Transformation From Soft Law to Hard Law of International Environmental Protection: Process, Basic Concepts and Principles – Part 1: “Common Heritage of Mankind”, “Present and Future Generations”, “Inter/Intra-generational Equity” and “Sustainable Development

Öz

In this study transformation from soft law to hard law of international environmental protection is analysed within the historical perspective with a special emphasis on process, basic concepts and principles. In Part I of this study, firstly soft- hard law dichotomy and enforcement is examined and attention has been drawn to the 1972 Stockholm and the 1992 Rio Declarations. It follows the examination of “common heritage of mankind”, “present and future generations”, “inter/ intra-generational equity”, and “sustainable development” as the basic notions and principles which have roots in soft law and subsequently become an integral part of international environmental protection of hard law instruments. In Part 2 of the study which will be published in the subsequent issue, “no transboundary environmental harm”, “precautionary”, “environmental impact assessment” principles as well as “access to information and participation to decision-making processes” criteria have been analysed. As a whole in this study in addition to relevant international literature and soft/ hard law documents some of the significant jurisprudence in its historical process have been referred to.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Common Heritage of Mankind
• Environmental Law
• Sustainable Development
• Present and Future Generations
• Inter/ Intragenerational Equity
• 1972 Stockholm Declaration
• 1992 Rio Declaration

Kaynakça

1. ‘Introduction to Part Three: The Emerging Ocean Regime’ in E. Borgese (ed.), PACEM IN MARIBU (1972).
2. ‘Selected International Legal Materials on Global Warming and Climate Change’ (1990) 5 Am. U. J. Int’l L. & Pol. 513-634.
3. ‘Thaw in International Law? Rights in Antarctica under the Law of Common Spaces’ (1978) 87/4 Yale L. J. 804-859.
4. Adede A. O., ‘The System for Exploitation of the ‘Common Heritage of Mankind’ at the Caracas Conference’ (1975) 69/1 AJIL 31-49.
5. Agarwala P. N., ‘The New International Economic Order: An Overview’ (Pergamon 2015)
6. Alam Shawkat, ‘The United Nations’ Approach to Trade, the Environment and Sustainable Development’ (2006) 12/3 ILSA J. Int’l & Comp. L.
7. Alexander Jr. Frank C., ‘Legal Aspects: Exploitation of Antarctic Resources: A Recommended Approach to the Antarctic Resource Problem’ (1978) 33/2 U. Miami L. Rev.
8. Alston Philip, ‘Conjuring up New Human Rights: A Proposal for Quality Control’ (1984) 78/3 AJIL 607-621.

9. Alston Philip, ‘Making Space for New Human Rights: The Case of the Right to Development’, (1988) 1 Harv. Hum. Rts. Y.B. 3-40.
10. Alston Philip, Robinson Mary (eds.), Human Rights and Development: Towards Mutual Reinforcement, (Oxford University Press, 2005)
11. Anand Ram Prakash, ‘Interests of the Developing Countries and the Developing Law of the Sea’ (1973) 4 Annals of Int’l Studies 13, 22, quoted in, Feder (n. 84) 826
12. Andreassen Bard A., Marks Stephen P. (eds.), Development as a Human Right: Legal, Political and Economic Dimensions, (Second edition, Intersentia, 2010).
13. Arnold Rudolph Preston, ‘The Common Heritage of Mankind as a Legal Concept’ (1975) 9/1 The International Lawyer 153
14. Asimakopoulou Eleftheria, Mohammad Essam Yassin, ‘Marine genetic resources in areas beyond national jurisdiction: a ‘common heritage of mankind’ (February 2019) IIED (International Institute for Environment and Development) Briefing http://pubs.iied.org/17498IIED
15. Balch Thomas W., ‘Arctic and Antarctic Regions and the Law of Nations’ (1910) 4/2 AJIL
16. Barrington Eileen, ‘European Environmental Law: Before and After Maastricht’, (1993) 2 U. Miami YBIL 79-89.
17. Baslar Kemal, The Concept of the Common Heritage of Mankind in International Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Published by Kluver Law International, 1998)
18. Batt John, Short David C., ‘The Jurisprudence of the 1992 Rio Declaration on Environment and Development: A Law, Science and Policy Explication of Certain Aspects of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development’, (1993) 8/2 J. Nat. Resources & Envtl. L.
