TRİBOELEKTROSTATİK AYIRMA İLE İNCE BOYDA KÖMÜR ZENGİNLEŞTİRİLMESİNİN İNCELENMESİ
Year 2020,
Volume: 59 Issue: 3, 183 - 192, 01.09.2020
Ergin Gülcan
T.onur Dizdar
Özcan Y. Gülsoy
Abstract
Bu çalışma kapsamında bir triboelektrik ayrım düzeneği tasarımı ve bu düzeneğin ülkemizdeki
belli başlı kömür cevherlerinin ince boyda zenginleştirilmesinde kullanımı incelenmiştir. Deneysel
çalışmalarda kullanılmak üzere Tunçbilek ve Soma bölgelerinde konumlanmış, işletmesi devam
eden dört farklı lavvardan kömür numuneleri temin edilmiştir. Deneysel çalışmalarda kullanılmak
üzere Hacettepe Üniversitesi Maden Mühendisliği Bölümü’nde geliştirilen triboelektrostatik
ayrım düzeneği 35 kV’a kadar statik yük üretebilmektedir. Gerekli statik yükün sürtünme
ile sağlanmasına ilişkin öncül testleri takiben kömür numuneleri ile zenginleştirme işlemleri
gerçekleştirilmiştir. İki ayrı bölgeden temin edilen dört farklı kömür numunesi ile gerçekleştirilen
deneysel çalışmalar sonucunda, triboelektrostatik ayrım ile kömürün yapısına bağlı olarak ince
tane boylarında %50’leri aşan kül uzaklaştırma verimleri elde edilebildiği görülmüştür.
References
- Alfano, G., Carbini, P., Carta, M., Ciccu, R., Del Fa,
C., Peretti, R., Zucca, A., 1985. Applications of Static
Electricity in Coal and Ore Beneficiation. J. Electrost.,
16, 315–328.
- Allen R. C., 2000. Triboelectric Generation: Getting
Charged Reproduced with Permission, EE-Evaluation
Engineering, 1-6.
- Baltrus J. P., Diehl J. R., Soong Y., Sands W., 2002.
Triboelectrostatic Separation of Fly Ash and Change
Reversal. Fuel, 81, 757-762.
- Ban H., Li T. X., Hower J. C., Schaefer J. L., Stencel
J. M., 1997. Dry Triboelectrostatic Beneficiation of Fly
Ash. Fuel, 76 (8), 801-805.
- Bittnera J. D., Hracha F. J., Gasiorowskia S. A.,
Canellopoulusb L. A., Guicherd H., 2014. Triboelectric
Belt Separator for Beneficiation of Fine Minerals. 2nd
International Symposium on Innovation and Technology
in the Phosphate Industry Procedia Engineering, 83,
122-129.
- Cangialosi F., Notarnicola M., Liberti L., Stencel J.
M., 2008. The Effects of Particle Concentration and
Charge Exchange on Fly Ash Beneficiation with
Pneumatic Triboelectrostatic Separation. Separation
and Purification Technology, 62, 240-248.
- Çelik M. S., Yaşar E., 1995. Effect of Temperature
and Impurities on Electrostatic Separation of Boron
Minerals. Mineral Engineering, Technical Note, 8 (7),
829-833.
- Chen J., Honaker R., 2015. Dry Separation on
Coal–Silica Mixture Using Rotary Triboelectrostatic
Separator. Fuel Processing Technology, 131, 317-324.
- Das S., Samuila A., Dragan C., Dascalescu L., 2009.
Behaviour of Charged Insulating Particles in Contact
with a Rotating Roll Electrode. Journal of Electrostatics,
67, 189–192.
- Diaza A. F., Felix-Navarrob R. M., 2004. A Semi-
Quantitative Tribo-Electric Series for Polymeric
Materials: The Influence of Chemical Structure and
properties, Journal of Electrostatics, 62, 277-290.
- Dizdar T. O., Kocausta G., Gülcan E., Gülsoy Ö. Y.,
2018. A New Method to Produce High Voltage Static
Electric Load for Electrostatic Separation–Triboelectric
Charging. Powder Technology, 327, 89-95.
- Dwari R. K., Hanumantha Rao K., 2006. Triboelectrostatic
Behaviour of High Ash Non-Coking, Indian
Thermal Coal. Int. J. Miner. Process, 81, 93–104.
