Student Participation: Auspices And Contradictions in An Educational Innovation Context

Year 2024, Volume: 11 Issue: 5, 59 - 80, 12.09.2024

Pedro Jesus , Joaquim Azevedo

https://doi.org/10.17275/per.24.64.11.5

Abstract

Understanding children and youngsters’ participation as a key dimension in educational innovation processes assumes the evolution from a conceptualisation of learners as beneficiaries to another which sees them as partners within that innovation and active individuals, agents of the teaching-learning-evaluation process. The research was centred on this topic, focusing on secondary education, within the scope of an ongoing innovation process in a school located in Porto. We sought to understand how the co-constructed social change is being experienced and perceived by the protagonists and which factors may enable or hinder it. The research was based on qualitative information, assuming it was an exploratory, descriptive, interpretative study. Data was collected through three focus groups – one with teachers and two with students (one with 5th and 9th graders and another with 11th graders) –, as well as an individual interview with the headmaster. The data analysis showed that the transition from conditional or advisory forms of participation to collaborative or co-decision-making ones is neither simple nor immediate. In identifying the barriers to their participation or the factors which can promote it, students have shown to be able to go deeper into the issues at stake and to clearly understand the need to walk a path towards the shared assumption of a participation perspective based on continuous and committed dialogue. As well as allowing an understanding of the innovation process being analysed, this study can also shed light on other research or practical experiences that link student participation and innovation in school education.

Keywords

student participation, student voice, educational innovation

Ethical Statement

The work presented is original and all citations are correctly indicated and identified.

Supporting Institution

Portuguese Catholic University, Centre for Human Development Studies

References

• Amorim, J. P., & Azevedo, J. (2017). Lessons of the students: The future of education as anticipated by the voices of children and young people. Revista Portuguesa de Investigação Educacional [Portuguese Journal of Educational Research], 17, 61-97.
• Azevedo, J. (2020). What the literature concludes about pedagogical innovation. Support document for the Theories and Models of Innovation and Change Unit of the Postgraduate Programme in Pedagogical Innovation and Educational Change. Porto: Faculdade de Educação e Psicologia da Universidade Católica Portuguesa.
• Argos, J., Ezquerra, P., & Castro, A. (2011). Escuchando la voz de la infância en los procesos de cambio e investigación educativos. Aproximación al estudio de las transiciones educativas entre las etapas de Educación Infantil y Educación Primaria [Listening to the voice of children in the processes of educational change and research. An approach to the study of educational transitions between the Infant and Primary Education stages.]. Revista Iberoamericana de Educación [Ibero-American Journal of Education], 54(5), 1-18.
• Bernstein, B. (2000). Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
• Carbonell Sebarroja, J. (2008). Una educación para mañana [An education for tomorrow]. Barcelona: Ediciones Octaedro.
• Castro, A., & Manzanares, N. M. (2016). The little ones take the word: The preschool that they would like. Revista Complutense de Educación [Complutense Journal of Education], 27(3), 923-941.
• Cortesão, I., & Jesus, P. (2022). Apart-icipation or participation of children? Educational innovation experiences seen by the children themselves. Revista Portuguesa de Investigação Educacional [Portuguese Journal of Educational Research], (23), 1-34.
• Cortesão, I., & Jesus, P. (2023). Pasos en Participación de niños y jóvenes en centros educativos: Una dinámica de investigación-acción [Steps in child and youth participation in schools: An action-research dynamic]. In M. Sánchez-Moreno & J. López-Yañez (Eds.), Construir comunidad en la escuela [Building community in schools] (pp. 353-364). Madrid: Narcea Ediciones.
• Fielding, M. (2001). Students as Radical Agents of Change. Journal of Educational Change, 2, 123-141.
• Fielding, M. (2012). Beyond Student Voice: Patterns of Partnership and the Demands of Deep Democracy. Revista de Educación [Journal of Education], 359, 45-65.
• Fullan, M. (2016). The New Meaning of Educational Change (5th edition). New York: Routledge.
• Gerard, F.-M., & Roegiers, X. (2011). Currículo e avaliação: ligações que nunca serão suficientemente fortes [Curriculum and evaluation: links that can never be strong enough]. In M. P. Alves e J. M. De Ketele (Orgs.), Do Currículo à Avaliação, da Avaliação ao Currículo [From Curriculum to Evaluation, from Evaluation to Curriculum] (pp. 143-158). Porto: Porto Editora.
• Hart, R. (1992). Children’s Participation. From Tokenism to Citizenship. Florence: UNICEF.
• Jesus, P. (2022). Inovação educacional: Dimensões, modos de apropriação, consequências pedagógicas e organizacionais [Educational innovation: Dimensions, modes of appropriation, pedagogical and organisational consequences]. (Unpublished doctoral’s thesis), Faculty of Education and Psychology, Portuguese Catholic University. Institutional repository of the Portuguese Catholic University.
• Lodge, C. (2005). From hearing voices to engaging in dialogue: problematizing student participation in school improvement. Journal of Educational Change, 6, 125-146.
• Morgado, J. C. (2019). O estudo de caso na investigação em educação [The case study in educational research] (4th edition). Santo Tirso: De Facto Editores.
• Nóvoa, A. (2020). La notion de réforme en éducation est-elle encore pertinente aujourd’hui? [Is the notion of educational reform still relevant today?]. Revue internationale d’éducation de Sèvres [Sèvres International Review of Education], 83, 23-31.
• Santos Guerra, M. (2018). Innovar o morir [Innovate or die]. In C. Palmeirão e J. M. Alves (Coords.), Escola e Mudança: Construindo autonomias, flexibilidade e novas gramáticas da escolarização – Os desafios essenciais [School and Change: Building autonomy, flexibility and new grammars of schooling - The essential challenges] (pp. 20-43). Porto: UCP.
• Shier, H. (2000). Pathways to Participation: Openings, Opportunities, and Obligations. Children and Society, 14, 107-117.
• Skivenes, M., & Strandbu, A. (2006). A child's perspective and children’s participation. Children, Youth and Environments, 16(2), 10-27.
• Susinos, T., & Ceballos, N. (2012). Student Voice and Participatory Presence in School Life. Notes for Mapping Student Voice in Educational Improvement. Revista de Educación [Journal of Education], 359, 24-44.