Winning The Zero on Eastern Mediterranean Chessboard: Players, Games and Moves

Yıl 2023, Cilt: 1 Sayı: 1, 69 - 93, 23.03.2023

Ali Faik Demir , Doğuş Sönmez , Emre Önkibar

Öz

Competition over the extraction, transmission, and marketing of energy resources is one of the most fundamental contentious topics in contemporary international relations literature. The parties to this competition are the states, international institutions, and multinational corporations. The participants in this competition, which has taken place mainly on the chessboard in the Eastern Mediterranean, include regional and global powers. The fact that Türkiye holds rights over a portion of Cyprus, its historical ties to the region, and its status as an energy hub make it a significant regional actor. The questions that must be answered are how the new energy resources emerging in the Eastern Mediterranean region, where individual interests do not produce results, which are based on alliances between players and differ from other energy regions in this regard, will affect the relationships between the players, what moves regional actors will make, and how these moves will continue the game. From this vantage point, this study will explore the chessboard in the Eastern Mediterranean region in terms of the players and the position of Türkiye in this region and among these actors. It will be asserted that Türkiye engages in a lose-lose game that it cannot win alongside other actors.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Eastern Mediterranean, Energy, Stag Hunt, Nash Equilibrium, Turkish Foreign Policy

Kaynakça

• Acharya, A. & Stubbs, R. (2006). Theorizing Southeast Asian Relations: An Introduction. The Pacific Review, 19(2), 125-134.
• Al Jazeera. (2022). Israel, Lebanon sign US-brokered maritime border deal. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/27/israel-lebanon-sign-us-brokered-maritime-border-deal
• Bahgat, G. (2012). The impact of the Arab spring on the oil and gas industry in North Africa – a preliminary assessment. The Journal of North African Studies, 17(3), 505-508.
• Braudel, F. (1989). Akdeniz ve Akdeniz Dünyası. M. A. Kılıçbay (Trans.). İstanbul: Eren Yayıncılık.
• Braudel, F. (1990). Akdeniz, Mekan ve Tarih. N. Erkurt (Trans.). İstanbul: Metis Yayınları.
• British Petroleum. (2019). BP Energy Outlook.
• British Petroleum. (2022). BP Energy Outlook.
• Brzezinski, Z. (1997). The Grand Chessboard. New York: Basic Books.
• Çelikpala, M. (2019, December 16). Türkiye Doğu Akdeniz’de Oyunu Nasıl Değiştirdi? Şimdi Ne Olacak? Fikirturu. https://fikirturu.com/jeo-strateji/turkiye-dogu-akdenizde-oyunu-nasil-degistirdi-simdi-ne-olacak/
• Connelly, C. (2022). Eastern Mediterranean gas discoveries, progress, and what to watch in 2023. Middle East Institute. https://www.mei.edu/publications/eastern-mediterranean-gas-discoveries-progress-and-what-watch-2023
• Council of the European Union. (2022). Eastern Mediterranean: Council prolongs the sanctions regime over unauthorised drilling activities for a further year. https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2022/11/08/eastern-mediterranean-council-prolongs-the-sanctions-regime-over-unauthorised-drilling-activities-for-a-further-year/
• Demiryol, T. (2019). Between Security and Prosperity: Türkiye and the Prospect of Energy Cooperation in the Eastern Mediterranean. Turkish Studies, 20(3), 442-464.
• Egypt Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019). FM hands Greek PM message from President Sisi. https://www.sis.gov.eg/Story/140939/FM-hands-Greek-PM-message-from-President-Sisi?lang=en-us
• Egypt State Information Service. (2019). At the outset of his visit to Cyprus, Shoukry holds talks with his
• Cypriot counterpart (1 August 2019). https://www.sis.gov.eg/Story/140966/At-the-outset-of-his-visit-to-Cyprus%2C-Shoukry-holds-talks-with-his-Cypriot-counterpart?lang=en-us
• ElBassoussy, A. (2018). East Mediterranean gas: a new arena for international rivalry. Review of Economics and Political Science, 3(2), 70-87.