19. Belsky Martin H., ‘Management of Large Marine Ecosystems: Developing a New Rule of Customary International Law’ (1985) 22/4 San Diego L. Rev. 733-763.
20. Berger-Eforo Judith, ‘Sanctuary for the Whales: Will This Be the Demise of the International Whaling Commission or a Viable Strategy for the Twenty-First Century?’ (1996) 8/2 Pace Int’l L. Rev. 439-483.
21. Bernhardt J. Peter A., ‘Sovereignty in Antarctica’, (1975) 5/2 Cal. W. Int’l L. J. 297-349
22. Bilder Richard B., ‘The Role of Unilateral State Action in Prevention International Environmental Injury’ (1981) 14/1 Vand. J. Transnat’l L. 51-95.
23. Birnie Patricia W., International Regulation of Whaling: From Conservation of Whaling to Conservation of Whales and Regulation of Whale-Watching (Vols.1 and 2, Oceana Publications Inc., New York, 1985).
24. Birnie Patricia, ‘Environmental Protection and Development’, (1995) 20/1 Melb. U. L. Rev.
25. Birnie Patricia, ‘Small Cetaceans and the International Whaling Commission’ (1997) 10/1 Geo. Int’l Envtl. L. Rev. 1.
26. Birnie Patricia, Alan Boyle and Catherine Redgwell, International Law and the Environment, (Third Edition, Oxford University Press 2009).
27. Blay S. K. N., ‘New Trends in the Protection of the Antarctic Environment: The 1991 Madrid Protocol’ (1992) 86/2 AJIL 377-399.
28. Bleicher Samuel A., ‘An Overview of International Environmental Regulation’ (1972) 2/1 Ecology L. Q. 1, 66
29. Bodansky Daniel, ‘The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change: A Commentary’ (1993) 18/2 Yale J. Int’l L. 451-558.
30. Bodansky Daniel, ‘Deconstructing the Precautionary Principle’, in D. D. Caron and H. N. scheiber (eds.) Bringing New Law to Ocean Waters, (Koninklijke Brill N. V., 2004).
31. Bostian Ida L., ‘Flushing the Danube: The World Court’s Decision Concerning the Gabcikovo Dam’, (1998) 9/2 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y 401-427
32. Boyle A. E., ‘Some Reflections on the Relationship of Treaties and Soft Law’, (1999) 48/4 ICLQ 901; Lluis Paradell-Trius, ‘Principles of International Environmental Law: an Overview’ (2000) 9/2 RECIEL.
33. Boyle Alan E., ‘Saving the World? Implementation and Enforcement of International Environmental Law Through International Institutions’ (1991) 3/2 J. Envtl. 229-245.
34. Brilmayer Lea, Klein Natalie, ‘Land and Sea: Two Sovereignty Regimes in Search of a Common Denominator’, (2001) 33/3 N.Y.U. J. Int’l. L. & Pol.
35. Brundtland Report, Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future (1987).
36. Bunge Thomas, ‘European Environmental Law: Community Legislation and Member States’ Competences under the EEC Treaty’, (1990) 59/4 Rev. Jur. U.P.R. 669-692
37. Cameron J., Abouchar J., ‘The Precautionary Principle: A Fundamental Principle of Law and Policy for the Protection of the Global Environment’ (1991) 14/1 B. C. Int’l & Comp. L. Rev. 1, 1-27.
38. Carducci Guido, ‘Articles 4 - 7: National and International Protection of the Cultural and Natural Heritage’, in Francesco Francioni (ed.) The 1972 World Heritage Convention: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2008).
39. Cheng Bin, ‘Article VI of the 1967 Space Treaty Revisited: ‘International Responsibility’, ‘National Activities’ and ‘The Appropriate State’ (1998) 26/1 J. Space L. 7-32.
40. Cherian Jijo George, Abraham Job, ‘Concept of Private Property in Space: An Analysis’ (2007) 2/4 J. Int’l. Com. L. & Tech. 211.
41. Chinkin C. M., ‘The Challenge of Soft Law: Development and Change in International Law’ (1989) 38/4 ICLQ
42. Chowdhury S., ‘Common but Differentiated Responsibility in International Environmental Law: from Stockholm (1972) to Rio (1992)’ in Denters E. M., Ginther K. and de Waart (Eds.) Sustainable Development and Good Governance (Brill 1995).
