Map Skills in Education: A Systematic Review of Terminology, Methodology and Influencing Factors

Abstract

For a few decades, map skills stay at the forefront of not only geographers’ and geographic educators’ research interest. To identify what has already been accomplished, where the research currently stands and where the potential for future studies lies, a review of the literature was carried out. Specifically, this comprehensive synthesis of map skill research focuses on three perspectives: terminology, methodological approaches, and mainly on investigated factors affecting the map skill level. As non-uniformity in terminology is apparent, an integrative framework of map skill types based on theoretical works and previous studies is proposed. Similarly, methods that can be more suitable and beneficial for future research than now prevailing non-standardized test are presented. These suggestions are mainly based on a variety of identified scarcely used methodological approaches. Furthermore, the synthesis shows that the number of factors which influence on the level of map skills has been tested is substantial. But that, frequently investigated categories of factors are identifiable. In addition, current gaps in map skill research are identified and insufficiently studied, yet potentially important factors are suggested for future studies.

Keywords

• Map skill
• map reading
• map use
• geography education
• systematic review

References

1. *Aksoy, B. (2013). Investigation of mapping skills of pre-service teachers as regards to various parameters. Educational Research and Reviews, 8(4), 134–143.
2. *Alhosani, N. M. D., & Yagoub, M. M. (2015). Geographic skills: a case study of students in the United Arab Emirates. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 24(1), 95–102.
3. *Allen, G. L., Miller Cowan, C. R., & Power, H. (2006). Acquiring information from simple weather maps: Influences of domain-specific knowledge and general visual–spatial abilities. Learning and Individual Differences, 16(4), 337–349.
4. *Baker, K. M., Petcovic, H., Wisniewska, M., & Libarkin, J. C. (2012). Spatial signatures of mapping expertise among field geologists. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 39(3), 119–132. Retrieved from Scopus.
5. *Barker, P., Hailstone, M., & Simmonds, M. (1986). An experimental study of some effects of figure-ground contrast on the use of street maps. Information Design Journal, 4(3), 212–220. Retrieved from Scopus.
6. *Battersby, S. E., Golledge, R. G., & Marsh, M. J. (2006). Incidental Learning of Geospatial Concepts Across Grade Levels: Map Overlay. Journal of Geography, 105(4), 139–146.
7. *Bausmith, J. M., & Leinhardt, G. (1998). Middle-School Students’ Map Construction: Understanding Complex Spatial Displays. Journal of Geography, 97(3), 93–107.
8. *Beatty, W. W., & Tröster, A. I. (1987). Gender differences in geographical knowledge. Sex Roles, 16(11–12), 565–590.

9. *Bein, F. L. (1990). Baseline Geography Competency Test: Administered in Indiana Universities. Journal of Geography, 89(6), 260–265.
10. *Bein, F. L., Hayes, J. J., & Jones, T. G. (2009). Fifteen Year Follow-Up Geography Skills Test Administered in Indiana, 1987 and 2002. Journal of Geography, 108(1), 30–36.
11. Blades, M., Blaut, J. M., Darvizeh, Z., Elguea, S., Sowden, S., Soni, D., … Uttal, D. (1998). A Cross-Cultural Study of Young Children’s Mapping Abilities. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 23(2), 269–277.
12. Board, C. (1978). Map reading tasks appropriate in experimental studies in cartographic communication. Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization, 15(1), 1–12.
13. Board, C. (1984). Higher Order Map-Using Tasks: Geographical Lessons In Danger Of Being Forgotten. Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization, 21(1), 85–97.
14. Carter, J. R. (2005). The many dimensions of map use. Proceedings of the XXII International Cartographic Conference, (A Coruña), 1–9.
15. Catling, S. J. (2005). Developing children’s understanding and use of maps. In C. Lee & C. C. Hung (Eds.), Primary Social Studies: Exploring Pedagogy and Content (pp. 220– 250). Singapore: Marshall Cavendish Education.