• European External Action Service. (2019). Statement by High Representative/Vice-President Federica Mogherini on Turkey's intended drilling activities within the exclusive economic zone of Cyprus. (4 April 2019). https://www.eeas.europa.eu/node/61836_en
• European Union. Eastern Mediterranean Natural Gas Pipeline – Pre-FEED Studies. https://ec.europa.eu/inea/en/connecting-europe-facility/cef-energy/7.3.1-0025-elcy-s-m-15
• European Union. EU imports of energy products - recent developments. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/SEPDF/cache/46126.pdf
• Foreign Relations Committee. (2019). Menendez, Rubio Introduce Eastern Mediterranean Security and Energy Partnership Act of 2019. https://www.foreign.senate.gov/press/ranking/release/menendez-rubio-introduce-Eastern-mediterranean-security-and-energy-partnership-act-of-2019
• France Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs. (2019a). Cyprus - Declaration (5 October 2019). https://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/country-files/cyprus/news/article/cyprus-declaration-05-10-19
• France Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs. (2019b). Cyprus – Drilling in the Eastern Mediterranean (9 July 2019). https://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/country-files/cyprus/news/article/cyprus-drilling-in-the-Eastern-mediterranean-09-07-19
• Gibbons, R. (1992). A Primer in Game Theory. New York: Harvester ve Wheatsheaf.
• Gilpin, R. (1987). The Political Economy of International Relations. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
• Government of the Russian Federation. (2022). Alexander Novak: Relations between Russia and China are based on equality and stability. (29 November 2022). http://government.ru/en/news/47176/
• Güner, S. (2003). Oyun kuramı ve uluslararası politika. METU Studies in Development 30(2), 163-180.
• Hargreaves Heap, S. P. ve Varoufakis, Y. (2004). Game Theory A Critical Text. New York: Routledge. 58-78.
• Hellenic Republic Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019a). Minister of Foreign Affairs Nikos Dendias' statement following his meeting with his Egyptian counterpart, Sameh Shoukry (Athens, 30 July 2019). https://www.mfa.gr/en/current-affairs/top-story/minister-of-foreign-affairs-nikos-dendias-statements-following-his-meeting-with-egyptian-counterpart-sameh-shoukry-cairo-22112022.html
• Hellenic Republic Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019b). Ministry of Foreign Affairs Spokesperson Alexandros Yennimatas's response to a journalist's question on yesterday's statement from the Spokesperson for the Turkish Foreign Ministry regarding the Turkey-Libya agreement. https://www.mfa.gr/turkey/tr/the-embassy/news/ministry-of-foreign-affairs-spokesperson-alexandros-yennimatass-response-to-journalists-question-on-yesterdays-statement-from-the-spokesperson-for-turkish-foreign-ministry-regarding-turkey-libya.html
• Hellenic Republic Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019c). Speech of Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs K. Fragogiannis at the Conference "Southeast Europe & East Med: New strategies, New Ρerspectives" with the title "Greece as a Pillar of Stability in the Eastern Mediterranean" (Washington, 19.11.2019). https://www.mfa.gr/en/current-affairs/statements-speeches/speech-of-deputy-minister-of-foreign-affairs-fragogiannis-at-the-conference-southeast-europe.html
• Hellenic Republic Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2020). Energy Diplomacy. https://www.mfa.gr/en/energy-diplomacy/
• Hellenic Republic Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2022). Minister of Foreign Affairs Nikos Dendias’ address via video-recorded message at the International Conference “EU Policies Towards the East Mediterranean:
• Energy and Security” (Athens, 04.11.2022). https://www.mfa.gr/en/current-affairs/statements-speeches/minister-of-foreign-affairs-nikos-dendias-address-via-video-recorded-message-at-the-international-conference-eu-policies-towards-the-east-mediterranean-energy-and-security-athens-04112022.html
• Heydemann, S. and Chace-Donahue, E. (2018). Sovereignty Versus Sectarianism: Contested Norms and the Logic of Regional Conflict in the Greater Levant. In Mustafa Aydın (Ed.), The Levant: From Ancient Gateway to Modern Chaos – The Search for a Regional Order. Tunis: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung.
• Huntington, S. P. (1996). The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order. New York: Simon & Schuster.
• Hussain, H. R. (2022, 31 October). Lebanon’s Maritime Deal with Israel. Carnegie Endowment For International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/sada/88292
• IHS Markit. (2017). Total's Offshore Cyprus Block 11 Could Rival Egypt's Zohr Natural Gas Discovery; Increasing Investment and Competition in Region, IHS Markit Says. https://news.ihsmarkit.com/prviewer/release_only/slug/catherine-gifford-totals-offshore-cyprus-block-11-could-rival-egypts-zohr-natural-gas-
• International Energy Agency. (2018). Country Analysis Brief: Egypt.
• International Energy Agency. (2019). World Energy Outlook.