43. Christol Carl Q., ‘The Moon Treaty Enters into Force’, (1985) 79/1 AJIL 163-168. Christol Carl Q., The Modern International Law of Outer Space (Pergamon Press, 1982).
44. Churchill Robin, ‘International Environmental Law and the United Kingdom’, (1991) 18/1 J. L. & Soc’y.
45. Cocca Aldo Armando, ‘The Advances in International Law through the Law of Outer Space’ (1981) 9/1-2 J. Space L. 13.
46. Coffey Sarah, ‘Establishing a Legal Framework for Property Rights to Natural Resources in Outer Space’, (2009) 41/1 Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law (Case W. Res. J. Int’l. L.) 119-147..
47. Colombos John, The International Law of the Sea (Longmans 1967).
48. Conforti Benedetto, ‘Territorial Claims in Antarctica: A Modern Way to Deal with an Old Problem’ (1986) 19/2 Cornell Int’l L. J. 249
49. D’Amato Anthony, ‘Do We Owe a Duty to Future Generations to Preserve the Global Environment?’(1990) 84/1 AJIL 190-198.
50. D’Amato Anthony, K. Chopra Sudhir, ‘Whales: Their Emerging Right to Life’, (1991) 85/1 AJIL 21-62.
51. Davis Kimberly, ‘International Management of Cetaceans Under the New Law of the Sea Convention’ (1985) 3/2 B. U. Int’l L. J. 477.
52. Doubleday Nancy C., ‘Aboriginal Subsistence Whaling: The Right of Inuit to Hunt Whales and Implications for International Environmental Law’ (1989) 17/2 Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y 373- 394.
53. Drankier Petra, Elfring Alex G. Oude, Visser Bert and Takacs Tamara, ‘Marine Genetic Resources in Areas beyond National Jurisdiction: Access and Benefit-Sharing’ (2012) 27/2 Int. J. Mar. Coast. L. 375-433.
54. Dupuy Pierre-Marie, ‘Soft Law and the International Law of the Environment’ (1991) 12/2 Mich. J. Int’l L.
55. Dupuy René-Jean, The Law of the Sea: Current Problems (Dobbs Ferry, Oceana Publications Inc.- Leiden, A. W. Sijthoff, 74)
56. Dyke Jon Van, Yuen Christopher, ‘Common Heritage v. Freedom of the Seas: Which Governs the Seabed?’ (1982) 19/3 San Diego L. Rev 493
57. F. Strong Maurice, ‘Beyond Rio: Prospects and Portents’ (1993) 4/1 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y 21
58. Falk Richard A., ‘The Global Environment and International Law: Challenge and Response’, (1975) 23/3 Kan L. Rev. 385
59. Fasan Ernst, ‘The Meaning of the Term ‘Mankind’ in Space Legal Language’ (1974) 2/2 J. Space L. Feder Barnaby J., ‘A Legal Regime for the Arctic’ (1978) 6/3 Ecology L. Q. 785, 800
60. Fountain Lynn M., ‘Creating Momentum in Space: Ending the Paralysis Produced by the ‘Common Heritage of Mankind’ Concept’ (2003) 35 Conn. L. Rev. 1753.
61. Frakes Jennifer, ‘The Common Heritage of Mankind Principle and the Deep Seabed, Outer Space, and Antarctica: Will Developed and Developing Nations Reach a Compromise?’ (2003) 21/2 Wisconsin Int’l L. J. 409
62. Francioni Francesco (ed.) The 1972 World Heritage Convention: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2008).
63. Francioni Francesco, ‘International ‘Soft Law’: A Contemporary Assessment’ in Vaughan Lowe and Malgosia Fitzmaurice (eds.) Fifty Years of the International Court of Justice - Essays in Honour of Sir Robert Jennings (Grotius Publications, Cambridge University Press 1996)
64. Francioni Francesco, ‘Legal Aspects of Mineral Exploitation in Antarctica’ (1986) 19/2 Cornell Int’l L. J. 163
65. Francioni Francesco, ‘Legal Aspects of Mineral Exploitation in Antarctica’ (n. 202) 169 citing U.N. Doc. A/38/193 (1983)
66. Francioni Francesco, ‘The Madrid Protocol on the Protection of the Antarctic Environment’ (1993) 28/1 Tex. Int’l L. J. 47-72.
