CONTROLLING THE NARRATIVE THROUGH TERRORISM LAWS: CASE OF UNITED KINGDOM

Öz

Narratives of terrorism are often used and misused for political goals. This has never been as blatantly apparent as in the UK and the West in general after the 7 October raid where even genocide is being legitimised as self-defence against terrorism. The hypocrisy of presenting resistance fighters as terrorists while entirely disregarding the state terrorism of the oppressor is nothing new. This article looks back at British narratives surrounding apartheid South Africa and the liberation movement fighting against it to draw parallels with the current hypocritical branding of Palestinian resistance fighters as terrorists while ignoring blatant state terrorism perpetrated by the occupier. The paper further analyses the use and abuse of the UK Terrorism Act in the current context, which reveals a severe assault on freedom of expression with the apparent goal of not merely manufacturing consent for the genocide but also forcefully concealing the lack of such consent and the outright rejection of the terrorism narrative in a large part of the general public. Finally, the paper briefly outlines how the UK terrorism narrative has infiltrated the International Criminal Court (ICC) through the language chosen by its British Prosecutor.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• United Kingdom
• Palestine
• freedom of expression
• terrorism laws
• proscription regimes
• Israel

TERÖRİZM YASALARI ARACILIĞIYLA ANLATIYI KONTROL ETME: BİRLEŞİK KRALLIK ÖRNEĞİ

Öz

Terörizme dair anlatılar çoğu zaman siyasi amaçlar doğrultusunda kullanılmakta ve suistimal edilmektedir. Bu, özellikle 7 Ekim baskınından sonra, Birleşik Krallık ve genel olarak Batı'da, soykırımın terörizme karşı kendini savunma olarak meşrulaştırıldığı bir biçimde, hiç olmadığı kadar açık bir şekilde görülmüştür. Zalimin devlet terörizmini tamamen göz ardı ederken direniş savaşçılarını terörist olarak sunma ikiyüzlülüğü yeni bir şey değildir. Bu makale, Birleşik Krallık’ın apartheid Güney Afrika’sı ve buna karşı savaşan kurtuluş hareketi etrafındaki anlatıları geriye dönük inceleyerek, Filistinli direniş savaşçılarının terörist olarak etiketlenmesi ve işgalciler tarafından gerçekleştirilen açık devlet terörizminin göz ardı edilmesi konusundaki ikiyüzlülük ile paralellikler kurmaktadır. Makale, ayrıca Birleşik Krallık Terörizm Yasası’nın mevcut bağlamdaki kullanımını ve kötüye kullanımını analiz etmekte, bu durumun, sadece soykırım için onay üretme amacı taşımakla kalmayıp, aynı zamanda böyle bir onayın yokluğunu ve geniş halk kitlelerinin terörizm anlatısını açıkça reddetmesini zorla gizlemeyi hedefleyen ciddi bir ifade özgürlüğü saldırısını ortaya koyduğunu göstermektedir. Son olarak makale, Birleşik Krallık terörizm anlatısının Uluslararası Ceza Mahkemesi'ne (UCM) İngiliz Savcı tarafından seçilen dil aracılığıyla nasıl sızdığını kısaca özetliyor.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Birleşik Krallık
• Filistin
• ifade özgürlüğü
• terörizm yasaları
• yasaklama rejimleri
• İsrail

Kaynakça

1. Bayev and Others v Russia App nos. 67667/09 and 2 others (ECtHR, 20 June 2017)
2. Castells v Spain App no 11798/85 (ECtHR, 23 April 1992)
3. Dink v Turkey App no 2668/07 and others (ECHR, 14 September 2010)
4. Gaši and Others v Serbia App no 24738/19 (ECHR, 6 September 2022)
5. Goodwin v United Kingdom App no 17488/90 (ECHR, 27 March 1996)
6. Haji and Others v Azerbaijan App no 3503/10 and others (ECtHR, 1 October 2020)
7. Handyside v the United Kingdom App no 5493/72 (ECtHR, 7 December 1976)
8. Huseynova v Azerbaijan App no 10653/10 (ECHR, 13 April 2017)

