Comparison of Traditional Methods and 3D Laser Scanners in Architectural Structures: The Case of Kuruçeşme in Mersin

Öz

Laser scanners create three-dimensional models of surrounding objects and are used as a basis or reference in fields such as architecture, engineering, archaeology, and others. Three-dimensional modeling, area scanning, monitoring the progress of large projects, and other related topics provide significant advantages. These techniques and tools, which are used in various applications such as distance measurement, object detection, and remote sensing, have a wide range of applications. 3D laser scanning technologies offer benefits in many areas, from detailed documentation of existing buildings to the design of new projects and the management of construction processes. With their ability to perform fast, precise, and efficient measurements, laser scanners greatly facilitate architectural applications. In the future, it is expected that this technology will be used more widely in architectural processes. This study examines the measurement of the Kuruçeşme structure using traditional measurement techniques and 3D laser scanners, and compares these two methods. It focuses on identifying the advantages and disadvantages of these two methods and their compliance with acceptable error values.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Laser scanners
• Architectural structures
• Traditional measurement methods
• Kuruçeşme

Teşekkür

The authors gratefully acknowledge Prof. Dr. Murat Yakar for his valuable contributions and continuous support throughout the conduct of this study.

Kaynakça

1. Alptekin, A., ve M. Yakar. "3D Modeling of Mersin Akyar Cliffs." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 2, 1 (2020): 5–9.
2. Alptekin, A., ve M. Yakar. "Kaya Bloklarının 3B Nokta Bulutunun Yersel Lazer Tarayıcı Kullanarak Elde Edilmesi." Türkiye LİDAR Dergisi 2, 1 (2020): 1–4.
3. AlYılmaz, C., S. AlYılmaz, ve M. Yakar. "Measurement of Petroglyphs (Rock of Arts) of Qobustan with Close Range Photogrammetry." International Archives of Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 38, Part 5 (2010): 29–32.
4. Atik, M. E., Ö. Güngör, E. Keskin, ve Z. Duran. "Classification of Photogrammetric Point Cloud Data Using Machine Learning." Journal of Geodesy and Geoinformation 9, 2 (2022): 137–149.
5. Balcı, D. "The Use of Laser Scanners in Documenting Cultural Heritage." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 4, 1 (2022): 27–36.
6. Ebrahim, M. "Overview of 3D Laser Scanners’ Techniques." International Journal of Scientific Research 4, 10 (2015): 323–331.
7. Erdoğan, A., A. Kabadayı, ve E. S. Akın. "3D Modeling of Cultural Heritage by Photogrammetric Method: The Case of Karabıyık Bridge." Turkish Journal of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles 3, 1 (2021): 23.
8. Güleç Korumaz, A., O. N. Dülgerler, ve M. Yakar. "Digital Approaches in the Documentation of Cultural Heritage." Selcuk University Journal of Engineering, Science and Technology 26, 3 (2011): 67–83.

