Hybrid solar–ground source heat pump systems for net-zero energy buildings: A review of thermal management, energy storage, and optimization approaches

Öz

Hybrid solar–ground source heat pump (GSHP) systems are promising solutions for Net-Zero Energy Buildings (NZEBs), combining abundant solar energy with the thermal stability of the ground. This study presents a structured literature review and comparative analysis of 57 peer-reviewed studies on hybrid solar–ground source heat pump systems and their integration with thermal energy storage and advanced control strategies. Although solar and GSHP technologies are individually mature, their integrated operation with thermal energy storage (TES), advanced controls, and system optimization remains underexplored. This review synthesizes recent developments in hybrid solar–GSHP configurations, including solar thermal coupling, photovoltaic (PV)-assisted GSHPs, and photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T)-supported heat pump systems. Comparative analysis of case studies from Europe, Asia, Africa, the Middle East, North America, and Oceania shows consistent primary energy savings of 50–75%, significant carbon emission reductions, and improved operational resilience. However, large-scale deployment remains constrained by high upfront costs, region-specific technical constraints, and fragmented policy frameworks. Key research gaps are identified in system modeling, long-term performance assessment, and integration with smart grids and AI-based control strategies. The findings emphasize the need for regionally adaptive policies, cost-reduction pathways, and stronger experimental validation in underrepresented regions such as Africa and Latin America. The convergence of intelligent optimization, flexible TES solutions, and supportive regulatory mechanisms is expected to accelerate the role of hybrid solar–GSHP systems in climate-neutral and energy-resilient buildings.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Hybrid solar–ground source heat pump (GSHP) systems
• Net-Zero Energy Buildings (NZEB)
• Thermal energy storage (TES)
• Borehole thermal energy storage (BTES)
• Ground heat exchangers (GHE)

Kaynakça

1. [1] Net I.E. Zero by 2050: a roadmap for the global energy sector. Int Energy Agency 2021; 224.
2. [2] Jaysawal R.K., Chakraborty S., Elangovan D., Padmanaban S. Concept of net zero energy buildings (NZEB)-a literature review. Cleaner Engineering And Technology 2022; 11:100582.
3. [3] Taherahmadi J., Noorollahi Y., Panahi M. Toward comprehensive zero energy building definitions: a literature review and recommendations. International Journal Of Sustainable Energy 2021; 40(2):120-148.
4. [4] You T., Wu W., Yang H., Liu J., Li X. Hybrid photovoltaic/thermal and ground source heat pump: review and perspective. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews 2021; 151:111569.
5. [5] Cao Y., Zhang Z., Jia G., Zhai J., Hao J., Zhang M., Jin L. Performance prediction and analysis of solar-assisted ground-source heat pump systems in typical rural areas, China. Energies 2025; 18(9):2208.
6. [6] Weeratunge H., Aditya G.R., Dunstall S., de Hoog J., Narsilio G., Halgamuge S. Feasibility and performance analysis of hybrid ground source heat pump systems in fourteen cities. Energy 2021; 234:121254.
7. [7] Lee M., Ham S.H., Lee S., Kim J., Kim Y. Multi-objective optimization of solar-assisted ground-source heat pumps for minimizing life-cycle cost and climate performance in heating-dominated regions. Energy 2023; 270:126868.
8. [8] Allouhi A. Techno-economic and environmental accounting analyses of an innovative power-to-heat concept based on solar PV systems and a geothermal heat pump. Renewable Energy 2022; 191:649-661.

9. [9] Sakellariou E.I., Axaopoulos P.J. Energy performance indexes for solar-assisted ground source heat pump systems with photovoltaic-thermal collectors. Applied Energy 2020; 272:115241.
10. [10] Chen H., Li X., Gao J., Cao J., Dong H., Wang W., Chen Y. Comparative study on a solar-assisted ground source heat pump with CPC solar collector and phase change heat storage. Renewable Energy 2025; 239:122065.
11. [11] Rynkowski P. The solar-assisted vertical ground source heat pump system in cold climates—a case study. Proceedings 2020; 51(1):24.
12. [12] Zhou J., Cui Z., Xu F., Zhang G. Performance analysis of solar-assisted ground-coupled heat pump systems with seasonal thermal energy storage to supply domestic hot water for campus buildings in southern China. Sustainability 2021; 13(15):8344.
