Journal of Cukurova Anesthesia and Surgical Sciences (J Cukurova Anesth Surg)
Overview
A conflict of interest exists when a participant in the publication process has financial, personal, professional, or institutional relationships that could inappropriately influence — or be perceived to influence — their judgment, decisions, or actions in that process. Conflicts of interest do not necessarily imply wrongdoing; however, transparency in their disclosure is essential to maintaining the integrity and credibility of the scientific record.
All participants in the peer-review and publication process at J Cukurova Anesth Surg — including authors, peer reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and editorial staff — are required to identify, disclose, and manage any actual or potential conflicts of interest in accordance with the guidelines of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE; https://www.icmje.org/conflicts-of-interest/) and the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE; https://publicationethics.org).
1. Authors
1.1. Disclosure Obligation
Authors are responsible for disclosing all financial and personal relationships that might bias, or be seen to bias, their work at the time of manuscript submission. This obligation applies to all manuscript types and all authors listed on the submission, including the corresponding author and all co-authors.
Relationships that must be disclosed include, but are not limited to:
- Employment or affiliation with any organization with a financial interest in the manuscript's findings
- Consultancy fees, honoraria, or speaker's bureau payments received from relevant companies or organizations
- Stock ownership or equity interests in companies related to the research
- Research funding, grants, or other financial support received from public, private, or commercial sources
- Patents held or pending that relate to the content of the manuscript
- Personal relationships (e.g., family members, close colleagues) with individuals who might benefit or be disadvantaged by the publication of the findings
- Travel grants or other benefits received from organizations with an interest in the research
1.2. Disclosure Form
Authors must complete and submit the ICMJE Disclosure Form for Conflicts of Interest at the time of submission. The form is available at: https://www.icmje.org/disclosure-of-interest/
A completed form must be submitted by every author individually. Conflict of interest disclosures will be published as part of the accepted article to ensure full transparency.
1.3. No Conflict of Interest
If no conflicts of interest exist, authors must explicitly state this in the manuscript using the following or equivalent wording: "The authors declare no conflict of interest."
1.4. Funding Sources
All sources of financial support for the research must be disclosed in a dedicated Funding section in the manuscript. The role of each funding source in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the decision to submit for publication must be described. If the funding source had no involvement in any of these aspects, this must be explicitly stated.
2. Peer Reviewers
2.1. Disclosure Obligation
Peer reviewers must disclose to the editor any relationships or circumstances that could bias, or could be perceived to bias, their evaluation of a manuscript. This disclosure must be made at the time of accepting or declining a review invitation, before the review is undertaken.
Conflicts of interest that require disclosure include:
- Current or recent (within the past three years) collaboration with any of the authors
- Employment at the same institution as any of the authors
- Personal relationships with any of the authors (e.g., close friendship, family connection, mentorship)
- Financial interest in the outcome of the review (e.g., stock ownership, competing research programs, competing patents)
- Prior public statements or published opinions that could be seen to prejudge the manuscript
2.2. Recusal
Reviewers with a conflict of interest must decline the review invitation and notify the editorial office of the nature of the conflict, so that an alternative reviewer can be appointed promptly. Reviewers must not allow potential conflicts to influence their evaluation in any direction — neither toward unwarranted criticism nor toward unwarranted endorsement.
2.3. Prohibition on Misuse of Unpublished Information
Reviewers must not use knowledge of the work they are reviewing — including methods, data, conclusions, or ideas — to further their own interests before the manuscript is published. This constitutes a serious breach of confidentiality and research ethics and will be handled in accordance with COPE guidelines.
3. Editors and Editorial Staff
3.1. Editors
Editors who are responsible for making final decisions on manuscripts must recuse themselves from handling any submission in which a conflict of interest exists. Situations requiring recusal include:
- Manuscripts authored or co-authored by the editor themselves
- Manuscripts submitted by current or recent close collaborators, students, or mentors of the editor
- Manuscripts from the editor's own institution where a direct benefit or disadvantage could arise
- Manuscripts related to research in which the editor has a financial interest (e.g., stock, patents, consultancy relationships)
- Any personal relationship that could bias the editorial decision
When a conflict of interest is identified, the manuscript must be transferred to another senior editor or a guest editor who has no conflict with the submission.
3.2. Editorial Board Members
Editorial board members who participate in editorial decisions must provide the editor-in-chief with an up-to-date description of their financial interests and any other relationships that might constitute a conflict of interest. Board members must recuse themselves from any decision in which a conflict of interest exists and must inform the editor-in-chief of the nature of the conflict.
3.3. Guest Editors
Guest editors handling manuscripts for special issues or supplements are subject to the same conflict of interest requirements as regular editors. Guest editors must disclose all potential conflicts of interest to the editor-in-chief before assuming editorial responsibilities for any submission.
3.4. Editorial Staff
All members of the editorial staff who have access to submitted manuscripts or who participate in any aspect of the editorial process must not use information gained through their work for private gain. Editorial staff must disclose any relationships or circumstances that could constitute a conflict of interest to the editor-in-chief and must recuse themselves from any process in which such a conflict exists.
3.5. Public Disclosure
The editor-in-chief will publish regular disclosure statements summarizing potential conflicts of interest related to their own professional commitments and those of journal staff and editorial board members. These statements will be made available on the journal's website and updated at least annually.
4. Handling Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest
If an undisclosed conflict of interest is identified after submission, during peer review, or following publication, J Cukurova Anesth Surg will investigate the matter in accordance with COPE guidelines. Depending on the nature and severity of the undisclosed conflict, actions may include:
- Requesting a formal explanation from the relevant party
- Issuing a correction or editorial expression of concern
- Retraction of the published article
- Notification of the author's or reviewer's institution
Authors, reviewers, and editors who become aware of an undisclosed conflict of interest at any stage of the process are encouraged to report it to the editorial office in confidence.
5. Related Resources
- ICMJE Conflicts of Interest disclosure form: https://www.icmje.org/disclosure-of-interest/
- ICMJE recommendations on conflicts of interest: https://www.icmje.org/conflicts-of-interest/
- COPE guidelines on conflicts of interest: https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Guidelines
- WAME conflict of interest policy: https://www.wame.org/conflict-of-interest-in-peer-reviewed-medical-journals
This policy applies to all manuscript types considered for publication in J Cukurova Anesth Surg. For questions regarding conflicts of interest disclosure, please contact the editorial office through the journal's contact page on DergiPark.