67. Francioni Francesco, ‘The Preamble’, in Francioni (ed.) The 1972 World Heritage Convention.
68. Frank R. F., ‘The Convention on the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources’, (1983) 13/3 Ocean Dev. & Int’l L. 291-346.
69. Freeland Steven, ‘For Better or for Worse? The Use of ‘Soft Law’ within the International Legal Regulation of Outer Space’ (2011) 36 Annals of Air and Space Law (Ann. Air & Space L.) 409-445.
70. Freeland Steven, ‘The Limits of Law: Challenges to the Global Governance of Space Activities’ (2020) 153/1 Journal & Proceedings of the Royal Society of New South Wales, (J. & Procee. R. S. New South Wales) 70-82.
71. Freestone David, ‘European Community Environmental Policy and Law’, (1991) 18/1 J. L. & Soc’y. 135-154.
72. Freestone David, ‘The Road from Rio: International Environmental Law After the Earth Summit’, (1994) 6/2 J. Envtl. L. 193.
73. French Duncan, ‘Developing States and International Environmental Law: The Importance of Differentiated Responsibilities’ (2000) 49/1 ICLQ 35-60.
74. Gabrynowicz Joanne Irene, ‘Space Law: Its Cold War Origins and Challenges in the Era of Globalization’ (2004) 37 Suffolk U. L. Rev. 1041.
75. Gemalmaz M. Semih, ‘Introduction to International Environmental Law: From Initial Steps to Institution Building for the Conservation of Environment-Part 1’, (2021) 33/2 ERPL/REDP (120)
76. Getches David H., ‘The Challenge of Rio’, (1993) 4/1 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y.
77. Gillespie Alexander, ‘Implementation and Compliance Concerns in International Environmental Law: The State of Art within Three International Regimes’, (2003) 7 N.Z. J. Envtl. L. 53.
78. Goedhuis D., ‘Some Recent Trends in the Interpretation and the Implementation of the Rules of International Space Law’ (1981) 19/2 Colum. J. Transnat’l L. 213.
79. Goh Gerardine Meishan, Dispute Settlement in International Space Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2007).
80. Goldie L.F.E., ‘A Note on Some Diverse Meanings of ‘the Common Heritage of Mankind’’ (1983) 10/1 Syracuse J. Int’l L. & Com. 69; Bradley Larschan and Bonnie C. Brennan, ‘The Common Heritage of Mankind Principle in International Law’ (1983) 21/2 Colum. J. Transnat’l L. 305
81. Gormley W. Paul, ‘The Right to Safe and Decent Environment’, (1988) 28/1 Indian J. Int’l L. 1.
82. Gorny Dietrich, ‘The European Environment Agency and the Freedom of Environmental Information Directive: Potential Cornerstones of EC Environmental Law’, (1991) 14/2 B. C. Int’l & Comp. L. Rev. 279-299.
83. Gorove Stephen, ‘The Concept of ‘Common Heritage of Mankind’: A Political, Moral or Legal Innovation?’ (1972) 9/3 San Diego L. Rev. 390
84. Gündling Lothar, ‘Our Responsibility to Future Generations’ (1990) 84/1 AJIL 207-212.
85. Handl Günther, ‘Controlling Implementation of and Compliance with International Environmental Commitments: The Rocky Road from Rio’, (1994) 5/2 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y 305.
86. Handl Günther, ‘Environmental Security and Global Change: The Challenge to International Law’ (1990) 1 Y.B. Int’l Envtl. L.
87. Handl Günther, ‘Human Rights and Protection of the Environment’ in A. Eide, C. Krause and A. Rosas (eds.) Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (second edition, Martinus Nijhoff, printed in the Netherlands, 2001).
88. Hanessian John, ‘The Antarctic Treaty 1959’ (1960) 9/3 ICLQ
89. Hayton Robert D., ‘The Antarctic Settlement of 1959’ (1960) 54/2 AJIL 349
90. Higgins Rosalyn, The Development of International Law through the Political Organs of the United Nations, (Oxford University Press 1963) 5, quoted in S. K., Chatterjee, ‘The Charter of Economic Rights and Duties of States: An Evaluation after 15 Years’ (1991) 40/3 ICLQ 669, 682 (According to the author “it may be unwise to dismiss the legal effect of all UN General Assembly resolutions, especially those pertaining to State responsibility”, ibid.).