13. [13] Biglarian H., Abdollahi S. Utilization of on-grid photovoltaic panels to offset the electricity consumption of a residential ground source heat pump. Energy 2022; 243:122770.
14. [14] Bae S., Nam Y. Feasibility analysis for an integrated system using photovoltaic-thermal and ground source heat pump based on real-scale experiment. Renewable Energy 2022; 185:1152-1166.
15. [15] Hesaraki A., Madani Larijani H. Energy performance of ground-source heat pump and photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) in retrofitted and new buildings: two case studies using simulation and on-site measurements. BuildSim Nordic Conference 2020; 2020.
16. [16] Li D., Wang Z., Wu Y., Yu N., Zhao X., Meng L., Arıcı M. Combined solar and ground source heat pump heating system with a latent heat storage tank as a sustainable system to replace an oilfield hot water station. Energy 2024; 307:132726.
17. [17] Naili N., Kooli S. Solar-assisted ground source heat pump system operated in heating mode: a case study in Tunisia. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews 2021; 145:111144.
18. [18] Sun T., Yang L., Jin L., Luo Z., Zhang Y., Liu Y., Wang Z. A novel solar-assisted ground-source heat pump (SAGSHP) with seasonal heat-storage and heat cascade utilization: field test and performance analysis. Solar Energy 2020; 201:362-372.
19. [19] Sun T., Li Z., Gou Y., Guo G., An Y., Fu Y., Li Q., Zhong X. Modeling and simulation analysis of photovoltaic photothermal modules in solar heat pump systems. Energies 2024; 17(5):1042.
20. [20] Cui Y., Zhu J., Zoras S., Qiao Y., Zhang X. Energy performance and life cycle cost assessments of a photovoltaic/thermal assisted heat pump system. Energy 2020; 206:118108.
21. [21] Tong W., Yu Q., Jia C. Design and simulation of a ground-source heat pump system coupled with solar heating. International Journal Of Low-Carbon Technologies 2025; 20:1184-1193.
22. [22] Mahon H., O'Connor D., Friedrich D., Hughes B. A review of thermal energy storage technologies for seasonal loops. Energy 2022; 239:122207.
23. [23] Adebayo P., Jathunge C.B., Darbandi A., Fry N., Shor R., Mohamad A., Wemhöner C., Mwesigye A. Development, modeling, and optimization of ground source heat pump systems for cold climates: a comprehensive review. Energy And Buildings 2024; 320:114646.
24. [24] Xue T., Jokisalo J., Kosonen R. Cost-effective control of hybrid ground source heat pump (GSHP) system coupled with district heating. Buildings 2024; 14(6):1724.
25. [25] Jeong Y.D., Yu M.G., Nam Y. Feasibility study of a heating, cooling, and domestic hot water system combining a photovoltaic-thermal system and a ground source heat pump. Energies 2017; 10(8):1243.
26. [26] Fahrioğlu M. Sustainable greenhouse heating in Al-Zarqa: a geothermal & hybrid system analysis. Master's Thesis, Middle East Technical University 2024.
27. [27] Saleem A., Ambreen T., Ugalde-Loo C.E. Energy storage-integrated ground-source heat pumps for heating and cooling applications: a systematic review. Journal Of Energy Storage 2024; 102:114097.
28. [28] Airò Farulla G., Cellura M., Guarino F., Ferraro M. A review of thermochemical energy storage systems for power grid support. Applied Sciences 2020; 10(9):3142.
29. [29] Ahmed S.F., Rafa N., Mehnaz T., Ahmed B., Islam N., Mofijur M., Hoang A.T., Shafiullah G.M. Integration of phase change materials in improving the performance of heating, cooling, and clean energy storage systems: an overview. Journal Of Cleaner Production 2022; 364:132639.
30. [30] Abdullah., Koushaeian M., Shah N.A., Chung J.D. A review of thermochemical seasonal solar energy storage materials and modeling methods. International Journal Of Air-Conditioning And Refrigeration 2024; 32(1):1.
31. [31] Ren C., Lin J., Guo N. Performance and optimization of novel solar-assisted heat pump system with hybrid thermal energy storage. Energies 2024; 17:5944.
32. [32] Yang W., Zhang Y., Wang F., Liu A. Experimental and numerical investigations on operation characteristics of seasonal borehole underground thermal energy storage. Renewable Energy 2023; 217:119365.