• International Energy Agency. (2022). World Energy Outlook.
• Israel Ministry of Foreign Affair. (2022). FM Lapid departs on official visit to Greece. https://www.gov.il/en/Departments/news/fm-lapid-departs-on-official-visit-to-greece-5-apr-2022
• Italian Government Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation. (2019). Italy concerned for the illegal operations of the Turkish vessel Yavutz in the exclusive economic zone of Cyprus. https://www.esteri.it/en/sala_stampa/archivionotizie/comunicati/2019/10/italia-preoccupata-per-le-operazioni-illegali-della-nave-turca-yavutz-nella-zona-economica-esclusiva-di-cipro_0/
• Kambas, M. & Zawadzki, S. (2019, 28 February). Exxon's Cyprus gas discovery adds another giant to East Med collection. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-exxon-mobil-cyprus/exxons-cyprus-gas-discovery-adds-another-giant-to-east-med-collection-idUSKCN1QH1O3
• Keohane, R. O. (1984). After Hegemony : Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
• Kutlu, Ö. & Erkul Kaya, N. (2018, 28 December). East Mediterranean gas no game-changer: IEA's Birol. Anadolu Agency. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/east-mediterranean-gas-no-game-changer-ieas-birol/1350787
• Marsi, F. (2022, 14 October). What to know about the Israel-Lebanon maritime border deal. Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/14/what-to-know-about-the-israel-lebanon-maritime-border-deal
• Matalucci, S. (2019, June 24). Will EastMed gas fuel tensions?. Deutsche Welle. https://www.dw.com/en/eastmed-gas-paving-the-way-for-a-new-geopolitical-era/a-49330250
• Mearsheimer, J, (2001). The Tragedy of Great Power Politics. New York: Norton.
• Open Secrets. (2022). Issue Profile: Fuel, Gas & Oil. https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/issues/summary?cycle=2022&id=FUE
• Prime Minister's Office of Israel. (2019a). PM Netanyahu Meets with US Energy Secretary Rick Perry – PM's Complete Remarks. https://www.gov.il/en/departments/news/event_perry230719
• Prime Minister's Office of Israel. (2019b). PM Netanyahu Meets with Greek Foreign Minister Nikos Dendias. https://www.gov.il/en/departments/news/event_greece280719
• Republic of Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019a). Statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in response to the Statement of the Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Turkey, dated 19 September 2019. https://www.pio.gov.cy/en/press-releases-article.html?id=9655#flat
• Republic of Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019b). Statement to the Press by Foreign Affairs Minister, Mr Nikos Christodoulides, after the deliberations with the Secretary-General of the Union for the Mediterranean. https://www.pio.gov.cy/en/press-releases-article.html?id=11032#flat
• Republic of Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019c). The Second Ministerial Meeting of the East Mediterranean Gas Forum (EMGF). https://www.pio.gov.cy/assets/pdf/newsroom/2019/07/EMGF%202%20Ministerial%20Meeting%20Declaration%20-%2025Jul%202019%20-%201600(1)%20(2).pdf
• Republic of Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2022). Address by Foreign Minister Kasoulides, The Black Sea and Eastern Mediterranean in Transition. (9 June 2022). https://mfa.gov.cy/speeches/2022/06/09/fm-kasoulides-black-sea/
• Republic of Türkiye Embassy of Turkey in Ulaanbaatar. (2019). SC-58, 28 Eylül 2019, Dışişleri Bakanlığı Sözcüsü Hami Aksoy’un Yunanistan-Mısır-GKRY Üçlü Toplantısı Sonunda Yayımlanan Ortak Açıklama Hakkındaki Soruya Cevabı. http://ulanbator.be.mfa.gov.tr/Mission/ShowAnnouncement/361676
• Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019a). No: 292, 9 Ekim 2019, Mısır-Yunanistan-GKRY Zirvesi Sonunda Yayımlanan Bildiri Hk. https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_292_-misir-yunanistan-gkry-zirvesi-hk.tr.mfa
• Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019b). SC-56, 19 Eylül 2019, Dışişleri Bakanlığı Sözcüsü Hami Aksoy’un GKRY'nin 7 Numaralı Sözde Ruhsat Sahası için Uluslararası Şirketlerle Anlaşma İmzaladığına Dair Haberler Hakkındaki Soruya Cevabı. http://www.mfa.gov.tr/sc_-56_-sozde-ruhsat-sahasi-hk-sc.tr.mfa Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019c). SC-73, 1 Aralık 2019, Dışişleri Bakanlığı Sözcüsü Hami Aksoy’un Doğu Akdeniz’de Deniz Yetki Alanlarına İlişkin Libya’yla İmzaladığımız Anlaşmayla İlgili Yunanistan’ın ve Mısır’ın Açıklamaları Hakkındaki Soruya Cevabı. http://www.mfa.gov.tr/sc_-73_-yunanistan-ve-misir-aciklamalari-hk-sc.tr.mfa
• Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2022). No: 323, 27 Ekim 2022, Lübnan ile İsrail Arasında Deniz Yetki Alanları Sınırlandırma Anlaşmasının İmzalanması Hk. https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_-323_-lubnan-ile-israil-arasinda-deniz-yetki-alanlari-sinirlandirma-anlasmasinin-imzalanmasi-hk.tr.mfa
• Reuters. (2017). Greece, Italy, Israel and Cyprus back natgas pipeline to Europe. https://www.reuters.com/article/energy-mediterranean-natgas/greece-italy-israel-and-cyprus-back-natgas-pipeline-to-europe-idUSL8N1O537F
• Reuters. (2018). Turkish blockade of ship off Cyprus is out of Eni's control: CEO. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyprus-natgas-Türkiye-eni/turkish-blockade-of-ship-off-cyprus-is-out-of-enis-control-ceo-idUSKCN1G01K0
• Reuters. (2019). Eni won't drill wells off Cyprus if warships sent in – CEO. https://www.reuters.com/article/cyprus-Türkiye-eni-idAFS8N1YM043
• Reuters. (2022). Turkey-Libya preliminary deal prompts Greece, Egypt to push back. https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/turkey-libyan-government-agree-preliminary-maritime-energy-deal-2022-10-03/
• Rousseau, J. J. (2010). İnsanlar Arasındaki Eşitsizliğin Kaynağı. R. N. İleri (Trans.) İstanbul: Say Yayınları.
• Rubin, A. & Eiran, E. (2019). Regional Maritime Security in the Eastern Mediterranean: Expectations and Reality. International Affairs 95(5), 979-997.
• Russian Federation Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019a). Comment by the Information and Press Department on developments in the exclusive economic zone of Cyprus. https://archive.mid.ru/en/web/guest/kommentarii_predstavitelya/-/asset_publisher/MCZ7HQuMdqBY/content/id/3831028
• Russian Federation Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019b). Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov's remarks and answers to questions at a joint news conference following talks with Foreign Minister of the Hellenic Republic Nikos Dendias, Moscow, 6 November, 2019. https://archive.mid.ru/en/web/guest/meropriyatiya_s_uchastiem_ministra/-/asset_publisher/xK1BhB2bUjd3/content/id/3887532
• Russian Federation Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2022). Briefing by Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman Maria Zakharova, Moscow, June 29, 2022. https://mid.ru/en/foreign_policy/news/1819949/ Sadeh, S. (2015, 11 July). Digging Into the Lobbying Efforts of Natural Gas Partner Noble Energy. HAARETZ. https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/business/.premium-digging-into-the-lobbying-efforts-of-noble-energy-1.5376108
• Schenk, C.J., Kirschbaum, M.A., Charpentier, R.R., Klett, T.R., Brownfield, M.E., Pitman, J.K., Cook, T.A. & Tennyson, M.E. (2010). Assessment of undiscovered oil and gas resources of the Levant Basin Province, Eastern Mediterranean. U.S. Geological Survey Fact Sheet 2010-2014.
• Skyrms, B. & Irvine, U. C. (2001). The Stag Hunt. The American Philosophical Association 75(2), 31-41.
• South EU Summit. (2018). ExxonMobil Searches For Natural Gas Offshore Cyprus & Greece – A Potential Boon For European Energy Security & Clean Energy Goals. https://www.southeusummit.com/europe/exxonmobil-searches-for-natural-gas-offshore-cyprus-greece-a-potential-boon-for-european-energy-security-clean-energy-goals/
• Stergiou, A. (2019). Geopolitics and Energy Security in the Eastern Mediterranean: The Formation of New' Energy Alliances'. In Zenonas Tziarras (Ed.), The New Geopolitics of the Eastern Mediterranean: Trilateral Partnerships and Regional Security. Oslo: Prio.
• Strange, S. (1994). States and Markets. London: Bloomsbury Academics.