91. Hodkova Iveta, ‘Is There a Right to a Healthy Environment in the International Legal Order?’ (1991) 7/1 Conn. J. Int’l L. 65.
92. Horn Laura, ‘The Implication of the Concept of Common Concern of a Human Kind on a Human Right to a Healthy Environment’, (2004) 1/2 MqJICEL 233-268
93. Husby Eric, ‘Sovereignty and Property Rights in Outer Space’ (1994) 3 J. Int’l. L. & Prac. 359.
94. ICJ, Press Release No.2010/16 of 1 June 2000, “Australia institutes proceedings against Japan for alleged breach of international obligations concerning whaling”, accessible at www.icj-cij.org/ docket/files/148/15953.pdf.
95. Jakhu Ram, ‘Legal Issues Relating to the Global Public Interest in Outer Space’ (2006) 32/1 J. Space L. 31-110.
96. Jenks C. Wilfred, ‘International Law and Activities in Space’ (1956) 5/1 ICLQ 99-114.
97. Jenks C. Wilfred, The Common Law of Mankind (Frederick A. Praeger 1958). Jessup Philip C., ‘Sovereignty in Antarctica’ (1947) 41/1 AJIL 117.
98. Jessup Philip C., ‘The International Protection of Whales’ (1930) 24/4 AJIL 751-752, League of Nations Doc. C.196.M.70.1927.V, 120 et al, reproduced in, AJIL (Volume 20 Supp., 1926).
99. Johnson D. H. N., ‘The Effect of Resolutions of the General Assembly of the United Nations’ (1955-56) 32 BYBIL 97-122.
100. Johnston Douglas M., ‘Systemic Environmental Damage: The Challenge to International Law and Organization’ (1985) 12/2 Syracuse J. Int’l L. & Com.
101. Joyner Christopher C., ‘Antarctica and the Law of the Sea: Rethinking the Current Legal Dilemmas’ (1981) 18/3 San Diego L. Rev.
102. Joyner Christopher C., ‘Protection of the Antarctic Environment: Rethinking the Problems and Prospects’ (1986) 19/2 Cornell Int’l L.J. 259
103. Joyner Christopher C., ‘The Common Heritage of Mankind’ (1986) 35 ICLQ 190. Alexander Charles Kiss, ‘Conserving the Common Heritage of Mankind’, (1990) 59/4 Rev. Jur. U.P.R. 773
104. Joyner Christopher C., ‘The Southern Ocean and Marine Pollution: Problems and Prospects’, (1985) 17/2 Case W. Res. J. Int’l L.
105. July 2007, “Decision I/2 – Review of Compliance”; available at,
106. Kamminga Menno T., ‘The IAEA Convention on Nuclear Safety’ (1995) 44/4 ICLQ 872-882
107. Kaye Stuart B., ‘Legal Approaches to Polar Fisheries Regimes: A Comparative Analysis of the Convention for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources and the Bering Sea Doughnut Hole Convention’, (1995) 26/1 Cal. W. Int’l L. J. 75
108. Kimball Lee, ‘Environmental Law and Policy in Antarctica’ in P. Sands (ed.), Greening International Law, (The New Press, 1994)
109. Kish John, The Law of International Spaces (A. W. Sijthoff, 1973)
110. Kiss Alexandra, ‘The Rio Declaration on Environment and Development’ in L. Campiglio et al., (eds.) The Environment after Rio: International Law and Economics (London/Dordrecht/ Boston: Graham & Trotman/Martinus Nijhoff, 1994).
111. Kiss Alexandre and Shelton Dinah, Guide to International Environmental Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers 2007)
112. Kiss Alexandre Charles, ‘Mechanisms of Supervision of International Environmental Rules’ in Frits Kalshoven, Pieter Jan Kuyper and Johan G. Lammers (eds.), Essays on the Development of the International Legal Order: in memory of Haro F. Van Panhuys (Sijthoff and Noordhoff 1980) 99-114.
113. Kiss Alexandre, ‘Concept and Possible Implications of the Right to Environment’, in K.H. Mahoney and P. Mahoney (eds.) Human Rights in the Twenty-first Century, (Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1993).
