Rusya-Avrupa Birliği İlişkileri ve Enerji Şartı

Year 2018, Volume: 1 Issue: 2, 45 - 73, 28.12.2018

Hüseyin Çağrı Çorlu

Abstract

Doğal gaz ve elektrik enerjisinin iletim hatlarından transit geçişine yönelik hukuki rejimlerin kurulması, ilgili devletler nezdinde enerji tedariğinin güvenliği ve rekabetçi enerji piyasalarının kurulması açısından büyük önem arz etmektedir. Uluslararası hukuk nezdinde enerji transitinin bir çözüme kavuşturulamamış olması, uluslararası hukukun temel aktörleri devletlerin ikili ve çoklu anlaşmalar yoluyla bu soruna eğilmesi neticesini doğurmuş olsa da, bu tür alternatif yolların, uyuşmazlıkların giderilmesi konusundaki başarısızlıkları, tecrübe edilen uluslararası krizler bağlamında açık bir şekilde görünmektedir. 1994 Enerji Şartı Anlaşması, özellikle enerji transitine yönelik olarak bünyesinde bulundurduğu 7. Madde uyarısınca, bu tür sorunların uluslararası boyutta ilk olarak ele alındığı bir hukuki rejim ön görmüştür. Fakat 2000’li yıllarda ard arda gerçekleşen enerji krizleri ve enerji şartının bu krizlerin önüne geçme konusundaki başarısızlığı, akademik camiada ve üye devletler nezdinde Şartın etkinliği ve gerekliliği konusunda çok ciddi eleştirilerin ortaya çıkmasına neden olmuştur. İş bu çalışma, bu eleştirilerin ortaya çıkmasının nedenleri ve Enerji Şartının enerji alanında ortaya çıkan uyuşmazlıklara ilişkin önceliklerini YUKOS davası ve 2009 doğal gaz krizi nezdinde detaylı bir şekilde incelemektedir. 

Keywords

nergy Charter Treaty, Gazprom, EU, YUKOS, Russia, Nabucco, Nord Stream, South Stream, Turkish Stream, Energy Security, Gas Crisis, Energy Transit, Fixed Infrastructure, GATT, WTO, Freedom of Transit