33. [33] Tinti F., Tassinari P., Rapti D., Benni S. Development of a pilot borehole storage system of solar thermal energy: modeling, design, and installation. Sustainability 2023; 15(9):7432.
34. [34] Fleuchaus P., Godschalk B., Stober I., Blum P. Worldwide application of aquifer thermal energy storage—a review. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews 2018; 94:861-876.
35. [35] Shehram M., Hamidi M.N., Abdul Wahab A.A., Mat Desa M.K. Comprehensive review of hybrid solar cooling systems for buildings: integrating PV and thermal energy storage in phase change materials. Journal Of Thermal Analysis And Calorimetry 2025; 1-34.
36. [36] Wei Z., Calautit J. Evaluation of model predictive control (MPC) of solar thermal heating system with thermal energy storage for buildings with highly variable occupancy levels. Building Simulation 2023; 16(10):1915-1931.
37. [37] Killian M., Kozek M. Ten questions concerning model predictive control for energy efficient buildings. Building And Environment 2016; 105:403-412.
38. [38] Kim Y.J., Yang L., Entchev E., Cho S., Kang E.C., Lee E.J. Hybrid solar geothermal heat pump system model demonstration study. Frontiers In Energy Research 2022; 9:778501.
39. [39] Muslim S.A. EnergyPlus: towards the selection of the right simulation tool for building energy and power systems research. Journal Of Energy And Power Technology 2021; 3(3):1-9.
40. [40] Möller M.C., Krauter S. Hybrid energy system model in Matlab/Simulink based on solar energy, lithium-ion battery, and hydrogen. Energies 2022; 15(6):2201.
41. [41] Mansoor M., Stadler M., Zellinger M., Lichtenegger K., Auer H., Cosic A. Optimal planning of thermal energy systems in a microgrid with seasonal storage and piecewise affine cost functions. Energy 2021; 215:119095.
42. [42] Lindholm O., Weiss R., Hasan A., Pettersson F., Shemeikka J. A MILP optimization method for building seasonal energy storage: a case study for a reversible solid oxide cell and hydrogen storage system. Buildings 2020; 10(7):123.
43. [43] Wei S., Wang H., Tian Y., Man X., Wang Y., Zhou S. Energy efficiency optimization analysis of a ground source heat pump system based on neural networks and genetic algorithms. Geothermal Energy 2024; 12(1):43.
44. [44] Jamali B., Rasekh M., Jamadi F., Gandomkar R., Makiabadi F. Using PSO-GA algorithm for training an artificial neural network to forecast solar space heating system parameters. Applied Thermal Engineering 2019; 147:647-660.
45. [45] Zhiguo W., Haoyu C., Xiao S., Haibing L., Tianyi W. Optimizing the solar air hybrid source heat pump heating system based on the particle swarm algorithm. Energy Reports 2022; 8(S7):379-393.
46. [46] Abualigah L., Zitar R.A., Almotairi K.H., Hussein A.M., Abd Elaziz M., Nikoo M.R., Gandomi A.H. Wind, solar, and photovoltaic renewable energy systems with and without energy storage optimization: a survey of advanced machine learning and deep learning techniques. Energies 2022; 15(2):578.
47. [47] Ekanayaka Gunasinghalge L.U.G., Alazab A., Talukder M. Artificial intelligence for energy optimization in smart buildings: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Energy Informatics 2025; 8:135.
48. [48] Razak T.R., Ismail M.H., Darus M.Y., Jarimi H., Su Y. Artificial intelligence in renewable energy: a systematic review of trends in solar, wind, and smart grid applications. Research And Reviews In Sustainability 2025; 1(1).
49. [49] Neshat M., Thilakaratne M., El-Abd M., Mirjalili S., Gandomi A.H., Boland J. Smart buildings energy consumption forecasting using adaptive evolutionary ensemble learning models. arXiv Preprint 2025; arXiv:2506.11864.
50. [50] Andalibi A., Safarzadeh M., Sobhani S.M.J., Pasdarshahri H. Optimization of a hybrid photovoltaic/thermal-ground source heat pump system using artificial neural networks and multi-objective genetic algorithms. Journal Of Building Engineering 2025; 103:112103.
51. [51] Du Q., Pan L., Zhao Z., Wang Y., Bai J., Zhang W. Performance analysis of solar-assisted ground source heat pump in severe cold regions. Energy Sources, Part A: Recovery, Utilization, And Environmental Effects 2024; 46(1):14055-14076.