114. Kiss Alexandre, ‘The Common Heritage of Mankind: Utopia or Reality?’ (1985) 40/3 International Journal 423
115. Kovar Jeffrey D., ‘A Short Guide to the Rio Declaration’, (1993) 4/1 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y 118-140.
116. Lachs Manfred, The Law of Outer Space: An Experience in Contemporary Law-Making (Sijthoff, 1972).
117. Lee Seokwoo, KimJeong Woo, ‘Chapter 2. Applying the Principle of the Common Heritage of Mankind: An East Asian Perspective’ in Keyuan Zou (ed.) Global Commons and the Law of Sea (Koninklijke Brill NV, 2018).
118. Llano George A., ‘Ecology of the Southern Ocean Region’ (1978) 33/2 U. Miami L. Rev.
119. Lones Laura L., ‘The Marine Mammal Protection Act and International Protection of Cetaceans: A Unilateral Attempt to Effectuate Transnational Conservation’ (1989) 22/3 Vand. J. Transnat’lL. 997.
120. Lopez Aurelie, ‘Criminal Liability for Environmental Damage Occurring in Times of Non- International Armed Conflict: Rights and Remedies’ (2007) 18/2 Fordham Envtl. L. Rev. 231, 256
121. Lyall Francis, Larsen Paul B., Space Law: A Treatise (Ashgate, 2009).
122. Maffei Maria Clara, ‘The International Convention for the Regulating of Whaling’ (1997) 12/3 Int’l J. Marine & Coastal L. 287.
123. Maffei Mariea Clara, ‘Evolving Trends in the International Protection of Species’ (1993) 36 German YBIL 131-187.
124. Maggio Gregory F., ‘Inter/intra-generational Equity: Current Applications under International Law for Promoting the Sustainable Development of Natural Resources’ (1997) 4/2 Buff. Envtl. L. J. 161-224.
125. Mann H., ‘Comment on the Paper by Philippe Sands’ in W. Lang (ed.) Sustainable Development in International Law (1995 Graham Trotman).
126. Marciniak Konrad Jan, ‘Chapter 16. Marine Genetic Resources: Do They Form the Part of the Common Heritage of Mankind Principle?’ in Natural Resources and the Law of the Sea: Exploration, Allocation, Exploitation of Natural Resources in Areas under National Jurisdiction and Beyond (Arbitration & Practice 2017).
127. Ni Kuei-Jung, ‘Contemporary Prospects for the Application of Principle 12 of the Rio Declaration’, (2001) 14/1 Geo. Int’l Envtl. L. Rev. 1-33
128. Ogunbanwo Ogunsola O., International Law and Outer Space Activities (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1975).
129. Onoda Masami, ‘Satellite Earth Observation as ‘Systematic Observation’ in Multilateral Environmental Treaties’ (2005) 31/2 J. Space L. 339-411.
130. Pallemaerts Marc, ‘International Environmental Law From Stockholm to Rio: Back to the Future’ in P. Sands (ed.) Greening International Law (The New Press 1994) 1, 2
131. Palmer Geoffrey, ‘The Earth Summit: What Went Wrong at Rio?’, (1992) 70/4 Wash. U. L. Q. 1005-1028.
132. Pinto M. C. W., ‘The International Community and Antarctica’ (1978) 33/2 U. Miami L. Rev. Quinn Adam G., ‘The New Age of Space Law: The Outer Space Treaty and the Weaponization of
133. Space’ (2008) 17/2 Minn. J. Int’l. L. 475.
134. Rana Harminderpal Singh, ‘Note, the ‘Common Heritage of Mankind’ & the Final Frontier: A Revaluation of Values Constituting the International Legal Regime for Outer Space Activities’, (1994) 26/1 Rutgers L.J. 225-250.
135. Redgwell Catherine, ‘Environmental Protection in Antarctica: The 1991 Protocol’ (1994) 43/3 ICLQ 599-634.
136. Rosas Allan, ‘The Right to Development’, in A. Eide, C. Krause and A. Rosas (eds.) Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, (Second edition, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2001) 119-130.
137. Rose Gregory, Crane Saundra, ‘The Evolution of International Whaling Law’ in Philippe Sands (ed.), Greening International Law (The New Press 1994) 159-181.
