A Gynocritical Analysis of Newman’s Julia as a Response to Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four

Abstract

Elaine Showalter believes it is restrictive to read stories about women written by male writers because male-dominated narration is filled with stereotypical representations of women, which consequently maintains the victimization of women. With her idea of gynocriticism, she refers to the need for female writers to write about the female. In that sense, she demands female characters to be put at the centre of literary works in order to reach a more inclusive understanding of human experience. Building on her theory of female writing, this paper attempts to show that female experience, perspective, and voice must be communicated within the literary landscape to have a better and multifaceted understanding of the lives of women and to fix the misinterpretations of womanhood through the analysis of Julia (2023) by Sandra Newman and Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949) by George Orwell. Even though Orwell manages to critique the horrible outcomes of totalitarianism in his canonical dystopia through his protagonist Winston, he completely ignores what Julia feels, thinks, or experiences. There is not much information about Julia’s life as an individual or as a woman. Therefore, Newman reconstructs Julia as the protagonist of her dystopia by focusing solely on Julia’s thoughts, endeavours, and emotions by filling in the missing parts that Orwell does not touch upon. Accordingly, this paper examines how a female writer establishes a society that is not solely governed by universally accepted maledominated ideals, creating a space for a formerly silenced and decentralised character so that she can be valued on her own terms.

Keywords

• Showalter
• gynocriticism
• Julia
• feminist criticism
• female writing

References

1. Adee, S. (2023, February 12). “Wrap up the best of sci-fi”. New Scientist. 30. google scholar
2. Chaudhary, K. (2013). Elaine Showalter’s Critical Examination of The Essay - “Feminist Criticism In Wilderness”. Research Journal of English Language and Literatüre, 1 (4), 174-177. google scholar
3. Connors, J. (1971). “Do It to Julia”: Thoughts On Orwell’s ‘ 1984. Modern Fiction Studies. 16(4), 463-473. google scholar
4. Dasgupta, N. & Sharma, J. (2013). Anne Sexton’s Poetry Tested on the Axis of Elaine Showalter’s Gynocriticism. The Criterion. 4(3), 1-8. google scholar
5. Donovan, J. (1984). Toward a Women’s Poetics. Tulsa Studies in Women’s Literature, 3 (1/2), 98-110. google scholar
6. Ettler, J. (2024, January 6). “How Julia saw life in Orwell’s Dystopia”. The Sydney Morning Herald. 12. google scholar
7. Gardiner, J. K. (1981).On Female Identity and Writing by Women. Critical Inquiry 8(2), 347-361. google scholar
8. Gass, W. H. (1972). Fiction and the Figures of Life. Vintage Books. google scholar

9. Gharachorlou, T.K., & Derabi, J.Y. (2017). “Riding’s poetry in the Theory of Gynocriticism”. Journal of English Language and Literature, 8(2), 627-632. google scholar
10. Greene, G. (1990). Feminist Fiction, Feminist Form. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 11(2/3), 82-88. google scholar
11. Gubar, S. (2014). The Blank Page and the Issues of Female Creativity. Lectora, 20, 249-269. google scholar
12. Hughes, K. (2023, October 1). Big Brother Is Still Watching You. Sunday Times. 31. google scholar
13. Hunt, W. (2013). Orwell’s Commedia: The Ironic Theology of Nineteen Eighty-Four. Modern Philology. 110(4), 536 563. google scholar
14. Jacobs, N. (2007). Dissent, Assent, and the Body in Nineteen Eighty-Four. Utopian Studies, 18(1), 3-20. google scholar
15. Kitch, S. (1987). Feminist Literary Criticism as Irony. Rocky Mountain Review of Language and Literature, 41(1/2), 7-19. google scholar
16. Lucas, J. M. & Ordeniza, S. (2023). Representation of Women in Literature Through Different Era. Technoarete Transactions on Language and Linguistics. 2(1), 6-10. google scholar
17. Mhamane, N.V. (2021). A Critique of Twentieth Century Feminist Criticism. The Creative Launcher, 6(4). 112-117. google scholar
18. Moi, T. (1988). Sexual/Textual Politics: Feminist Literary Theory. Routledge. google scholar
19. Morris, S. (2023, October 20). Literary Fiction. Daily Mail. 35. google scholar
20. Newman, S. (2023). Julia. Granta Books. google scholar
21. Nodeh, S. & Pourgiv, F. (2012). Showalter’s Gynocriticism: Female Wild Zone of Experience in Adrienne Rich’s A google scholar
22. Wild Patience Has Taken Me This Far. The Criterion, 3(4), 1-12. google scholar
23. Orwell, G. (2023). 1984. MK Publications. google scholar
24. Patai, D. (1982). Gamesmanship and Androcentrism in Orwell’s 1984. PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America, 97, 856-870. google scholar
25. Patai, D. (1984). The Orwell Mystique: A Study in Male Ideology. The University of Massachusetts Press. google scholar
26. Philip, M. (2023). “Love, Power, And Control: Exploring the Dynamics Of Relationships In George Orwell’s “Nineteen Eighty-Four”. A Global Journal of Humanities, VI(I), 37-41. google scholar
27. Pratt, A. (1982). Archetypal Patterns in Women’s Fiction. The Harvester Press. google scholar
28. Pujara, T. (2024). Gynocriticism in Snapshots of a Daughter-in-law by Adrienne Rich. Vidhyayana. 9(2), 1252-1259. google scholar
29. Putri, E. J. (2014). Female Experiences in Different Cultural Backgrounds: Gynocriticism on Short Stories of Five Continents. Vivid Journal, 3(1), 1-10. google scholar
30. Rani, S. (2013). Elaine Showalter’s “Feminist Criticism in the Wilderness”: A Critique. Research Scholar. 1(4), 1-5. google scholar
31. Rania, K. C. & Latiff, N. (2020). Male is Feminine Under Patriarchal Governments: Male Characters of 1984 by George Orwell. International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences, 5(4), 900-903. google scholar
32. Selden, R., & Widdowson, P., & Brooker, B. (2005). A Reader’s Guide to Literary Theory. Pearson Education Limited. google scholar
33. Shilling, J. (2024, July 19). Mustreads. Daily Mail. 41. google scholar
34. Showalter, E. (1977). A Literature of Their Own. Princeton University Press. google scholar
35. Showalter, E. (1981). Feminist Criticism in Wilderness. Critical Inquiry, 8(2), 179-205. google scholar
36. Showalter, E. (1997). Towards a Feminist Poetics. In K. M. Newton (Ed.), Twentieth-Century Literary Theory. St. Martin’s Press. google scholar
37. Xinyue, W. (2021). George Orwell’s Misogyny—A Feminist Interpretation of Animal Farm. US-China Foreign Language. 19(6), 153-157. google scholar