Thermal design and CFD simulation of an internal heat exchanger with R1234yf as an alternate refrigerant to R134a

Abstract

The most widely utilized refrigerant in car air conditioners today is still R134a, particularly in developing nations, but its global warming potential is very high (1430). The use of high global warming potential working substances is progressively prohibited and restricted by the F-gas act and the Kigali Amendment in developing and developed nations. R1234yf has been the subject of thermodynamic research as a potential replacement for R134a in vehicle air conditioning systems. Compared to R134a, R1234yf performs somewhat inferior, that can be improved by incorporating an internal heat exchanger into the existing system. Refereeing to the literature available, computational fluid dynamics analysis of the internal heat exchanger for an automobile air conditioning system with refrigerant R1234yf is rarely observed. Hence the novel concept of computational fluid dynamics analysis of thermally designed internal heat exchanger is focused here. This study analyzes the thermal design of an internal heat exchanger and its impact on the coefficient of performance for R1234yf and R134a. And computational fluid dynamics analysis of the thermal designed internal heat exchanger is performed to finalize the dimension of the internal heat exchanger. For similar cooling capacity, the system with refrigerant R134a performance is not much af-fected by the application of an internal heat exchanger. Its COP increases from 3.636 to 3.676, i.e., only 1.09%. While the performance gap of the system with refrigerant R1234yf as compared to the system with R134a without an internal heat exchanger is 5.17%, while the gap is decreased up to 3.16% with an internal heat exchanger. Identical results are obtained in computational fluid dynamics analysis, with an increment in the internal heat exchanger length, heat transfer increases as well, and the outlet temperature meets the necessary level within a tolerable pressure drop.

Keywords

• Automobile Air Conditioning
• COP
• CFD
• R1234yf
• R134a
• Internal Heat Exchanger

References

1. [1] UNEP Technical Options Committee. 2018 report of the Refrigeration, Air Conditioning and Heat Pumps Technical Options Committee. Nairobi: United Nations Environment Programme; 2019. [Crossref]
2. [2] United Nations. Kigali Amendment 2016;2:1–16.
3. [3] India Cooling Action Plan. Ozone Cell, Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, Government of India; 2019.
4. [4] Yang CY, Nalbandian H. Condensation heat transfer and pressure drop of refrigerants HFO-1234yf and HFC-134a in small circular tube. Int J Heat Mass Transf 2018;127:218–227. [Crossref]
5. [5] Hasheer SM, Srinivas K, Bala PK. Energy analysis of HFC-152a, HFO-1234yf and HFC/HFO mixtures as a direct substitute to HFC-134a in a domestic refrigerator. Stroj Cas 2021;71:107–120. [Crossref]
6. [6] Satapathy PP, Satapathy PK, Sahoo SS. Comparative performance study of autocascade and cascade refrigeration systems using working fluid pair R23/R507A. Recent Adv Mech Eng 2024:411–426. [Crossref]
7. [7] Reasor P, Aute V, Radermacher R. Refrigerant R1234yf performance comparison investigation. Int Refrig Air Cond Conf Purdue 2010:1–7.
8. [8] Devotta S, Waghmare AV, Sawant NN, Domkundwar BM. Alternatives to HCFC-22 for air conditioners. Appl Therm Eng 2001;21:703–715. [Crossref]

