Experimental Study of Evolution of Breach Resulting from Seepage at Upper Part of Earth-Fill Dam

Abstract

Piping and overtopping are the most important causes of earth-fill dam failure. Such dams may erode under seepage, causing a reduction in the structural strength. The aim of this study was to investigate the temporal evolution of the breach and flow rate from the breach resulting from the piping in earth-fill dams. The experiments were carried out at Hydraulics Laboratory of Civil Engineering Department within İzmir University of Economics. The dam was constructed by using a mixture consisting of 85 % sand and 15 % fine (low plasticity clay). In the first scenario a circular tunnel with a diameter of 2 cm was created along the centreline at 6 cm below the dam crest whereas in the second one it was located at the upper edge. Six cameras at different locations recorded the evolution of the progress of the breach formation. The pump flow rate was measured by magnetic flow meter, and the continuity equation was used to calculate the flow rate values from the breach. The time-varied values of the total breach areas were determined using the Gauss Area formula. The image processing method was also applied in the determination of the breach areas. The time-dependent changes of water depth in the channel were also recorded. The obtained experimental findings are presented and commented, together with the universal dimensionless curves. The failure of the dams occurred mainly because of the headcut erosion developed from downstream to upstream. When breaching started, the orifice flow was converted to open channel flow where breach bottom behaved like a broad crested weir. In the second scenario, the rigid lateral side considerably influenced the flow rate and the development of the breach. The peak flow rate corresponding to the first scenario was found approximately 2.3 times greater than that of the second one. The maximum values of all the breach parameters were reached earlier in the case of the seepage along the centerline. The ratios between the values corresponding to the first and the second scenarios were found as 3.25 and 1.75 for maximum breach areas at downstream and at upstream sides, respectively. These ratios were 2.44 and 1.37 for the average breach widths at downstream and upstream sides, respectively. A very good agreement was found between the area values obtained from Gauss area method and image processing technique, in both scenarios. This fact demonstrated that either of these two approaches can be used to determine the time-dependent breach areas. These experimental findings provide the opportunities for the calibration and validation of the numerical models used in the relevant numerical investigations. This study also offers guidance for the strategies concerning emergency action plans related to the failure of homogeneous earth-fill dams when the piping starts at upper part of the homogeneous earth-fill dams.

Keywords

• Earth-fill dam
• piping
• breach geometry
• breach development
• discharge from the breach

Project Number

1119M609

Experimental Study of Evolution of Breach Resulting from Piping at Upper Part of Earth-Fill Dam

Abstract

Piping and overtopping are the most important causes of earth-fill dam failure. Such dams may erode under seepage, causing a reduction in the structural strength. The aim of this study was to investigate the temporal evolution of the breach and flow rate from the breach resulting from the piping in earth-fill dams. The experiments were carried out at Hydraulics Laboratory of Civil Engineering Department within İzmir University of Economics. The dam was constructed by using a mixture consisting of 85 % sand and 15 % fine (low plasticity clay). In the first scenario a circular tunnel with a diameter of 2 cm was created along the centreline at 6 cm below the dam crest whereas in the second one it was located at the upper edge. Six cameras at different locations recorded the evolution of the progress of the breach formation. The pump flow rate was measured by magnetic flow meter, and the continuity equation was used to calculate the flow rate values from the breach. The time-varied values of the total breach areas were determined using the Gauss Area formula. The image processing method was also applied in the determination of the breach areas. The time-dependent changes of water depth in the channel were also recorded. The obtained experimental findings are presented and commented, together with the universal dimensionless curves. The failure of the dams occurred mainly because of the headcut erosion developed from downstream to upstream. When breaching started, the orifice flow was converted to open channel flow where breach bottom behaved like a broad crested weir. In the second scenario, the rigid lateral side considerably influenced the flow rate and the development of the breach. The peak flow rate corresponding to the first scenario was found approximately 2.3 times greater than that of the second one. The maximum values of all the breach parameters were reached earlier in the case of the seepage along the centerline. The ratios between the values corresponding to the first and the second scenarios were found as 3.25 and 1.75 for maximum breach areas at downstream and at upstream sides, respectively. These ratios were 2.44 and 1.37 for the average breach widths at downstream and upstream sides, respectively. A very good agreement was found between the area values obtained from Gauss area method and image processing technique, in both scenarios. This fact demonstrated that either of these two approaches can be used to determine the time-dependent breach areas. These experimental findings provide the opportunities for the calibration and validation of the numerical models used in the relevant numerical investigations. This study also offers guidance for the strategies concerning emergency action plans related to the failure of homogeneous earth-fill dams when the piping starts at upper part of the homogeneous earth-fill dams.

Keywords

• Earth-fill dam
• piping
• breach geometry
• breach development
• discharge from the breach

Supporting Institution

The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (TUBITAK)

Project Number

1119M609

Thanks

The authors thank the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (TUBITAK) for supporting financially this study through the project 119M609.

References

1. Zhong, Q., Wang, L., Chen, S., Chen, Z., Shan, Y., Zhang, Q., Ren, Q., Mei, S., Jiang, J., Hu, L., & Liu, J., Breaches of embankment and landslide dams - State of the art review. Earth-Science Reviews, 216, 103597, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2021.103597
2. Robbins, B. A., & van Beek, V. M., Backward erosion piping: A historical review and discussion of influential factors. Association of State Dam Safety Officials, Dam Safety 2015, September, 2015.
3. ASCE/EWRI Task Committee on Dam/Levee Breaching, Earthen Embankment Breaching. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 137, 12, 1549–1564, 2011. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HY.1943-7900.0000498
4. Sellmeijer, J. B. On the mechanism of piping under impervious structures [Bibliotheek Technische Universiteit], 1988. http://repository.tudelft.nl/assets/uuid:7f3c5919-1b37-4de9-a552-1f6e900eeaad/TR diss 1670(1).pdf
5. Teton Dam History & Facts . http://www.usbr.gov/ssle/damsafety/index.html, 2016.
6. Al-Janabi A.M.S., Ghazali A.H., Ghazaw Y.M., Afan H.A., Al-Ansari N., and Yaseen Z.M., Experimental and numerical analysis for earth-fill dam seepage. Sustainability, 12(6),2490, 2020. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12062490.
7. Dhiman, S., and Patra, K. C., Experimental study of embankment breach based on its soil properties. ISH Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, Taylor & Francis, 26, 3, 247–257, 2020.
8. Zhu, Y., Visser, P. J., Vrijling, J. K., and Wang, G., Experimental investigation on breaching of embankments. Science China Technological Sciences, 54, 1, 148–155, 2011.

9. Morris, M., Hassan, M., Kortenhaus, A., Geisenhainer, P., Visser, P., and Zhu, Y., Modelling breach initiation and growth. Flood Risk Management: Research and Practice, 581–591, 2008.
10. Zomorodian, S. M. A., Noghab, M. J. A., Zolghadr, M., and O’Kelly, B. C., Overtopping erosion of model earthen dams analysed using digital image-processing method. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Water Management, 173, 6, 304–316, 2020.
11. Sharif, Y. A., Elkholy, M., Hanif Chaudhry, M., and Imran, J., Experimental Study on the Piping Erosion Process in Earthen Embankments. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 141, 7, 04015012, 2015.
12. Elkholy, M., Sharif, Y. A., Chaudhry, M. H., and Imran, J., Effect of soil composition on piping erosion of earthen levees. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 53, 4, 478–487, 2015.
13. Annunziato, A., Santini, M., Proietti, C., Girolamo, L., Lorini, V., Gerhandinger, A., Tucci, M., Modelling and Validation of the Derna Dam Break Event GeoHazards, 5, 2, 504-529, 2024. https://doi.org/10.3390/geohazards5020026.
14. Guney, M. S., Dumlu, E., Okan, M., and Tayfur, G., Experimental Study of Breach Evolution and Discharge Through Breach Resulting from Piping due to Seepage at the Upper Corner of in an Earth-Fill Dam. 14th International Conference on Hydroscience & Engineering (ICHE 2022) MAY 26-27, 2022, İzmir, Turkey, 99–109, 2022a.
15. Guney, M. S., Okan, M., Dumlu, E., Bor, A., Aklık, P., and Tayfur, G., Experimental Study of the Evolution of the Breach and the Discharge Through the Breach Resulting from Piping due to Seepage at the Earth-Fill Dam Top. Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress 19-24 June 2022, Granada, Spain, 2735–2743, 2022b.
16. Ojha, C. S. P., Singh, V. P., and Adrian, D. D., Influence of Porosity on Piping Models of Levee Failure. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 127, December, 1071–1074, 2001.
17. Richards, K. S., and Reddy, K. R., Critical appraisal of piping phenomena in earth dams. Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 66, 4, 381–402, 2007.
18. Terzaghi, K., Peck, R. B., and Mesri, G., Soil mechanics in engineering practice. Wiley, New York, 1996.
19. Okan, M., Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Piping in Uniform Embankment Dam with Weak Layer at the Upper Region. M.Sc. Thesis, İzmir Institute of Technology, 2022.