16. *Chang, K. T., & Antes, J. R. (1987). Sex and cultural differences in map reading. American Cartographer, 14(1), 29–42. Retrieved from Scopus.
17. *Clark, D., Reynolds, S., Lemanowski, V., Stiles, T., Yasar, S., Proctor, S., … Corkins, J. (2008). University Students’ Conceptualization and Interpretation of Topographic Maps. International Journal of Science Education, 30(3), 377–408.
18. Çöltekin, A., Fabrikant, S. I., & Lacayo, M. (2010). Exploring the efficiency of users’ visual analytics strategies based on sequence analysis of eye movement recordings. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 24(10), 1559–1575. Retrieved from Scopus.
19. DiBiase, D., Corbin, T., Fox, T., Francica, J., Green, K., Jackson, J., … Van Sickle, J. (2010). The New Geospatial Technology Competency Model: Bringing Workforce Needs into Focus. Journal of the Urban & Regional Information Systems Association, 22(2), 55–72.
20. Downs, R. M. (1994). The Need for Research in Geography Education: It Would be Nice to Have Some Data. Journal of Geography, 93(1), 57–60.
21. Drumheller, S. J. (1968). Conjure up a map – A crucial but much neglected skill. Journal of Geography, 67(3), 140–146.
22. *Eve, R. A., Price, B., & Counts, M. (1994). Geographic Illiteracy among College Students. Youth & Society, 25(3), 408–427.
23. Fox, P., & Avramidis, E. (2003). An evaluation of an outdoor education programme for students with emotional and behavioural difficulties. Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties, 8(4), 267–283. Retrieved from Scopus.
24. *Gerber, R. (1984). Factors affecting the competence and performance in map language for children at the concrete level of map-reasoning. Cartography, 13(3), 205–213. Retrieved from Scopus.
25. Gilmartin, P. P., & Patton, J. C. (1984). Comparing the Sexes on Spatial Abilities: Map-Use Skills. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 74(4), 605–619. Retrieved from Scopus.
26. *Gilmartin, P. P., & Shelton, E. (1989). Choropleth maps on high resolution CRTs, the effects of number of classes and hue on communication. Cartographica, 26(2), 40–52. Retrieved from Scopus.
27. Gökçe, N. (2015). Social Studies in Improving Students’ Map Skills: Teachers’ Opinions. Educational Sciences: Theory and Practice, 15(5), 1345–1362.
28. *Griffin, M. M. (1995). You Can′t Get There from Here: Situated Learning Transfer, and Map Skills. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 20(1), 65–87.
29. *Griffin, M. M., & Griffin, B. W. (1996). Situated Cognition and Cognitive Style: Effects on Students’ Learning as Measured by Conventional Tests and Performance Assessments. The Journal of Experimental Education, 64(4), 293–308.
30. *Grofelnik, H., & Pap, I. (2013). Mastery of Long-Term Cartographic Knowledge and Skills of New Entry Secondary Level Pupils. Kartografija i Geoinformacije (Cartography and Geoinformation), 12(19), 86–102.
31. Hamerlinck, J. D. (2015). Whither goes the “maps” course? Maintaining map-use concepts, skills, and appreciation in GIS&T curricula. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 42(1), 11–17.
32. Hanus, M., & Havelková, L. (2019). Teachers’ concepts of map skill development. Journal of Geography, 118(3), 101–116.
33. Hanus, M., & Marada, M. (2014). Mapové dovednosti: vymezení a výzkum. Geografie, 119(4), 406–422.
34. Hanus, M., & Marada, M. (2016). What does a map-skills-test tell us about Czech pupils? Geografie, 121(2), 279–299.
35. Harte, J., & Dunbar, C. (1994). Skills in Geography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
36. *Harwood, D., & Usher, M. (1999). Assessing Progression in Primary Children’s Map Drawing Skills. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 8(3), 222–238.
