HERKES TANRI’NIN KÜÇÜK KİLİSE BAHÇESİNİ KONUŞUYOR: BİR ZÜMRE KİLİSE BİRLİĞİNDEN AYRILINCA MÜLKİYET SAHİPLİĞİ KİMDEDİR?

Yıl 2012, Cilt: 1 Sayı: 2, 1 - 18, 01.07.2012

Carol Daugherty Rasnıc

Öz

Bir zümrenin bağlı olduğu kiliseden, kısmen ya da tamamen ayrılmasıyla ortaya çıkan
isim değişikliği durumunda, ortaya hak sahipliği, özellikle de gayrimenkullerin sahipliği sorunu
çıkmaktadır. Ayrılan zümre mi hak sahibidir, yoksa ilk isim sahibi mi? Bu durum mahkemelerin,
anayasanın dinsel işlere karışmama hükmünden dolayı, kiliseler arası anlaşmazlıklara dahil
olmakta isteksiz olduğu Amerika’da daha da problemli olmaktadır. Kiliselerin hiyersrşik idari
yapısı belirleyici bir çözüm sunabilmektedir. Örneğin Roma Katolik Kilise hiyerarşisi kontrolü
piskoposluk düzeyinde sağlarken, öte yandan daha yerel bir şekilde yönetilen Babtist
Kilisesi’nde bölgesel birim, papazlığın yetki alanında yok denecek kadar az otorite
kullanmaktadır. Bu makale, ABD’de Virginia bölgesinde piskoposlar tarafından yönetilen
kilisenin (Anglikan Komünyonu) dâhil olduğu ve halen devam eden bir hukuk davasına
odaklanmaktadır. Daha muhafazakâr üyelerin temel doktrinsel değişimleri ulusal düzeyde
değerlendirmelerinden dolayı, bazı piskoposluk bölgeleri isim haklarından mülk sahipliği talep
ederek feragat etmek istemişlerdir. Alışılmamış bir çözüm, ana kiliseyi yerel kiliselerle maliyetli,
gereğinden fazla uzayan ve acı duygular uyandıran mahkeme savaşları cehenneminin ortasında
bırakmaktadır. Çalışmada özet olarak Birleşik Devletlerdeki diğer “isim ayrılmaları” ve
Balkanlardaki Hıristiyan ve Hıristiyan-Müslüman hak sahipliği anlaşmazlıklarına da
değinilmiştir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Hukuk, din, tarih, kültür, siyaset bilimi

EVERYBODY’S TALKIN’ ‘BOUT GOD’S LITTLE ACRE: WHO OWNS THE PROPERTY WHEN A SEGMENT OF A CHURCH LEAVES THE DENOMINATION?

Öz

The departure of a segment of a church or an entire parish that leaves the denomination presents the problem of property ownership, particularly real property. Does the departing faction or the denomination have rightful title? This can be more problematic in an American jurisdiction where the courts are reluctant to enter into an intra-church dispute because of the constitutional non-establishment of religion clause. An added decisive element is reflected in the hierarchical governmental structure of a church. For example, the Roman Catholic Church hierarchy provides control at the diocesan level, whereas, in a more locally ruled Baptist church, a regional body exercises little, if any, authority over a parish. This paper focuses primarily on the ongoing litigation involving the Diocese of Virginia of the Episcopal Church USA (Anglican Communion). Because of what more conservative members regard as fundamental doctrinal shifts at the national level, several parishes opted to leave the denomination, claiming property ownership. The atypical result is a costly, protracted, and embittered court battle pitting the mother church against the local churches. Similar legal issues in other denominations in the United States and Christian and Christian-Moslem property disputes in the Balkans are more summarily addressed