- Dwari R. K., Hanumantha Rao K., Somasundaran P.,
2009. Characterisation of Particle Tribo-Charging and
Electron Transfer with Reference to Electrostatic Dry
Coal Cleaning. Int. J. Miner. Process, 91, 100-110.
- Dwari R. K., Mohanta S. K., Rout B., Soni R. K., Reddy
P. S. R., Mishra B. K., 2015. Studies on the Effect of
Electrode Plate Position and Feed Temperature on
the Tribo-Electrostatic Separation of High Ash Indian
Coking Coal. Advanced Powder Technology, 26, 31-41.
- Finseth, D., Newby, T., Elstrodt, R., 1993. Dry
Electrostatic Separation of Fine Coal. In: Parekh,
V.B.K., Gropps, J.G. (Eds.), Processing and Utilization
of High-Sulfur Coals. Elsevier Science Publisher, B.V.,
Amsterdam, 91-98.
- Hangsubcharoen M., 1999(a). Thesis. A Study of
Triboelectrification Mechanisms for Coal, Quartz and
Pyrite. Blacksburg, Virginia Tech., 193-224.
- Hangsubcharoen M., 1999(b). Thesis. A Study of
Triboelectrification Mechanisms for Coal, Quartz and
Pyrite. Blacksburg, Virginia Tech., 1-25.
- Higashiyama Y., Asano K., 1998. Recent Progress
in Electrostatic Separation Technology, Particulate
Science and Technology, 16:1, 77-90.
- Iuga A., Cuglesan I., Samuila A., Blajan M., Vadan
D., Ascalescu L., 2001. Electrostatic Separation of
Muscovite Mica from Feldspathic Pegmatites, 0-7803-
7116-X/01 (C) IEEE, 2249- 2255.
- Iuga A., Samuila A., Morar R., Bilici M., Dascalescu L.,
2016. Tribocharging Techniques for the Electrostatic
Separation of Granular Plastics from Waste Electric
and Electronic Equipment. Particulate Science and
Technology, 34 (1), 45-54.
- Kelly E.G., Spottiswood D.J., 1982. Introduction to
Mineral Processing. Wiley-Interscience Publication,
291-300.
- Li T. X., Ban H., Hower J. C., Stencel J. M., Saito K.,
1999. Dry Triboelectrostatic Separation of Mineral
Particles: A Potential Application in Space Exploration.
Journal of Electrostatics, 47, 133-142.
- Mirkowska M., Kratzer M., Teichert C., Flachberger H.,
2014. Atomic Force Microscopy as a Tool to Explore
Triboelectrostatic Phenomena in Mineral Processing.
Chem. Ing. Tech., 86 (6), 857-864.
- Mular A. L., Halbe D. N., Barratt D. J., 2002. Mineral
Processing Plant Design, Practice, and Control.
Editörler: Mular A. L. Vancouver: SME, Halbe D. Salt
Lake City: SME, Barratt D.J. North Vancouver: SME.
p.168.
- Panat R., Wang J, Parks E., 2014. Effects of
Triboelectrostatic Charging Between Polymer
Surfaces in Manufacturing and Test of Integrated
Circuit Packages, IEEE Transactions on Components.
Packaging And Manufacturing Technology, 4 (5), 943-
946.
- Park C. H., Park J. K., Jeon H. S., Chul Chun B., 2008.
Triboelectric Series and Charging Properties of Plastics
Using the Designed Vertical-Reciprocation Charger.
Journal of Electrostatics, 66, 578-583.
- Richard G., Touhami S., Zeghloul T., Dascalescu L.,
2016. Optimization of Metals and Plastics Recovery
from Electric Cable Wastes Using a Plate-Type
Electrostatic Separator. Waste Management. 60:112-
122.
- Saeki M., 2010. Triboelectric Separation of Binary
Plastic Mixture. World Academy of Science.
Engineering and Technology, 4, 818-821.
- Soong Y., Schoffstall M. R., Link T.A., 2001.
Triboelectrostatic Benefciation of Ash. Fuel, 80, 879-
884.
Tao D., AL-hwaiti M., 2010. Beneficiation Study of
Eshidiya Phosphorites Using A Rotary Triboelectrostatic
Separator. Mining Science and Technology, 20, 0357–
0364.
- Tao D., Fan M., Jiang X., 2009. Dry Coal Fly Ash
Cleaning Using Rotary Triboelectrostatic Separator.
Mining Science and Technology, 19, 0642–0647.
- Tao D., Sobhy A., Li Q., Honaker R., Zhao Y., 2011.
