Finite Element Analysis of Lateral Plate, Intramedullary Nail, and Nail-Plate Combination Techniques in Osteoporotic Distal Femur Fractures
Öz
Background: Osteoporotic distal femur fractures are associated with high mechanical complication rates. This study used finite element analysis to compare three fixation methods—lateral plate, intramedullary nail, and nail–plate combination—in an osteoporotic distal femur model. Fracture displacement, implant stress, and fatigue behavior were examined under two loading conditions.
Methods: A 3D femur model was created using Materialise Mimics Medical 21.0®. Models of intramedullary nails, lateral plates, and screws were designed with SolidWorks 2021 SP4.1®. Three fixation groups were formed by combining the fracture model with either a lateral plate, intramedullary nail, or nail–plate combination. Total deformation under loading was measured, implant stress distribution was evaluated, and fatigue failure was defined as breakage under cyclic loading.
Results: In compression analysis, maximum total deformation was 101.1 mm for the nail, 110.4 mm for the lateral plate, and 50.3 mm for the nail–plate combination. Maximum implant stress values were 1132 MPa for the nail, 1278 MPa for the plate, 671 MPa for the nail, and 595 MPa for the plate in the combined model. Fatigue failure occurred after 4110 cycles for the nail, 2523 cycles for the plate, and 1692900 cycles for the nail–plate combination.
Conclusion: The nail–plate combination may reduce mechanical complications in osteoporotic distal femur fractures by lowering fracture displacement, reducing implant stress, and improving cyclic strength. Randomized clinical studies are needed to further evaluate these findings.
Anahtar Kelimeler
finite element analysis, distal femur, nail plate combination, osteoporotic fracture
Destekleyen Kurum
All authors declare that they have no funding.
Etik Beyan
This study was submitted to the Prof Dr Cemil Taşçıoğlu Şehir Hospital Institutional Ethics Committee and received ethics approval under decision number 117 dated 23.09.2024.
Teşekkür
Not applicable.
Kaynakça
- Khan AM, Tang QO, Spicer D. The epidemiology of adult distal femoral shaft fractures in a central London major trauma centre over five years. Open Orthop J. 2017; 11:1277-91.
- Gangavalli AK, Nwachuku CO. Management of distal femur fractures in adults: an overview of options. Orthop Clin North Am. 2016;47(1):85-96.
- Başcı O, Karakaşlı A, Kumtepe E, Güran O, Havıtçıoğlu H. Combination of anatomical locking plate and retrograde intramedullary nail in distal femoral fractures: comparison of mechanical stability. Eklem Hastalik Cerrahisi. 2015;26(1):21-6.
- Wilson JL, Squires M, McHugh M, Ahn J, Perdue A, Hake M. The geriatric distal femur fracture: nail, plate or both? Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2023;33(5):1485-93.
- Kontakis MG, Giannoudis PV. Nail plate combination in fractures of the distal femur in the elderly: a new paradigm for optimum fixation and early mobilization? Injury. 2023;54(2):288-91.
- Oefner C, Herrmann S, Kebbach M, Lange HE, Kluess D, Woiczinski M. Reporting checklist for verification and validation of finite element analysis in orthopedic and trauma biomechanics. Med Eng Phys. 2021; 92:25-32.
- Huang X, Yu B, Gu Y, Li Z. Biomechanical comparison of dynamic hip screw and Gamma nail for unstable trochanteric fractures: a finite element study. Int J Clin Exp Med. 2017;10(5):7867-74.
- Salas C, Mercer D, DeCoster TA, Taha MM. Experimental and probabilistic finite element analysis of distal femoral fractures: comparison of locking plate versus intramedullary nail fixation. Proc Summer Bioeng Conf. 2010:731-2.
- Chen SH, Chiang MC, Hung CH, Lin SC, Chang HW. Finite element comparison of retrograde intramedullary nailing and locking plate fixation for distal femur fracture after total knee arthroplasty. Knee. 2014;21(1):224-31.
- Liu CC, Xing WZ, Zhang YX, Pan ZH, Feng WL. Three-dimensional finite element analysis of a new intramedullary fixation system. Cell Biochem Biophys. 2015; 71:717-24.