RİVAYETİN METNE DÖNÜŞTÜRÜLMESİNDE RAVİ TASARRUFUNA SEYF B. ÖMER’DEN ÖRNEKLER

Year 2008, Volume: 1 Issue: 6, 105 - 124, 30.11.2008

İsrafil Balcı

Abstract

This article deals with some narration of Saif b. Omar that is one of im
portant sources of Tabari. These narrations are compared with those nar
rations taken place in other sources and then they are examined in terms
of whether they are exposed to any changes or not. The reason for being
chosen from Saif, he narrated differently from previous sources in many
points. Thus, giving some examples from his works, it tries to indicate that
how much a narrator or writer intervenes with the narration or not.

Keywords

Saif b. Omar, Tabari, narration, narrator’s interference

Some Examples for Narrator’s Interference In the Transformation of Narration to the Text

Abstract

This article deals with some narration of Saif b. Omar that is one of im
portant sources of Tabari. These narrations are compared with those nar
rations taken place in other sources and then they are examined in terms
of whether they are exposed to any changes or not. The reason for being
chosen from Saif, he narrated differently from previous sources in many
points. Thus, giving some examples from his works, it tries to indicate that
how much a narrator or writer intervenes with the narration or not.

Keywords

Saif b. Omar, Tabari, narration, narrator’s interference

References

• Seyyid İsmail Kâşif, İslâm Tarihinin Kaynakları ve Araştırma Metotları, (çev:. Mehmet Şeker Rıza Savaş-Ramazan Şimşek), İzmir İlahiyat Vakfı Yay., İzmir 1997