The Femoral Midshaft Index as Evidence of a Transition in Mobility Patterns in the Chalcolithic and Bronze Age Populations of Anatolia

Öz

Several studies have demonstrated mechanical loading to be associated with activity patterns such as human subsistence strategies and to generate an adaptive response in bone. The femoral midshaft index (FMI), also known as the pilasteric index, is used to infer functional loading effects on the femur to indicative of bone strength as a product of physiological loading. FMI is calculated by dividing the femoral midshaft anteroposterior (AP) diameter by its mediolateral (ML) diameter; measurements are taken from the periosteal surface. This research examines FMI in Chalcolithic and Bronze Age populations across Anatolian regions to observe changes in midshaft geometry and test correlations with spatiotemporal and sociocultural transformations. The FMI data were sourced from published literature containing post-cranial measurements of anatomically modern humans from the populations of interest. Overall, FMI in the Anatolian region declined over time, with the exception of Central Anatolian sites where FMI increased through the Chalcolithic to Early Bronze Ages before decreasing during the Middle Bronze Age. Fluctuations in FMI during the transition from the Chalcolithic and Bronze Ages correlate to the gradual lifestyle changes in the region, with sociocultural transformations being linked to the development of new activities. The observed overall decline in FMI correlates to the archaeological evidence, which depicts a local decline in pastoral communities and development of complex export-driven villages.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Mobility
• Bioarchaeology
• Prehistory Of Anatolia

Kaynakça

1. Açıkkol, A. (2000). Küçükhöyük Eski Tunç Çağı insanlarının paleoantropolojik açıdan incelemesi [The paleoanthropological analysis of Early Bronze Age Kücükhöyük skeletons]. Master’s thesis, Ankara University. google scholar
2. Açikkol, A., Yilmaz, H., Baykara, I., Şahin, S. (2003). Kütahya Ağızören Hitit iskeletlerinin paleoantropolojik analizi ve Tunç Çağı Anadolu halkları arasındaki yeri [The paleoanthropological analysis of Kutahya Agizoren Hittites skeletons and the place of among Bronze Age Anatolian Populations]. Antropoloji, 17, 1-26. google scholar
3. Adams, R. (1960) Factors Influencing the Rise of Civilization in the Alluvium: Illustrated by Mesopotamia, City Invincible. A Symposium on Urbanization and Cultural Development in the Near East, (Eds). C.H. Kraeling, R.Mcc. Adams, Chicago: University of Chicago, 24-46. google scholar
4. Agostini, G.M., Ross, A.H. (2011). The effect of weight on the femur: a cross-sectional analysis. J Forensic Sci 56:339-343 google scholar
5. Akkermans, P.M., Schwartz, M.G. (2003). The Archaeology of Syria. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. google scholar
6. Anthony, D.W. (2007). The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. google scholar
7. Arbuckle, B.S. (2014). The rise of cattle cultures in Bronze Age Anatolia. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies, Vol2(4). google scholar
8. Arbuckle, B. S., & Hammer, E. L. (2019). The Rise of Pastoralism in the Ancient Near East. Journal of ArchaeologicalResearch, 27(3), 391-449. google scholar

9. Aslan, G. (2005). Anadolu’da Neolitik Dönemden günümüze uzun kemiklerin boyutları ve iskelet kütleviliğinin değerlendirilmesi [Evaluation of the dimensions and robusticity of Anatolia populations long bone from the Neolithic Period to the present day]. Doctoral dissertation, Hacettepe University. google scholar
