Performance Evaluation of Various Multicarrier Pulse Width Modulation Techniques for Seven-level Packed U-Cell Multilevel Inverter with a Novel Switching Generating Method

Abstract

In this paper, a novel switching generation method is presented that adapts conventional pulse width modulation (PWM) methods to the packed U-cell multilevel inverter topology. The proposed solution involves designing a combinational logic circuit constructed using minterms. By selecting and summing appropriate minterms, the resulting output signal is used to drive the power semiconductors. Additionally, various multicarrier PWM methods are analyzed and compared based on performance metrics such as output current harmonics, DC bus utilization, and semiconductor losses. Numerical studies are conducted in MATLAB on a single-phase 324 kVA, seven-level PUC-MLI using an improved semiconductor loss estimation approach that employs higher-order loss curves for both IGBT and diode, derived from the manufacturer's data sheet. When compared to level-shifted PWM, phase-shifted PWM (PS-PWM) consistently achieves lower current THD, even at low carrier frequencies, and always maintaints THD within the limits of the IEEE-519 power quality standard. It is also shown that the PS-PWM method results in approximately 3.3 times higher semiconductor losses on average than level-shifted PWM methods. Across all PWM methods, the carrier frequency has a negligible effect on the fundamental component of the output voltage, which remains below 1V. Furthermore, when comparing the PS-PWM method as a whole to level-shifted PWM methods, DC voltage variations of up to 0.5% are observed at the output for a given modulation index. The simulation results indicate that while level-shifted PWM methods generate lower semiconductor losses, the phase-shifted PWM option provides better power quality.

Keywords

• Packed U-cell (PUC)
• Multilevel Inverter
• Multicarrier Pulse Width Modulation
• Conduction Loss
• Switching Loss

References

1. [1] Krishna, M., Raj, P. Ajay D. Vimal, Subramaniam, N.P., “Transformer based 25-level t-type MLI for renewable energy integration”, IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Industrial Electronics, 3(4): 1127-1136, (2022).
2. [2] Vishal, A., Singh, V., “Implementation of cascaded asymmetrical multilevel inverter for renewable energy integration”, International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications, 49(6): 1776-1794, (2021).
3. [3] Bharatiraja, C., Padmanaban, S., Blaabjerg, F., “Investigation and comparative analysis of advanced PWM techniques for three-phase three-level NPC-MLI drives”, Electric Power Components and Systems, 46(3): 258-269, (2018).
4. [4] Arunkumar, S., Mohana, S.N., Malarvizhi, K., “Frequency modulated PV powered MLI fed induction motor drive for water pumping applications” Design and Development of Efficient Energy Systems, 119-130, (2022).
5. [5] Allu, B., Singh. A., “Performance analysis of SLMS based control for PV-STATCOM using a CHB-MLI”, International Journal of Electronics, 108(10): 1710-1732, (2021).
6. [6] Hema, S., Manikandan, V., “Power quality enhancement using multi-level inverter with UPQC and robust back propagation neural network strategy”, ECS Transactions, 107(1): 5879, (2022).
7. [7] Rao, S.M., Satputaley, R.J., Keshri R.K., Buja, G., “Performance evaluation of MLI based DVR in grid fed EV fast charging station”, IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, 39(1): 49-61, (2024).
8. [8] Choudhury, S., Bajaj, M., Dash, T., Kamel, S., Jurado, F., “Multilevel inverter: A survey on classical and advanced topologies, control schemes, applications to power system and future prospects”, Energies, 14(18): 5773, (2021).