37. Havelková, L., & Hanus, M. (2019). Research into map-analysis strategies: theory- and data-driven approaches. Geografie, 124(2), 187–216.
38. Hemmer, I., Hemmer, M., Kruschel, K., Neidhardt, E., Obermaier, G., & Uphues, R. (2013). Which children can find a way through a strange town using a streetmap? – results of an empirical study on children’s orientation competence. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 22(1), 23–40.
39. *Henrie, R. L., Aron, R. H., Nelson, B. D., & Poole, D. A. (1997). Gender-Related Knowledge Variations Within Geography. Sex Roles, 36(9), 605–623.
40. Herrmann, D., & Pickle, L. W. (1996). A cognitive subtask model of statistical map reading. Visual Cognition, 3(2), 165–190. Retrieved from Scopus.
41. Higgins, J. P. T., & Green, S. (2011). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley.
42. *Hirsch, P. L., & Sandberg, E. H. (2013). Development of Map Construction Skills in Childhood. Journal of Cognition and Development, 14(3), 397–423.
43. Hurst, P., & Clough, P. (2013). Will We Be Lost Without Paper Maps in the Digital Age? Journal of Information Science, 39(1), 48–60.
44. Huynh, N. T., & Sharpe, B. (2013). An Assessment Instrument to Measure Geospatial Thinking Expertise. Journal of Geography, 112(1), 3–17.
45. *Ishikawa, T. (2016). Spatial thinking in geographic information science: Students’ geospatial conceptions, map-based reasoning, and spatial visualization ability. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 106(1), 76–95. Retrieved from Scopus.
46. Jo, I., Hong, J. E., & Verma, K. (2016). Facilitating spatial thinking in world geography using web-based GIS. Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 40(3), 442–459.
47. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., Stanne, M. B., & Garibaldi, A. (1990). Impact of Group Processing on Achievement in Cooperative Groups. The Journal of Social Psychology, 130(4), 507–516.
48. *Kastens, K. A., & Liben, L. S. (2010). Children’s Strategies and Difficulties while Using a Map to Record Locations in an Outdoor Environment. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 19(4), 315–340.
49. Keates, J. S. (1996). Understanding Maps. Harlow: Longman.
50. *Kelly, J. T., Kelly, G. N., & Miller, R. B. (1987). Logo experience: Effects on map skills. Computers in the Schools, 4(2), 57–64. Retrieved from Scopus.
51. Kim, K., Kim, M., Shin, J., & Ryu, J. (2015). Eye-Movement Analysis of Students’ Active Examination Strategy and Its Transfer in Visuospatial Representations. Journal of Geography, 114(4), 133–145.
52. Kimerling, A. J., Buckley, A. R., Muehrcke, P. C., & Muehrcke, J. O. (2009). Map Use: Reading and Analysis. Redlands: ESRI Press Academic.
53. Koláčný, A. (1969). Cartographic Information – a Fundamental Concept and Term in Modern Cartography. The Cartographic Journal, 6(1), 47–49.
54. Krassanakis, V., & Cybulski, P. (2019). A review on eye movement analysis in map reading process: The status of the last decade. Geodesy and Cartography, 68(1), 191–209.
55. LaSpina, J. A. (1998). The Visual Turn and the Transformation of the Textbook. Mahwah, NJ: Routledge.
56. Lauer, J. E., Yhang, E., & Lourenco, S. F. (2019). The development of gender differences in spatial reasoning: A meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 145(6), 537–565.
57. Lee, J., & Bednarz, R. (2012). Components of Spatial Thinking: Evidence from a Spatial Thinking Ability Test. Journal of Geography, 111(1), 15–26.
58. *Leinhardt, G., Stainton, C., & Bausmith, J. M. (1998). Constructing Maps Collaboratively. Journal of Geography, 97(1), 19–30.
59. *Liben, L. S., Myers, L. J., Christensen, A. E., & Bower, C. A. (2013). Environmental-Scale Map Use in Middle Childhood: Links to Spatial Skills, Strategies, and Gender. Child Development, 84(6), 2047–2063.