Anahtar Kelimeler

Law, religion, history, culture, political science

Kaynakça

• THE BIBLE (King James Version).Genesis 13:180-12; 1 John 4:8.
• Caldwell, Erskine. GOD’S LITTLE ACRE (1933) New York, NY: Viking Press.
• Spong. John S. LIVING IN SIN? A BISHOP RETHINKS HUMAN SEXUALITY (1990). New York, NY: Harper Collins.
• Spong, J.S. BORN OF A WOMAN: A BISHOP RETHINKS THE BIRTH OF JESUS. (1992) New York, NY: Harper Collins.
• Spong, J.S. RESURRECTION: MYTH OR REALITY? (1993) New York, NY: Harper Collins.
• Slaughter, the Rev. Philip (addenda by Goodwin, the Rev. Edward) THE HISTORY OF TRURO CHURCH IN VIRGINIA (1907) Philadelphia, PA: George W. Jacobs.
• Vaknin, Sam. MALIGNANT SELF LOVE (1999) Skopje, Macedonia: Lidija Rangelovska.
• Welch, Robert H. CHURCH ADMINISTRATION (2011) Nashville, TN: B & H Pub. C
• Belzer, Nathan. Deference in the Resolution of Intrachurch Disputes (1998) St. Thomas Law Review 11, 109, 122, 133.
• Chambers, Henry, Jr., and McBeth, Isaac. Much Ado About Nothing Much (20xxx) University of Richmond Law Review 45, 141-167.
• Massey, C.R. Church Schisms, Church Property, and Civil Authority (2009) St. John’s Law Review 84, 23-62
• McElroy, Meaghan Cecilia. Possession is 9/10 of the Law (2008) William & Mary Law Review 50, 311-348.
• Reeder, Kathleen E. Whose Church is it Anyway? (2006) Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 40, 125-174.
• National Council of Churches (NCC) (date) Retrieved from www.nccusa.org/news/11210yearbook/2011.html
• Coats, Wiliam R. Who or what Caused the Declne in Membership in the Episcopal Church (date) Retrieved from www.rci.rutgers.edu/lcrew/dojustice/j325.html
• Crew, L.L.(date) www.rci.rutgers.edu/lccrew/dojustice/j325html
• Virtue, David W.(June 12, 2010) Virtue on Line. Retrieved from www.virtueonline.org/porta/modules/news/print.php?storyid=5183
• Virtue, David W. (February 21, 2011) Liberal Episcopal Dioceses Demonstrate New twist in Property Settlements. Retrieved from http://www.virtueonline.org/portalk/modules/news/article.php?storyid=13999
• American Anglican, (date) ACNA: Church Property Settlement Heartbreaking. February 1, 2011. Retrieved from www.americananglilcan.org/acna-church-property-settlements-heartbreaking/pageprint
• New Precedent Set by N.J. Property Settlement. (December 23, 2010) Retrieved from http://canaconvocatgion.rg/pages/page.asp?page.id=67929&articleId=18597
• Harmon, Kendall. (April 18, 2011.) Virginia Anglican Church Settles Lawsuit. Retrieved from http://www.Kendalharmon.netr/t19/index.php/t19/article/36057
• Stern, Marc. Breaking Up is Hard to Adjudicate, (spring, 2009, p. 3), Retrieved from www.trincoll.edu.../Breaking%20Up%2is%20Hard%20to%20Adjudicate
• Speciale, Alessandro. Croatia-Vatican relations sour over monastery crisis. (November 26, 2011) Retrieved from http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/enhomepage/world-news/detal/articolo/crozia-vaticano
• CBS News. Vatican, Croats split over monastery (August 11, 2011). http://www.cbsnews.com/2102-501714.162- 20091181.html?tag=contgentMain.contentBo
• Erebana, Gjergl. Kosovo’s New Cathedral Stirs Muslim Resentment. Balkan Insight. (October 4, 2010). Retrieved from http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/albanians-vie-for-religious-sites
• Barlovac, Bojana. Serbia’s Churches Demand More Property Back. (July 25, 2011). Balkan Insight. Retrieved from http://www.balkaniknsight.com/en/article/churches-in-serbia-demand-property-back
• Luminarium Encylopedia Project. Anthology of English Literature. (1996) Henry VIII page. Retrieved from www.luminarium.org/renlit/tudorbiio.html
• The World Book. Encyclopedia.. The Episcopal Church (Vol. 6, p. 264). Chicago, IL: World Book International.
• Van Biema, David. The Episcopal Property War. (April 4, 20088) Time
• MacDonald, Gregg. (April 7, 2010) $40 million property case heads to Virginia Supreme Court. The Fairfax Times.
• Settlements and appeals in Canadian church property cases. (February 18, 2011) The Church of England Newspaper, p. 6.
• The Christian Post, Washington, D.C. (June 7, 2011) Retrieved from www.christianpost
• duLac and Boordsten (October 9, 2011) Episcopal parish in Bladensburg converts to Roman Catholicism. The Washington Post.
• Vatican welcomes Anglican priests. (January 1, 2012). Richmond TimesDispatch, p. A-9.
• Episcopal Church wins control (January 12, 2012). Richmond Times-Dispatch, p. B-2.
• Church Property Settlement ‘Heartbreaking. January 2, 2012. Retrieved from http:www.americananglican.org/acna-church-property-settlementheartbreaking/pageprint
• New Precedent Set by NJ Church Property Settlement. January 3, 2012. CANA News Articles. Retrieved from http://canaconvocation.org/pages/page.asp?page_id=67929&articlesId=18597
• All Saints Parish Waccamaw v. Protestant Episcopal Church n the Diocese of South Carolina, 685 S.E.2d 163 (2009)
• California-Nevada Conference v. St. Luke’s United Methodist Church, 17 Cal. Rept. 3d 442 (2005)
• Congregation Yetev Lev D’Samar v. Kohana, 879 N.E.2d 1282 (N.Y. 2007)
• Craigdallie v. Aikman, 2 High. 429, 1 Dow, 1 (1813).
• Episcopal Diocese of Rochester v. Harnish, 899 N.E.2d 920 (N.Y. 2008)
• First Presbyterian Church of Schenectady v. United Presbyterian Church US, 464 N.E.2d 454 (N.Y. 1984).
• Jones v. Wolf, 443 U.S. 595 (1975).
• Larson v. Vilente, 456 U.S. 228 (1982).
• Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 595 (1971).
• Presbytery of Hudson River of the Presbyterian Church US v. Trustees of First Presbyterian Church of Ridgeberry, 821 N.Y.S.2d 834 (2006).
• Protestant Episcopal Church in the Diocese of Virginia v. Truro Church, 694 S.E.2d 555 (Va. 2010)
• Rasmussen v. Superior Court, 51 Cal.4th 804 (2011).
• Rector, Wardens and Vestrymen of Trinity St. Michaels Parish v. Episcopal Church, Diocese of Connecticut, 620 A.2d 1280 (Conn. 1993)
• The Episcopal Church in the Diocese of Connecticut v. Gauss, 224 Conn. 804 (2011)
• Watson v. Jones, 80 U.S.679, 13 Wall. 679 (1872)
• Constitution of The United States, Amend. I (1791).
• Virginia Code sec. 57-7 (1865)
• Constitution and Canons of the General Convention of the Episcopal Church (1765), Title I. 7.4 (Dennis Canon, 1981)
• Canons of the Episcopal Church in the Diocese of Virginia. (1986) Canon 15 secs 1, 2, and 5
• The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A) (2009-2011) Part II, Book of Order
• Windsor Report of the Anglican Communion (2004)
• Anglicanorum Coetibus (2009) The Vatican