Dry Cleaning of Pulverized Coal Using A Novel Rotary
Triboelectrostatic Separator (RTS). International
Journal of Coal Preparation and Utilization, 31, 187-
202.
- Telford, W., Geldart, L., Sheriff, R., 1990. Electrical
Properties of Rocks and Minerals. In Applied
Geophysics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.,
pp. 283-292.
- Tilmatine A., Medles K., Bendimerad S.E., Boukholda
F., Dascalescu L., 2009. Electrostatic Separators of
Particles: Application to Plastic/Metal, Metal/Metal
and Plastic/Plastic Mixtures. Waste Management, 29,
228–232.
- Tripathy S. K., Ramamurthy Y., Kumar C. R., 2010.
Modeling of High-Tension Roll Separator for Separation
of Titanium Bearing Minerals. Powder Technology, 201,
181–186.
- Tunçbilek Belediyesi. http://www.tuncbilek.bel.tr/sayfa.
php?id=52. (Son erişim: 2020)
- Wang H., Chen S., Cai B., Ge L., Chen Q., 2014.
Study on the Dynamics of Tribocharged Coal and
Mineral Particles in Free-Fall Triboelectric Separator.
Separation Science and Technology, 49, 2990–2998.
- Wei J., Realff M. J., 2005. Design and Optimization
of Drum-type Electrostatic Separators for Plastics
Recycling. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 44, 3503-3509.
- Wills B. A., Napier-Munn T., 2006. Mineral Processing
Technology an Introduction to the Practical Aspects of
Ore Treatment and Mineral Recovery. Editörler: Wills,
B. A., Napier-Munn T. Elsevier Science & Technology
Books, 365-372.
- Wu G., Li J., Xu Z., 2013. Triboelectrostatic Separation
for Granular Plastic Waste Recycling: A Review. Waste
Management, 33, 585–597.
- Xin-xi Z., Dai-yong D., Bing T., Jin-song W., Feng
D., Hai-sheng L., Rui-xin M., 2009. Research on
the Triboelectrostatic Separation of Minerals from
Coal. The 6th International Conference on Mining
Science&Technology Procedia Earth and Planetary
Science, 1, 845–850.
- Younes M., Younes A. Sayah H., Tilmatine A., Samuila
A., Dascalescu L., 2013. Numerical and Experimental
Study of Insulating Particles Behavior in Roll-Type
Corona-Electrostatic Separators. Particulate Science
and Technology, 31, 71–80.
- Zeghloul T., Touhami S., Richard G, Miloudi M, Dahou
O., Dascalescu L., 2016. Optimal Operation of a Plate-
Type Corona-Electrostatic Separator for the Recovery
of Metals and Plastics from Granular Wastes. IEEE
Transactions on Industry Applications, 52 (3).
- Zhang L., Hou J., Bi X. T., Grace J. R., Janke T., 2012.
Electrostatic Beneficiation of Fly Ash in A Free-Falling
System. Claudio Arato Particuology, 10, 154-160.
Year 2020,
Volume: 59 Issue: 3, 183 - 192, 01.09.2020
Ergin Gülcan
T.onur Dizdar
Özcan Y. Gülsoy
References
- Alfano, G., Carbini, P., Carta, M., Ciccu, R., Del Fa,
C., Peretti, R., Zucca, A., 1985. Applications of Static
Electricity in Coal and Ore Beneficiation. J. Electrost.,
16, 315–328.
- Allen R. C., 2000. Triboelectric Generation: Getting
Charged Reproduced with Permission, EE-Evaluation
Engineering, 1-6.
- Baltrus J. P., Diehl J. R., Soong Y., Sands W., 2002.
Triboelectrostatic Separation of Fly Ash and Change
Reversal. Fuel, 81, 757-762.
- Ban H., Li T. X., Hower J. C., Schaefer J. L., Stencel
J. M., 1997. Dry Triboelectrostatic Beneficiation of Fly
Ash. Fuel, 76 (8), 801-805.
- Bittnera J. D., Hracha F. J., Gasiorowskia S. A.,
Canellopoulusb L. A., Guicherd H., 2014. Triboelectric
Belt Separator for Beneficiation of Fine Minerals. 2nd
International Symposium on Innovation and Technology
in the Phosphate Industry Procedia Engineering, 83,
122-129.
- Cangialosi F., Notarnicola M., Liberti L., Stencel J.
M., 2008. The Effects of Particle Concentration and
Charge Exchange on Fly Ash Beneficiation with
Pneumatic Triboelectrostatic Separation. Separation
and Purification Technology, 62, 240-248.
