اعتراضات ابن الصلاح الشهرزوري على الحاكم النيسابوري في علوم الحديث

Yıl 2019, Cilt: 3 Sayı: 1, 73 - 97, 30.06.2019

Yasir Derşevi

https://doi.org/10.32711/tiad.528280

Öz

يعد الحاكم النيسابوري من الأوائل الذين جمعوا علوم الحديث في مؤلف واحد،
وقد جاء العلماء من بعده وعكفوا على دراسة مؤلفاته وشرحوا عباراته وأضافوا إليها
وصوّبوا ما وقع فيها من وهم أو قصور، وهذا أمر طبيعي لا يخلو منه أي عمل إنساني،
ولا ينقص ذلك من مكانته العلمية، وقد شهد له أئمة هذا الفن بالإمامة، ويكفيه أنه
حاز قصب السبق في التصنيف في هذا الفن، وقد قمت بدراسة ما وقعت عليه من
اعتراضات  لابن الصلاح  في كتابه علوم الحديث على الحاكم النيسابوري،
فدققت النظر في كلام الحاكم ، ورجعت إلى المصادر الأصلية لعلماء الحديث ودققت النظر
في كلامهم، لأتأكد من هذه الاعتراضات، أمقبولة هذه الاعتراضات أم لا؟ وذكرت أدلتهم
وقارنت بينها وذكرت ما ترجح لدي في نهاية المطاف، وقد تبين لي من خلال البحث أن
بعض هذه الاعتراضات صحيحة، وبعضها ليست كذلك، وفي نهاية البحث كتبت النتائج التي
توصلت إليها.

Anahtar Kelimeler

اعتراضات، ابن الصلاح، الحاكم، علم، الحديث

İbn Salah el-Şehrezuri'nin Hadis İlimlerinde Hakim-i Nisaburi'ye İtirazları

Öz

Nisaburi hakimi, hadis
bilimi tek yazarda toplayan ilk kişidir. Onun sonraki gelen Alimler. Yazılarını
incelemek için çalıştılar, sözlerini açıkladılar ve eklediler ve yanılsama veya
eksikliklerde olanları düzelttiler. Bu doğal bir insani hareketi dir. Bu azaltmaz
bilimsel durumunundan. Bu sanatın imamleri onu imamlikta gördüler. Yeterki Bu
alanda sınıflandırmada liderliği elde etti. Nisaburi hakimi üzerine Hadis
Bilimi adlı kitabında İbn-i Salah'a yaptığı itirazları inceledim. Hadis bilim
adamlarının orijinal kaynaklarına geriye döndüm ve bu itirazlardan emin olmak
için sözlerini kontrol ettim, bu itirazlar Kabul edilebilir mi değil mi,
onlardan bahsettim ve karşılaştırdım ve sonunda neye inandığımı bildirdim, bazı
itirazların doğru olduğunu araştırdım. Bazı değil. Araştırmanın sonunda
ulastigim sonuclari yazdım

Anahtar Kelimeler

Ibn el-Salah, Hadis, bilim, Hakim-i Nisaburi

Kaynakça

• Abn abi khaythamah, 'Abu Bakr Ahmad bin, al-Tarikh al-kabir al-maerufu bi tarikh ibn abi khaythamah. Investigation: Salah bin Fathi Hilal. Cairo: Al-Farouk modern printing and publishing, 1427.
• Abn al-Jawzi, Jamal al-din Abu al-faraj Abd al-Rahman bin Ali bin Muhamad, al-Dueafa wa’l-matrukin. Investigation: Abdullah al-Qadi. Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Alami, 1406
• Al-Iraqi, Abu al-fadl Zayn al-din Abd al-rahim bin al-Husayn, Sharh alfiat al-iraqi. Investigation: Abd al-latif al-hamim-Mahir Yasin Fahl. Bayrut: Dar al-kutub al-ilmiyyah, 1423/2002.
• Al-Ubnasi, Ibrahim bin Musaa bin Ayyub, al-Shatha al-fayyah min ulum ibn al-salah. Investigation: Salah Fathi Hilala. al-Riyad: Maktabat al-rushd, 1418.
• Askalani, Ahmed bin Ali bin Hajar, al-Nukat ealaa kitab ibn al-Salah. Investigation: Rabie Hadi. Medina: the publisher of the Deanship of Scientific Research Islamic University, 1405.
• Askalani, Ahmed bin Ali bin Hajar, Nozhat al-Nathar fi Tawthih Nokhbat. Investigation: Dr. Noor al-Din Itr. Damascus: al-Sabah, 1421.
• Asqalani, Ahmad bin Ali bin Hajar, al-Isaba fi tamyiz al-sahaba, Investigation: Adel Abdul-Muqeem and Ali Moawad. Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah, 1415.
• Baghawi, Abu Al-Qasim Abdullah bin Mohammed bin Abdul Aziz bin Marzaban, Muejam al-sahabah. Investigation: Mohammed Al-Ameen bin Mohammed Al-Jikni. Kuwait: Dar al-bayan library, 1421-2000.
• Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmad Bin Ali Bin Thabit Bin Ahmed Bin Mahdi, al-Kafayah fi ilim al-riwayah. Investigation: Abu Abdullah Al-Sorqi, Ibrahim Hamdi. al-Madinah al-Munawarah, Maktabat al-İlmiyyah.
• Baghdadi, Abu Bakr Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit, al-Khatib. Al-jamie li akhlaq al-raawi wa adab al-sami.
• Bayhaqi, Ahmad İbn al-Husayn Ibn Ali Ibn Musa, Abu Bakr, al Madkhal ila al-Sunan al-kubra. Investigation: Dr. Mohammed Zia al-Rahman al-Azmi. Kuwait, Dar al-khulafa li’l-kitab al-İslami.
• Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail, al-tarikh al-kabir. Haydarabad: Dairat al-maearif al-euthmaniah.
• Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail, Sahih al-Bukhari. tahqiq: Muhammad Zahir bin Nasir al-Nasir. Beirut: Dar Tavq al-Najat, 1422.
• Darami, Muhammad ibn Habban bin Ahmed bin Habban bin Mu'adh bin Maabad, al-Tamimi, Abu Hatem, al-Basti. al-Thaqat, Hayderabad: 1393.
• Dhahabi, Imam Shamsudin Muhammad b Ahmed, Siyar A’lam al-Nubala. Investigation: al-shaykh shueayb al-Arnawut. Beirut: Muassasat al-risalah, 1405/1985.
• Hakim, Abu Abdullah, Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Hamdouiya , al-Mustadrak ala al-Sahihain. Investigation: Mustafa Abd al-Qadir Atta. Beirut, Dar al-kitab al-alemi, 1411
• Hakim, Abu Abdullah, Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Hamdouiya, al-Madkhal ila kitab al-iklil. Investigation: Fouad Abd al-Moneim. Alexandria: without a edition and without a date.
• Ibn Abd al-Barr, Abu Omar bin Yusuf bin Abdullah bin Mohammed bin Abdul-Barr bin Asim Al-Nimri Al-Qurtubi, al-Istieab fi ma’erifat al-ashab. Investigation: Ali Mohammed Al-Bejawi. Beirut: Dar Al-Jeel, 1412/1992.
• Ibn al-Atheer, Abu’l-Hassan Ali bin Abi Al-Karam Muhammad bin Mohammed bin Abdul Karim bin Abdu’l-Wahid Al-Shibani al-Jazari, Ezz Al-Din, Asd al-ghaba fi ma’erifat al-sahaba. Beirut: Dar Al-Fikr.
• Ibn al-Mulaqqin, saraj al-din abu hafs omar bin Ali, al-Badr al-munir fi takhrij al-ahadith wa’l-athaar al-waqieah fi al-sharh al-kabir. Investigation, Mustafa Abu’l-Gheit, Abdullah Bin Sulaiman and Yasser Bin Kamal. 2004.
