİ
New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye)

English Language Editor

Bilal Genç
Prof. Dr. Bilal GENÇ ERCİYES ÜNİVERSİTESİ Web
English As A Second Language, Linguistic Performance Science, British and Irish Language, Literature and Culture, Other Fields of Education (Other)

Social Media and Statistics Editor

Asian Cultural Studies, Environment and Culture, Race, Ethnicity and Law, Administrative Law, Public Administration, Political Science, Constitutional and Political Theories, Studies of Asian Society, Studies of the Turkic World, War Studies

Proofreader

Serdar Altuntaş
Doctoral Serdar ALTUNTAŞ ERCİYES ÜNİVERSİTESİ, EDEBİYAT FAKÜLTESİ Web
Linguistic Structures (Incl. Phonology, Morphology and Syntax), Turkish Language and Literature

Secretary

Regional Studies, Turkish Foreign Policy, Studies of the Turkic World, International Relations (Other)

Section Editor (History)

Default avatar
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ebubekir GÜNGÖR HACETTEPE ÜNİVERSİTESİ, TÜRKİYAT ARAŞTIRMALARI ENSTİTÜSÜ, TÜRKİYAT ARAŞTIRMALARI ANABİLİM DALI
Contemporary Russian History, Modern Turkish History, History of Central Asia, Turkish Savannah Culture, Turkish Society and Community, Turkish Cultural History, Late Modern Russian History

Section Editor (Art History and Archaeology)

Eyüp Polat
Asst. Prof. Dr. Eyüp POLAT ERCİYES ÜNİVERSİTESİ Web
Islamic Arts, Cultural and Natural Heritage, History of Architecture

Section Editor (Sociology)

Default avatar
Prof. Dr. Bülent ŞEN Tarsus Üniversitesi
Poverty, Inclusivity and Wellbeing, Migration Sociology, Urban Sociology and Community Studies

Section Editor (Law)

Emin Hüseyinoğlu
Asst. Prof. Dr. Emin HÜSEYİNOĞLU KARABÜK ÜNİVERSİTESİ
Law and Legal Studies, Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure

Section Editor (Politics and International Relations)

Political Science, International Politics, International Relations, Politics in International Relations

Section Editor (Philosophy and Religious Sciences)

Rafız Manafov
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Rafız MANAFOV Muş Alparslan Üniversitesi
Philosophy of Science, Philosophy of Religion, Islamic Philosophy

Section Editor (Modern Turkish Literature)

Default avatar
Prof. Dr. Şamil YEŞİLYURT Nevşehir Hacı Bektaş Veli Üniversitesi
Modern Turkish Literature in Turkiye Field

Section Editor (Turkish Philology)

Modern Turkic Languages and Literatures, North-West (Kipczak) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, North-East (Altai, Khakas, Tuva, Sakha/Yakut) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Turkish Language and Literature, Turkish Education

Section Editor (Turkish Folklore)

Recep Tek
Prof. Dr. Recep TEK NEVŞEHİR HACI BEKTAŞ VELİ ÜNİVERSİTESİ
Turkish Folk Literature, Turkish Folklore in the Türkiye Field

Section Editor (Educational Sciencies)

Education, Education Management, Gender, Sexuality and Education, Education Policy, Philosophy of Education, Ethics, Applied Ethics

Editorial Board

Elvira Latifova
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Elvira LATİFOVA BAKÜ DEVLET ÜNİVERSİTESİ
Medieval History, Political and Civilization History of Islam, Medieval Folk Culture, History of Muslim Turkish Countries and Societies, Turkish and Islamic Intellectual History, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Islamic Intellectual History
Ali Asker
Prof. Dr. Ali ASKER Karabük Üniversitesi İİBF Web
Constitutional Law, Regional Studies, Studies of the Turkic World, Security Studies
Şevket Öznur
Prof. Dr. Şevket ÖZNUR YAKIN DOĞU ÜNİVERSİTESİ
Comparative and Transnational Literature, Modern Turkish Literature in Turkiye Field, Turkish Folk Literature, Turkish Folklore, Turkish Folklore Outside Türkiye, Turkish Language and Literature Education
Vasif Qafarov
Prof. Dr. Vasif QAFAROV Azerbaycan Milli İlimler Akademisi Tarih ve Etnoloji Enstitüsü
General Turkish History (Other), Late Modern Ottoman History
Zeki Akçam
Asst. Prof. Dr. Zeki AKÇAM Ankara Sosyal Bilimler Üniversitesi
Turkish Folklore
Epistemology, Philosophy of Religion
South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Language Studies, Translation Studies, Indian Language, Literature and Culture, Comparative and Transnational Literature, New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye), Turkish Folklore Outside Türkiye, Turkish Folklore in the Türkiye Field
Default avatar
Dr. Sebahattin ABDURRAHMAN BIRKBECK, UNIVERSITY OF LONDON
International Humanitarian and Human Rights Law, Regional Studies, Studies of the Turkic World
Juliboy Eltazarov
Prof. Juliboy ELTAZAROV Uluslararası "İpek Yolu" Turizm ve Kültürel Miras Üniverditesi
South-East (Latest Uyghur/Uzbek) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Language Studies, Turkish Language and Literature (Other), History of Central Asia
Tulkin Sultanov
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Tulkin SULTANOV “İpek yolu” turizm ve kültürel miras uluslararası üniversitesi Web
South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, South-East (Latest Uyghur/Uzbek) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Language Studies, Translation Studies, Comparative and Transnational Literature, Turkish Language and Literature, Classical Turkish Literature, Cultural and Natural Heritage

Advisory Board

Murad Halmet
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murad HALMET Kastamonu Üniversitesi
Modern Turkic Languages and Literatures, South-East (Latest Uyghur/Uzbek) Turkic Dialects and Literatures
Nodirkhon Khasanov
Prof. Dr. Nodirkhon KHASANOV Özbekistan Millî Üniversitesi
South-East (Latest Uyghur/Uzbek) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Sufism
Default avatar
Prof. Dr. Birsel ORUÇ ASLAN BALIKESİR ÜNİVERSİTESİ, NECATİBEY EĞİTİM FAKÜLTESİ
Modern Turkic Languages and Literatures, South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, North-West (Kipczak) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Dialectology, Linguistics, Linguistic Structures (Incl. Phonology, Morphology and Syntax), Phonetics and Speech Science, Discourse and Pragmatics, Textlinguistics, Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan), Historical North East Turkish Language (Khwarezm, Kipchak, Chagatai), New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye)
Vüsale Musalı
Prof. Dr. Vüsale MUSALI KASTAMONU ÜNİVERSİTESİ, FEN-EDEBİYAT FAKÜLTESİ
South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Comparative and Transnational Literature
Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan), Historical North East Turkish Language (Khwarezm, Kipchak, Chagatai)
Default avatar
Prof. Dr. Yıldız KOCASAVAŞ İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa Web
South-West (Oghuz) Turkic Dialects and Literatures, Dialectology, Modern Turkic Languages and Literatures (Other), Turkish Language and Literature, Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan), Historical North East Turkish Language (Khwarezm, Kipchak, Chagatai), New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye)