Application of Value Engineering to Identify and Solve Irrigation Water Allocation Problems

Year 2022, , 430 - 441, 31.12.2022

Nura Jafar Shanono , Nuraddeen Mukhtar Nasidi

https://doi.org/10.46592/turkager.1191442

Abstract

Periodic assessment and monitoring of the functionality of irrigation scheme components is the popularly known approach for identifying and fixing existing or looming problems. For example the widely used quantitative metrics for irrigation water allocation performance assessment include equity, adequacy, and reliability of water supply. However, a qualitative metric that is seldom applied particularly in Nigeria is the value engineering method. A value engineering method is problem identification and solving approach commonly used to analyze the level of functionality of a given system or its components. The approach comprised the following phases; problem identification, system functionality analysis, creation, evaluation and development of value alternatives. A value engineering approach was applied to identify and solve the water allocation problem at Watari Irrigation Project (WIP), Kano Nigeria. Eleven (11) major problems related to water allocation were identified, and 27 solutions (ideas) were suggested, screened and reduced to 13 by the irrigating management experts. Five (5) value alternatives (VA) from the finally screened ideas were formed by putting 2 or 3 ideas as an integrated solution for a given problem. The 5 value alternatives include repairing water conveyance infrastructures, dredging water conveyance infrastructures, improving on-farm water management, conducting policy dialogue and alteration and creating awareness and sensitization campaigns. After scoring these value alternatives using a scale of 0 to 10 by another set of irrigation experts, dredging water conveyance infrastructures is having the highest score of 8.19 and hence, it requires urgent attention from the relevant authority.

Keywords

Irrigation, Water allocation, Problem identification and solving, Value engineering

References

• Atabay S and Galipogullari N (2013): Application of value engineering in a construction project. Dec. 2013, Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering, 1(1) (Serial No. 1): 39-48.
• Cakmak B, Polat E, Kendirli B, Gokalp Z (2009). Evaluation of irrigation performance of Asartepe irrigation association. A case study from Turkey, Akdeniz Univesitesi Ziraat Fakultesi Dergisi, 22(1): 1-8.
• Chen Tsai and Liou, Shen. (2013). A simplified way of implementing value engineering or public works. Applied Mechanics and Materials, Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland 2013; 357-360: 2925-390.
• El-Nashar WY and Elyamany AH (2017). Value engineering for canal tail irrigation water problem. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 9: 1989-1997.
• Gorantiwar SD and Smont IK (2005). Performance assessment of irrigation water management of heterogenous irrigation scheme; 1. A framework for evaluation of irrigation and drainage systems. Management Research in Tanzania, 19 (1): 1-36.
• Jubril G, Saidu M and Yabagi AA (2017). Performance evaluation of Baddegi irrigation scheme, Niger State Nigeria, using efficiency techniques. Journal of Science Research and Essay, 6(2): 42-47. http://www.scholarly-journals.com/SJSRE
• Nasidi NM, Shanono NJ and Bello MM (2016). Performance evaluation of water conveyance system at watari ırrigation project (WIP). Proceedings of the iSTEAMS Multidisciplinary Cross- Border Conference University of Professional Studies, Accra Ghana.
• Raghava S, Rani Y, Venkateswarao B and Sreeenth S (2011). Modernization of an existing ırrigation project by performance evaluation using performance ındicators. International Journal of Mathematics and Engineering, 141: 1273-1292.
• Sabo AA, Abubakar MS, Zakari MD, Shanono NJ, Jibril AN and Adamu UK (2021). Effect of organic materials on soil physio-chemical properties at Bayero University, Kano-Nigeria. Agricultural Engineering International: CIGR Journal, 23(3): 52-59. https://cigrjournal.org/index.php/Ejounral/article/view/6893/3669
• Shanono NJ, Othman MK, Nasidi NM and Ismail H (2012). Evaluation of soil and water quality of water irrigation project in Semi, Arid Region, Kano, Nigeria. Proceedings of the 33rd Nigerian Institute of Agricultural Engineers, 33: 181-186.
• Shanono NJ, Nasidi NM, Zakari MD and Bello MM (2014). Assessment of field channels performance at Watari irrigation project kano, Nigeria. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Drylands 2014.
• Shanono NJ, Sabo AA, Nasidi NM, Zakari MD, Mohammed M, Ismail H and Halilu AG (2015). Hydraulic Infrastructures and Institutional Assessment of Watari Irrigation Project, Kano. Journal of Engineering and Technology, 10(2): 44-51. https://www.bayerojet.com/papers/infrastructures-and-institutional-assessment-of-watari-irrigation-project-kano/
• Shanono NJ, Bello MM, Zakari MD, Ibrahim A, Usman IMT, Nasidi NM and Maina MM (2020). Stakeholders conflict and infrastructural decay in Nigeria irrigation schemes: A Review. Nigeria Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Research, 6(1): 78-90.
• Shanono NJ, Isma’il H, Nasidi NM, Yahya MN, Umar SI, Nuradeen AY, Musa AM, Mustapha Z and Zakari MD (2021a). Assessing the operational performance and stakeholders’ perceptions on the management of ırrigation projects in Kano, Nigeria. COMU Journal of Agriculture Faculty, 9(2): 317-325. http://dx.doi.org/10.33202/comuagri.936306
• Shanono NJ, Isma’il H, Nasidi NM, Yahya MN, Umar SI, Nuradeen AY, Musa AM, Mustapha Z and Zakari MD (2021b). Assessing the operational performance and stakeholders’ perceptions on the management of irrigation projects in Kano, Nigeria, 9(2): 317-325.
• Shanono NJ, Lawan A and Nasidi NM (2022). Value Engineering-based Framework for Assessing the Performance of Irrigation Scheme Components. Proceedings of the Nigerian Institution of Agricultural Engineers, 42: 144-153.
• Zakari MD, Haruna ND, Ishaq SO, Sani S, Mohammed Ahmadu SE, Ibrahim A, Nasidi NM, Shanono NJ and Sabo AA (2021). Assessing the farmers’ awareness and practices of irrigation water conservation techniques in Kano - Nigeria. Algerian Journal of Engineering and Technology, 5:14-18. http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4697030