• Ibn al-Mulaqqin, Siraj al-Din Abu Hafs Umar, al-Muqni fi ulum al-hadith. Investigation: Abdullah bin Yusuf al-Jedai. Saudi Arabia: Fawaz Publishing House, 1413.
• Ibn Duraid, Abu Bakr Muhammad bin al-Hasan al-Azdi. Jamharat al-lughah. Beirut: Dar al-ilm li’l-malayin, 1987.
• Ibn Makoola, Abu Nasr Ali bin Hebatallah bin Jaafar, al-Ikmal fi raf’ al-Irtiab an al-mu’talaf wa’l-mukhtalaf fi al-asma' wa’l-kunaa wa’l-ansab. Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah, 1411/1990.
• Ibn Manzoor, Muhammad Bin Makram Bin Ali, Lisan al-Arab. Beirut, Dar sader, 1414.
• Ibn Saad, Abu Abdullah Mohammed Al-Hashemi, al-Tabaqat al-kubra. Investigate: Muhammed Abd al-Qadir Ata. Beirut: dar al-kutub ilmiyyah, 1410/1990.
• Ibn Sobki, Taj al-Din Abdul Wahhab bin Taqi, Tabaqat al-Shafi’iyyah al-kubra. Investigate: Mahmoud Mohamed Al-Tanahi, Abdelfattah Mohamed El Helou. Qaherah: Hager Publishing, 1413.
• İbn Hibban, Al-Basti, Muhammad İbn Ahmed, al-Tamimi, Abu Hatem, al-Darami, al-Busty, al-Majrūḥīn min al-muḥaddithin wa’l-ḍuʿafa wa’l-matrukin. İnvestigation: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed. Aleppo: Dar al-alawi, 1396.
• Jurjani, Abu Ahmad Bin Uday, al-Kamil fi dueafa al-rijal. Investigation: Ahmed Adel Abdul-Muqeem. Beirut, Dar al-Kitab al-Alami, 1418.
• Khalili, Abu Ya’ali Khalil bin Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Ibrahim bin Khalil al-Qazwini, al-Irshad fi ma’erifat eulama al-hadithi. Investigation: Dr. Mohammed Saeed Omar Idris, Riyadh: Al-Rushd Library, 1409.
• Khattabi, Abu Sulaiman Hamad Ibn Mohammed Ibn Ibrahim, Ghurayb al-Hadith. Investigation: Abdul Karim Ibrahim Gharbawi. Dar al-Fikr, 1402.
• Manawi, Zayn al-Din Muhamma, al-Taysir bi-Sharh al-jami al-saghir. Library of Imam Shafi'i, 1408.
• Mazzi, Yousef bin Abd al-Rahman bin Yusuf, Abu al-Hajjaj, Jamal al-Din ibn al-Zaki Abu Muhammad al-Qudai Kalbi Al-Mazi, Tahdhib al-Kamal fi Asma' al-Rijal. by: Dr. Bashshar Ewad Maeruf. Beirut: Muasasat al-risalah ,1400/1980.
• Muslim Ibn al-Hajjaj Abul-Hasan al-Qushayri, al-Nisaburi, Saheeh Muslim. Tahqeeq: Mohamed Fouad Abdel Baqi. Beirut: Dar Ihya al-turath al-Arabi.
• Nawawi, Yahya Bin Sharaf, al-Majmu sharh al-muhaddhab. Dar al-Fikr.
• Qadi eyad bin musaa bin eyad bin eumrun al-yahsibii al-sabti, abu al-fadl, al-Ilma’ ila ma’erifat usul al-rawayah wa taqyid al-sama’. Investigation: Mr. Ahmed Saqr. Tunisia: Dar Al-Tarath / Cairo: Antique Library, 1379/1970.
• Sakhawi, Mohammed Bin Abdulrahman, Fateh al-moghith bi’s-sharh al-fiyyat al-hadith li’l-İraqi. Investigation: Ali Hussein Ali. Egypt, Library of the Sunnah, 1424.
• Sam'ani, Abu al-Muzaffar Mansoor Bin Mohammed, Qawatie al-adillah fi usul al-fİqh. Investigation: Mohamed Hassan Al-Shafei. Beirut, Dar al-kutub al-ilmiyyah, 1418.
• Shahrzoori, Uthman Ibn Abd al-Rahman, Abu Amr, Taqi al-Din, Tabaqat Fuqahaa al- Shafi’iyyah. Investigation: Muhyiddin Ali Najib. Beirut, Dar al-Bashaer Islamic, 1992.
• Sharzoori, Uthman ibn Abd al-Rahman, Abu Amr, Ibn Salah, Ulum al-Hadith. Investigation: Dr. Nuraldin Enar. Dar al-Fikr, 2000.
• Shirazi, Ibrahim Bin Ali Bin Yusuf, Abu Ishaq, al-Luma’ Fi Usul al-Fİqh. Dar al-kutub ilmiyyah, 1424.
• Suyuti, abd al-rahman bin abi bakr, jalal al-din, Tadrib al-raawi fi sharh taqrib al-nawawi. By: Abu Qatibah Nazar Muhamad al-Fariabi. Dar at-taeba, d.t.
• Zamakhshari, Abu al-Qasim Mahmud Ibn Amr Ibn Ahmad, al-Fayiq fi ghurayb al-Hadith wa’l-athar. Investigation: Ali Muhammad al-Bagawi. Lebanon, Dar al-Maarifah.