COMPARISON OF RENEWABLE AND CONVENTIONAL ENERGY COSTS BY WAVELET TECHNIQUES

Yıl 2013, Cilt: 3 Sayı: 1, 437 - 446, 01.06.2013

Zelha Altınkaya Zafer Aslan

Öz

This paper aims to compare the cost of renewable energy to conventional energy sources in production. It is
argued that advantage in cost of production would support competitiveness of Turkish manufacturing industry in
international trade. In this paper an export model has been developed to forecast competitive advantage of Turkish
manufacturing industry on international trade by using renewable energy in production. Data on the cost of energy on
Turkish manufacturing industry and export performance in past 10 years were processed. This study utilizes 1D wavelet
packets and continuous wavelets on historical cost and export values in Turkey. Wavelet and regression analysis have been
applied to define variation in temporal and spatial patterns. Wavelet techniques detect sudden changing, increasing and
decreasing trends of data and define the role of factors small and large scale effects. Actual share of energy usage in
production cost and usage of renewable energy instead of conventional energy values were compared to other countries data
analyses.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Cost of renewable energy, wavelet analysis, cost advantage, competitiveness, international trade

Kaynakça

• Akan,Y, Casuality
• Consumption and Economic Growth? The Case of Between
• Energy Arastırmaları Sempozyumu,
• Istanbul [3] Aslan, Z., and N. Çağlar. Wind Speed and Energy
• Analyses, I. International Symposium on Global Climate Change, Environment and Energy: Global Challenges and Opportunities to Global Stability, IAU, April 24, Istanbul, 2011 on
• Statistical [4] Arslan, Ismail & van Wijnbergen, Sweder ( 1990). "Turkey : export miracle or accounting trick?," Policy Research Working Paper Series 370, The World Bank
• Balassa, Bela (1995). Trade Liberalization and Revealed Comparative ``, Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies, 33, 99-123,
• Baris, K.(2011). ” The Role of Coal In energy Policy and Sustainable Development of Turkey: Is it Compatible to the EU Energy Policy? `` Energy Policy, Vol.39 Issue 3. March 2011. pp: 1754-1763. [7] Bubula, A and İnci Robe-Otker ( 2002). The Evolution of Exchange Rate Regimes Since 1990: Evidence from the De Factor Policies. IMF Working Paper
• Dooley,M.,L. Folkerts and Peter Garber ( 2009). Bretton Woods II Still Defines The International Monetary w14731
• Durand and Giorno (1987). Indicators of international Competitiveness: Conceptual Aspects and Evaluation. OECD Economic Studies. Vol.9
• Hassett, K, Hubbard Glenn and Matthew H.Jensen (2011 ) Rethinking Competitiveness. American Enterprise Institute for Publicy Policy Research” “ Is Competitiveness Worth Defending?” Prepared for the American Enterprise Institute International Monetary Fund (2009),” Review of Recent Crisis Programs” Approved by Reza Moghadam, R (2009)
• Maltsoglu, Irini (2009)”Simulating exogenous and endogenous technology when depletables renewables and pollution co-exist: how to achieve sustainability?”http://dspace.uniroma2.it/dspace/bit stream/2108/1007/3/Paper+II_Maltsoglou_June09. pdf
• Melek, M., A. Tokgozlu and Z.Aslan (2008) Wavelet Analyses of Oil Prices, USA Variations and Impact On Logistics.
• Obstfeld, M. and Kenneth Rogoff ( 2007 ). The Unsustainable US Current Account Position RevisitedURL: http://www.nber.org/chapters/c0127 [14] Obstfeld, M and Kenneth Rogoff(2007) G7 Current Account Imbalances: Sustainability and Adjustment.
• http://www.nber.org/books/clar06-2 Volume
