Why does not China’s Growing Influence in Central Asia Bring Conflict? A Normative Partnership between Moscow and Beijing

Öz

While perceiving the influence of the United States and the European Union in Central Asia as a threat, Russia has adopted a more accommodating attitude towards China’s foreign policy initiatives in the region. This difference in Russia’s attitude is intriguing as China’s increasing influence in Central Asia has caused a decline in the former’s relative power in the region. This paper investigates why Russia approaches China’s influence and initiatives in Central Asia differently than those of Western powers. The paper argues that the following factors can explain Russia’s preference: Russia’s ongoing supremacy in terms of diplomatic and military influence in the region, China’s diplomatic attitude that is attentive to Russia’s image as the dominant power in the region, and finally, the ideational alignment between the two states regarding the regional and global order. This article contributes to the literature emphasizing ideational factors in Russian foreign policy by examining the convergence between Russia’s and China’s Central Asia policies in the context of normative partnership and regional cooperation.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Russia
• China
• Central Asia
• Normative Partnership

Çin’in Orta Asya’da Artan Etkisi Neden Çatışma Getirmiyor? Moskova ve Pekin Arasında Normatif Ortaklık

Öz

Kremlin, Amerika Birleşik Devletleri ve Avrupa Birliği’nin Orta Asya üzerindeki etkisini bir tehdit olarak algılarken Çin’in bölgeye yönelik dış politika açılımları konusunda daha olumlu bir tavır takınmaktadır. Pekin’in Orta Asya’da artan varlığı Rusya’nın bölgedeki göreli gücünün azalmasını beraberinde getirmesine karşın Rusya’nın Çin’e karşı olumsuz bir yaklaşım geliştirmemesi merak uyandırıcıdır. Bu makale Rusya’nın Orta Asya’daki Çin etki ve faaliyetlerine neden Batılı güçlerinkinden farklı yaklaştığını sorgulamaktadır. Yazarlar Rusya’nın bu tercihinin şu faktörler ile açıklanabileceğini ileri sürmektedir: Rusya’nın diplomatik ve askeri etki bakımından bölgedeki üstünlüğünün sürmesi, Çin’in Moskova’nın bölgedeki hâkim güç imajını gözeten diplomatik tavrı ve son olarak iki devlet arasında bölgesel ve küresel düzene dair fikirsel uyuşma. Bu makale, Rusya ve Çin’in Orta Asya politikalarındaki uyumu normatif ortaklık ve bölgesel iş birliği bağlamında inceleyerek, Rus dış politikasında düşünsel faktörleri vurgulayan literatüre katkıda bulunmayı amaçlamaktadır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Rusya
• Çin
• Orta Asya
• Normatif Ortaklık

Kaynakça

1. Ambrosio, Thomas (2008). “Catching the ‘Shanghai Spirit’: How the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Promotes Authoritarian Norms in Central Asia”, Europe-Asia Studies 60 (8): 1321–1344.
2. Aliyev, Nurlan (2019). “China’s Soft Power in Central Asia”, https://www.cacianalyst.org/publications/analytical-articles/item/13599-chinas-soft-power-in-central-asia.html (Erişim tarihi: 18.09.2024).
3. Baev, Pavel K. (2021). “Russia and China: A Mutually Exaggerated Strategic Partnership?”, https://jamestown.org/program/russia-and-china-a-mutually-exaggerated-strategic-partnership/ (Erişim Tarihi: 12.09.2024).
4. BBC (2023). “Ukraine war: What support is China giving Russia?”, https://www.bbc.com/news/60571253 (Erişim Tarihi: 07.09.2024).
5. Bekkevold, Jo I. ve Bobo Lo (2018). Sino-Russian relations in the 21st century (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).
6. Belt and Road Portal. (Tarih yok). “Profiles”, https://eng.yidaiyilu.gov.cn/info/iList.jsp?cat_id=10076 (Erişim Tarihi: 15.10.2023).
7. Blank, Stephen (2019). “China’s Military Base in Tajikistan: What Does it Mean?”, https://www.cacianalyst.org/publications/analytical-articles/item/13569-chinas-military-base-in-tajikistan-what-does-it-mean?.html (Erişim Tarihi: 14.10.2024).
8. China Daily (2012). “Xinjiang to crack down on “three evil forces”, https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2012-03/06/content_14766900.htm (Erişim Tarihi: 28.09.2024).

