From Wagner to Metal Through Nietzsche: Dramatic Representation of Metal Music as Ritual, Sacrifice and Catharsis

Yıl 2025, Cilt: 12 Sayı: 2, 670 - 685, 31.12.2025

Melis Mulazimoglu

https://doi.org/10.26650/CONS2025-1675391

https://izlik.org/JA86CK34NC

Öz

The combined use of metal music, Wagner, and Nietzsche in the same context is rarely seen. Metal, as a modern musical style and subcultural movement, resonates with protest and musical distortion, while Wagner’s name is associated with opera and classical music, which are regarded as the highest and most harmonious art forms of the 19th century. Although each genre has developed its own distinct musical features, closer examination reveals striking parallels between classical and metal music. Scholars from various fields and perspectives have explored this similarity (Middleton, 1990; Walser, 1992; Lilja, 2009; St-Laurent, 2012; Popoff, 2015; Heritage, 2016; Mynett, 2019; Herbst, 2020; Miguel, 2025). In this article, I argue that both metal music and Wagnerian opera share a common origin: early Greek tragedy. The musical intensity, theatricality, and transgressive structure of ancient Greek drama provide both genres with a rich heritage that fosters authenticity, aesthetic fusion, and cultural vitality. Furthermore, the study discusses how German philosopher F. Nietzsche’s critique of the concepts of Dionysus and Apollo, as presented in The Birth of Tragedy (1872), serves as a vital reference point and unifying principle behind the coexistence of metal and opera. Thus, this article aims to explore the interaction between metal music and Wagnerian opera through the lens of a ritual-sacrifice-catharsis trilogy, paying homage to the dithyrambic practices of early antiquity, analyzed from a Nietzschean perspective.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Metal Music , Wagner , Opera , Nietzsche , Dionysian and Apollonian