9. Kahveci, M., ve N. Can. "İnsansız Hava Araçları: Tarihçesi, Tanımı, Dünyada ve Türkiye'deki Yasal Durumu." Selçuk Üniversitesi Mühendislik, Bilim ve Teknoloji Dergisi 5, 4 (2017): 511–535.
10. Kanun, E., A. Alptekin, ve M. Yakar. "Cultural Heritage Modeling Using UAV Photogrammetric Methods: A Case Study of Kanlidivane Archaeological Site." Advanced UAV 1, 1 (2021): 24–33.
11. Kanun, E., A. Alptekin, L. Karataş, ve M. Yakar. "The Use of UAV Photogrammetry in Modeling Ancient Structures: A Case Study of 'Kanytellis'." Advanced UAV 2, 2 (2022): 41–50.
12. Kanun, E., A. Metin, ve M. Yakar. "Obtaining 3D Point Cloud of Ağzıkara Han Using Terrestrial Laser Scanning Technique." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 3, 2 (2021): 58–64.
13. Karabacak, A., ve M. Yakar. "Application Areas of Wearable Mobile LiDAR and 3D Modeling of Cambazlı Church." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 4, 2 (2022): 37–52.
14. Karabacak, A., ve M. Yakar. "3D Modeling of Mersin Akyar Cliffs with Wearable Mobile LiDAR." Advanced Engineering Days 6 (2023): 86–89.
15. Karabacak, A., ve M. Yakar. "3D Modeling of Mersin Sarisih Caravanserai with Wearable Mobile LiDAR." Advanced Engineering Days 6 (2023): 90–93.
16. Karabacak, A., ve M. Yakar. "3D Modeling of Mufti Abdullah Sıddık Mosque Using Wearable Mobile LiDAR." Advanced LiDAR 3, 1 (2023): 1–9.
17. Karabork, H., F. Yıldız, E. Coskun, H. M. Yılmaz, ve M. Yakar. "Investigation of Accuracy for Digital Elevation Models Generated with Different Methods in Photogrammetry." International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 35, B3 (2004).
18. Karataş, L., A. Alptekin, A. Karabacak, ve M. Yakar. "Detection and Documentation of Stone Material Deterioration in Historical Masonry Buildings Using UAV Photogrammetry: A Case Study of Mersin Sarisih Inn." Mersin Photogrammetry Journal 4, 2 (2022): 53–61.
19. Mohammed, O., ve M. Yakar. "Yersel Fotogrametrik Yöntem ile İbadethanelerin Modellenmesi." Selcuk University Journal of Engineering Sciences 15, 2 (2016): 85–95.
20. Nazari, S. W., V. Akarsu, ve M. Yakar. "Analysis of 3D Laser Scanning Data of Farabi Mosque Using Various Software." Advanced LiDAR 3, 1 (2023): 22–34.
21. Oruç, M. E., ve G. Baş. "Use of Terrestrial Laser Scanning Technology in Complex Structures and Areas." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 3, 2 (2021): 39–47.
22. Pulat, F., M. Yakar, ve A. Ulvi. "Three-Dimensional Modeling of the Kubbe-i Hasiye Shrine with Terrestrial Photogrammetric Method." Cultural Heritage and Science 3, 1 (2022): 6–11.
23. Pulat, F., M. Yakar, ve A. Ulvi. "Yersel Fotogrametrik Yöntem Kullanılarak Fotogrametrik Yazılımların Karşılaştırılması: Hüsrev Paşa Camii Örneği." Türkiye Fotogrametri Dergisi 4, 1 (2022): 30–40.
24. Şasi, A., ve M. Yakar. "Photogrammetric Modelling of Sakahane Masjid Using an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle." Turkish Journal of Engineering 1, 2 (2017): 82–87.
25. Tükenmez, F., ve M. Yakar. "Production of Road Maps in Highway Projects by Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV)." Advanced Engineering Days 6 (2023): 94–96.
26. Ünel, F. B., L. Kuşak, M. Çelik, A. Alptekin, ve M. Yakar. "Kıyı Çizgisinin Belirlenerek Mülkiyet Durumunun İncelenmesi." Türkiye Arazi Yönetimi Dergisi 2, 1 (2020): 33–40.
27. Villi, O., ve M. Yakar. "İnsansız Hava Araçlarının Kullanım Alanları ve Sensör Tipleri." Türkiye İnsansız Hava Araçları Dergisi 4, 2 (2022): 73–100.
28. Villi, O., ve M. Yakar. "İnsansız Hava Araçları ve Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri Uygulamaları." Türkiye Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri Dergisi 5, 1 (2023): 20–33.
29. Yakar, M., ve Y. Doğan. "Mersin Silifke Mezgit Kale Anıt Mezarı Fotogrametrik Rölöve Alımı ve Üç Boyutlu Modelleme Çalışması." Geomatik 2, 1 (2017): 11–17.
30. Yakar, M., ve H. M. Yılmaz. "Using in Volume Computing of Digital Close Range Photogrammetry." The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 37, B3b (2008).
31. Yakar, M., H. Murat Yılmaz, F. Yıldız, M. Zeybek, H. Şentürk, ve H. Çelik. "Silifke-Mersin Bölgesinde Roma Dönemi Eserlerinin 3 Boyutlu Modelleme Çalışması ve Animasyonu." Jeodezi ve Jeoinformasyon Dergisi, sayı 101 (2010).
32. Yakar, M., O. Orhan, A. Ulvi, A. Y. Yiğit, ve M. M. Yüzer. Sahip Ata Külliyesi Rölöve Örneği. TMMOB Harita ve Kadastro Mühendisleri Odası, 10 (2015).
33. Yakar, M., F. Yıldız, F. Uray, ve A. Metin. "Photogrammetric Measurement of The Meke Lake and Its Environment with Kite Photographs to Monitoring of Water Level to Climate Change." ISPRS Commission V Mid-Term Symposium içinde (2010): 613–616.
34. Yakar, M., F. Yıldız, C. AlYılmaz, ve H. M. Yılmaz. "Photogrammetric Study for Sircali Medrese Door." 9th International Multidisciplinary Scientific GeoConference SGEM 2009 içinde (2009): 879–884.
35. Yakar, M., H. M. Yılmaz, ve K. Yurt. "The Effect of Grid Resolution in Defining Terrain Surface." Experimental Techniques 34, 6 (2010): 23–29.
36. Yaman, A., ve K. Muhammed. "Investigation of the Use of Geoslam Terrestrial Laser Scanner for Documentation and 3D Modeling of Historical and Cultural Heritage: Example of Ulucami in Aksaray Province." Turkish Journal of LiDAR 1, 1 (2019): 5–9.
37. Yıldız, F., H. Karabörk, M. Yakar, ve H. M. Yılmaz. "Yersel Fotogrametride Kullanılan Metrik Olmayan Dijital Kameraların Kalibrasyonunda Kullanılan Yazılımların İncelenmesi Üzerine Bir Çalışma." Harita Dergisi, sayı 134 (2005): 61–70.
38. Yılmaz, H. M., ve M. Yakar. "Lidar (Light Detection And Ranging) Tarama Sistemi." Yapı Teknolojileri Elektronik Dergisi 2, 2 (2006): 23–33.
39. Yılmaz, H. M., ve M. Yakar. "Yersel Lazer Tarama Teknolojisi." Yapı Teknolojileri Elektronik Dergisi 2, 2 (2006): 43.
40. Yılmaz, H. M., Ö. Mutluoğlu, A. Ulvi, A. Yaman, ve S. S. Bilgilioğlu. "İnsansız Hava Aracı ile Ortofoto Üretimi ve Aksaray Üniversitesi Kampüsü Örneği." Geomatik 3, 2 (2018): 129–136.
41. Yılmaz, H. M., M. Yakar, ve F. Yıldız. "Digital Photogrammetry in Obtaining of 3D Model Data of Irregular Small Objects." The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 37 (2008): 125–130.