10. Bıçakçı, E., Ç. Altınbilek, E. Faydalı. (2006). Tepecik-Çiftlik 2004 Yılı Çalışmaları. 27. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı. 1. Cilt. pp.219-228. google scholar
11. Bıçakçı, E., F. Açıkgöz, S. Yıldırım-Balcı, Ç. Altınbilek-Algül. (2008). Tepecik-Çiftlik 2006 Yılı Çalışmaları. 29. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı, 1. Cilt. pp.483-496. google scholar
12. Brauer, G. (1988). Osteometrie. (Ed). Knussman R. Gustav Fisher. In: Anthropologie: Handbuch der Vergleichenden Biologie des Menchen. Stuttgart; pp.160-232. google scholar
13. Bridges, P. S. (1989). Changes in Activities with the Shift to Agriculture in the Southeastern United States. Current Anthropology, 30(3), 385-394. google scholar
14. Brock, S. L., & Ruff, C. B. (1988). Diachronic patterns of change in structural properties of the femur in the prehistoric American Southwest. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 75(1), 113-127. google scholar
15. Burr, D. B., Piotrowski, G., Martin, R. B., & Cook, P. N. (1982). Femoral mechanics in the lesser bushbaby (Galago senegalensis): Structural adaptations to leaping in primates. The Anatomical Record, 202(3), 419-429 google scholar
16. Büyükkarakaya, A. M., Y. G. Çakan, M. Godon, Y. S. Erdal, E. Bıçakçı. (2019). Handling dead bodies: Investigating the formation process of a collective burial from Neolithic Tepecik-Çiftlik, Central Anatolia (Turkey). Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 56. pp.101118. google scholar
17. Büyükkarakaya, A. M., Y. S. Erdal, M. Özbek, (2009). Tepecik-Çiftlik İnsanlarının Antropolojik Açıdan Değerlendirilmesi. 24. Arkeometri Sonuçları Toplantısı. pp.119-138.Campbell, S. (2007). Rethinking Halaf Chronologies. Paleorient, 33(1). Pp.103-36 google scholar
18. Caneva, I. (2012). Mersin-Yumuktepe in the Seventh Millennium BC: An Updated View. In: M. Özdoğan, N. Başgelen and P. Kuniholm (eds.), The Neolithic in Turkey. New Excavations & New Research. Central Turkey (Istanbul). 1-29. google scholar
19. Caneva, I., Palumbi, G. (2019). Concluding remarks on Yumuktepe Level XVI: the combined data. The Chalcolithic at Mersin-Yumuktepe Level XVI Reconsidered. Ege Yayinlari, pp.185-192. google scholar
20. Carlson, K. J. (2002). Shape and material properties of African pongid femora and humeri: Their relationship to observed positional behaviors. [Ph.D. dissertation] Indiana University. google scholar
21. Cowgill, L. W., Warrener, A., Pontzer, H., & Ocobock, C. (2010). Waddling and toddling: The biomechanical effects of an immature gait. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 143(1), 52-61. google scholar
22. Çakan, Y.G. (2013). Tepecik-Çiftlik Son Neolitik Dönem Mimarisi. İstanbul Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü. Unpublished MA thesis. google scholar
23. Çiner, R. (1963). Evdi Tepesi ve civarından çıkarılan iskelet kalıntılarının tetkiki [The examination of skeletal remains excavated from Evdi Tepesi and its vicinity]. Antropoloji, 1, 78-98. google scholar
24. Çiner, R. (1965). Acemhöyük İskeletleri [Acemhöyük Skeletons]. Ankara Üniversitesi DTCF Dergisi, 13, 1-24. google scholar
25. Çiner, R. (1967). Ilıca-Ayaş iskelet kalıntılarının tetkiki [The examination of skeletal remains from Ilica-Ayas]. Antropoloji, 4, 195-237. google scholar
26. Demes, B., Jungers, W. L., & Selpien, K. (1991). Body size, locomotion, and long bone cross-sectional geometry in indriid primates. American Journal of PhysicalAnthropology, 86(4), 537-547. google scholar
27. Dercksen, J.G. (2008). Subsistence, Surplus and the Market for Grain and Meat at Ancient Kanesh. Altorientalische Forschungen, 35, 86-102. google scholar