9. International Court of Justice, Advisory Opinion on the Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem (19 July 2024)
10. International Court of Justice, Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (South Africa v Israel), Request for the Indication of Provisional Measures, Order of 26 January 2024 [2024] ICJ Rep
11. International Court of Justice, Legal Consequences of the Construction of the Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136
12. Khadija Ismayilova v Azerbaijan App no 65286/13 and 57270/14 (ECtHR, 10 January 2019)
13. Kilin v Russia App no 10271/12 (ECtHR, 11 August 2021)
14. Ligens v Austria App no 9815/82 (ECHR, 8 July 1986)
15. Morice v France App no 29369/10 (ECtHR, 23 April 2015) Observer and Guardian v United Kingdom App no 13585/88 (ECtHR, 26 November 1991)
16. Open Door and Dublin Well Woman v Ireland App no 14234/88 (ECtHR, 29 October 1992)
17. Pentikäinen v Finland App no. 11882/10 (ECtHR, 20 October 2015)
18. Perinçek v Switzerland App no 27510/08(ECtHR, 15 October 2015)
19. R v Ali [2018] EWCA Crim 547, [2018] 1 WLR 6105
20. R v Choudary and Rahman [2016] EWCA Crim 61
21. R v Faraz [2012] EWCA Crim 2820
22. R v Iqbal [2010] EWCA Crim 3215
23. R v Khan [2015] EWCA Crim 1341
24. R v Mohammed [2008] EWCA Crim 1465
25. Shin v Republic of Korea Communication No 926/2000, UN Doc CCPR/C/80/D/926/2000
26. Stroll v Switzerland App no. 69698/01 (ECtHR, 10 December 2007)
27. Suresh v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) [2002] 1 Supreme Court Reports 3, 2002
28. Supreme Court of Canada
29. Tagiyeva v Azerbaijan App no 72611/14 (ECtHR, 7 July 2022)
30. Tromsø and Stensaas v Norway 21980/93 (ECHR, 20 May 1999)
31. Uzeyir Jafarov v Azerbaijan App no 54204/08 (ECHR, 29 January 2015)
32. Terrorism Act 2000
33. Terrorism Act 2006
34. The Terrorism Act 2000 (Proscribed Organisations) (Amendment) (No3) Order 2021
35. Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (adopted 9 December 1948, entered into force 12 January 1951) 78 UNTS 277
36. Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (Protocol I) (adopted 8 June 1977, entered into force 7 December 1978) 1125 UNTS 3
37. Hall KC J, ‘Written Evidence Submitted by Jonathan Hall KC Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation, in reply to Letter of 21 December 2023’ paras. 16-17 accessed 27 June 2025
38. Hall KC J, Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation, ‘Report on Terrorism Legislation and Protests’ (2023)
39. HC Deb 12 April 1948, vol 449 accessed 27 June 2025
40. HC Deb 14 February 1997, vol 290
41. HC Deb 17 November 1944, vol 404 accessed 27 June 2025
42. Human Rights Committee, ‘General Comment No 34: Article 19: Freedoms of opinion and expression’ (12 September 2011) UN Doc CCPR/C/GC/34
43. Report of the Secretary-General, ‘The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms while Countering Terrorism’ (28 August 2008) UN Doc A/63/337
44. UN General Assembly session on the International Criminal Court and Israel and Palestine (1 November 2023) min. 1.31.52 accessed 27 June 2025
45. UN Human Rights Council, Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, ‘Detailed findings on attacks carried out on and after 7 October 2023 in Israel’ (2024) UN Doc A/HRC/56/CRP.3
46. UN Official Records of the General Assembly, Thirty-first Session, Supplement No 24 (A/31/24) vol I
47. UN, ‘Decolonization, No. 9, Dec. 1977: Issue on Namibia’ (Revised edn, United Nations Department of Political Affairs, Trusteeship and Decolonization 1977) accessed 27 June 2025 UNGA Res 3314(XXIX) (14 December 1947)
48. Bibliography ‘Attlee Accuses Jew Underground; Vast Cache of Munitions Found’ The Montreal Gazette, (2 July 1946) 1
49. ‘British State Ramps up War on Independent Journalism’ Jewish Voice for Labour (17 October 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
50. ‘Exclusive: Prof Haim Bresheeth’s Anti-Genocide Speech before he was Arrested for ‘Terrorism’” The Skwawkbox (3 Nov 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
51. ‘Greenstein Takes Police to Court the Week for Return of Seized Electronics’ The Skwawkbox (14 April 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
52. ‘How Israel Killed Hundreds of its own People on 7 October, with Asa Winstanley and Ali Abunimah’ The Electronic Intifada,= (19 October 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
53. ‘If you Protest for Palestinian Rights in the UK you Could be Arrested under Antiterrorism Laws’ AJ+ (28 Nov 2024)
54. ‘Israel-Palestine war: Keir Starmer Supports Israel’s ‘Right’ to Cut Gaza’s Water and Power’, Middle East Eye, (11 October 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
55. ‘NUJ Condemns Abuse of Counter-Terror Legislation as Harmful to Media Freedom, National Union of Journalists’ (21 Oct 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
