The Battle of Tigranocerta (69 BC): A Reconsideration

Yıl 2021, Sayı: 24, 145 - 176, 20.09.2021

Muzaffer Demir

https://doi.org/10.26650/anar.2021.24.898025

Öz

The ancient city of Tigranocerta (Tigranakert) is thought to be localized to the site of Ancient A/Erzen near Bozhöyük, which is in the district of Siirt Province. The Armenian king, Tigranes II, established this city in 76 BC, as it would be more at the center of the borders of his empire, which had spread over Cappadocia, Cilicia, Syria, Palestine, and as far as Parthia. This city, described in ancient sources as rich and magnificent, became the empire’s new capital, where many people from various areas, especially Cappadocia, were forced to immigrate and settle. In 69 BC, it witnessed one of history’s most significant battles between the Roman proconsul Lucullus and Tigranes II. Before the pitched battle near the city, it appears that the legates of Lucullus, Sextilius, and Murena had been sent out to harass and cut off those who marched to the support of Tigranes II. They seem to have defeated the enemy in all these engagements. Eventually, Sextilius started to besiege Tigranocerta, where Mankaios was in command. As the size of the Roman army appeared inconsiderable to Tigranes II and his allies, even jeering at it, they did not listen to the advice of their ally, Mithradates VI, the king of Pontus (Black Sea), to try and cut off the supplies of the Roman army. They instead preferred to engage in a pitched battle, where they were heavily defeated by Lucullus. Thus, Tigranocerta fell and was sacked, and the city’s immigrant population was sent back to their homes. In this article, we first explain the circumstances before the battle and then concentrate on the question of army size on both sides, which appears to have been exaggerated by some ancient writers, and finally reevaluate their battle strategies within this conjecture.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Armenia, Tigranes II, Lucullus, Tigranocerta, A/Erzen

Tigranokerta Savaşı (MÖ 69): Yeni Bir Gözden Geçirme

Öz

Tigranokerta (Tigranakert) kentinin Siirt İli Kurtalan İlçesi Bozhöyük köyü yakınlarındaki bugünkü Antik A/Erzen yerleşimi olduğu düşünülmektedir. Armenia kralı II. Tigranes, MÖ 76 yılından itibaren Kappadokia, Kilikia, Suriye ve Parthia içlerine kadar yayılmış olan imparatorluğunun sınırlarının daha merkezinde olduğundan dolayı bu kenti kurmuştur. Zengin ve görkemli olduğu söylenen kent, imparatorluğun yeni başkenti olmuş ve başta Kappadokialılar olmak üzere pek çok halk burada iskâna zorlanmıştır. Kent aynı zamanda MÖ 69 yılında II. Tigranes ve Roma generali Lucullus arasında tarihin önemli savaşlarından birisine sahne olmuştur. Roma proconsulu Lucullus’un legatuslarından Sextilius ve Murena, kent yakınlarında meydan savaşı başlamadan önce düşman destek birliklerinin önünü keserek zafer elde etmişlerdir. Sonrasında Sextilius, Mankaios’un garnizon komutanlığını yaptığı kenti kuşatmaya başlamıştır. II. Tigranes’in Lucullus’un ordusunu sayıca küçük gördüğünden müttefiki Pontos (Karadeniz) kralı VI. Mithradates’in meydan savaşından kaçınması gerektiği yönündeki tavsiyesini dinlemediği iddia edilmektedir. Ancak Lucullus II. Tigranes’i ağır bir yenilgiye uğratarak kenti ele geçirmiş, yağmalamış ve hatta zorla iskân ettirilen yabancı nüfusunun evlerine geri dönmesini sağlamıştır. Biz bu çalışmamızda, ilk önce savaş öncesi durumu, sonrasında da halen tartışma konusu olan her iki tarafın asker sayısını açıklamaya çalışacağız. Sonuçta, özellikle her iki tarafın asker sayısı hakkında bazı antik yazarların verdiği abartılı rakamların tekrar gözden geçirilmesi ve bu bağlamda savaş stratejilerinde göz ardı edilen bazı noktalar üzerinde de yeni değerlendirmeler yapılması gerekmektedir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Armenia, II. Tigranes, Lucullus, Tigranokerta, A/Erzen

