The Problem of Repeating Revelation - I
Abstract
This study examines the idea of repeating revelation in Quran. This issue that discussing between accepters and decliners. I aim to figure the subject; scholars’ opinions, examine ever opinion their evidences’ with analysis and preference; and to attract notice the reason for Repeating Revelation. This study arrives some results: 1. Reducing this view 's scope. Because, what really matters is not to happen repetition. 2. this view is between understatement and extravagance. 3. Most of who defends an opinion repetition of descend shows up when the reports’ causes of nuzul increases or the describing Makki and Madani conflicts among the parties. 4. Some scientists in the wrong with win a seat when there is incompatibility among the reports’ causes of nuzul.
Keywords
Repeat,Tafseer,Quran,Revelation,Repeating Revelation,Causes of nozul
References
- Abdülbâkî, Muhammed Fuâd, el-Mu'cemü'l-Müfehres li-Elfâzi'l-Kur'âni'l-Kerîm, Beyrut: Dâru’l-Endelüs, 1959/1378.
- Abdülmün’im en-Nemr, Ulûmü’l-Kur’âni’l-Kerîm, Kahire : Dârü’l-Kitâbi’l-Mısri ; Beyrut : Dârü’l-Kütübi’l-İslâmiyye, 1983/1403.
- Ahmed b. Hanbel, Ebû Abdullah Ahmed b. Muhammed eş-Şeybani, Kitâbü's-sünne, thk. Muhammed b. Saîd b. Salim el-Kahtani, ts. : Dâru Âlemi’l-Kütüb, 1996/1416
- Abdürrezzak Hüseyin Ahmed, el-Mekkî ve’l-Medenî fi’l-Kur’âni’l-Kerîm, I-II, Kahire : Daru İbn Affân, 1999/1420.
- Âlûsî, Ebü's-Senâ Şehâbeddîn Mahmûd b. Abdullâh b. Mahmûd, Ruhü'l-meani fî tefsiri'l-Kur'âni'l-azim ve's-seb’i'l-mesani, Beyrut : Dâru İhyai't-Türasi'l-Arabi, I-XXX, ts.
- Ahmed Muhtar Ömer, Mu’cemü’l-lugati’l-Arabiyyeti’l-muâsıra, Kahire : Alemü’l-Kütüb, I-IV, 2008/1429.
- Batalyûsî, İbn Seyyid, el-İnsâf fi’t-Tenbîh ale’l-Meânî ve’l-Esbâbi’lletî Evcebeti’l-İhtilâfü beyne’l-Müslimîne fî Ârâihim ve Mezâhibihim ve İ’tikâdâtihim, thk. Muhammed Rıdvan ed-Daye, Dımaşk : Darul Fikr, 2003.
- Beyhakî, Ebû Bekr Ahmed b. el-Hüseyin b. Ali, Şuabü'l-iman, thk. Ebû Hacer Muhammed Zaglul, Beyrut : Dârü'l-Kütübi'l-İlmiyye, I-IX, 1990.
- Cedî, Abdullah Yusuf, el-Mukaddimâtü’l-Esâsiyye fî Ulûmi’l-Kur’ân, Britanya: Merkezü’l-Bühûs el-İslâmiyye, 2000.
- Cevherî, es-Sıhah, İsmail b. Hammad Cevheri, thk. Ahmed Abdülgafur Attar, Beyrut : Dârü'l-İlm li'l-Melayin, I-VI, 1990.