52. [52] Fouad H., Mahmoud A.H., Moussa R.R. The effectiveness of geothermal systems in cooling residential buildings: a case study of a residential building in Alexandria, Egypt. Journal Of Engineering And Applied Science 2024; 71(1):45.
53. [53] Hu L., Tischler N., Rizvi Z.H., Nordbeck J., Wuttke F. Thermal, electrical, and economic performance of a hybrid solar-wind-geothermal system: case study of a detached house in Hamburg and Sylt, Germany. Energies 2024; 17(12):2856.
54. [54] Jesper M., Pag F., Vajen K., Jordan U. Hybrid solar thermal and heat pump systems in industry: model-based development of globally applicable design guidelines. Solar Energy Advances 2023; 3:100034.
55. [55] Mesquita L., McClenahan D., Thornton J., Carriere J., Wong B. Drake landing solar community: 10 years of operation. SEES Solar World Congress 2017; 2017.
56. [56] Duarte W.M., Paulino T.F., Tavares S.G., Maia A.A., Machado L. Feasibility of solar-geothermal hybrid source heat pump for producing domestic hot water in hot climates. International Journal Of Refrigeration 2021; 124:184-196.
57. [57] Calise F., Cappiello F.L., Dentice d’Accadia M., Vicidomini M. Thermo-economic analysis of hybrid solar-geothermal polygeneration plants in different configurations. Energies 2020; 13(9):2391.
58. [58] Chen K., Soga K., Dobson P., Nico P. Application potential of a hybrid ground source heat pump array for the UC Berkeley campus business and law node energy system: a preliminary study. arXiv Preprint 2023; arXiv:2310.03260.
59. [59] Galindo-Luna Y.R., Gómez-Arias E., Romero R.J., Venegas-Reyes E., Montiel-González M., Unland-Weiss H.E., Pacheco-Hernández P., González-Fernández A., Díaz-Salgado J. Hybrid solar-geothermal energy absorption air-conditioning system operating with NaOH-H2O—Las tres vírgenes (Baja California Sur), “la reforma” case. Energies 2018; 11(5):1268.
60. [60] Eisapour A.H., Rad F.M., Fung A.S. Techno-economic and environmental study of a hybrid solar ground source heat pumps for a heating-dominated community in a cold climate: a case study in Toronto. Renewable Energy 2024; 231:120874.
61. [61] Andalibi A., Safarzadeh M., Sobhani S.M.J., Pasdarshahri H. Performance, economic, and environmental analysis of a novel hybrid photovoltaic/thermal and ground-source heat pump system for a multi-zone sports and administrative complex in a cold climate. Energy Conversion And Management 2024; 321:119030.
62. [62] Dou Z., Liu J., Li B. Study on the solar-assisted ground-source heat pump system with seasonal heat storage in cold regions. Integrated Intelligent Energy 2023; 45(4):52-58.
63. [63] Federal Ministry For Economic Affairs And Climate Action. Market incentive programme for renewable energies in the heat market (MAP). 2021. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://www.iea.org/policies/4115-market-incentive-programme
64. [64] Netherlands Enterprise Agency. Sustainable energy production and climate transition (SDE++). 2020. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://business.gov.nl/subsidies-and-schemes/sustainable-energy-production/
65. [65] U.S. Department Of Energy. Federal solar tax credits for businesses. 2022. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://www.energy.gov/eere/solar/federal-solar-tax-credits-for-businesses
66. [66] Natural Resources Canada. Canada greener homes initiative: program overview. 2022. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://natural-resources.canada.ca/energy-efficiency/home-energy-efficiency/canada-greener-homes-initiative/23441
67. [67] Innovation, Science And Economic Development Canada. Canada green buildings strategy. 2024. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://www.canada.ca/en/innovation-science-economic-development/news/2024/07/government-of-
68. [68] International Energy Agency. General code for building energy efficiency and renewable energy utilization (GB 55015–2021). 2021. [cited 2025 Jan 26]. Available from: https://www.iea.org/policies/19531-gb-55015-2021-general-code-for-building-energy-efficiency-and-renewable-energy-utilization
69. [69] Li H., Zhou J., Cao J., Zhao M., Chen J., Liu L., Cuce E., Liu W. Advances in photovoltaic/thermal assisted ground source heat pump: structural design, material selection, coupling integration, and control strategy optimization. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews 2026; 229:116669.