- Çelik M. S., Yaşar E., 1995. Effect of Temperature
and Impurities on Electrostatic Separation of Boron
Minerals. Mineral Engineering, Technical Note, 8 (7),
829-833.
- Chen J., Honaker R., 2015. Dry Separation on
Coal–Silica Mixture Using Rotary Triboelectrostatic
Separator. Fuel Processing Technology, 131, 317-324.
- Das S., Samuila A., Dragan C., Dascalescu L., 2009.
Behaviour of Charged Insulating Particles in Contact
with a Rotating Roll Electrode. Journal of Electrostatics,
67, 189–192.
- Diaza A. F., Felix-Navarrob R. M., 2004. A Semi-
Quantitative Tribo-Electric Series for Polymeric
Materials: The Influence of Chemical Structure and
properties, Journal of Electrostatics, 62, 277-290.
- Dizdar T. O., Kocausta G., Gülcan E., Gülsoy Ö. Y.,
2018. A New Method to Produce High Voltage Static
Electric Load for Electrostatic Separation–Triboelectric
Charging. Powder Technology, 327, 89-95.
- Dwari R. K., Hanumantha Rao K., 2006. Triboelectrostatic
Behaviour of High Ash Non-Coking, Indian
Thermal Coal. Int. J. Miner. Process, 81, 93–104.
- Dwari R. K., Hanumantha Rao K., Somasundaran P.,
2009. Characterisation of Particle Tribo-Charging and
Electron Transfer with Reference to Electrostatic Dry
Coal Cleaning. Int. J. Miner. Process, 91, 100-110.
- Dwari R. K., Mohanta S. K., Rout B., Soni R. K., Reddy
P. S. R., Mishra B. K., 2015. Studies on the Effect of
Electrode Plate Position and Feed Temperature on
the Tribo-Electrostatic Separation of High Ash Indian
Coking Coal. Advanced Powder Technology, 26, 31-41.
- Finseth, D., Newby, T., Elstrodt, R., 1993. Dry
Electrostatic Separation of Fine Coal. In: Parekh,
V.B.K., Gropps, J.G. (Eds.), Processing and Utilization
of High-Sulfur Coals. Elsevier Science Publisher, B.V.,
Amsterdam, 91-98.
- Hangsubcharoen M., 1999(a). Thesis. A Study of
Triboelectrification Mechanisms for Coal, Quartz and
Pyrite. Blacksburg, Virginia Tech., 193-224.
- Hangsubcharoen M., 1999(b). Thesis. A Study of
Triboelectrification Mechanisms for Coal, Quartz and
Pyrite. Blacksburg, Virginia Tech., 1-25.
- Higashiyama Y., Asano K., 1998. Recent Progress
in Electrostatic Separation Technology, Particulate
Science and Technology, 16:1, 77-90.
- Iuga A., Cuglesan I., Samuila A., Blajan M., Vadan
D., Ascalescu L., 2001. Electrostatic Separation of
Muscovite Mica from Feldspathic Pegmatites, 0-7803-
7116-X/01 (C) IEEE, 2249- 2255.
- Iuga A., Samuila A., Morar R., Bilici M., Dascalescu L.,
2016. Tribocharging Techniques for the Electrostatic
Separation of Granular Plastics from Waste Electric
and Electronic Equipment. Particulate Science and
Technology, 34 (1), 45-54.
- Kelly E.G., Spottiswood D.J., 1982. Introduction to
Mineral Processing. Wiley-Interscience Publication,
291-300.
- Li T. X., Ban H., Hower J. C., Stencel J. M., Saito K.,
1999. Dry Triboelectrostatic Separation of Mineral
Particles: A Potential Application in Space Exploration.
Journal of Electrostatics, 47, 133-142.
- Mirkowska M., Kratzer M., Teichert C., Flachberger H.,
2014. Atomic Force Microscopy as a Tool to Explore
Triboelectrostatic Phenomena in Mineral Processing.
Chem. Ing. Tech., 86 (6), 857-864.
- Mular A. L., Halbe D. N., Barratt D. J., 2002. Mineral
Processing Plant Design, Practice, and Control.
Editörler: Mular A. L. Vancouver: SME, Halbe D. Salt
Lake City: SME, Barratt D.J. North Vancouver: SME.
p.168.
