Varieties of Belonging Among Migrants: Turkish Migrants in Norway

Abstract

This article examines differentways of belonging among migrants of Turkish origin who were born in Türkiye and are currently living in Norway (in/around Oslo and Drammen). The discussion in the article is based on the findings of semi-structured interviews conducted between March 2019 and August 2020 with 71 Turkish migrants as part of a qualitative study. Different categories of responses to the questions about belonging and the meanings respondents attached to belonging/not belonging are discussed. The paper aims to demonstrate the heterogeneity and complexity of feelings of belonging among the members of an ethnic group that is assumed to feel belonging to their country of origin rather than the destination country in the context of Europe. Additionally, the paper also aims to elaborate on what migrants actually mean when they talk about their belonging (or not belonging) to territories such as the country of origin or destination country, and collectivities like nations. Here it is argued that questioning and criticizing migrants’ feelings of belonging (especially to their countries of origin) as a part of civic integration agendas is an effort to intervene in and have control over their emotions. This claim to the right to intervene in migrants’ emotional lives is approached critically.

Keywords

• ways of belonging
• transnational belonging
• Turkish
• Norway
• civic integration

References

1. Akçapar, Ş. K., & Aksel, D. B. (2017). Public diplomacy through diaspora engagement: The case of Turkey. Perceptions: Journal of International Affairs, 22(3), 135-160. google scholar
2. Antonsich, M., 2010. Searching for belonging-an analytical framework. Geography Compass, 4(6), 644- 659. google scholar
3. Ataman, A., Sener, T., Noack, P. and Born, M., 2017. Political participation beyond borders: a comparative analysis of Turkish youth living in home country, Germany and Belgium. Journal of Youth Studies, 20(5), 565- 582. google scholar
4. Bauböck, R., 2005. Theorizing identity politics, belonging modes, and citizenship. In H.G. Sicakkan & Y.G. Lithman (eds.) Changing the Basis of Citizenship in the Modern State: Political Theory and Political Diversity (pp.iii-vii). New York: Edwin Mellen Press. google scholar
5. Bhimji, F., 2008. Cosmopolitan belonging and diaspora: second-generation British Muslim women travelling to South Asia. Citizenship Studies, 12(4), 413- 427. google scholar
6. Boccagni, P., & Kivisto, P. (2019). Introduction: Ambivalence and the social processes of immigrant inclusion. International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 60(1-2), 3-13. google scholar
7. Bochove, M., Rusinovic, K. and Engbersen, G., 2010. The multiplicity of citizenship: transnational and local practices and identifications of middle-class migrants. Global Networks, 10(3), 344-364. google scholar
8. Bonjour, S. and Duyvendak, J.W., 2018. The “migrant with poor prospects”: Racialized intersections of class and culture in Dutch civic integration debates. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 41(5), 882- 900. google scholar