Kaynakça

• Adler, E. (2006). Who’s Anti-Roman? Sallust and Pompeius Trogus on Mithridates. The Classical Journal, 101 (4), 383-407. google scholar
• Ahlheid, F. (1988). Oratorical Strategy in Sallust’s Letter of Mithridates Reconsidered. Mnemosyne, 41 (1/2), 167-92. google scholar
• Andrade, N. (2011). Local authority and civic Hellenism: Tarcondimotus, Hierapolis-Castabala and the cult of Perasia. Anatolian Studies, 61, 123-132. google scholar
• Arslan, M. (2007). Mithradates VI Eupator: Romanın Büyük Düşmanı. İstanbul. google scholar
• Ash, R. (2006). Following in the Footsteps of Lucullus? Tacitus’ Characterisation of Corbulo. Arethusa, 39 (2), 355-375. google scholar
• Avdoyan, L. (2006). Tigranocerta: the city ‘built’ by Tigranes. R. G. Hovannisian (Ed.), Armenian Tigranakert/ Dijarbekir and Edessa/Urfa, Costa Mesa CA, 81-95. google scholar
• Brunt, P. A. (1962). The Army and the Land in the Roman Revolution. The Journal of Roman Studies, 52 (1/2), 69-86. google scholar
• Cameron, A. (1969). Review: The Breviarium of Festus, ed. J.W. Eadie. The Classical Review, 19 (3), 305-307. google scholar
• Cameron, H., Constructing A Borderland: Roman Imperial Geographic Writers On Mesopotamia From The 1st to the 4th Centuries BC (Phd Thesis). Ann Arbor: UMI 2014. google scholar
• Carter, M. (2004). The “Lex Portorii” and the Armenian Campaign of Caesennius Paetus. Latomus, 63 (2), 370-379. google scholar
• Comfort, A. (2017). Fortresses of the Tur Abdin and the confrontation between Rome and Persia. Anatolian Studies, 67, 181-229. google scholar
• Cowan, R. - Hook, A. (2007). Roman Battle Tactics 109 BC - AD 313. Osprey Publishing. google scholar
• Coyne, J. J. A. (1912), Hellenism and the Oriental Reaction. An Irish Quarterly Review, 1 (4), 599-620. google scholar
• Demir, M. (2008). Antik Kaynakları Işığında Tigranokerta Şehrinin Lokalizasyonu Meselesi. I. Uluslararası Batman ve Çevresi Tarih ve Kültür Sempozyumu, 15-17 Nisan, Batman, Cilt 1, 171-182. google scholar
• Eckhardt, K. 1910. Die armenischen Feldzüge des Lukullus. II. Abschnitt. Das Kriegsjahr 69. Klio, 10, 72-115. google scholar
• Elmore, J. (1925), Caesar on the Causes of Mutiny. The Classical Journal, 20 (7), 430-432. google scholar
• Foss, C. (1986). The Coinage of Tigranes the Great: Problems, Suggestions and a New Find. The Numismatic Chronicle (1966-), 146, 19-66. google scholar
• Gerrish, J. (2012). Sallust’s Histories and Triumviral Historiography (Phd Thesis). University of Pennsylvania. google scholar
• Gurzadyan, V. G. - Vardanyan, R. (2004). Halley’s comet of 87 BC on the Coins of Armenian King Tigranes?. Astronomy & Geophysics, 45 (4), 4.6. google scholar
• Holmes, T. R. (1917). Tigranokerta. The Journal of Roman Studies, 7, 120-138. google scholar
• Keaveney, A. (1981). Roman Treaties with Parthia circa 95-circa 64 B.C. The American Journal of Philology, 102 (2), 195-212. google scholar
• Mahdesian, A. (1917). Armenia, Her Culture and Aspirations. The Journal of Race Development, 7 (4), 448-466. google scholar
• Marciak, M. (2016). The site of Tigranokerta: status quaestionis. Acta Antiqua Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae, 56 (3), 293-314. google scholar
• Mayor, A. (2014). Common Cause Versus Rome: The Alliance between Mithradates VI of Pontus and Tigranes II of Armenia, 94-66 BC. M. M. Hülagu et al (Eds.), Tarihte Turkler ve Ermeniler: İlkcağ & Ortacağ, Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu, 99-119. google scholar