28. Erarslan, A. (2008). The Ubaid Period In The Urbanisation Process; The Birth Of Urbanism In The Near East (5500-3800 B.C.). Belleten, 72, 395-412. google scholar
29. Frangipane, M. (2002). “Non-Uruk” developments and Uruk-linked features on the northern borders of Greater Mesopotamia, pp. 123-48 in (J. Nicholas, ed.) Artefacts of Complexity, Tracking the Uruk in the Near East. Postgate, Aris & Phillips: Warminster. google scholar
30. (2004). Arslantepe. Alle origini del potere. Arslantepe, la collina dei leoni. Mondadori Electa S.p.A.: Milan. (ed.) google scholar
31. (2007). Arslantepe Cretulae. An Early Centralised Administrative System Before Writing. Universita di Roma “La Sapienza”, Dipartimento di Scienze Storiche Archeologiche e Antropologiche dell’Antichita. Missione Archeologica Italiana nell’Anatolia Orientale, Arslantepe vol. V: Rome. google scholar
32. (2016). The development of centralized societies in Greater Mesopotamia and the foundation of economic inequality. In: Tagungen des Landesmuseums für Vorgeschichte Halle, Band 14/II. google scholar
33. French, D. (1985). Mersin and Tell esh-Sheikh. Ed. Mario Liverani, Alba Palmieri, and Renato Peroni. In Studi di paletnologia in onore di Salvatore M. Puglisi. Roma: Universita di Roma “La Sapienza.” pp.265-71. google scholar
34. Foster, C.P. (2009). Household Archaeology and the Uruk Phenomenon: A case Study from Kenan Tepe Turkey. Ph.D. Dissertation. The University of California Berkley. google scholar
35. Godon, M. (2005). New Results and Remarques about Pottery Neolithic in Central Anatolia: A View from Tepecik-Çiftlik. Colloquium Anatolicum IV. pp. 91-103. google scholar
36. Goldman, H. (1956). Excavations at Gözlü Kule, Tarsus II. From the Neolithic through the Bronze Age. Princeton: Princeton University Press. google scholar
37. Gökdemir, S. (2014). Oylum Höyük Erken Tunç Çağı popülasyonunun paleoantrhopolojik analizi [The paleoanthropological analysis of the Early Bronze Age Population from Oylum Höyük]. Master’s thesis, Cumhuriyet University. google scholar
38. Gressner, G.C. (2011). A Brief overview of the Halaf Tradition. (Eds). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press. google scholar
39. Harmanşah, Ö. (2011). Monuments and memory: Architecture and visual culture in ancient Anatolian history. (Eds). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press. google scholar
40. Holt, B.M. (2003). Mobility in Upper Paleolithic and Mesolithic Europe: evidence from the lower limb. Am J Phys Anthropol 122:200-215 google scholar
41. Jepsen, K. J., Silva, M. J., Vashishth, D., Guo, X. E., & van der Meulen, M. C. (2015). Establishing Biomechanical Mechanisms in Mouse Models: Practical Guidelines for Systematically Evaluating Phenotypic Changes in the Diaphyses of Long Bones. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 30(6), 951-966. google scholar
42. Jungers, W. L., & Minns, R. J. (1979). Computed tomography and biomechanical analysis of fossil long bones. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 50(2), 285-290. google scholar
43. Klaunzer, M. (2013). Early bronze age elites and long-distance relations. Metalla, 20(2), 87-115. google scholar
44. Larsen, C. (1997). Bioarchaeology: Interpreting Behavior from the Human Skeleton (Cambridge Studies in Biological and Evolutionary Anthropology). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. google scholar
45. Larsen, C.S., Hillson, S., Ruff, C. et al. (2013). The human remains II: interpreting lifestyle and activity in Neolithic Çatalhöyük. (Ed). Ian Hodder. In: Humans and Landscapes of Çatalhöyük. Monumenta Archaeologica 30. Cotsen Institute of Archaeology Press. google scholar
