Religion, Diplomacy, and Fear: The 1858 Jeddah Incident and the Rise of Anti-Muslim Sentiment in Europe

Öz

The Jeddah Incident of 1858 offers a revealing case for understanding how local tensions in the Ottoman provinces were represented in the European press. A discursive repertoire shaped during events such as the Greek Revolt, French expansion in North Africa, and developments in India from the early nineteenth century onward resurfaced prominently in European narratives following the Jeddah Incident. The events that erupted in Jeddah on June 15th were portrayed by elements of the European press as a continuation of “Islamic fanaticism,” a framing that recast the incident within a civilisation–barbarism dichotomy while obscuring underlying economic rivalries and diplomatic frictions. The fact that extreme proposals, such as the temporary occupation of Mecca, were discussed in certain British political circles illustrates the extent to which religious sensitivities and imperial interests had become intertwined. Drawing on British diplomatic correspondence, consular reports, and European press coverage, this study examines how the Jeddah Incident intensified existing discourses and was interpreted across different ideological milieus. It demonstrates that the rhetorical patterns crystallised in 1858 were not confined to Jeddah but would go on to reappear in European public and political debates during subsequent crises, including those in Damascus and Mount Lebanon in 1860, as well as the later Cretan, Bulgarian, and Armenian crises. These narratives, which influenced the pressure policies of figures such as William Ewart Gladstone, render the Jeddah Incident a significant moment for understanding the continuity of anti-Islamic and, more specifically, anti-Ottoman thought in nineteenth-century Europe.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• 1858 Jeddah incident
• Ottoman Empire
• Indian rebellion
• Perception of Islam
• European press
• British diplomacy

Din, Diplomasi ve Korku: 1858 Cidde Olayı ve Avrupa’da Müslüman Karşıtı Duyguların Yükselişi

Öz

1858 Cidde olayı, Osmanlı taşrasındaki yerel gerilimlerin Avrupa basınında nasıl temsil edildiğini anlamak açısından dikkat çekici bir örnektir. XIX. yüzyılın ilk yarısından itibaren Yunan isyanı, Kuzey Afrika’daki Fransız yayılmacılığı ve Hindistan’daki gelişmeler sırasında oluşan söylemsel birikim, Cidde hadisesi sonrasında Avrupa basınında yeniden görünür hale gelmiştir. Cidde’de 15 Haziran’da patlak veren olaylar, Avrupa kamuoyunda “İslamî fanatizmin devamı” olarak sunulurken, bu söylem yerel ekonomik rekabet ve diplomatik gerilimlerin üstünü örterek olayı medeniyet-barbarlık karşıtlığı içinde yeniden kurgulamıştır. Bazı İngiliz siyasî çevrelerinde Mekke’nin geçici işgali gibi uç önerilerin tartışılması, dönemin dinî hassasiyetleriyle emperyal çıkarlarının nasıl iç içe geçtiğini göstermektedir. Bu çalışma, İngiliz diplomatik belgeleri, konsolosluk raporları ve Avrupa basınındaki yansımaları karşılaştırmalı olarak ele alarak, Cidde olayının mevcut söylemleri nasıl yoğunlaştırdığını ve farklı ideolojik çevrelerde nasıl yorumlandığını incelemektedir. Bu bağlamda çalışma, 1858 söyleminin yalnızca Cidde bağlamında kalmayıp, 1860 Şam ve Lübnan ile sonraki yıllarda Girit, Bulgar ve Ermeni krizlerinde Avrupa kamuoyunda ve siyasî söyleminde tekrarlandığını göstermektedir. Bu retorik, William Evart Gladstone gibi liderlerin Osmanlı’ya yönelik baskı politikalarında etkili olurken, Cidde olayını Avrupa’da genelde İslam ancak özelde Osmanlı karşıtı düşüncenin sürekliliğini anlamak açısından tarihsel bir dönüm noktası haline getirmiştir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• 1858 Cidde olayı
• Osmanlı Devleti
• Hindistan ayaklanması
• İslam algısı
• Avrupa basını
• İngiliz diplomasisi