138. Rosencranz Armin, ‘The Origin and Emergence of International Environmental Norms’ (2003) 26/3 Hastings Int’l & Comp. L. Rev. 309-320
139. Rothwell Donald R., ‘International Law and the Protection of the Arctic Environment’ (1995) 44/2 ICLQ 280
140. Rubin Alfred P., ‘The International Legal Effects of Unilateral Declarations’, (1977) 71/1 AJIL 1-30
141. Sand Peter H., ‘UNCED and the Development of International Environmental Law’ (1992-93) 8/2 J. Nat. Resources & Envtl. L.
142. Sands Philippe, ‘Introduction’ in P. Sands (ed.) Greening International Law (Routledge 1994). Sands Philippe, ‘Principles of International Environmental Law’ (Cambridge University Press 2003).
143. Sattler Rosanna, ‘Transporting a Legal System for Property Rights: From the Earth to the Stars’, (2005) 6/1 Chi. J. Int’l. L. 23
144. Schachter Oscar, ‘The Emergence of International Environmental Law’, (1990) J. Int’l Aff. 457- 493.
145. Schachter Oscar, ‘The Twilight Existence of Nonbinding International Agreements’ (1977) 71/2 AJIL 296
146. Schafer Bernard K., ‘The Relationship Between the International Laws of Armed Conflict and Environmental Protection: The Need to Reevaluate What Types of Conduct are Permissible During Hostilities’ (1989) 19/2 Cal. W. Int’l L. J. 287-325
147. Scholtz Werner, ‘Common Heritage: Saving the Environment for Humankind or Exploiting Resources in the Name of Eco-Imperialism?’ (2008) 41/2 Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa (Comp. Int’l L. J. S. Africa) 273-293.
148. Scott Davidson J., ‘The Single European Act and the Environment’, (1987) 2/4 Int’l J. Estuarine & Coastal L. 259-263.
149. Scott James B., ‘Arctic Exploration and International Law’ (1909) 3/4 AJIL 928, 941.
150. Scott Karen N., ‘Chapter 16. Protecting the Commons in the Polar South: Progress and Prospects for Marine Protected Areas in the Antarctic’ in Keyuan Zou (ed.) Global Commons and the Law of Sea (Koninklijke Brill NV, 2018).
151. Scovazzi Tullio, ‘Articles 8 - 11: World Heritage Committee and World Heritage List’, in Francioni (ed.) The 1972 World Heritage Convention (2008).
152. Scovazzi Tullio, The Evolution of International Law of the Sea: New Issues, New Challenges (Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law Vol. 286, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2000).
153. Scully R. Tucker, ‘The Marine Living Resources of the Southern Ocean’ (1978) 33/2 U. Miami L. Rev. 345-348.
154. Shelton Dinah, ‘What Happened in Rio to Human Rights?’ (1992) 3 Yearbook Int’l. Envtl. L. 75-93.
155. Simma Bruno, ‘The Antarctic Treaty as a Treaty Providing for an Objective Regime’ (1986) 19/2 Cornell Int’l L. J.
156. Simpson Tony, Jackson Vanessa, ‘Human Rights and the Environment’ (1997) 14/4 Envtl. & Plan. L. J.
157. Simsarian James, ‘Inspection Experience under the Antarctic Treaty and the International Atomic Energy Agency’ (1966) 60/3 AJIL 502-510 and 503-507; Kish (n. 202) 175 citing C. W. Jenks, The Common Law of Mankind (n. 112)
158. Sloan F. Blaine, ‘The Binding Force of a ‘Recommendation’ of the General Assembly of the United Nations’ (1948) 25 BYBIL 1.
159. Smith H. A., The Law and the Custom of the Sea (Stevens & Sons Limited, 1950).
160. Soto Max V., ‘General Principles of International Environmental Law’, (1996) 3/1 ILSA J. Int’l & Comp. L.
161. Suarez M. Jose “Exploitation of the Products of the Sea” Report to the Council of the League of Nations on the Questions Which Appear Ripe for Codification, League of L. Larry Leonard, ‘Recent Negotiations toward the International Regulation of Whaling’ (1941) 35/1 AJIL 90
162. Sumi Kazuo, ‘The ‘Whale War’ Between Japan and the United States: Problems and Prospects’ (1989) 17/2 Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y 317-372.
163. Suy E., ‘Antarctica: Common Heritage of Mankind?’ in J. Verhoeven - Ph. Sand - M. Bruce (eds.), The Antarctic Environment and International Law (1992).