- Panat R., Wang J, Parks E., 2014. Effects of
Triboelectrostatic Charging Between Polymer
Surfaces in Manufacturing and Test of Integrated
Circuit Packages, IEEE Transactions on Components.
Packaging And Manufacturing Technology, 4 (5), 943-
946.
- Park C. H., Park J. K., Jeon H. S., Chul Chun B., 2008.
Triboelectric Series and Charging Properties of Plastics
Using the Designed Vertical-Reciprocation Charger.
Journal of Electrostatics, 66, 578-583.
- Richard G., Touhami S., Zeghloul T., Dascalescu L.,
2016. Optimization of Metals and Plastics Recovery
from Electric Cable Wastes Using a Plate-Type
Electrostatic Separator. Waste Management. 60:112-
122.
- Saeki M., 2010. Triboelectric Separation of Binary
Plastic Mixture. World Academy of Science.
Engineering and Technology, 4, 818-821.
- Soong Y., Schoffstall M. R., Link T.A., 2001.
Triboelectrostatic Benefciation of Ash. Fuel, 80, 879-
884.
Tao D., AL-hwaiti M., 2010. Beneficiation Study of
Eshidiya Phosphorites Using A Rotary Triboelectrostatic
Separator. Mining Science and Technology, 20, 0357–
0364.
- Tao D., Fan M., Jiang X., 2009. Dry Coal Fly Ash
Cleaning Using Rotary Triboelectrostatic Separator.
Mining Science and Technology, 19, 0642–0647.
- Tao D., Sobhy A., Li Q., Honaker R., Zhao Y., 2011.
Dry Cleaning of Pulverized Coal Using A Novel Rotary
Triboelectrostatic Separator (RTS). International
Journal of Coal Preparation and Utilization, 31, 187-
202.
- Telford, W., Geldart, L., Sheriff, R., 1990. Electrical
Properties of Rocks and Minerals. In Applied
Geophysics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.,
pp. 283-292.
- Tilmatine A., Medles K., Bendimerad S.E., Boukholda
F., Dascalescu L., 2009. Electrostatic Separators of
Particles: Application to Plastic/Metal, Metal/Metal
and Plastic/Plastic Mixtures. Waste Management, 29,
228–232.
- Tripathy S. K., Ramamurthy Y., Kumar C. R., 2010.
Modeling of High-Tension Roll Separator for Separation
of Titanium Bearing Minerals. Powder Technology, 201,
181–186.
- Tunçbilek Belediyesi. http://www.tuncbilek.bel.tr/sayfa.
php?id=52. (Son erişim: 2020)
- Wang H., Chen S., Cai B., Ge L., Chen Q., 2014.
Study on the Dynamics of Tribocharged Coal and
Mineral Particles in Free-Fall Triboelectric Separator.
Separation Science and Technology, 49, 2990–2998.
- Wei J., Realff M. J., 2005. Design and Optimization
of Drum-type Electrostatic Separators for Plastics
Recycling. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 44, 3503-3509.
- Wills B. A., Napier-Munn T., 2006. Mineral Processing
Technology an Introduction to the Practical Aspects of
Ore Treatment and Mineral Recovery. Editörler: Wills,
B. A., Napier-Munn T. Elsevier Science & Technology
Books, 365-372.
- Wu G., Li J., Xu Z., 2013. Triboelectrostatic Separation
for Granular Plastic Waste Recycling: A Review. Waste
Management, 33, 585–597.
- Xin-xi Z., Dai-yong D., Bing T., Jin-song W., Feng
D., Hai-sheng L., Rui-xin M., 2009. Research on
the Triboelectrostatic Separation of Minerals from
Coal. The 6th International Conference on Mining
Science&Technology Procedia Earth and Planetary
Science, 1, 845–850.
- Younes M., Younes A. Sayah H., Tilmatine A., Samuila
A., Dascalescu L., 2013. Numerical and Experimental
Study of Insulating Particles Behavior in Roll-Type
Corona-Electrostatic Separators. Particulate Science
and Technology, 31, 71–80.
- Zeghloul T., Touhami S., Richard G, Miloudi M, Dahou
O., Dascalescu L., 2016. Optimal Operation of a Plate-
Type Corona-Electrostatic Separator for the Recovery
of Metals and Plastics from Granular Wastes. IEEE
Transactions on Industry Applications, 52 (3).
- Zhang L., Hou J., Bi X. T., Grace J. R., Janke T., 2012.
Electrostatic Beneficiation of Fly Ash in A Free-Falling
System. Claudio Arato Particuology, 10, 154-160.