References

• Abdallah, H. (2005) "Oil Exports under GATT and the WTO," OPEC review, 29: 267-294.
• Aseeva, A. (2011) "EU-Russia Energy Relations: the Role of International Law from Energy Investment and Transit Perspective," In: University of Geneva.
• Azaria, D. (2009) "Energy Transit under the Energy Charter Treaty and the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade," Journal of energy & natural resources law, 27: 559-596.
• Bamberger, C (1995) The Energy Charter Treaty - a description of its provisions, International Energy Association
• Behn, D., & Pogoretskyy, V. (2011) "The Tension Between Trade Liberalization and Resource Sovereignty: Russia-EU Energy Relations and the Problem of Natural Gas Dual Pricing," Oil, Gas & Energy Law Journal (OGEL), 9.
• Christie, E. (2009) "Energy Vulnerability and EU-Russia Energy Relations," Journal of Contemporary European Research, 5: 274-292.
• Clark, B. (1998) "Transit and the Energy Charter Treaty: rhetoric and reality," Web Journal of Current Legal Issues, 5.
• Cossy, M. (2010) "Energy Transport and Transit in WTO," In Global Challenges at the Intersection of Trade, Energy and the Environment, edited by J. Pauwelyn. Geneva: Center for Trade and Economic Integration.
• Cottier, T., Malumfashi, G., Matteotti-Berkutova, S., Nartova, O., De Sepibus, J., & ZBigdeli, S. (2009) Energy in WTO law and policy: NCCR and World Trade Institute.
• Government of RF, 2003 Energy Strategy of Russia 2020. Adopted by the Decree of the Government of RF #1715, August 2003.
• General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, Apr. 15, 1994, Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, Annex 1A, THE LEGAL TEXTS: THE RESULTS OF THE URUGUAY ROUND OF MULTILATERAL TRADE NEGOTIATIONS 17 (1999), 1867 U.N.T.S. 187, 33 I.L.M. 1153 (1994) [GATT 1994].
• Kaveshnikov, N. (2010) "The issue of energy security in relations between Russia and the European Union," European security, 19: 585-605.
• Konoplyanik, A., & Wälde, T. (2006) "Energy Charter Treaty and its Role in International Energy," Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law, 24: 523-558.
• Konoplyanik, A. A. (2009) "Gas Transit in Eurasia: Transit Issues between Russia and the European Union and the Role of the Energy Charter," Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law, 27: 445-486.
• Lauterpacht, E. (1958) "Freedom of transit in international law," In Transactions of the Grotius Society: British Institute of International and Comparative Law.
• Liesen, R. (1999) "Transit under the 1994 Energy Charter Treaty," J. Energy & Nat. Resources L., 17: 56.
• Niebruegge, A. M. (2007) "Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty: The Yukos Arbitration and the Future Place of Provisional Application in International Law," Chi. J. Int'l L., 8: 355-376.
• Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, (2009), Who gets what from imported oil Vienna: OPEC.
• Papava, V., Bagirov, S., Grigoriev, L., Paczynski, W., & Salikhov, M. (2009) "Energy Trade and Cooperation between the EU and CIS Countries," In: CASE Network Reports.Pierros, P.-X., & Nuesch, S. (2000) "Trade in Electricity--Spot On," Journal of World Trade, 34: 95-124.
• Pirani, S., Stern, J. P., & Yafimava, K. (2009) The Russo-Ukrainian gas dispute of January 2009: a comprehensive assessment: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies Oxford.
• Putin, V., 2006. Replies to Russian journalists after the Russia-EU summit press conference, 25 May 2006, Sochi. Available from: http://president.kremlin.ru/appears/2006/05/25/2358_ type63380_106079.shtml
• Redgwell, C., (2005), “International energy security”, at: Barton, Barry et al. ed., Energy Security: managing risk in a dynamic legal and regulatory environment, Oxford: Oxford University Press,
• Roggenkamp, M. M. (1994) "Implications of GATT and EEC on Networkbound Energy Trade in Europe," J. Energy & Nat. Resources L., 12: 59-82.
• Roggenkamp, M. M. (1995) "Transit of Networkbound Energy: A New Phenomenon?—Transit Examined from the Barcelona Transit Convention to the Energy charter Treaty," World Competition, 19: 119-146.
• Saunders, J. O. (1994) "GATT, NAFTA and North American Energy Trade: A Canadian Perspective," J. Energy & Nat. Resources L., 12: 4.
• Selivanova, J. (2004) "World Trade Organization Rules and Energy Pricing: Russia’s Case," Journal of World Trade, 38: 559-602.
• Selivanova, J. (2008) Energy Dual Pricing in WTO Law: Analysis and Prospects in the Context of Russia's Accession to the WTO: Cameron May.
• Selivanova, Y. (2010) "Challenges for Multilateral Energy Trade Regulation: WTO and Energy Charter," In Society of International Economic Law (SIEL), Second Biennial Global Conference, University of Barcelona.
• Selivanova, Y. (2012) "International Energy Governance: The Role of the Energy Charter," In Proceedings of the Annual Meeting American Society of International Law.
• Shih, W.-C. (2008) "Energy Security, GATT/WTO and Regional Agreements," In Society of International Economic Law (SIEL) Inaugural Conference.
• The Energy Charter Treaty and Related Documents: a Legal Framework on International Energy Cooperation, available at: http://www.encharter.org/fileadmin/user_upload/document/EN.pdf
• UN Office of Legal Affairs Treaty Section, Treaty Handbook, para. 3.4, available at: https://treaties.un.org/doc/source/publications/THB/English.pdf ,
• Vinogradov, S. (1999) "Cross-border pipelines in international law, 14 Nat," In Res. & Env: American Bar Association.
• Yukos Universal Limited v. The Russian Federation, (PCA Case no. AA 227).
• Walde, T. W., & Gunst, A. J. (2002) "International energy trade and access to energy networks," Journal of World Trade, 36: 191-218.