Kaynakça

1. NA, FO 424/18, Inclosure 1 in No. 378, Commodore Edgell to the Secretary to the Admiralty, 12 January 1859.
2. NA, FO 424/18, Inclosure in No. 373.
3. NA, FO 424/18, No. 373, Consul Walne to the Earl of Malmesbury, 19 January 1859.
4. NA, FO 424/18, No. 382, Consul Walne to the Earl of Malmesbury, 31 January 1859.
5. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 1 in No. 120, Captain Pullen to the Secretary to the Admiralty, 19 June 1858.
6. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 1 in No. 193, Namick Pasha to the Grand Vizier, 27 Zilhicce 1274.
7. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 11, Precis of Captain Pullen’s Letter to the Secretary to the Admiralty, Jeddah 25 June 1858.
8. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 138, Vice-Consul Calvert to Acting Consul-General Green, 8 August 1858.

9. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 249, The Political Agent at Aden to Captain Pullen, 21 October 1858.
10. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 53, M. Emerat to Consul Walewski, 9 Juillet 1858.
11. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 87, Information obtained by Captain Curling from a Pilot who came off, and boarded at noon. 22 July 1858.
12. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 2 in No. 88, Captain Pullen to the Political Agent at Aden, 23 June 1858.
13. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 3 in No. 120, Captain Pullen to the Secretary to the Admiralty, 25 June 1858.
14. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 3 in No. 249, The Political Agent at Aden to Captain Pullen, 23 October 1858.
15. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 4 in No. 88, Captain Pullen to Namick Pasha, 21 June 1858.
16. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure 8 in No. 148, Namick Pasha to Captain Pullen, 24 July 1858.
17. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure in No. 17, Extract from the “Moniteur” of July 16, 1858.
18. NA, FO, 424/18, Inclosure in No. 99, Extract from the “Moniteur” of August 21, 1858.
19. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 1, Acting Consul-General Green to the Earl of Malmesbury, 6 July 1858.
20. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 101. Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 23 August 1858.
21. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 102, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 23 August 1858.
22. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 12, Acting Consul-General Green to the Earl of Malmesbury, 7 July 1858.
23. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 15, The Earl of Malmesbury to Sir H. Bulwer, 15 July 1858.
24. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 150, The Secretary to the Admiralty to Mr. Fitzgerald, 4 September 1858.
25. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 17, Earl Cowley to the Earl of Malmesbury, 16 July 1858.
26. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 230, The Earl of Malmesbury to Consul Walne, 8 November 1858.
27. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 249, Captain Pullen to the Earl of Malmesbury, 3 November 1858.
28. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 259, The Earl of Malmesbury to Earl Cowley, 23 November 1858.
29. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 269, The Earl of Malmesbury to Consul Walne, 25 November 1858.
30. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 330, Consul Walne to the Earl of Malmesbury, 22 December 1858.
31. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 334, Consul Walne to the Earl of Malmesbury, 24 December 1858.
32. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 370, Consul Walne to the Earl of Malmesbury, 14 January 1859.
33. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 46, The Earl of Malmesbury to Sir H. Bulwer, 23 July 1858.
34. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 51, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 24 July 1858.
35. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 54, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 27 July 1858.
36. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 56, The Earl of Malmesbury to Sir H. Bulwer, 27 July 1858.
37. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 62, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 27 July 1858.
38. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 78, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 27 July 1858.
39. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 90, Earl Cowley to the Earl of Malmesbury, 17 August 1858.
40. NA, FO, 424/18, No. 97, Sir H. Bulwer to the Earl of Malmesbury, 23 August 1858.
41. NA, FO, 424/18, No. Inclosure in No. 369, Commodore Edgell to Vice-Admiral Fanshaws, January 1859.
42. Bâb-ı Âsafî Âmedî Kalemi (A.AMD), nr. 84/69, 83/22, 90/5.
43. Hariciye Nezâreti Mektûbî Kalemi Evrakı (HR.MKT), nr. 234/91, 93/59, 410/11, 360/41, 360/50.
44. Hariciye Nezâreti Siyasi (HR.SYS), nr. 97/1.
45. Hariciye Nezâreti Tercüme Odası Evrakı (HR.TO), nr. 231/25, 231/10, 53/32, 53/31, 161/57, 53/47.
46. İrade Dahiliye (İ.DH), nr. 411/27228.
47. İrade Hariciye (İ.HR), nr. 160/8566.
48. İrade Meclis-i Mahsûs (İ.MMS), nr. 13/532, 13/564, 14/587, 15/614.
49. Meclis-i Vâlâ Evrakı (MVL), nr. 293/1.
50. Sadâret Mektubi Kalemi Nezâret ve Devâ’ir Evrakı (A.MKT.NZD), nr. 68/90, 249/15.
51. Sadâret Mektûbî Kalemi Umum Vilâyât Evrakı (A.MKT.UM), nr. 322/43, 322/42.
52. Sadâret Mektûbî Mühimme Kalemi Evrakı (A.MKT.MHM), nr. 145/54, 148/34, 140/78.
53. UK Parliament House of Commons Hansard/ House of Lords Hansard
54. HC Deb 12 July 1858 vol 151 cc1285-6.
55. HL Deb 19 July 1858 vol 151 cc1655-9
56. HC Deb 22 July 1858 vol 151 cc1931-3.
57. Madras Record Office, Correspondence on Moplah Outrages in Malabar for the years 1853-1859, II, Madras: United Scottish, Graves, Cookson, 1863.
58. The British Colonist, 29.07. 1858.
59. The Economist, 12.09.1857.
60. The Evangelist, 2.02.09.1858.
61. Journal Du Tarn, 17.07.1858.
62. The Leader, 17.07.1858.
63. The Living Age, 18.09.1858.
64. Memorial de la Loire, 16 Juillet 1858.
65. Le Moniteur Universel, 14.07.1858, 25.07.1858.
66. Le Mousquetaire, 29.12.1854.
67. The Nonconformist, 21.07.1858.
68. The Presbyterian, 31.07.1858.
69. The Spectator, 17.07.1858, 21.08.1858, 11.09.1858.
70. Aydın, Cemil, İslam Dünyası Fikri: Küresel Bir Entelektüel Tarih Çalışması, trc. Hasan Aksakal, İstanbul: Alfa Yay., 2021.
71. Baldwin, George, Political Recollections Relative to Egypt, London: W. Bulmer & Co., 1802.
72. Bang, Anne K., Sufis and Scholars of the Sea: Family networks in East Africa, 1860-1925, London: Routledge, 2003.
73. Bayly, Christopher Alan, La Naissance du monde moderne (1780-1914), trc. Michel Cordillot, Paris: Les Éditions de l’Atelier, 2007.
74. Bender, Jill C., The 1857 Indian Uprising and the British Empire, Cambridge: Camridge University Press, 2016.
75. Bertrand, Romain, L’Histoire à parts égales: récits d’une rencontre Orient-Occident, XVIe-XVIIe siècle, Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 2011.
76. Bolsover, G. H., “Nicholas I and the Partition of Turkey”, The Slavonic and East European Review, 27/68 (1948): 115-145.
77. Burton, Isabel, Arabia, Egypt, India: A Narrative of Travel, London and Belfast: William Mullan and Son, 1879.
78. Buzpınar, Tufan, Hilafet ve Saltanat, II. Abdülhamid Döneminde Halifelik ve Araplar, İstanbul: Alfa Yay., 2016.
79. Chekkutty, Naripatta Puthenveettil, Muhmmed Abdur Rahman, New Delhi: National Book Trust, 2005.
80. Cole, Juan R. I., “Of Crowds and Empires: Afro-Asian Riots and European Expansion, 1857–1882”, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 31/1, (1989): 106-133.
81. Cunningham, Allan, Anglo-Ottoman Encounters in the Age of Revolution, Collected Essays, I-II, ed. Edward Ingram, London and New York: Routledge, 2013.
82. Çınar, Tuba, Emperyal Çatışma Alanı Olarak Süveyş Kanalı ve Büyük Güçler 1869-1882, İstanbul: Çizgi Kitabevi Yay., 2024.
83. Dale, Stephen F., “The Mappilla Outbreaks: Ideology and Social Conflict in Nineteenth-Century Kerala”, The Journal of Asian Studies, 35/1 (1975): 85-97
84. David, Saul, The Indian Mutiny 1857, London: Penguin Books, 2003.