46. Lieberman, D.E. and Shea, J.J. (1994). Behavioral Differences between Archaic and Modern Humans in the Levantine Mousterian. American Anthropologist, 96: 300-332. google scholar
47. MaClatchy, L., Gebo, D., Kityo, R., & Pilbeam, D. (2000). Postcranial functional morphology of Morotopithecus bishopi, with implications for the evolution of modern ape locomotion. Journal of Human Evolution, 39(2), 159-183. google scholar
48. Macintosh, A. A., Davies, T. G., Ryan, T. M., Shaw, C. N., & Stock, J. T. (2013). Periosteal versus true cross-sectional geometry: A comparison along humeral, femoral, and tibial diaphyses. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 150(3), 442-452. google scholar
49. Macintosh, A.A., Pinhasi, R., Stock, J.T. (2014). Lower limb skeletal biomechanics track long-term decline in mobility across ~6150 years of agriculture in Central Europe. J Arch Sci 52:376-390. google scholar
50. Marchi, D. (2008). Relationships between lower limb cross-sectional geometry and mobility: the case of a Neolithic sample from Italy. Am J Phys Anthropol 137:188-200. google scholar
51. Marchi, D., Sparacello, V.S., Holt, B.M., Formicola, V. (2006). Biomechanical approach to the reconstruction of activity patterns in Neolithic Western Liguria, Italy. Am J Phys Anthropol 131:447-455. google scholar
52. Marchi, D., Sparacello, V., & Shaw, C. (2011). Mobility and Lower Limb Robusticity of a Pastoralist Neolithic Population from North-Western Italy. In Human Bioarchaeology of the Transition to Agriculture (pp. 317-346). John Wiley & Sons. google scholar
53. Marro, C. (2011). Eastern Anatolia in the Early Bronze Age. (Ed). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press google scholar
54. Mellart, J. (1966). The Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Ages in the Near East and Anatolia. Khayats: Beirut. google scholar
55. Michel, C. (2011). The Karum Period on Plateau. (Ed). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press. google scholar
56. Ökse, A.T. (2011). The Early Bronze Age in Southeastern Anatolia. (Ed). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press. google scholar
57. Özbal, R. (2011). The Chalcolithic of Southeast Anatolia. (Ed). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. Oxford University Press 174-204. google scholar
58. Özdemir, S. (2011). Anadolu Tunç Çağı İnsan İskeletlerinin Paleodemografık ve Morfometrik Analizi: Kütahya Seyitömer. Ankara University Ph.D. dissertation. google scholar
59. Özdoğan, M. (2014). Anatolia: From pre-pottery Neolithic to the end of the early bronze age (10,5002000 BCE). In: C. Renfrew & P. Bahn (Eds.). The Cambridge World Prehistory (pp.1508-1544). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. google scholar
60. Özfirat, A., Marro, C. (2007). 2004 Yili Van, Ağri ve Iğdir İlleri Yüzey Araştirmasi. Türk Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Dergisi 7. google scholar
61. Palumbi, G., Chataigner, C. (2014). The Kura-Araxes Culture from the Caucasus to Iran, Anatolia and the Levant: Between unity and diversity. A Synthesis. In: Paleorient. google scholar
62. Parker, B. (2010). Networks of interregional interaction during Mesopotamia’s Ubaid period. (Eds). R. google scholar
63. Carter and G. Philip. In: Beyond the Ubaid. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 339-360. google scholar
64. Pearson, O.M., (2000). Activity, climate, and postcranial robusticity. Curr Anthropol, 41, 569e607. google scholar