9. [9] Meraj, S.T., Yu, S.S., Rahman, M.S., Arefin, A.A., Lipu, M.S.H., Trinh, H.A., “A novel extendable multilevel inverter for efficient energy conversion with fewer power components: configuration and experimental validation”, International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications, 52(6): 2760-2785, (2024).
10. [10] Neha T., Chattopadhyay, S.K., “Three-phase NPC-LDN hybrid transformerless multilevel inverter”, IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Industrial Electronics, (2023).
11. [11] Youssef, O., Al-Haddad, K., “A novel high energetic efficiency multilevel topology with reduced impact on supply network”, Proceedings of the 34th International Conference on Annual Conference of IEEE Industrial Electronics, Orlando, Florida, (2008).
12. [12] Vahedi, H., Al-Haddad, K., “PUC5 inverter—A promising topology for single-phase and three-phase applications”, Proceedings of the 42th Annual Conference of IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Florence, (2016).
13. [13] Vahedi, H., Labbé, P.-A., Al-Haddad, K., “Sensor-less five-level packed U-cell (PUC5) inverter operating in stand-alone and grid-connected modes”, in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, 12(1): 361-370, (2016).
14. [14] Khawaja, R., Sebaaly, F., Kanaan, H.Y., “Design of a 7-level single-stage/phase PUC grid-connected PV inverter with FS-MPC control”, Proceedings of the 2020 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Technology, Buenos Aires, (2020).
15. [15] Li, P., Tong, X., He, Y., Chen, T., “Adaptive model predictive control for PUC grid-connected inverter system with inaccurate parameters”, Control Engineering Practice, 139, (2023).
16. [16] Lamreoua A., Benslimane, A., Boucnaif, J., Hirech, K., Adaliou, A., Elouariachi, M., “Current harmonic reduction for grid-connected photovoltaic system (PV) based on improved control of three-phase seven-level PUC inverter”, Materials Today, 72(7): 3536-3543, (2023).
17. [17] Mishra, N., Singh, B., Yadav, S.K., Tariq, M., “Power quality improvement in fifteen level PUC converter for solar PV grid-tied applications”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, 59(4): 4264-4273, (2023).
18. [18] May, A., Krim, F., Feroura, H., Belaout, A., “Power quality enhancement of grid-tied 7L-PUC inverter-based PV system using a novel DC-link controller”, Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 48(11): 15305-15319, (2023).
19. [19] Alquennah, A.N., Chida, M., Zamzam, T., Trabelsi, M., “Reinforcement learning based controller for grid-connected PUC PV inverter”, Proceedings of the 49th Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Singapore, (2023).
20. [20] Hasirci, H.Y., Vural, A.M., “Design and experimental verification of PUC multilevel inverter-based PMSG wind energy conversion system”, Applied Sciences, 13(24): 13018, (2023).
21. [21] Sahli, A., Krim, F., Laib, A., Talbi, B., “Model predictive control for single phase active power filter using modified packed U-cell (MPUC5) converter”, Electric Power Systems Research, 180: 106139, (2020).
22. [22] Ananthi, K., Manoharan, S., “Enhancing power quality using packed U Cell 5 multilevel inverter-based shunt active power filter with fuzzy controller”, International Journal of Fuzzy Systems, 24: 1356-1370, (2022).
23. [23] Vahedi, H., Dehghanzadeh, A., Al-Haddad, K., “Static VAr compensator using packed U-cell based multilevel converter”, Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Compatibility, Power Electronics and Power Engineering, Doha, Qatar, (2018).
24. [24] Cardoso, J.T., Jacobina, C.B., Rodrigues, P.L.S., Lima, A.M.N., “PUC converter based on AC-DC-AC multilevel topologies with a shared leg”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, 59(6): 6876-6888, (2023).
25. [25] Trabelsi, M., Komurcugil, H., Bayhan, S., Abu-Rub H., “An effective transformerless PUC7-based dynamic voltage restorer using model predictive control”, Sustainability, 15(4): 3041, (2023).
26. [26] Krishnamoorthy, U., Pitchaikani, U., Rusu, E., Fayek, H.H., “Performance analysis of harmonic-reduced modified PUC multi-level inverter based on an MPC algorithm”, Inventions, 8(4): 90, (2023).
27. [27] Bhanuchandar, A., K. Murthy, B., “A new floor function single-carrier-based modulated model predictive current control technique for single-phase PUC5 inverter topology”, 52(2): 812-834, (2024).
28. [28] Rayane, K., Bougrine, M., Abu-Rub, H., Benalia, A., Trabelsi, M., “Average model-based sliding mode control for quality improvement of a grid-connected PUC inverter”, IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, 11(4): 3765-3774, (2023).
29. [29] Babaie, M., Sharifzadeh, M., Kanaan, H.Y., Al-Haddad, K., “Switching-based optimized sliding-mode control for capacitor self-voltage balancing operation of seven-level PUC inverter”, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 68(4): 3044-3057, (2021).
30. [30] Sathik, M.J., Bhatnagar, K., Sandeep, N., Blaabjerg, F., “An improved seven-level PUC inverter topology with voltage boosting”, IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems II: Express Briefs, 67(1): 127-131, (2020).
31. [31] Makhamreh, H., Trabelsi, M., Kükrer, O., Abu-Rub, H., “An effective sliding mode control design for a grid-connected PUC7 multilevel inverter”, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 67(5): 3717-3725, (2020).
32. [32] Vasu, R., Chattopadhyay, S.K., Chakraborty, C., “Seven-level packed u-cell (PUC) converter with natural balancing of capacitor voltages”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, 56(5): 5234-5244, (2020).
33. [33] Arazm, S., Zgheib, R., Al-Haddad, K., “A novel sensor-less voltage balancing on PUC5 to reduce the size of flying capacitor”, Proceedings of the 47th Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Toronto, Ontario, (2021).
34. [34] McGrath, B.P., Holmes, D.G., “Multicarrier PWM strategies for multilevel inverters”, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 49(4): 858-867, (2002).
35. [35] Iderus, S., Vijayakumar, A., Peter, G., Stonier, A.A., “Performance of modified structure asymmetrical multilevel inverter with multicarrier PWM control strategies”, Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Inventive Research in Computing Applications, Coimbatore, (2023).
36. [36] Chinnaraj, G., Kumarasamy, V., Paramasivan, M., Chandrasekaran, G., Kumar, N.S., “Mathematical formulation of multicarrier PWM techniques and design an eleven-level modular multilevel inverter to improve power quality”, International Journal of System Assurance Engineering and Management, 14: 1218-1227, (2023).
37. [37] Gudipati, K., Maramreddy, H.V.R., Kolli, S.G., Lakshmi, V.U., Reddy, G.S., “Comparison of pulse width modulation techniques for diode-clamped and cascaded multilevel inverters”, Engineering, Technology and Applied Science Research, 13(4): 11078-11084, (2023).
38. [38] Tariq, M., Iqbal, M.T., Iqbal, A., Meraj, M., Roomi, M.M., Khan, M.S.U., “Comparative analysis of carrier schemes for PWM in multilevel PUC inverter for PV applications," Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on the Development in the in Renewable Energy Technology, Dhaka, (2016).
39. [39] Zaragoza, J., Pou, J., Ceballos, S., Robles, E., Ibanez, P., Villate, J.L., “A comprehensive study of a hybrid modulation technique for the neutral-point-clamped converter”, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 56(2): 294-304, (2009).
40. [40] Gleissner, M., Nehmer, D., Bakran, M. -M., “Junction temperature measurement based on the internal gate resistance for a wide range of power semiconductors”, IEEE Open Journal of Power Electronics, 4: 293-305, (2023).
41. [41] FF600R17ME4 700 V, 600 A dual IGBT module data sheet, 2016, [Online]. Available: https://www.infineon.com/dgdl/Infineon-FF600R17ME4-DS-v03_00-EN.pdf?fileId=db3a304333b8a7ca0133c67bfb6d6156