The Effect of Group-Discussion on the Nurses' Performance of Patients' Rights

Abstract

Objective: Group discussion enhances the knowledge and the quality of cares provided for patients and reinforces nurses' skills and diagnostic reasoning, its effect on changing and respecting patients' right has though been less considered. This paper, thus, aims to study the effect of group discussion on nurses' performance in respecting the rights of patients staying inMadaniHospital inTabrizIran in 2014.

Methods: This is a semi-empirical research study conducted on nurses using a pre- and post-test design. A research sample of 71 nurses randomly selected with negative attitude scores or less than 80 on respecting patients' rights. Data were gathered by an observation checklist including the principle components of patients' physical, mental and social rights. Data were analyzed in SPSS.

Results: Mac Nemar Test was used to compare results before and after intervention. Results indicated that there was a significant statistical difference in the group on respecting patients' rights (p < 0.05). 

Conclusion: According to results, group discussion may contribute to the improvement of nurses' performance in respecting and understanding patients' rights. Group discussion is recommended to be held as an appropriate method in educational therapy centers to improve nurses' perception of patients' rights

Keywords

• Patients' rights, Group Discussion, Performance, Intervention

The Effect of Group-Discussion on the Nurses' Performance in Recognizing Patients' Rights

Öz

Kaynakça

1. Javadyneya A,Najafy N,Ghanbarzadeh k,Sorgi S.Survey of nurses khowledge of pationts bill of righths in Birjand of Medical Sciences during 2011.Journal of Education and Ethics in nursing.2013;5(3):49-56. (Persian)
2. Amany F,Moharamy F,Seigy S,MouzamyR,Sudegyfar V.Determination of compliance with the pationts bill of rights the teaching hospital in tabriz.Journal of science student kaduseh.2012;2(2): 28-37.(Persian)
3. Joolaees,Nikhakht Nasrabady AR,Parsa Yektaz.An Iranian prespective on pationts right: experiences of pationts and their companion . Iran journal of Nursing Ethic. 2009;13(5):488-502.(Persian)
4. Mohamadinejad R, Ehsani R, Begjani ch, Abotalebi G, Kalantarzadeh M, M. A. Awareness of the rights of nurses in 89 hospitals Bymardryk. Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2012;6(19):69-80. (Persian)
5. Ozdemir H, Can O, Ergonen A, Hilal A, Onder M, D. M. Midwives and nurses awareness of patients' rights. Midwifery. 2009;756:25-65.
6. Naseriyani KH, Farniya F, F. N. Patient rights of nurses in hospitals in Yazd Journal of Forensic Medicine. 2007;13(1):7-33. (Persian)
7. BokaieM,AnjazabB,SarvaryM ,FotouhiZ,FarajkhodaT,AbbasiM, Evaluation of the rights of heaith personal By health care From the parspective of hospital patients in yazd.Journal of Medical Ethics.2013;6(19):101-113.(Persian)
8. Safari M, Salsali M, F. G. Effects of group discussion on the quality of nursing education in nursing care of patients with myocardial infarction Journal of Army University of Medical Sciences, Iran. 2004;2(4):37-441. (Persian)

9. SorayaM, Discussion and negotiation- on the interaction of group of impression.Growth of Tehran.1997;52-61. (Persian)
10. Bagchi N, Kohestani H, K. R. Comparison of lecture and group discussion teaching method on nursing students' communication skills with patients. Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2010; (3): 7-10. (Persian)
11. Galajeh M, Zakeri Z, Rezai N, R. A. Knowledge and practice of physicians and nurses to observe patients' charter of Zahedan University of Medical Sciences in 2009 Special rights of patients, Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2010; 70-74 .(Persian)
12. DehbozorgeM,Hadian M,MohamadiJ, The effect of the disease on the patient's bill of rights Paskhkhgvyy expectations before and after training in Namazi Hospital.2012;37-44. (Persian)
13. Cruickshank, D.R, Jenkins, D.B, Metcalf, K.K. The act of teaching. New Yourk: Mcgraw-hill.; 2006:10(1):510.
14. Barret-Sheriden, SE.A quanntitative correlationaal study of political bevavior and attitudes of nurses toward macro-social pationt advocacy.university of Phoenix.2009; (292):3384630.
15. KHosravi SH, J. AS. Focus group method of data collection. Journal of Nursing and Midwifery, Tehran University of Medical Sciences. 2010; 23(68):19-30 .(Persian)
16. Salimi G, Yarmohammadiyan M, Balochestani M. Patient rights awareness and respect by staff health centers in Isfahan. Health Info Manag. 2006;3(2):63-79. (Persian)
17. Khodamardy, K, Amiraliakbary, S, Jalaly, SH, et al. Knowledge of undergraduate and graduate nursing students and pationts right. Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2009;4(12):134-47. (Persian)
18. HoshmandA,jolaeiS,MehrdadN,BohraniN.Awarness of the rights of nurses in teaching hospitals in Tehran Bymarv facilitators observe the rights of theiviews.Journal of Nursing and Midwifery,Tehran university of Medical Sciences(life). 2007;57-66. (Persian).
19. Basiri mogadam K, Basiri mogadam M, Moslem A, Ajamzobid H, F. J. Patients and medical staff awareness of patient rights and observance of hospitals in gonabad. Knowledge horizon. Medical sciences and health services gonabad. 2011;17(1):46-52. (Persian)
20. Rangrazje, F, Rabiei, R. Astudy on the attitude of physicians and nurses of kashan hospital about the chapter of pationts right. feyz. 2007;10(3):40-46. (Persian)
21. Eteraf oskue A,Tabrizi S,Gariby F,jafarabady M. Recavery and promotion respecting patient bill of rights through the intervention of the education center.Journal of medical law quarterly . 2012;14-27. (Persian)
22. Khatony, S. Respect the rights of pationts in public hospital in qazvin. Journal of medical law. 2010;3(11):17-85. (Persian)
23. Polit, Ch, Beck, C, al. e. Essentials of Nursing research: methods, appraiscal and utilization.2006.
24. Hajbageri,M,Mirbager,N,Heydari,S. The application of the nursing process and group discussion based clinical training in nursing students. Iranian Journal of Medical Education Development Center.2011;7(11):728-733 .(Persian)
25. Karimi,M,Tavakol,KH,Alavi,M. Comparison of two methods of teaching and learning by lecture and group discussion on teaching nursing students. Journal of School of Nursing and Midwifery , Hamadan.2008;13(2):15-25. (persian).
26. Kazemnezhad SM, Hesamzadeh A. Implementation of patients’ bills of rights by physicians and nurses from their colleagues’ points of view in educational hospitals of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences Journal. 2013;23(97):216-23. (Persian)
27. Babamahmodi, F, Mafathi, M, Khadmloo, M. Patient Bill of Rights Observance of the patients in the hospitals of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine. 2012;3(19):37-44. (Persian)
28. Mahram ,M,Mahram,M,Mosavi nasab,S. The effect of group discussion, student-centered teaching methods on learning with lecture medical students. Journal of Medical Education Development Center.2009;5(12):71-79. (Persian)
29. Light,G,Com,R.Learning and Teaching in higher education,London:poul chapmau ;2009(207):19-328.
30. Ledo, R, Salas, L, Gonzala, Z, et al. The rights of the hospital pationt:the knowledge and perception of their fulfilment on the part of the professional. The group in catalonia of the spanish socity of care for the health service user.1998; 198(11): 730-5.(Spanish).