Gıda Güvencesi İlkesi ve Gıda Egemenliği Hakkının İnsan Hakları Perspektifinden Karşılaştırmalı Analizi

Abstract

Günümüz küresel gıda sistemi, dünya nüfusunun gereksinimlerinin çok üzerinde gıda üretilmesine rağmen, açlık ve gıda güvencesizliğinin milyonlarca insanı etkilemeye devam ettiği bir çelişkiyi barındırmaktadır. Gıda güvencesi ilkesi tüm insanların sağlıklı ve aktif bir yaşam sürmek için gerekli olan sağlıklı ve besleyici gıdaya her zaman erişebildikleri bir durumu belirtmektedir. İlk kez 1974 yılında uluslararası düzeyde ortaya konulan bu ilke, zaman içerisinde değişen sosyoekonomik ve politik koşullar doğrultusunda farklı şekillerde tanımlanmış ve yorumlanmıştır. Gıda egemenliği hakkı ise uluslararası bir çiftçi ve köylü örgütü olan La Via Campesina tarafından 1996 yılında, küçük ölçekli üretim yapan köylü ve çiftçilerin yaşadığı sorunları dile getirmek amacıyla bir hak talebi olarak ortaya konmuştur. Bununla birlikte gıda egemenliği hakkı sadece bir hak talebi olmanın ötesinde bazı temel ilkelere dayanan alternatif bir gıda ve tarım sistemine dayanmaktadır. Bu model, üçüncü gıda rejimi olarak adlandırılan çok uluslu şirketlerin kontrol sahibi olduğu, enerji ve girdi yoğun tarım sistemine bir alternatif oluşturmaktadır. La via Campesina, aynı zamanda gıda egemenliği hakkını gerçek bir gıda güvencesini sağlamanın ön koşulu olarak görmektedir. Gıda güvencesi ilkesi ve gıda egemenliği hakkı doktrinde sıklıkla birbirleri ile karşılaştırılmakta ve birbirlerinin karşıtı olarak nitelendirilmektedir. Bununla birlikte gıda güvencesi ilkesi ve gıda egemenliği hakkı, gıda bir insan hakkı olarak ele alındığında birbirini tamamlar nitelikler taşımaktadır. Gıdanın yalnızca piyasa mekanizmalarının konusu olan bir meta değil, bireylerin ihtiyaçlarına yönelik bir hak olduğunun kabul edilmesi durumunda; gıda güvencesi ilkesi gıdaya erişimin sağlanmasını hedeflerken, gıda egemenliği hakkı bu erişimin, demokratik, adil ve sürdürülebilir koşullarda gerçekleşmesini güvence altına alacaktır.

Keywords

• Gıda Güvencesi İlkesi
• Gıda Egemenliği Hakkı
• La Via Campesina
• Nyéléni Deklarasyonu
• Amartya Sen

Comparative Analysis of the Principle of Food Security and the Right to Food Sovereignty from a Human Rights Perspective

Abstract

The contemporary global food system embodies a profound paradox: despite the production of food at levels far exceeding the needs of the world’s population, hunger and food insecurity continue to affect millions of people worldwide. The principle of food security refers to a condition in which all individuals have constant access to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food necessary for leading and active and healthy life. First introduced at the international level in 1974, this principle has undergone various reinterpretations over time in response to changing socioeconomic and political conditions. The right to food sovereignty, on the other hand, was articulated in 1996 by La Via Campesina, an international farmers’ and peasants’ movement, as a rights-based demand aimed at addressing the problems faced by small-scale farmers and rural producers. However, food sovereignty extends beyond being merely a rights claim; it represents an alternative agricultural model grounded in fundamental principles that challenge the existing system. This model provides an alternative to the so-called “third food regime,” characterized by the dominance of transnational corporations and highly industrialized, input-intensive agriculture. La Via Campesina also regard the right to food sovereignty as a prerequisite for achieving genuine food security. Within academic discourse, the principle of food security and the right to food sovereignty are frequently compared and often portrayed as opposing concepts. Yet, when food is recognized as a human right, these two frameworks can be understood as complementary. Once food is acknowledged not merely as a market commodity but as a fundamental human entitlement, the principle of food security ensures access to food, while the right to food sovereignty guarantees that such access occurs under democratic, equitable, and sustainable conditions.