9. [9] Ghodbane M. An investigation of R152a and hydrocarbon refrigerants in mobile air conditioning. SAE Trans Sect J Passeng Cars 1999;108:1658–1673. [Crossref]
10. [10] Alkan A, Kolip A, Hosoz M. Energetic and exergetic performance comparison of an experimental automotive air conditioning system using refrigerants R1234yf and R134a. J Therm Eng 2021;7:1163–1173. [Crossref]
11. [11] Direk M, Kelesoglu A. Automotive air conditioning system with an internal heat exchanger using R1234yf and different evaporation and condensation temperatures. Therm Sci 2019;23:1115–1125. [Crossref]
12. [12] Hmood KS, Apostol V, Pop H, Badescu V, Pop E. Drop-in and retrofit refrigerants as replacement possibilities of R134a in domestic/commercial refrigeration and automobile air conditioner applications. J Therm Eng 2021;7:1815–1835. [Crossref]
13. [13] Sharif MZ, Azmi WH, Ghazali MF, Samykano M, Ali HM. Performance improvement strategies of R1234yf in vapor compression refrigeration system as a R134a replacement: a review. J Taiwan Inst Chem Eng 2023;148:105032. [Crossref]
14. [14] Karademir H, Wongwises S. Comprehensive review on the flow characteristics of two-phase flows in inclined tubes. J Therm Eng 2021;7:483–549. [Crossref]
15. [15] Agarwal SA, Akhilesh AA, Arora BB. Energy and exergy investigations of R1234yf and R1234ze as R134a replacements in mechanically subcooled vapour compression refrigeration cycle. J Therm Eng 2020;7:109–132. [Crossref]
16. [16] Daviran S, Kasaeian A, Golzari S, Mahian O, Nasirivatan S, Wongwises S, et al. A comparative study on the performance of HFO-1234yf and HFC-134a as an alternative in automotive air conditioning systems. Appl Therm Eng 2017;110:1091–1100. [Crossref]
17. [17] Lin Y, Meng Z, Huo Z, Ding C, Wang S, Wang L. Theoretical analysis of R1234yf and R1234yf/R125 mixture as replacement of R134a in vapor compression system. Int J Low-Carbon Technol 2024;19:490–496. [Crossref]
18. [18] Lee Y, Kang DG, Jung D. Performance of virtually non-flammable azeotropic HFO1234yf/HFC134a mixture for HFC134a applications. Int J Refrig 2013;36:1203–1207. [Crossref]
19. [19] Patel B, Parekh A. Energy, exergy and entropy analysis with R1234yf as an alternate refrigerant to R134a of automobile air conditioning system. J Therm Eng 2024;10:101–114. [Crossref]
20. [20] Wantha C. Analysis of heat transfer characteristics of tube-in-tube internal heat exchangers for HFO-1234yf and HFC-134a refrigeration systems. Appl Therm Eng 2019;157:113747. [Crossref]
21. [21] Kwon YC, Kim DH, Lee JH, Choi JY, Lee SJ. Experimental study on heat transfer characteristics of internal heat exchangers for CO2 system under cooling condition. J Mech Sci Technol 2009;23:698–706. [Crossref]
22. [22] Alkan A, Kolip A, Hosoz M, Yashawantha KM, Vinod AV, Khatoon S, et al. Energetic and exergetic performance comparison of an experimental automotive air conditioning system using refrigerants R1234yf and R134a. J Therm Eng 2021;7:490–504. [Crossref]
23. [23] Alkan A, Kolip A. Thermodynamic analysis of an automotive air conditioning system using R1234yf and R134a. In: Sixth Int Exergy, Energy Environ Symp (IEEES-6), Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Univ, Rize, Turkey; 2013.
24. [24] Direk M, Kelesoglu A, Akin A. Drop-in performance analysis and effect of IHX for an automotive air conditioning system with R1234yf as a replacement of R134a. Stroj Vestn J Mech Eng 2017;63:314–319. [Crossref]
25. [25] Direk M, Kelesoglu A. Theoretical performance analysis of an R1234yf refrigeration cycle based on the effectiveness of internal heat exchanger. Hittite J Sci Eng 2017;4:23–30. [Crossref]
26. [26] Cho H, Lee H, Park C. Performance characteristics of an automobile air conditioning system with internal heat exchanger using refrigerant R1234yf. Appl Therm Eng 2013;61:563–569. [Crossref]
27. [27] Mota-Babiloni A, Navarro-Esbrí J, Barragán Á, Molés F, Peris B. Drop-in energy performance evaluation of R1234yf and R1234ze(E) in a vapor compression system as R134a replacements. Appl Therm Eng 2014;71:259–265. [Crossref]
28. [28] Mohapatra T, Ray S, Sahoo SS, Padhi BN. Numerical study on heat transfer and pressure drop characteristics of fluid flow in an inserted coiled tube type three fluid heat exchanger. Heat Transf Asian Res 2019;48:1440–1465. [Crossref]
29. [29] Navarro E, Martinez-Galvan IO, Nohales J, Gonzálvez-Macia J. Comparative experimental study of an open piston compressor working with R1234yf, R134a and R290. Int J Refrig 2013;36:768–775. [Crossref]
30. [30] Klein SA, Alvarado F. Engineering Equation Solver. Middleton, WI: F-Chart Software; 2005.
31. [31] Shah RK, Sekulic DP. Fundamentals of heat exchanger design. 1st ed. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons; 2003. [Crossref]
32. [32] Perez Gracia V, Belman-Flores JM, Rodriguez-Munoz JL, Rangel-Hernandez VH, Gallegos-Munoz A. Second law analysis of a mobile air conditioning system with internal heat exchanger using low GWP refrigerants. Entropy 2017;19:40175. [Crossref]