85. Davis, Alexander E., “The Indian Uprising of 1857”, The Oxford Handbook of History and International Relations, ed. Mlada Bukovansjy v.dğr., Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2023, s. 617-630.
86. Fargher, James Andrew, “Steam, Cannon, and Wires: The Royal Navy and British Imperialism in Northeastern Africa, 1799-1899” (doktora tezi), King’s College University of London, 2018.
87. Ferris, John, “‘The Internationalism of Islam’: The British Perception of a Muslim Menace: 1840–1951”, Intelligence and National Security 24/1 (2009): 57-77.
88. Freitag, Ulrike, “Helpless Representatives of the Great Powers? Western Consuls in Jeddah: 1830s to 1914”, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, 40 (2012): 357-381.
89. Freitag, Ulrike, “Symbolic Politics and Urban Violence in Late Ottoman Jeddah”, Urban Violence in the Middle East: Changing Cityscapes in the Transition from Empire to Nation State, ed. Ulrike Freitag v.dğr., New York, Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2015, s. 111-138.
90. Freitag, Ulrike, A History of Jeddah: The Gate to Mecca in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020.
91. Hamilton, Charles Iain, The Making of the Modern Admiralty, British Naval Policy-Making: 1805-1927, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
92. Hamilton, James, Sinai, The Hedjaz, and Soudan: Wanderings around the Birth-Place of the Prophet and across the Aethiopian Desert, from Sawakin to Chartum, London: 1857.
93. Hoskins, Halford Lancaster, British Routes to India, New York, London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1928.
94. Kurşun, Zekeriya, “Osmanlı Devleti İdaresinde Hicaz (1517-1919)”, Osmanlı, Ankara: Yeni Türkiye Yayınları, 1999, I, 316-325.
95. Long, David E., The Hajj Today: A Survey of the Contemporary Pilgrimage to Makkah, Albany: State University of New York Press, 1979.
96. Low, Michael Christopher, “Empire and the Hajj: Pilgrims, Plagues, and Pan-Islam under British Surveillance: 1865-1908”, International Journal of Middle East Studies, 40/2, (2008): 269-290.
97. Ma‘oz, Moshe, Ottoman Reform in Syria and Palestine 1840-1861: The Impact of the Tanzimat on Politics and Society, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1968.
98. Macintyre, James J., A Plan for the Military Seizure and Occupation of the Temple and City of Mecca: As a Defensive and Offensive Measure for the War in Asia, London: 1858.
99. Marston, Thomas E., Britain’s Imperial Role in the Red Sea Area 1800-1878, The Shoe String Press, 1961.
100. Masters, Bruce, Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Arab World, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001.
101. Ochsenwald, William, “The Jidda Massacre of 1858”, Middle Eastern Studies, 13/3 (1977): 314-326.
102. Palmer, Alan, Kırım Savaşı ve Modern Avrupa’nın Doğuşu, trc. Meral Gaspıralı, İstanbul: Alfa Yay., 2012.
103. Panikkar, Kallidaikurichi Narayana, Against Lord and State: Religion and Peasant Uprisings in Malabar 1836-1921, Oxford University Press, 1989.
104. Pearson, Michael N., Pilgrimage to Mecca: The Indian Experience, 1500–1800, Princeton: Markus Weiner, 1996.
105. Pétriat, Philippe, “D’une histoire locale à une histoire mondiale du massacre de Djedda (1858)”, Hypothèses, (2014): 115-128.
106. Pétriat, Philippe, Le négoce des Lieux Saints: négociants hadramis de Djedda, 1850–1950, Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne, 2016.
107. Prousis, Theophilus C., British Consular Reports from the Ottoman Levant in an Age of Upheaval, 1815–1830, Istanbul: The Isis Press, 2010.
108. Raymond, André, British Policy towards Tunis (1830-1881), Oxford: University of Oxford, 1953.
109. Reese, Scott S., Imperial Muslims: Islam, Community and Authority in the Indian Ocean, 1839–1937, Edinburgh University Press, 2018.
110. Smith, Nicholas W. Stephenson, Colonial Chaos in the Southern Red Sea, A history of Violence from 1830 to the Twentieth Centruy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021.
111. Wong, J. Y., Deadly Dreams: Opium, Imperialism, and the Arrow War (1856-60) in China, New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
112. Wood, Conrad, The Moplah Rebellion and Its Genesis, People’s Publishing House, 1987.