Keywords

• Food Security
• Right to Food Sovereignty
• La via Campesina
• The Declaration of Nyéléni
• Amartya Sen

References

1. Andrée P, Ayres J, Bosia MJ AND Massicotte MJ (eds), Globalization and Food Sovereignty: Global and Local Change in the New Politics of Food (University of Toronto Press 2014).
2. Araghi F, ‘The Invisible Hand and the Visible Foot: Peasants, Dispossession and Globalization’ in A. Haroon Akram-Lodhi, Cristóbal Kay (eds) Peasants and Globalization: Poitical Economy, Rural Transformation and the Agrarian Question (Routledge, 2009).
3. Bernstein H, ‘Food Regimes and Food Regime Analysis: A Selective Survey’ (Conference Paper No 1, Land Grabbing, Conflict and Agrarian-environmental Transformations: Perspectives from East and Southeast Asia, Chiang Mai University, 5-6 June 2015)
4. Byaruhanga R and Isgren E, ‘Rethinking the Alternatives: Food Sovereignty as a Prerequisite for Sustainable Food Security’ (2023) 8(16) Food Ethics 1.
5. Byres TJ, ‘Neoliberalizm ve Az Kalkınmış Ülkelerde İlkel Sermaye Birikimi’ in Alfredo Saad-Filho, Deborah Johnston (eds) Neoliberalizm: Muhalif Bir Seçki (Şeyda Başlı, Tuncel Öncel çev. Yordam Kitap 2020).
6. Canfield M, Translating Food Sovereignty: Cultivating Justice in an Age of Transnational Governance (Stanford University Press 2022).
7. Claeys P, ‘The Creation of New Rights by the Food Sovereignty Movement: The Challenge of Institutionalizing Subversion’ (2012) 46(5) Sociology 844. - Human Rights and the Food Sovereignty Movement: Reclaiming Control (Routledge Studies in Food, Society and Environment 2015).
8. Clapp J, ‘Food Security and Food Sovereignty: Getting Past the Binary’ (2015) 4(2) Dialogues in Human Geography 206.