60. Liben, L. S., & Yekel, C. A. (1996). Preschoolers’ Understanding of Plan and Oblique Maps: The Role of Geometric and Representational Correspondence. Child Development, 67(6), 2780–2796.
61. *Liebenberg, E. C. (1998). Teaching map use in a multicultural environment. South African Geographical Journal, 80(2), 111–117. Retrieved from Scopus.
62. *Lim, K. Y. T. (2005). Augmenting Spatial Intelligence in the Geography Classroom. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 14(3), 187–199.
63. *Livni, S., & Bar, V. (2001). A controlled experiment in teaching physical map skills to grade 4 pupils in elementary schools. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 10(2), 149–167. Retrieved from Scopus.
64. *Logan, T., Lowrie, T., & Diezmann, C. M. (2014). Co-thought gestures: Supporting students to successfully navigate map tasks. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 87(1), 87–102.
65. *Malinowski, J. C., & Gillespie, W. T. (2001). Individual differences in performance on a large-scale, real-world wayfinding task. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 21(1), 73–82. Retrieved from Scopus.
66. *Matthews, M. H. (1986). Gender, Graphicacy and Geography. Educational Review, 38(3), 259–271.
67. McClure, R. W. (1992). A conceptual model for map skills curriculum development based upon a cognitive field theory philosophy (Unpublished PhD Dissertation). Oklahoma State University, Oklahoma.
68. McKissick, B. R., Spooner, F., Wood, C. L., & Diegelmann, K. M. (2013). Effects of computer-assisted explicit instruction on map-reading skills for students with autism. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, 7(12), 1653–1662.
69. *Michaelidou, E., Nakos, B., & Filippakopoulou, V. (2004). The Ability of Elementary School Children to Analyse General Reference and Thematic Maps. Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization, 39(4), 65–88.
70. Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., & The PRISMA Group. (2009). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. PLOS Medicine, 6(7), 1–28.
71. National Research Council. (2006). Learning to Think Spatially. Retrieved from http://www.nap.edu/catalog/11019
72. *Nelson, B. D., Henrie, R. L., Aron, R. H., & Poole, D. A. (1996). Academic achievement variations in geography: A public-parochial comparison. Great Lakes Geographer, 3(2), 51–56. Retrieved from Scopus.
73. *Ooms, K., De Maeyer, P., Dupont, L., Van der Veken, N., Van de Weghe, N., & Verplaetse, S. (2015). Education in cartography: what is the status of young people’s map-reading skills? Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 43(2), 134–153.
74. *Pedersen, P., Farrell, P., & McPhee, E. (2005). Paper versus Pixel: Effectiveness of Paper versus Electronic Maps to Teach Map Reading Skills in an Introductory Physical Geography Course. Journal of Geography, 104(5), 195–202.
75. Pike, E., Blades, M., & Spencer, C. (1992). A Comparison Of Two Types Of Tactile Maps For Blind Children. Cartographica, 29(3–4), 83–88. (world).
76. *Postigo, Y., & Pozo, J. I. (1998). The Learning of a Geographical Map by Experts and Novices. Educational Psychology, 18(1), 65–80.
77. *Postigo, Y., & Pozo, J. I. (2004). On the Road to Graphicacy: The learning of graphical representation systems. Educational Psychology, 24(5), 623–644.
78. *Riding, R. J., & Boardman, D. J. (1983). The Relationship between Sex and Learning Style and Graphicacy in 14‐year‐old Children. Educational Review, 35(1), 69–79.
79. Rittschof, K. A., Griffin, M. M., & Custer, W. L. (1998). Learner Differences Affecting Schemata for Thematic Maps. International Journal of Instructional Media, 25(2), 179–199.
80. Robinson, A. H. (1995). Elements of Cartography. New York: Wiley.
81. Roth, R. E. (2012). Cartographic Interaction Primitives: Framework and Synthesis. The Cartographic Journal, 49(4), 376–395.