56. ‘Palestine Action Co-founder Back in Court Again. Here’s Where and When’ The Canary (3 Oct 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
57. ‘Pro-Palestinian Protests: Paraglider Badge Wearers Found Guilty’ BBC News (13 Feb 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
58. ‘Rape as Self-Defense? Israeli Soldiers Accused of Gang Raping Palestinian Defended as “Heroes”’ Mintpress News (1 August 2024) accessed 27 June 2025 ‘Statement of Solidarity with Palestine Action’ Cage International (5 Nov 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
59. ‘Terrorism Charges against SPSC Campaigner Dropped’ Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign (26 Jan 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
60. ‘UK Journalist under House Arrest on Terrorism Charges’ The Crispin Flintoff Show (2 Sep 2024), accessed 27 June 2025
61. A Life Exposed: Military Invasions of Palestinian Homes in the West Bank (Yesh Din, Physicians for Human Rights Israel, Breaking the Silence, 2020) 68 accessed 27 June 2025
62. Amnesty International ‘Israel/OPT: Two months of cruel and inhumane siege and further evidence of Israel’s genocidal intent in Gaza’, (2 May 2025) accessed 27 June 2025.
63. Amnesty International, Briefing: Namibia (Briefing Paper No 10, April 1977) accessed 27 June 2025
64. Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies, ‘Arab Public Opinion about the Israeli War on Gaza’ (10 January 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
65. Biden J, ‘Remarks by President Biden at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum’s Annual Days of Remembrance Ceremony’ (US Capitol, Washington DC, 7 May 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
66. Blumenthal M, ‘Leaked Israel Lobby Presentation Urges US Officials to Justify War on Gaza with “Hamas rape” Claims’ The Grayzone (6 March 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
67. Blumenthal M, Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel (Nation Books, 2013) Chapter 2 ‘The Army of God’ Borger J, ‘The Conservative Party’s Uncomfortable Relationship with Nelson Mandela’ The Guardian (6 Dec 2013) accessed 27 June 2025
68. Breaking the Silence, ‘How to create a sense of being pursued’ accessed 27 June 2025.
69. Breaking the Silence, ‘The Controller and the Controlled’ accessed 27 June 2025.
70. Breaking the Silence, The Perimeter: Soldiers’ testimonies from the Gaza Buffer Zone 2023-2024 (Breaking the Silence, 2025) accessed 27 June 2025
71. Campaign Against Criminalising Communities (CAMPACC), 20 Years of Terrorism Acts: 20 Years of Injustice (June 2021)
72. Charif M, ‘Policy Paper: The Roots Of Zionist Terrorism’ (Institute for Palestine Studies, 13 December 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
73. Charters DA, ‘Jewish Terrorism and the Modern Middle East’ (2007) 27 Journal of Conflict Studies 80 Chayut N, The Girl Who Stole My Holocaust (Verso Books, 2013)
74. Conquest R, The Great Terror (Oxford University Press 1968)
75. Cordall SS, ‘Everything is Legitimate: Israeli Leaders Defend Soldiers Accused of Rape’ Aljazeera (9 Aug 2024), accessed 27 June 2025
76. Cornford A, ‘Terrorist Precursor Offences: Evaluating the Law in Practice’ 8 Criminal Law Review 663
77. Craven E, ‘Case comment: R v Faraz – Terrorist publications and free speech in the Court of Appeal’ (10 January 2013) accessed 27 June 2025. Crown Prosecution Service, ‘Three Women Convicted of Displaying Paraglider Stickers at Protest’ (13 February 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
78. Dill SE, ‘Sanctions, Terrorist Designations, and Social Media Content Moderation: The Challenges for Peace Negotiations, War Crimes Documentation, and Humanitarian Aid in the Gaza War’ (The Situation in Palestine: Emerging Domestic and International Jurisprudence, Maynooth University, Ireland, 9 July 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
79. Fabian E, ‘Defense minister announces “complete siege” of Gaza: No power, food or fuel’ Times of Israel (9 October 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
80. Ferguson D and Gecsoyler S, ‘Thousands Join Pro-Palestine Marches in London and Edinburgh’, The Guardian (3 Feb 2024), accessed 27 June 2025
81. Filatova I and Davidson A, The Hidden Thread: Russia and South Africa in the Soviet Era, (Jonathan Ball Publishers 2013)
82. Fink R, ‘“We Won’t Look the Other Way”: U.K. Starmer Unveils Mandatory Holocaust Education Curriculum Amid Antisemitism Spike’, Haaretz (17 September 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
83. Genuinely Unwilling: An Update The Failure of Israel’s Investigative and Judicial System to Comply with the Requirements of International Law, with particular regard to the Crimes Committed during the Offensive on the Gaza Strip (27 December 2008 – 18 January 2009) (Palestinian Centre for Human Rights, August 2010)