• Misssirian, G. M. (1916). Armenia in the Agonies of National Crucifixion. The Journal of Race Development, 6 (3), 324-338. google scholar
• Mulroy, D. (1988). The Early Career of P. Clodius Pulcher: A Re-examination of the Charges of Mutiny and Sacrilige. Transactions of the American Philological Association, 118, 155-178. google scholar
• Nercessian, Y. T. (2000). Silver Coins of Tigranes II of Armenia. Armenian Numismatic Journal, 26, pts. 3&4, Group 3. google scholar
• Norris, S. (2005). Roman Strategies of Control: Terror and Intimidation (Phd Thesis). Alberta: University of Calgary. google scholar
• Polanski, T. (2013). The Destruction of Cultural Heritage in the Kingdoms of Pontus and Kommagene during the Roman Conquest. Iran & the Caucasus, 17 (3), 239-252. google scholar
• Pothecary, S. (2016). A Road Trip with Strabo: Memory and Composition in the “Geography”. Mnemosyne, 69 (2), 202-225. google scholar
• Raditsa, L. F. (1970). A Historical Commentary to Sallust’s Letter of Mithridates. Columbia University. google scholar
• Rey, S. (2015). Roman tears and their impact: a questin of gender? Clio. Women, Gender and History, 41, “Real socialism” and the challenge of gender, Trans. by M. Rothstein, 225-245. google scholar
• Schlude, J. M. (2009). Rome, Parthia, and Empire: The First Century of Roman-Parthian Relations (Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi). Berkeley: University of California. google scholar
• Simonetta, A. M. (2001). A Proposed Revision of the Attributions of the Parthian Coins Struck during the So-called ‘Dark Age’ and Its Historical Significance. East and West, 51 (1/2), 69-108. google scholar
• Sinclair, T. A. (1989). Eastern Turkey: An Architectural and Archaeological Survey III, London. google scholar
• --------------------(1995). The site of Tigranocerta, I. Revue desEtudesArmeniennes, 25, 183-254. https://doi. org/10.2143/REA.25.0.2003781 google scholar
• --------------------(1996-1997). The site of Tigranocerta, II. Revue des Etudes Armeniennes, 26, 51-118. https://doi.org/10.2143/REA.26.0.2003745 google scholar
• Sullivan, R. D. (1971). Some Dynastic Answers to the Armenian Question: A Study in East Anatolian Prosopography (Phd Thesis). Los Angeles: University of California. google scholar
• Sunkar, M. et al. (2015). Erzen (Garzan) Bölgesi’nde (Siirt) Uydu Görüntüleri Analizleri ile Tarihi Yerleşme Alanlarının Belirlenmesi ve Bu Yerleşmelerin Tahrip Olmasında Beşer Faktörlerin Etkileri. Coğrafyacılar Derneği Uluslararası Kongresi Bildiriler Kitabı, 21-23 Mayıs 2015, Gazi Üniversitesi, Ankara, 702-709. google scholar
• Syme, S. R. (1983). Tigranokerta. A Problem Misconceived. S. Mitchell (Ed.), Armies and Frontiers in Roman and Byzantine Anatolia: Proceedings of a Colloquium held at University College, Swansea, in April 1981, Oxford: BAR, 61-70. google scholar
• ----------------(1987). Exotic Names, Notably in Seneca’s Tragedies. Acta Classica, 30, 49-64. google scholar
• Taylor, J. H. (1952). Political Motives in Cicero’s Defense of Archias. The American Journal of Philology, 73 (1), 62-70. google scholar
• Telford, L. (2014). Sulla: A Dictator Reconsidered, Pen and Sword Military Books, Barnsley. google scholar
• Thomson, R. W. (1978). Moses Khorenats‘i: History of the Armenians. Translation and Commentary. Cambridge, Mass.-London. google scholar
• Wylie, G. J. (1994). Lucullus Daemoniac. L’Antiquite Classique, 63, 109-119. google scholar
• Wilcox, P. (1986). Rome’s Enemies (3): Parthians and Sassanid Persians, Osprey Publishing. google scholar