9. Breen, L. 2007. The researcher ’in the middle’: Negotiating the insider/outsider dichotomy. The Australian community psychologist, 19(1), 163-174. google scholar
10. Chavez, C. 2008. Conceptualizing from the inside: Advantages, complications, and demands on insider positionality. The Qualitative Report, 13(3), 474- 494. google scholar
11. Dahinden, J., 2012. Transnational belonging, non-ethnic forms of identification and diverse mobilities: rethinking migrant integration? Vienna: Spinger. google scholar
12. Duru, D. N., Favell, A., & Varela, A. 2019. Transnational Turkey: The everyday transnationalism and diversity of Turkish populations in Europe. In E. Recchi, A. Favell, F. Apaydin, et al. (eds.) Europe: Social transnationalism in an unsettled continent (pp.225- 254). Bristol: Policy Press. google scholar
13. Erdal, M.B., 2013. Migrant transnationalism and multi-layered integration: Norwegian-Pakistani migrants’ own reflections. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 39(6), 983- 999. google scholar
14. Erdal, M. B. 2021. Migrants’ multifocal sedentarism: Ambivalent belonging and desired recognition in transnational social fields connecting Pakistan and Norway. Journal of Intercultural Studies, 42(5), 643- 659. google scholar
15. Fenster, T., 2005. Gender and the city: the different formations of belonging. In L. Nelson & J. Seager (eds.) A companion to feminist geography (pp.242-256). Malden: Blackwell Publishing. google scholar
16. Greene, M. J. 2014. On the inside looking in: Methodological insights and challenges in conducting qualitative insider research. The qualitative report, 19(29), 1-13. google scholar
17. Healy, M., & Perry, C. 2000. Comprehensive criteria to judge validity and reliability of qualitative research within the realism paradigm. Qualitative market research: An international journal, 3(3), 118- 126. google scholar
18. Hoffman, M., Makovsky, A., & Werz, M. (2020). The Turkish diaspora in Europe: Integration, migration, and politics. Center for American Progress, 10(12). google scholar
19. Kaya, A., 2011. Euro-Turks as a force in EU-Turkey relations. South European Society and Politics, 16(3), 499- 512. google scholar
20. Klok, J., van Tilburg, T.G., Suanet, B., Fokkema, T. and Huisman, M., 2017. National and transnational belonging among Turkish and Moroccan older migrants in the Netherlands: Protective against loneliness? European Journal of Ageing, 14, 341- 351. google scholar
21. Kolbaşı-Muyan, G. (2023). Türkiye’s diaspora engagement policy: Change in perspective since 2010. Bilig, 105, 99-128. google scholar
22. Krzyzanowski, M. and Wodak, R., 2008. Multiple identities, migration and belonging: ‘Voices of migrants’. In C.R. Caldas-Coulthard & R. Iedema (eds.) Identity trouble: Critical discourse and contested identities. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. google scholar
23. Leary, M. R., & Kelly, K. M. (2009). Belonging motivation. In M.R. Leary & R.H. Hyle (eds.) Handbook of individual differences in social behavior (pp.400- 409). New York: Guilford Press. google scholar
24. Levitt, P., 2001. Transnational migration: taking stock and future directions. Global networks, 1(3), 195- 216. google scholar
25. Lewis, D. 1973. Anthropology and colonialism. Current Anthropology, 14(5), 581- 602. google scholar
26. May, V., 2011. Self, belonging and social change. Sociology, 45(3), 363- 378. google scholar
27. McCracken, G. 1988. The long interview. London: Sage Publications. google scholar
28. Naples, N. A. 2003. Feminism and method: Ethnography, discourse analysis, and activist research. New York: Routledge. google scholar
29. Nititham, D.S., 2016. Making home in diasporic communities: Transnational belonging amongst Filipina migrants. London and New York: Routledge. google scholar
30. Noble, H., & Smith, J. 2015. Issues of validity and reliability in qualitative research. Evidence-based nursing, 18(2), 34— 35. google scholar
31. Norwegian Ministries. (2022). Migration and Integration 2020-2021: Report for Norway to the OECD. google scholar
32. Over, H. 2016. The origins of belonging: Social motivation in infants and young children. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 371(1686), 20150072. google scholar
33. Özbilgin, M., & Yıldız, H. (2022). Turkish academic diaspora in Britain: A scoping review. Migration Letters, 19(4), 387- 400. google scholar
34. Palmberger, M. (2019). Relational ambivalence: Exploring the social and discursive dimensions of ambivalence—The case of Turkish aging labor migrants. International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 60(1-2), 74- 90. google scholar
35. Piercy, K. W. 2004. Analysis of semi-structured interview data. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Family, Consumer, & Human Development, Utah State University, Logan, Utah, United-States. google scholar
36. Portes, A., 1997. Globalization from below: The rise of transnational communities (Vol. 98). Princeton: Princeton University. google scholar
37. Schellenberg, B., 2013. Developments within the radical right in Germany: Discourses, attitudes and actors. In R. Wodak, M. KhosraviNik & B. Mral (eds.) Right-Wing populism in Europe: Politics and discourse, (pp.149-162). London & New York: Bloomsbury. google scholar
38. Schiller, N.G., Basch, L. and Blanc-Szanton, C., 1992. Transnationalism: A new analytic framework for understanding migration. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 645(1), 1- 24. google scholar
39. Sicakkan, H.G. and Lithman, Y., 2005. Politics of identity, modes of belonging and citizenship: An overview of conceptual and theoretical challenges. In H.G. Sicakkan & Y.G. Lithman (eds.) Changing the Basis of Citizenship in the Modern State. Political Theory and Political Diversity (pp.1- 35). New York: Edwin Mellen Press. google scholar
40. Skey, M., 2014. ‘How do you think I feel? It’s my country’: Belonging, entitlement, and the politics of immigration. The Political Quarterly, 85(3), 326- 332. google scholar
41. Skey, M., 2013. Why do nations matter? The struggle for belonging and security in an uncertain world. The British Journal of Sociology, 64(1), 81- 98. google scholar
42. Skrbis, Z., 2008. Transnational families: Theorizing migration, emotions and belonging. Journal of Intercultural Studies, 29(3), 231- 246. google scholar
43. Somerville, K., 2008. Transnational belonging among second generation youth: Identity in a globalized world. Journal of Social Sciences, 10(1), 23- 33. google scholar
44. Stenbacka, C. 2001. Qualitative research requires quality concepts of its own. Management decision, 39(7), 551- 556. google scholar
45. Vertovec, S., 2001. Transnationalism and identity. Journal of Ethnic and Migration studies, 27(4), 573- 582. google scholar
46. Wilkinson, S., & Kitzinger, C. 2013. Representing our own experience: Issues in “insider” research. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 37(2), 251- 255. google scholar
47. Wimmer, A. and Schiller, N.G., 2002. Methodological nationalism and the study of migration. European Journal of Sociology/Archives Europeennes de Sociologie, 43(2), 217-240. google scholar
48. Wong, L.L., 2008. Transnationalism, active citizenship, and belonging in Canada. International Journal, 63(1), 79- 100. google scholar
49. Yabancı, B. (2021). Home state-oriented diaspora organizations and the making of partisan citizens abroad: Motivations, discursive frames, and actions towards co-opting the Turkish diaspora in Europe. Diaspora, 21(2), 139- 165. google scholar
50. Yaldız, F. (2019). A Critical Approach to the Term Turkish Diaspora: Is there ‘the’ Turkish Diaspora?. Bilig, (91), 53- 80. google scholar
51. Yuval-Davis, N., 2006. Belonging and the politics of belonging. Patterns of prejudice, 40(3), 197- 214. google scholar