• TANAP. (2014). https://www.tanap.com/store/file/81e3e4dc104e1717d6ad620de3752257.pdf
• The Guardian. (2019). Armed Turkish drone lands in Cyprus as regional tensions rise. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/dec/16/turkey-delivers-armed-drone-to-northern-cyprus-amid-growing-tension-libya-deal
• The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies. (2018). Let's not exaggerate: Southern Gas Corridor prospects to 2030. Tsafos, N. (2019, 22 January). Can the East Med Pipeline Work?. CSIS. https://www.csis.org/analysis/can-east-med-pipeline-work
• Tsakiris, T., Ülgen, S. & Han, A. K. (2018). Gas Developments in the Eastern Mediterranean: Trigger or Obstacle for EU-Türkiye Cooperation?. FEUTURE Online Paper 22.
• Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2019). Hidrokarbon faaliyetleri hk. https://mfa.gov.ct.tr/tr/gkrynin-kibrisli-turklere-de-ait-olan-bir-alanda-faaliyetler-yapilmasini-haksiz-ve-anlamsiz-sekilde-tanimlamasi-hk/
• Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2021). Güney Kıbrıs Rum Yönetimi Enerji Bakanı Natasa Pilides’in açıklamaları hk. https://mfa.gov.ct.tr/tr/guney-kibris-rum-yonetimi-enerji-bakani-natasa-pilidesin-aciklamalari-hk/
• Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus Public Information Office. (2019). Özersay spoke to Deutsche Welle: “We are determining the point of drilling” (30 January 2019). https://pio.mfa.gov.ct.tr/en/ozersay-spoke-to-deutsche-welle-we-are-determining-the-point-of-drilling/
• Tzionis, T. (2019, 31 May). Recent developments in the continental shelf/EEZ of the Republic of Cyprus. Ministry of Foreign Affairs Republic of Cyprus. https://cyprusinuk.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/FOR-WEB-Presentation-to-EU-HoMs-31.05.2019-FINAL-31.05.2019ii.pdf
• U.S. Congressional Research Service. (2021). TurkStream: Russia’s Southern Pipeline to Europe. (IF11177; 6 May 2021). https://sgp.fas.org/crs/row/IF11177.pdf
• U.S. Department of State. (2019a). Joint Declaration Between Cyprus, Greece, Israel, and the United States After the Sixth Trilateral Summit. https://2017-2021.state.gov/joint-declaration-between-cyprus-greece-israel-and-the-united-states-after-the-sixth-trilateral-summit/index.html
• U.S. Department of State. (2019b). Turkish Drilling in Cypriot Claimed Waters. https://2017-2021.state.gov/turkish-drilling-in-cypriot-claimed-waters-2/index.html
• U.S. Department of State. (2022). Historic Agreement Establishing a Permanent Israel-Lebanon Maritime Boundary. https://www.state.gov/historic-agreement-establishing-a-permanent-israel-lebanon-maritime-boundary/
• U.S. Embassy & Consulate in Greece. (2019a). Joint Declaration Between Cyprus, Greece, Israel, and the U.S. After the 6th Trilateral Summit. https://gr.usembassy.gov/joint-declaration-between-cyprus-greece-israel-and-the-u-s-after-the-6th-trilateral-summit/
• U.S. Embassy & Consulate in Greece. (2019b). Secretary Michael R. Pompeo and Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis Remarks to the Press (5 October 2019). https://gr.usembassy.gov/secretary-michael-r-pompeo-and-greek-prime-minister-kyriakos-mitsotakis-remarks-to-the-press/
• U.S. Embassy & Consulate in Greece. (2022). Statement on East Med Energy Cooperation. https://gr.usembassy.gov/statement-on-east-med-energy-cooperation/
• U.S. Energy Information Agency. (2019). International Energy Outlook 2009 with projections to 2050.
• Waltz, K. N. (1959). Man, the State and War. New York: Columbia University Press.
• Weiss, I. (2019). Prospects of Mediterranean gas for the region's stability and EU's energy security. paper presented at Middle East Energy and Geopolitics, Lebanon. Beirut: Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung e. V., https://www.kas.de/documents/284382/284431/Bericht+1-+Oil+and+Gas+Middle+East.pdf/0a31b7e7-baca-3b39-a956-ff3cae514fa2?version=1.0&t=1563869107244
• Zalel, Y. (2015, December 24). A Short History of the Regulatory Natural Gas Framework in Israel. NATURAL GAS WORLD. https://www.naturalgasworld.com/short-history-regulatory-natural-gas-framework-israel