Kaynakça

• Adorno, T. W. (1981). In search of Wagner (R. Livingstone, Trans.). Merlin Press. google scholar
• Aristotle. (1819). Poetics (T. Twining, Trans.). [Digitized 2007]. Retrieved from: https://dn790004.ca.archive.org/0/items/aristotlespoetic00arisiala/aristotlespoetic00arisiala.pdfgoogle scholar
• Barnett, B. (2017). Black Sabbath’s pioneering lyrical rhetoric: Tragic structure and cathartic potential in song narratives. Metal Music Studies. Vol. 3 (1), 81-96. http://10.1386/mms. 3.1.81_1 google scholar
• Berger, H. (1999). Metal, rock, and jazz. UP of New England. google scholar
• Bauer, K. (2005). Adorno's Wagner: History and the potential of the artwork. The German Quarterly, 77(4), 455–467. [suspicious link removed] google scholar
• Benjamin, W. (1935). The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction. (H. Zohn, Trans.). Illuminations, New York: Schocken Books: 1-26. https://web.mit.edu/allanmc/www/benjamin.pdf google scholar
• Bennett, S. (1997). Theatre audiences: A theory of production and reception. 2nd ed. Routledge. google scholar
• Berry, M. (2004). Richard Wagner and the politics of music-drama. The Historical Journal, 47(3), 663–683. [suspicious link removed] scholar
• Borchmeyer, D. (1991). Richard Wagner: Theory and theater. Oxford: Clarendon. google scholar
• Brown, A., Spracklen, K., Kahn-Harris, K., Scott, N. W. R. (Eds). (2016). Introduction. Global metal music and culture, Routledge. google scholar
• de Moor, W. (2023). One ring to rule them all. Wagner & heavy metal. Retrieved from: https://www.wagner-heavymetal.com/one-ring-to-rule-them-all.htmlgoogle scholar
• Dunn, S. (Director), & McFadyen, S. (Producer). (2005). Metal: A headbanger’s journey [Film]. Seville Pictures. google scholar
• Encyclopedia Metallum. (n.d.). Pentagram. https://www.metal-archives.com/bands/Pentagram/268 google scholar
• Ergur, A. (2024, July 1). Müzik iyileştirir. Sanattan yansımalar. Retrieved from: https://www.sanattanyansimalar.com/yazarlar/ali-ergur/muzik-iyilestirir/3335/google scholar
• Fernández-Morales, R. (2015, January 1). Heavy metal: A genre for all and none. Academia.edu.https://www.academia.edu/66224128/Heavy_Metal_A_Genre_for_All_and_Nonegoogle scholar
• Filimowicz, M. (2024, March 24). How Wagner’s conception of music drama differed from opera. Sound & Design. Retrieved from: https://soundand.design/how-wagners-conception-of-music-drama-differed-from-opera-8e53df007ee3google scholar
• Glynatsis, T. (2023, March 15). Ideology and machines in the work of Richard Wagner. Critical Stages/Scènes critiques. Retrieved from: https://www.critical-stages.org/21/ideology-and-machines-in-the-work-of-richard-wagner/google scholar
• Gojira, (2024). “Mea Culpa.” Summer Olympics, Paris, France. [Youtube Video]. google scholar
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hTMYk7orHw google scholar
• Guibert, C. & Guibert, G. (2016). The social characteristics of the contemporary metalhead: google scholar
• The Hellfest survey. Global metal music and culture. (Eds.) Brown, A., Spracklen, K., Kahn-Harris, K., Scott, N. W. R. Routledge, 167-190. google scholar
• Hecker, P. (2012). Turkish metal music, meaning, and morality in a Muslim society. Routledge. google scholar
• Herbst, J. P. (2020). From Bach to Helloween: ‘Teutonic’ stereotypes in the history of popular music and heavy metal. Metal Music Studies Vol. 6 (1). Intellect. http://10.1386/mms_00006_1 google scholar
• Herbst, J. P. & Mynett, M. (2022). What is “heavy” in metal? A netnographic analysis of online forums for metal musicians and producers. 633-653. https://doi.org/10.1080/03007766.2022.2114155 google scholar
• Heritage, G. (2016). ‘It’s Like a Mach Piece, Really’: Critiquing the neo-classical aesthetic of ’80s heavy metal music. Global metal music and culture. (Eds.) Brown, A., Spracklen, K., Kahn-Harris, K., Scott, N. W. R. Routledge, 50-68. google scholar
• Horkheimer, M., & Adorno, T. W. (1993). Dialectic of enlightenment (J. Cumming, Trans.). Continuum. google scholar
• Horn, K. (2023, August 12). What is the Tristan chord? [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b3yHQp5FNk4 google scholar
• Irwin, W. (2013). Black Sabbath & philosophy: Mastering reality. Wiley-Blackwell. google scholar
• Jepson, B. (2013, April 4). Music: It takes brass to play the Wagner tuba. The Wall Street Journal. https://www.proquest.com/docview/1323193266 google scholar
• Jones, E. (n.d.). Richard Wagner. In Music 101. SUNY Services. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-musicapp-medieval-modern/chapter/richard-wagner/google scholar
• Kahn-Harris, K. (2006). Extreme metal: music and culture on the edge. Bloomsbury. google scholar
• Krause, C. (2015). The metal festival as a place for emotional liberation and officially permitted revolution.https://www.academia.edu/37335020/The_Metal_Festival_as_a_Place_for_Emotional_Liberation_and_Officially_Permitted_Revolutiongoogle scholar
• Lennert. (2006, May 3). A Night at the opera [Review of the album a night at the opera by Blind Guardian]. Encyclopaedia Metallum: The Metal Archives. Retrieved from: https://www.metalarchives.com/reviews/Blind_Guardian/A_Night_at_the_Opera/21/Lennert/24405google scholar
• LeVine, M. (2008). Heavy metal Islam. New York: Three Rivers Press. google scholar