9. Cooley, Alexander ve Daniel H. Nexon (2020). “(No) Exit from liberalism?”, New Perspectives, 28 (3): 280-291.
10. Düben, Björn A. (2022). “What Putin’s War in Ukraine Means for the Future of China-Russia Relations”, https://lseideas.medium.com/what-putins-war-in-ukraine-means-for-the-future-of-china-russia-relations-b47a8461a8a7 (Erişim Tarihi: 22.09.2024).
11. Ekman, Alice, Sinikukka Saari ve Stanislav Secrieru (2020). “STAND BY ME! The Sino-Russian Normative Partnership in Action”, Institute for Security Studies, Brief 18: 1-8.
12. Flonk, Daniëlle (2021). “Emerging Illiberal Norms: Russia and China as Promoters of Internet Content Control”, International Affairs 97 (6): 1925–1944.
13. France24 (2022). “Moscow-led bloc to send 'peacekeeping forces' to protest-hit Kazakhstan”, https://www.france24.com/en/asia-pacific/20220105-kazakhstan-appeals-to-russia-led-security-alliance-for-help-against-terrorists (Erişim Tarihi: 12.11.2024).
14. Godehardt, Nadine (2014). The Chinese Constitution of Central Asia (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).
15. Götz Elias ve Neil MacFarlane (2019). “Russia’s Role in World Politics: Power, Ideas, and Domestic Influences”, International Politics, 56: 713-725.
16. Karaganov, Sergey (2018). “The New Cold War and the Emerging Greater Eurasia”, Journal of Eurasian Studies, 9 (2): 85–93.
17. Kerr, David (2010). “Central Asian and Russian Perspectives on China’s Strategic Emergence”, International Affairs, 86 (1): 127–52.
18. Kim, Younkyoo ve Stephen Blank (2013). “Same Bed, Different Dreams: China’s ‘Peaceful Rise’ and Sino–Russian Rivalry in Central Asia”, Journal of Contemporary China, 22 (8): 773–90.
19. Kortunov, Andrey (2019). “Who Will Build the New World Order?”, https://russiancouncil.ru/en/analytics-and-comments/analytics/who-will-build-the-new-world-order/ (Erişim Tarihi: 03.11.2024).
20. Krapohl, Sebastian ve Alexandra Vasileva-Dienes (2020). “The Region that isn’t: China, Russia and the Failure of Regional Integration in Central Asia”, Asia Europe Journal, 18 (3): 347-366.
21. Lain, Sarah (2017). “China and Russia: Cooperation and Competition in Central Asia”, Tiang Boo Hoo (ed.), Chinese Foreign Policy under Xi (London: Routledge): 74–94
22. Lewis, David G. (2018). “Geopolitical Imaginaries in Russian Foreign Policy: The Evolution of ‘Greater Eurasia’”, Europe-Asia Studies, 70 (10): 1612–37.
23. Lewis, David (2019). “Strategic Culture and Russia’s “Pivot to the East:” Russia, China, and “Greater Eurasia””, Marshall Center Security Insight, 34.
24. Lo, Bobo (2008). Axis of Convenience: Moscow, Beijing, and the New Geopolitics (Washington: Brookings Institution Press).
25. Lukin, Alexander (2018). China and Russia: the New Rapprochement (Cambridge: Polity).
26. Lukin, Alexander ve Anatoly Torkunov (2020). “Trump’s Policies and the Sino-Russian Entente”, Survival. 62 (2): 27–36.
27. Markey, Daniel S. (2020). China’s Western Horizon: Beijing and the New Geopolitics of Eurasia (New York: Oxford University Press).
28. Karásková, Ivana (2022). “How China Lost Central and Eastern Europe”, https://merics.org/en/short-analysis/how-china-lost-central-and-eastern-europe (Erişim Tarihi: 18.11.2024).
29. Melnikova, Julia (2024). “Eurasian Security as a Communicative Practice: Tasks for Russia and China”, Russian International Affairs Council. https://russiancouncil.ru/en/analytics-and-comments/analytics/eurasian-security-as-a-communicative-practice-tasks-for-russia-and-china/ (Erişim: 30.01.2025)
30. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation (2023). The Concept of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation. https://mid.ru/en/foreign_policy/fundamental_documents/1860586/ (Erişim Tarihi: 30.01.2025)
31. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. (2022a). Remarks by Ambassador Zhang Jun at the UN Security Council Briefing on Ukraine. https://www.mfa.gov.cn/mfa_eng/wjb_663304/zwjg_665342/zwbd_665378/202204/t20220406_10664879.html (Erişim Tarihi: 09.11.2023).
32. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China (2022b). “Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Zhao Lijian’s Regular Press Conference on April 11, 2022”, https://www.mfa.gov.cn/eng/xwfw_665399/s2510_665401/202204/t20220411_10666750.html (Erişim Tarihi: 09.11.2023).