82. *Scevak, J. J., & Moore, P. J. (1998). Levels of Processing Effects on Learning from Texts with Maps. Educational Psychology, 18(2), 133–155.
83. Schlemper, M. B., Adams, J. K., & Solem, M. (2014). Geographers in Business, Government, and Nonprofit Organizations: Skills, Challenges, and Professional Identities. The Professional Geographer, 66(3), 480–492.
84. Schulze, U., Kanwischer, D., & Reudenbach, C. (2011). Competence Dimensions in a Bologna-oriented GIS Education. In T. Jekel, A. Koller, AGIT-Symposium, & Geoinformatics Forum (Eds.), Learning with GI 2011. Berlin: Wichmann.
85. *Shin, E. K. (2007). Using Geographic Information System (GIS) Technology to Enhance Elementary Students’ Geographic Understanding. Theory & Research in Social Education, 35(2), 231–255.
86. *Sholl, M. J., & Egeth, H. E. (1982). Cognitive correlates of map-reading ability. Intelligence, 6(2), 215–230. Retrieved from Scopus.
87. Solem, M. (2017). Geography Education, Workforce Trends, Twenty-First-Century Skills, and Geographical Capabilities. In D. Richardson, N. Castree, M. F. Goodchild, A. Kobayashi, W. Liu, & R. A. Marston (Eds.), The International Encyclopedia of Geography (pp. 1–9).
88. Solem, M., Cheung, I., & Schlemper, M. B. (2008). Skills in Professional Geography: An Assessment of Workforce Needs and Expectations. The Professional Geographer, 60(3), 356–373.
89. Sowden, S., Stea, D., Blades, M., Spencer, C., & Blaut, J. M. (1996). Mapping Abilities of Four-Year-Old Children in York, England. Journal of Geography, 95(3), 107–111.
90. *Teck, L. B. (1989). Effects of Practical Experience and Sequential Skills in Map Reading. Singapore Journal of Education, 10(1), 55–59. Retrieved from Scopus.
91. *Trifonoff, K. M. (1995). Going beyond location: Thematic maps in the early elementary grades. Journal of Geography, 94(2), 368–374.
92. *Ugodulunwa, C., & Wakjissa, S. (2015). Use of Portfolio Assessment Technique in Teaching Map Sketching and Location in Secondary School Geography in Jos, Nigeria. Journal of Education and Practice, 6(17), 23–30.
93. *Umek, M. (2003). A comparison of the effectiveness of drawing maps and reading maps in beginning map teaching. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 12(1), 18–31. Retrieved from Scopus.
94. *Ungar, S., Blades, M., & Spencer, C. (1997). Strategies for knowledge acquisition from cartographic maps by blind and visually impaired adults. Cartographic Journal, 34(2), 93–110. Retrieved from Scopus.
95. *van der Schee, J. A., & van Dijk, H. (1999). The effect of student freedom of choice in learning map skills. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 8(3), 256–267. Retrieved from Scopus.
96. *van Dijk, H., van der Schee, J., Trimp, H., & van der Zijpp, T. (1994). Map skills and geographical knowledge. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 3(1), 68–80. Retrieved from Scopus.
97. Wiegand, P. (2006). Learning and Teaching with Maps. New York: Routledge.
98. *Wiegand, P., & Stiell, B. (1997). Children’s Relief Maps of Model Landscapes. British Educational Research Journal, 23(2), 179–192.
99. *Winn, W. D., & Sutherland, S. W. (1989). Factors influencing the recall of elements in maps and diagrams and the strategies used to encode them. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81(1), 33–39.
100. Wood, M. (1972). Human Factors in Cartographic Communication. The Cartographic Journal, 9(2), 123–132.
101. Zadrozny, J., McClure, C., Lee, J., & Jo, I. (2016). Designs, Techniques, and Reporting Strategies in Geography Education: A Review of Research Methods. Review of International Geographical Education Online, 6(3), 216–233.