• Lilja, E. (2009). Theory and analysis of classic heavy metal harmony. Finnish Music Library Association. Poroila, H. (ed.) Vol. 136, Helsinki. google scholar
• Marcus, G. E., & Fischer, M. M. J. (1986). Anthropology as cultural critique: an experimental moment in the human sciences. Chicago UP. google scholar
• Middleton, R. (1990). Studying popular music. Buckingham: Open University Press. google scholar
• Miguel, D. (2025). A reflection on Esa Lilja’s theory and analysis of classic heavy metal harmony. Metal Music Studies, Vol. 11, Issue Ten years of metal music studies, 149 – 152. https://doi.org/10.1386/mms_00157_7 google scholar
• Miguel, D. (2025). On Wagner and metal music. (Zoom meeting). Turkey.google scholar
• Mynett, M. (2019). Defining contemporary metal music: Performance, sounds and practices. google scholar
• Metal Music Studies. Vol. 5 (3). Intellect. 297-313. http://10.1386/mms.5.3.297_1 google scholar
• Nietzsche, F. W. (1910). The birth of tragedy; or, Hellenism and pessimism (W. A. Haussmann, Trans.). 1872. Project Gutenberg. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/51356/51356-h/51356-h.htm google scholar
• Nietzsche, F. W. (1909). Richard Wagner in Bayreuth (A. M. Ludovici, Trans.). Thoughts out of season. The Edinburgh Press. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Richard_Wagner_in_Bayreuth google scholar
• Nietzsche, F. W. (2008). The case of Wagner, Nietzsche contra Wagner, and selected aphorisms. Project Gutenberg. Retrieved from: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/25012/25012-pdf.pdf (Original work published 1911) google scholar
• Paksoylu, G. (2024, November 14). In the Pursuit of Heavy Metal and the Birmingham Chronicles, Part I. Metaloda. Retrieved from: https://metaloda.com/in-the-pursuit-of-heavy-metal-the-birmingham-chronicles-part-1/google scholar
• Plato (n.d.). The republic. Retrieved 2002. google scholar
• https://www.sciencetheearth.com/uploads/2/4/6/5/24658156/plato_-_the_republic.pdfgoogle scholar
• Popoff, M. (2019). Who invented heavy metal? Wymer, UK. google scholar
• Rammstein Live Recordings. (2013). “Mein Teil.” Hurricane Festival in Scheeßel, Germany. [YouTube Video]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ve6AxSxEYtY google scholar
• Riches, G. (2012). ‘Caught in a Mosh’: Moshpit culture, extreme metal music and the reconceptualization of leisure. MA thesis. Alberta. google scholar
• “Riff.” (1986). New Harvard Dictionary of Music. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press: p. 708. google scholar
• Rock’ n Metal. (2011). “Killer/I Love the Dead Guillotine Row,” [YouTube Video] by Alice Cooper, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOq-UiY6yGggoogle scholar
• Rogers, N. G. (2023). Richard Wagner’s visual worlds: The Gesamtkunstwerk and the spectacle of empire. PhD Thesis. https://repository.upenn.edu/handle/20.500.14332/59333 google scholar
• Schopenhauer, A. (2005). İrade ve tasarım olarak evren (L. Özşar, Çev.). Biblos. google scholar
• St-Laurent, M. (2012). Les rapprochements entre la musique metal et la musique klasik : le cas de Therion et de Richard Wagner. Sociétés. 117(3):129. google scholar
• http://10.3917/soc.117.0129 google scholar
• Steel, S. (2014). The birth of Dionysian education (out of the spirit of music)? Part one. Philosophy of Music Education Review, 22(1), 38–60. ResearchGate. 10.2979/philmusieducrevi.22.1.38 google scholar
• Ülger, E. (2014). Wagner’de müzik felsefesinin temelleri. Elektronik Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 13(49), 203-220. https://doi.org/10.17755/esosder.08947google scholar
• Vincenzo, J. (2021, June 23). Nietzsche's the birth of tragedy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPOb1kW5qk4 google scholar
• Wagner, R. (1913). Opera & drama (Oper und Drama) (W. Ashton Ellis, Trans.). Reeves. Retrieved from: https://archive.org/details/operadramaoperun01wagnuoft/page/xxvi/mode/2upgoogle scholar
• Wallach, J., Berger, H. M., & Greene, P. D., eds. (2011). Metal rules the globe: Heavy metal music around the world. Duke University Press. google scholar
• Walser, R. (1992). Eruptions: Heavy metal appropriations of classical virtuosity. Popular Music, 11(3), 263–308. Cambridge University Press. [suspicious link removed] google scholar
• Walser, R. (2014). Running with the devil: Power, gender, and madness in heavy metal music (H. M. Berger, Foreword). Wesleyan University Press.google scholar
• Varas-Diaz, N. (2021). Decolonial metal music in Latin America. Intellect.google scholar
• Weinstein, D. (1991). Heavy metal: The music and its culture. Da Capo Press.google scholar
• Weinstein, D. (2016). Reflections on metal studies. Global metal music and culture. (Eds.) Brown, A., Spracklen, K., Kahn-Harris, K., Scott, N. W. R. Routledge, 22-35. google scholar
• Wiederhorn, J. & Turman, K. (2014). Louder than hell: The definitive oral history of metal. Harper Collins. google scholar
• Williams, R. (2003). Phil Spector: Out of his head. Music Sales Group.google scholar
• Wolfman, U. R. (2013, March 12). Richard Wagner’s concept of the ‘Gesamtkunstwerk’. Interlude. Retrieved from: https://interlude.hk/richard-wagners-concept-of-the-gesamtkunstwerk/google scholar