• URL: [15] Ozturk, İ.(2006). “Exchange Rate Volatility and Trade : A literature Survey” International Journal of Applied Econometrics and Quantitative Studies Vol.3-1( 2006)
• Parrinelo,Sergio (2009). “The Notion of National Economyniversity
• Forthcoming in “Economic Theory and Economic Thought: Essays in Honour of Ian Steedman edited by J Vint S Metcalfe, H.Kurz, P. Samuelson and N.Salvadori, Routhledge
• Johansson, T. Kelly, Amulya K.N. H. Reddy, R.Williams (1993).Renewable Fuels and Electricity For a Growing World Economy. Island Press. ISBN 1 55963
• Turner, Anthony G and Golub, S (1997). Multilateral Unit Labor Cost Based Indicators of Competitivees for Industrial, Developing and Transition Economies.IMF Staff Studies for the World Economic Outlook. [19]
• “Rüzgar Energisi Maliyetleri ve Teşvikleri” Incentives for Wind Energy. VII Ulusal Temiz Enerji Sempozyumu, UTES 2008. Istanbul.
• Kenisarina, M., V. M. Karslı and M. Caglar, Wind power engineering in the world and perspectives of its development in Turkey, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 10, 341–369, 2006.
• Kotan, Z and S.Sayan, (2001) ``Comparison of the Price Competitiveness of Turkish and South East Asian Export in the European Union Market in the 1990s”. Research Department. Discussion Paper No: 2001 / 2. The Central Bank of The Republic of Turkey.
• Leelahaphan, T. J (2009).”Crude, Oil Price, House Price and UA Canada Imbalance. [23]
• competitiveness and international specialization, Eclac Review, Nº 45 (1991).
• International [24] Meyer, Y. The role of oscillation in some nonlinear problems, School on Mathematical Problems in Image Processing, ICTP, SMR 1237/4, pp. 4-22, 2000.
• Sabuncu,F.and M.Colakoglu(2012).”Turkey’s Renewable
• Perspective”www.pwc.com from a
• Global [26] Siddiqi, A., Aslan, Z. and Tokgozlu,A. Wavelet based computer simulation of some meteorological parameters: Case study in Turkey”, Trends in Industrial and Applied Mathematics. H. Siddiqi and M. Kocvara (Editors), pp. 95-105, Kluwer Academic Publishers, London, 2002.
• Sims, R. Hans, H. Rogner and Ken Gregory,(2003) “Carbon Emission and Mitigation Cost Comparison between fossil fuel, nuclear and renewable
• generation”. Energy Policy 31.pp: 1315-1326. for
• electricity [28] Rich, D. and L. Karp “Climate Change, Carbon Taxes and International Trade: An Analysis of the Emerging Conflict Between the Kyoto Protocol and the WTO. 2004.
• Ricardo,D.(1814:1932).“Political Economy On Foreign Trade”, Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. Edited with introductory essay, notes and appendices, by Sir E.C.K.Gonner, G.Bell and Sons Ltd.London.pp:108-130.
• Sovacool, B. (2007) Coal and Nuclear Technologies: Creating a False Dichotomy for American Energy Policy. Policy Sciences, Vol. 40, No. 2, pp. 101-122.
• Siggel.E. (2007). International Competitivenes and Comparatıve Advantage: A Survey and Proposal for Measurement. CESIFO Venice Summer Institute. 2007.
• Tolun S., Mentes S., Aslan Z., Yukselen M. The Wind Energy Potential of Gokceada in the Northern Aegena Sea, 1995, Renewable Energy, Vol. 6, No. 7, pp. 679-685, 1995.
• Turksoy F. Investigation of wind power potential at Bozcaada, Turkey”, Renewable Energy, 6(8), p. 917–23, 1995.
• TEIAŞ.(2011) Türkiye Elektrik Üretimi – İletim İstatistikleri, Statistic for Turkey’s Electricity Distribution
• Under Secretariat of Treasury, Republic of Turkey(2010).Dis Sorunlar.Main
• http://www.treasury.gov.tr/irj/portal/anonymous For
• Export. [36] TEIAS.(2005) Türkiye Elektrik Enerjisi 10 Yıllık Üretim Kapasite Projeksiyonu. [37]
• Environmental and Social Statistics.ISBN 92-64- 08356-2 2010:
• Economic, [38] World Economic Forum (WEF), (2011): Green Investing 2011: A Preview
• TWEA, (2011): Turkish Wind Energy Association, April 30, 2011.