65. Peltenburg, E. (2007). New Perspectives on the Carchemish Sector of the Middle Euphrates River Valley in the 3rd millennium BC. In: Euphrates Valley Settlement. (Ed.). Edgar Peltenburg. Levant Supplementary Series 5. Oxford: Oxbow Books. google scholar
66. Rothman, M.S. (2003). Ripples in the Stream: Transcaucasia-Anatolian Interaction in the Murat/Euphrates Basin at the Beginning of the Third Millennium BC. (Eds.) Adam Smith and Karen Rubinson. In: Archaeology in The Borderlands Investigations in Caucasia and Beyond. Los Angeles: Cotsen Institute Press. google scholar
67. Rubin, C.T., Lanyon, L.E. (1984). Regulation of bone formation by applied dynamic loads. J Bone Joint Surg Am, 66(3). pp.397-402. google scholar
68. Ruff, C. B. (1984). Allometry between length and cross-sectional dimensions of the femur and tibia in Homo sapiens sapiens. American Journal of PhysicalAnthropology, 65(4), pp.347-358. google scholar
69. Ruff, C.B. (1987) Sexual dimorphism in human lower limb bone structure: relationship to subsistence strategy and sexual division of labor. Journal ofHuman Evolution, 16(391), 416. google scholar
70. Ruff, C.B, Larsen CS. 1990. Postcranial biomechanical adaptations to subsistence changes on the Georgia Coast. Anth PapAm Mus Nat Hist 68:94-120. google scholar
71. Robling, A.G., Robyn, K.F., Burr, D.B. (2014). Chapter 9: Mechanical Adaptation. In: Basic and Applied Bone Biology. Ed(s): David B. Burr, Matthew R. Allen. Elsevier. google scholar
72. Schoop, U. 2005. Das Anatolische Chalkolithikum. Verlag Bernhard Albert Greiner. Urgeschichtliche Studien I: Remshalden. google scholar
73. Schoop, U. D. (2012). The Chalcolithic on the Plateau. In The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia: (10,000-323 BCE). Oxford University Press. google scholar
74. Seeman, E., (2003). Periosteal bone formation is a neglected determinant of bone strength. N Engl. J. Med. 349, 320e323 google scholar
75. Serpil, Ö. (2011). Anadolu Tunç Çaği İnsan İskeletlerinin Paleodemografik ve Morfometrik Analizi: Kütahya Seyitömer Örneği [Paleodemographic and Morphometric Analysis of Anatolian Bronze Age Human Skeletons: The Case of Kütahya Seyitömer]. Doctoral dissertation, Ankara University. google scholar
76. Schaffler, M. B., Burr, D. B., Jungers, W. L., & Ruff, C. B. (1985). Structural and mechanical indicators of limb specialization in primates. Folia Primatologica; International Journal of Primatology, 45(2), 61-75. google scholar
77. Shaw, C.N., Stock, S.T., Davies, T.G., Ryan, T.M. (2014). Does the distribution and variation in cortical bone along lower limb diaphyses reflect selection for locomotor economy? In: Carlson KJ, Marchi D (eds) Reconstructing mobility: environmental, behavioral, and morphological determinants. Springer, New York google scholar
78. Slâdek, V, Berner, M. and Sailer, R. (2006), Mobility in Central European Late Eneolithic and Early Bronze Age: Femoral cross-sectional geometry. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 130: 320-332. google scholar
79. Smith, A. T. (2015). The Political Machine: Assembling Sovereignity in the Bronze Age Caucasus. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. google scholar
80. Steadman, S.R. (2011). The Early Bronze Age on the Plateau. In: Ancient Anatolia 10.000-323 B.C.E. (Ed). Sharon R. Steadman & Gregory McMahon. Oxford University Press. google scholar
81. Stock, J., Pfeiffer, S. (2001). Linking structural variability in long bone diaphyses to habitual behaviors: foragers from southern African Later Stone Age and the Andaman Islands. Am J Phys Anthropol 115:337-348 google scholar
82. Stock, J.T. (2006). Hunter-gatherer postcranial robusticity relative to pattems of mobility, climatic adaptation, and selection for tissue economy. Am J Phys Anthropol 131:194-204 google scholar
