The Well-Tempered Reader: The Legitimization of Adab in the Arabic Literary Tradition: Sarah R. Bin Tyeer, University of California Press, 2026. 250 pp.: ISBN 9780520424982

Yıl 2026, Sayı: 10 , 301 - 305 , 22.04.2026

Ahmet Barış Ekiz

https://doi.org/10.64957/nesir.1935065

https://izlik.org/JA58HU62LY

Öz

Bu kitap değerlendirmesi Sarah R. Bin Tyeer’in The Well-Tempered Reader: The Legitimization of Adab in the Arabic Literary Tradition adlı eserini incelemekte ve kitaptan hareketle edeb kavramını tartışmaktadır. Edeb kavramı modern öncesi İslam toplumlarında eğitimli, rafıne ve ahlaklı insan olma ideallerini ihtiva etmektedir. Yazıda, kitabın yazarının etik ve etik olmayan okur ve okuma biçimlerine dair kategorileştirmelerini ele almaktayım. Kitaptaki okuyucu tiplerine dair idealleştirme ve bağlamsal olmayan yaklaşım eleştirilmektedir. Ayrıca, kitabın kapsamının Arap dünyasındaki Arap edebi geleneği ile sınırlandırılmasını tartışmakta, bu geleneğin aynı zamanda Fars ve Osmanlı entelektüel dünyalarını da içerdiğine işaret etmekteyim.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Edeb kavramı , bilgi , Arap edebi geleneği , okuma kültürü , hermenötik , etik

The Well-Tempered Reader: The Legitimization of Adab in the Arabic Literary Tradition: Sarah R. Bin Tyeer, University of California Press, 2026. 250 pp.: ISBN 9780520424982

https://izlik.org/JA58HU62LY

Öz

This book review investigates Sarah R. Bin Tyeer’s book The Well-Tempered Reader: The Legitimization of Adab in the Arabic Literary Tradition, to explore the concept of adab. In premodern Islamic societies, adab embodied the ideal of the educated and ethical human being. In this review, I examine the author’s categorization of readers and modes of reading as ethical and unethical. I critique the idealization of reader types and the book’s noncontextual approach to reading. Furthermore, I challenge the book’s limited scope, focusing on the Arabic literary tradition in the Arab lands. I point out that the cultivation of Arabic literary tradition extended beyond these regions, encompassing the Persian and Ottoman intellectual milieus.

Anahtar Kelimeler

The concept of adab , knowledge , Arabic literary tradition , the culture of reading , hermeneutics , ethics

Destekleyen Kurum

This book review was produced without any financial support.

Teşekkür

An artificial intelligence-supported tool, Grammarly Pro, was used to enhance the grammatical and punctuational accuracy and the textual fluency within the acceptable boundaries defined in Nesir: Journal of Literary Studies’ Artificial Intelligence Use Policy. All content was reviewed and approved in its final form by the author.

Kaynakça

• Ahmed, Shahab. 2016. What Is Islam? The Importance of Being Islamic. Princeton University Press.
• Ghraowi, Ghayde, and Hacı Osman Gündüz, eds. 2022. “The Ascendant Field: Critical Engagements with Ottoman Arabic Literature.” Philological Encounters 7 (3–4).
• Harb, Lara. 2020. Arabic Poetics: Aesthetic Experience in Classical Arabic Literature. Cambridge University Press.
• Pfeifer, Helen. 2022. Empire of Salons: Conquest and Community in Early Modern Ottoman Lands. Princeton University Press.
• el-Rouayheb, Khaled. 2015. Islamic Intellectual History in the Seventeenth Century: Scholarly Currents in the Ottoman Empire and the Maghreb. Cambridge University Press.
• Tyeer, Sarah R. bin. 2025. The Well-Tempered Reader: The Legitimization of Adab in the Arabic Literary Tradition. California University Press.