9. Devereux S, ‘Sen’s Entitlement Approach: Critiques and Counter-critiques’ (2001) 29(3) Oxford Development Studies 245.
10. Dréze J and Sen A, Hunger and Public Action, (Oxford University Press 1998).
11. Eide A, Oshaug A and Eide W B, ‘The Food Security and the Right to Food in International Law and Development’ (1991) 1(2) Transnational Law and Contemporary Problems 415.
12. Ertuğrul C, Tarımda Küreselleşme: Uruguay Görüşmeleri ve Sonrası (1. Baskı Odak Yayınları 2004).
13. Friedmann H and McMichael P, ‘Agriculture and State System: The Rise and Decline of National Agricultures, 1870 to the present’ (1989) 29(2) Sociologia Ruralis 93.
14. Gonzalez CG, ‘Climate Change, Food Security and Agrobiodiversity: Toward a Just, Resilient and Sustainable Food System’ (2011) 22(3) Fordham Environmental Law Review 493.
15. Gordillo G and Méndez Jerónimo O, ‘Food Security and Sovereignty’ (Base Document of Discussion FAO 2012).
16. Harvey D, Neoliberalizmin Kısa Tarihi (Aylin Onacak çev. Sel Yayınları 2015).
17. Henneberry SR and Diaz Carrasco C, ‘Food Security Issues: Concepts and the Role of Emerging Markets’ in Schmitz A, Kennedy PL and Schmitz TG (eds) Food Security in an Uncertain World: An International Perspective (Frontiers of Economics and Globalization vol.15 Emerald Group Publishing 2015) 63.
18. Jarosz L, ‘Defining World Hunger: Scale and Neoliberal Ideology in International Food Security Policy Discourse’ (2011) 14(1) Food Culture and Society, 117.
19. Keyder Ç ve Yenal Z, Bildiğimiz Tarımın Sonu: Küresel İktidar ve Köylülük (İletişim Yayınları, 2021).
20. Lang T and Barling D, ‘Food Security and Food Sustainability: Reformulating the Debate’ (2012) 178(4) The Geographical Journal, 313.
21. Martínez-Torres ME and Rosset PM, ‘La Vía Campesina: The Birth and Evolution of a Transnational Social Movement’ (2010) 37(1) The Journal of Peasant Studies 149.
22. McClain-Nhlapo C, ‘Implementing a Human Rights Approach to Food Security’ (International Food Policy Research Institute Africa Conference Policy Brief 13 2020).
23. McKay BM, Nehring, R and Catacora-Vargas G, ‘The Political Economy of Agroecological Transitions: Key Analytical Dimensions’ (2025) 52(3) The Journal of Peasant Studies 461.
24. McMichael P, ‘Food System Sustainability: Questions of Environmental Governance in the New World (Dis)order’ (2011) 21 Global Environmental Change 804.
25. McMichael P, Gıda Rejimleri ve Tarım Sorunları (Duygu Avcı Çev. Nota Bene 2022).
26. Orago NW, ‘Food Security and Access to Food: The Viability of Rights Based Approach to Food Sovereignty in Kenya’ (2017) East African Law Journal 19.
27. Oya C, ‘Kalkınmakta Olan Ülkelerde Çiftçilere Sopa ve Havuç: Kuramda ve Uygulamada Tarımsal Neoliberalizm’ in Alfredo Saad-Filho, Deborah Johnston (eds) Neoliberalizm: Muhalif Bir Seçki (Şeyda Başlı, Tuncel Öncel çev. Yordam Kitap 2020)
28. Palley TI, ‘Keynesçilikten Neoliberalizme: İktisat Biliminde Paradigma Kayması’ in Alfredo Saad-Filho, Deborah Johnston (eds) Neoliberalizm: Muhalif Bir Seçki (Şeyda Başlı, Tuncel Öncel çev. Yordam Kitap 2020)
29. Patel R, ‘Food Sovereignty’ (2009) 36(3) The Journal of Peasant Studies 663.
30. Pimbert MP and Claeys P, ‘Food Sovereignty’ in Mark Aldenferder (ed.) Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Anthropology (Oxford University Press 2024) https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190854584.013.297.
31. Schanbacher WD, The Politics of Food: The Global Conflict between Food Security and Food Sovereignty (Praeger Security International 2010).
32. Sen A, Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation (Clarendon Press 1981).
33. Shattuck A and Holt-Giménez E, ‘Moving from the Food Crisis to Food Sovereignty’ (2010) 13(2) Yale Human Rights and Development Law Journal 421.
34. Shepherd B, ‘Thinking Critically About Food Security’ (2012) 43(3) Security Dialogue 195.
35. Wittman H, ‘Food Sovereignty: A New Rights Framework for Food and Nature’ (2011) 2 Environment and Society: Advances in Research 87.
36. Ziegler J, ‘Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: The Right to Food’ (2004) UN Economic and Social Council 2004 E/CN.4/2004/10.
37. Çevrimiçi Kaynaklar
38. CFS, High Level Panel of Experts Report 15: Food Security and Nutrition Building a Global Narrative Towards 2030 (2020) .
39. FAO, Report of the Eighth Session of the Commitee on World Food Security (1983) .
40. - Rome Declaration on World Food Security (1996) .
41. - The State of Food Insecurity in the World (2000) < https://openknowledge.fao.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/06b68b00-3fcc-4969-b4b7-b93ec29f95e2/content>.
42. - The State of Food Insecurity in the World (2001) .
43. - Trade Reforms and Food Security: Conceptualizing the Linkages (2003) .
44. - The Right to Food Voluntary Guidelines, Adopted by the 127th Session of the FAO Council (2004) .
45. - Food Security, Policy Brief (2006)
46. - The State of Food Insecurity in the World: The Multiple Dimensions of Food Security (2013) .
47. - The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World (2025) .
48. La Vía Campesina, The Right to Produce and Access to Land (1996) .
49. - Nyéléni 2007: Forum for Food Sovereignty (2007) . UN, Report of the World Food Conference (1974) . World Bank, Poverty and Hunger (1986) .