83. Şenyürek, M. (1952). A study of the human skeletons from Kültepe, excavated under the auspices of the Turkish Historical Society. The skeletons from the excavation season of 1948. Belleten. 16(63), 323-343. google scholar
84. Şenyürek, M. (1954). A note on the long bones of Chalcolithic Age from Yümüktepe. Belleten, 18(72), 519-522. google scholar
85. Senyurek, M. (1955). A note on the long bones of Chalcolithic Age from Şeyh Höyük. Belleten, 19(74), 247-270. google scholar
86. Tunakan, S. (1965). Türk Tarih Kurumu adına 1964 yazında Alaca-Höyük’te yapılan kazıda çıkarılan iki eski bronz çağı iskeletinin incelenmesi [The examination of two Early Bronze Age skeletons from Alaca-Höyük recovered on behalf of the Turkish Historical Society in 1964]. Belleten, 29(116), 571584. google scholar
87. Tunakan, S. (1969). Malatya-Aslantepe iskeletleri [Malatya-Aslantepe Skeletons]. Antropoloji, 5, 1-7. google scholar
88. Turner, C.H. (1998). Three rules for bone adaptation to mechanical stimuli. Bone, 23(5). pp.399-407. google scholar
89. Trinkaus, E., Ruff, C.B., Conroy, G.C. (1999). The anomalous archaic Homo femur from Berg Aukas, Namibia: A biomechanical assessment. Am. J. Physical Anthro 110: 379-391. google scholar
90. Yalçın, Ü. (2000). Frühchalkolitische Metallfunde von Mersin - Yumuktepe: Beginn der Extraktiven Metallurgie? TÜBA-AR 3, pp. 109-128. google scholar
91. Yıldırım, A.Ç. (2013). Oylum Höyük toplumunun (Orta Tunç Çaği, Kilis) paleodemografik yapisi [The paleodemographic pattern of Oylum Hoyuk population (The Middle Bronze Age, Kilis)]. Zeitschrift für die Welt der Türken, 5(3), 35-48. google scholar
92. Yiğit, A., Kırmızıoğlu, P. G., İbiş, R., & Erol, A. S. (2010). Çankiri Salur Erken Tunç dönemi insanları [Early Bronze Age Salur population in Cankiri]. 26. Arkeometri Sonuçları Toplantısı, 273-290. google scholar
93. Vinet, A., D. Guilbeau, D. (2018). A first glimpse of the Late Neolithic and Early Chalcolithic in Cappadocia through the lithic industry of Tepecik-Çiftlik 2017 season. Anatolia Antiqua XXVI. pp. 1-12. google scholar
94. Vinet, A. and Guilbeau, D. (2020). Obsidian on the Move: From the Sources to the Tool. The Case of Tepeçik-Çiftlik (Turkey) around 6000 BC. Proceedings of the 11th International Congress on the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East. Vol(1). google scholar
95. Weiss, E. (2003). The effects of rowing on humeral strength. Am J Phys Anthropol 121:293-302. google scholar
96. Wescott, D.J. (2006). Effect of mobility on femur midshaft external shape and robusticity. Am J Phys Anthropol, 130:201-213. google scholar
97. Wescott, D.J. (2014). The relationship between femur shape and terrestrial mobility patterns. (Eds.) Carlson K, Marchi D. In: Mobility: Interpreting Behavior from Skeletal Adaptations and Environmental Interactions. New York: Springer. pp. 111-132. google scholar
98. Wescott, D.J., Cunningham, D.L. (2006). Temporal changes in Arikara humeral and femoral cross-sectional geometry associated with horticultural intensification. J Archaeol Sci, 33:1022-1036. google scholar
99. Wescott, D.J., Zephro, L. (2012). Secular change in the femur. Am J Phys Anthropol 147(S54):308 google scholar
100. Woolley, C.L. (1959). A Forgotten Kingdom: Being a Record of the Results Obtained from the Excavations of Two Mounds, Atchana and Al Mina in the Turkish Hatay. rev. ed. London: Parrish. google scholar
101. Zimmermann, T. (2006). Early Daggers in Anatolia—A Necessary Reappraisal. ANODOS - Studies of the Ancient World 4-5/ 2004-2005. google scholar