84. Harpin L, ‘Palestine Activist who Praised “Incredible Oct 7 Infiltration” Arrested by Counter-Terrorism Police’ Jewish News (29 Aug 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
85. ICC, Statement, ‘ICC Prosecutor, Karim A. A. Khan KC, concludes first visit to Israel and State of Palestine by an ICC Prosecutor: “We must show that the law is there, on the front lines, and that it is capable of protecting all”’ (3 Dec 2023), accessed 27 June 2025
86. James I and Price E, ‘Palestine Action Group to be Banned, Home Secretary Confirms’ BBC (23 June 2025) accessed 27 June 2025
87. Katie Pentney, ‘States’ Positive Obligation to Create a Favourable Environment for Participation in Public Debate: a Principle in Search of a Practical Effect’ 16 Journal of Media Law 146
88. Khan KC AA, ICC, ‘Statement of ICC Prosecutor Karim A.A. Khan KC: Applications for arrest warrants in the situation in the State of Palestine’ (20 May 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
89. Kuttler H, ‘75 Years After His Death, why Orde Wingate Remains a Hero in Israel’ Times of Israel (23 March 2019) accessed 27 June 2025
90. Lavrysen L, Human Rights in a Positive State: Rethinking the Relationship between Positive and Negative Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights (Interstitia 2016)
91. Maximillien Robespierre: Justification of the Use of Terror’, Fordham University, Modern History Sourcebook, accessed 27 June 2025
92. Merriam-Webster Dictionary, ‘terror’, Word History accessed 27 June 2025
93. Miller P, ‘British Fighters in Israel’s Military: is it Legal?’ Declassified UK (13 November 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
94. Mitchell A, UK Parliament, Written Questions, Answers and Statements, ‘Israel Defense Forces: British Nationals Abroad’ Question for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, 22 December 2023 accessed 27 June 2025
95. Mowbray A, The Development of Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights by the European Court of Human Rights (Hart Publishing 2004)
96. Muller QC M, ‘Terrorism, Proscription and the Right to Resist in the Age of Conflict’ (2008) 22 Denning Law Journal 111
97. Murphy MC, ‘ICC’s Karim Khan Centers Israelis in Palestine Investigation’ The Electronic Intifada (6 Dec 2023), accessed 27 June 2025
98. Our Narrative, Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, Hamas Media Office (Jan 2024)
99. Oxford English Dictionary, ‘terror’, Meaning and Use accessed 27 June 2025
100. Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PSR): Survey Research Unit 4, Public Opinion Poll No (92) (12 June 2024) accessed 27 June 2025
101. Pappé I, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (One World 2006)
102. Parker N and Farrell S, ‘British Anger at Terror Celebrations’ The Times (20 July 2006), accessed 27 June 2025
103. Peeke JL, Jewish-Zionist Terrorism and the Establishment of Israel (U.S. Naval Postgraduate School 1977)
104. Peled-Elhanan N, Palestine in Israeli School Books: Ideology and Propaganda in Education (I.B. Tauris 2012)
105. Said EW, Culture and Imperialism (Vintage Books 1994)
106. Segal R, Mission: Hebron (2020) accessed 27 June 2025 Shlaim A, Three Worlds: Memoirs of an Arab-Jew (Oneworld Publications, 2024)
107. Siddique H, ‘Police and prosecutors’ details shared with Israel during UK protests inquiry, papers suggest’ The Guardian (29 April 2025) accessed 27 June 2025
108. Sobol I, ‘Glorification of Terrorist Violence at the European Court of Human Rights’ 24 Human Rights Law Review 1 Sofuoglu M, ‘A Lookback at the Zionist Terrorism that led to Israel’s Creation’ TRTWorld (undated) accessed 27 June 2025
109. Stoyanova V, Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights:Within and Beyond Boundaries (Oxford University Press 2023)
110. Taylor S, ‘Status Quo Terrorism: State-Terrorism in South Africa during Apartheid’ (2021) 35 Terrorism and Political Violence 304
111. Ullah A, ‘UK Police Charge Co-founder of Palestine Action under Terrorism Act’ Middle East Eye (30 Aug 2024), accessed 27 June 2025
112. Unwilling and Unable, Israel’s Whitewashed Investigations of the Great March of Return Protests (B’Tselem, Palestinian Centre for Human Rights, December 2021) accessed 27 June 2025
113. Wadsworth J, ‘Tony Greenstein Charged with Terrorism Offence’ Brighton and Hove News (29 November 2024) accessed 27 June 2025.
114. Wilde R, ‘Israel’s War in Gaza is Not a Valid Act of Self-defence in International Law’, Opinio Juris (9 Nov 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
115. Winstanley A, ‘“Anti-terror” Arrests in UK over Support for Palestinian Resistance’ The Electronic Intifada, (22 Dec 2023) accessed 27 June 2025
116. Winstanley A, ‘Did British Police Raid me for This? Palestine is Still the Issue’ (31 Oct 2024) accessed 27 June 2025