33. Murataliyeva, Nergize (2024). “Chinese Lending Adapts to Central Asia’s Realities”, Carnegie, Policy Brief, https://carnegieendowment.org/posts/2024/08/china-investment-central-asia-debt?lang=en (Erişim Tarihi: 23.03.2025 )
34. Nye, Joseph S. (1990). “Soft Power”, Foreign Policy, 80: 153–71.
35. Oresman, Matthew ve Raffaello Pantucci (2018). “Central Asia”, Joshua Eisenman ve Eric Heginbotham (eds.), China steps out: Beijing’s major power engagement with the world (New York: Routledge): 81–101.
36. Pantucci, Raffaello (2015). “China and Russia’s Soft Competition in Central Asia”, Current History, 114 (777): 77–272.
37. Peyrouse, Sebastien (2016). “Discussing China: Sinophilia and Sinophobia in Central Asia”, Journal of Eurasian Studies, 7 (1): 14–23.
38. Putz, Catherine (2021). “Kazakhstan Bans Sale of Agricultural Lands to Foreigners”, https://thediplomat.com/2021/05/kazakhstan-bans-sale-of-agricultural-lands-to-foreigners/ (Erişim Tarihi: 23.10.2024).
39. Sher, Nathaniel (2022). “Why isn't China going all out to help Russia in Ukraine?”, https://responsiblestatecraft.org/2022/04/04/why-isnt-china-going-all-out-to-help-russia-in-ukraine/ (Erişim Tarihi: 14.11.2024).
40. Reuters (2022). “China, Russia Partner up against West at Olympics summit”, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-china-tell-nato-stop-expansion-moscow-backs-beijing-taiwan-2022-02-04/ (Erişim Tarihi: 13.11.2024).
41. Rolland, Nadege (2019). “A China–Russia Condominium over Eurasia”, Survival, 61 (1): 7–22. Rozman, Gilbert ve Gaye Christoffersen (eds.) (2024). Putin’s “Turn to the East” in the Xi Jinping Era (Londra: Routledge).
42. Rumer, Eugene (2017). “Russia’s China Policy: This Bear Hug is Real”, Michale S. Chase, Evan. S. Medeiros, J. Stapleton Roy, Eugene Rumer, Robert Sutter ve Richard Weitz (eds.), Russia-China Relations: Assessing Common Ground and Strategic Fault Lines (Washington: The National Bureau of Asia Research): 13–25.
43. Samokhvalov, Vsevolod (2017). “Russia and its shared neighbourhoods: a comparative analysis of Russia-EU and Russia-China relations in the EU’s Eastern neighbourhood and Central Asia”, Contemporary Politics, 24 (1): 30–45.
44. Soboleva, Elena ve Svetlana Krivokhizh (2021). “Chinese initiatives in Central Asia: claim for regional leadership?”, Eurasian Geography and Economics, 62 (5-6): 634-658.
45. Solomentseva, Anastasia (2014). “The ‘Rise’ of China in the Eyes of Russia: A Source of Threats or New Opportunities?”, Connections, 14 (1): 3–40.
46. Standish, Reid ( 2020). “China Seen as Rising Military Power in Central Asia, Foreshadowing Future Friction With Russia”, https://www.rferl.org/a/china-seen-as-rising-military-power-in-central-asia-foreshadowing-future-friction-with-russia/30639964.html (Erişim Tarihi: 10.10.2024).
47. Stent, Angela (2019). Putin’s World : Russia against the West and with the Rest (New York: Twelve).
48. Sternberg, Troy, Ariel Ahearn ve Fiona McConnell (2017). “Central Asian ‘Characteristics’ on China’s New Silk Road: The Role of Landscape and the Politics of Infrastructure”, Land, 6 (3): 55.
49. Study in Russia (2017). “How Kazakh Students Can Apply to Russian Universities”, https://studyinrussia.ru/en/actual/articles/how-kazakh-students-can-apply-to-russian-universities/ (Erişim Tarihi: 16.09.2023).
50. Suslov, Mikhail (2015). “Russian World Concept: Post-Soviet Geopolitical Ideology and the Logic of ‘Spheres of Influence’”, Geopolitics, 23 (2): 330–353.
51. Swanström, Niklas (2014). “Sino–Russian Relations at the Start of the New Millennium in Central Asia and Beyond”, Journal of Contemporary China, 23 (87): 480–97.
52. Trenin, Dmitri (2015). “From Greater Europe to Greater Asia? The Sino-Russian Entente”, https://carnegiemoscow.org/2015/02/26/from-greater-europe-to-greater-asia-pub-59192 (Erişim Tarihi: 26.06.2024).
53. Wilson, Jeanne (2019). “Russia’s Relationship with China: The Role of Domestic and Ideational Factors”, International Politics 56 (6): 778–794.
54. Wishnick, Elizabeth (2016). “In Search of the ‘Other’ in Asia: Russia–China Relations Revisited.” The Pacific Review 30 (1): 114–132.
55. World Bank (tarih yok). “Personal remittances, received (% of GDP)”, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.TRF.PWKR.DT.GD.ZS (Erişim Tarihi: 13.10.2023).
56. Zhou, Qiang, Ze He ve Yu Yang (2020). “Energy Geopolitics in Central Asia: China’s Involvement and Responses”, Journal of Geographical Sciences, 30: 1871–1895.