164. Symonides Janusz, ‘The Human Right to a Clean, Balanced and Protected Environment’ (1992) 20/1 Int’l. J. Legal Info.
165. Tennen Leslie I., ‘Outer Space: A Preserve for All Humankind’ (1979-80) 2/1 Hous. J. Int’l L. 145-158.
166. Thorme Melissa, ‘Establishing Environment as a Human Right’ (1991) 19/2 Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y 301-342.
167. Tinker Catherine, ‘Environmental Planet Management by the United Nations: An Idea Whose Time Has Not Yet Come?’ (1990) 22/4 N.Y.U. J. Int’l L & Pol.
168. Triggs Gillian, ‘The Antarctic Treaty Regime: A Workable Compromise or a ‘Purgatory of Ambiguity’?’ (1985) 17/2 Case W. Res. J. Int’l L. 195
169. Trindade Antonio Augusto Cançado, ‘The Contribution of International Human Rights Law to Environmental Protection, with special reference to Global Environmental Change’, in B Weiss (ed.) Environmental Change and International Law: New Challenges and Dimensions (United Nations University Press, 1992).
170. Trindade Cf. Antonio Augusto Cançado, ‘Human Rights and the Environment’ in Janusz Symonides (ed.), Human Rights: New Dimensions and Challenges (Manual on the Rights, UNESCO Publishing, Ashgate, 1998).
171. Tromans Stephen, Nuclear Law (Second edition, Hart Publishing, 2010)
172. Vigni Patrizia, ‘The Interaction between the Antarctic Treaty System and the Other Relevant Conventions Applicable to the Antarctic Area’ in J.A. Frowein and R. Wolfrum (eds.), Max Planck UNYB, vol 4 (Kluwer Law International, 2000) 481
173. Viikari Lotta, The Environmental Element in Space Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2008).
174. Wang Chuanliang, ‘On the Legal Status of Marine Genetic Resources in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction’ (2021) 13/14: 7993 Sustainability, https://doi.org/10.3390/su13147993.
175. Wang Chuanliang, Chang Yen-Chiang, ‘A New Interpretation of Common Heritage of Mankind in the Context of International Law of the Sea’ (2020) 191 Ocean. & Coast. Manag.
176. Watts Arthur, International Law and the Antarctic Treaty System, (Grotius Publications Ltd.,1992) Weiss Edith Brown, ‘Environmentally Sustainable Competitiveness: A Comment’, (1993) 102/ 8 Yale L. J. 2123-2142.
177. Weiss Edith Brown, ‘International Environmental Law: Contemporary Issues and the Emergence of a New World Order’ (1992-93) 81/3 Geo. L. J. 675-710.
178. Weiss Edith Brown, ‘Our Rights and Obligations to Future Generations for the Environment’ (1990) 84/1 AJIL 198-207.
179. Weiss Edith Brown, In Fairness to Future Generations: International Law, Common Patrimony and Intergenerational Equity, (Transnational, United Nations University, 1989).
180. Wilkinson David, ‘Maastricht and the Environment: The Implications for the EC’s Environment Policy of the Treaty on European Union’, (1992) 4/2 J. Envtl. L. 221-239.
181. Wolfrum Rüdiger, ‘The Principle of the Common Heritage of Mankind’ (1983) 43 ZaöRV 312
182. Yoshida O., ‘Soft Enforcement of Treaties: The Montreal Protocol’s Noncompliance Procedure and the Functions of Internal International Institutions’ (1999) 10/1 Colo. J. Int’l Envtl. L. & Pol’y 95, 123-127
183. Zacker Christian, ‘Environmental Law of the European Economic Community: New Powers Under the Single European Act’, (1991) 14/2 B. C. Int’l & Comp. L. Rev. 249-278.
184. Zaelke Durwood, Cameron James, ‘Global Warming and Climate Change - An Overview of the International Legal Process’ (1990) 5 Am. U. J. Int’l L. & Pol. 249-290.
185. Zhang Hua, ‘Chapter 14. The Obligation of Due Diligence in Regulating the Marine Genetic Resources in Areas beyond National Jurisdiction’ in Keyuan Zou (ed.) Global Commons and the Law of Sea (Koninklijke Brill NV, 2018).