A CRITIQUE OF ENERGY SECURITY MEASUREMENT

Öz

Enerji güvenliğinin sağlanması bütün dünya ülkelerinin ilgi alanında olsa da; enerji güvenliği ölçümü bir güçlük olarak karşımıza çıkmaktadır. Enerji güvenliğini ölçmek için çeşitli göstergeler ve indeksler bulunmaktadır. Ancak enerji güvenliği ölçümü, bileşenlerini ölçmenin zorluğu ve kimi zaman da imkansızlığı nedeniyle komplike bir meseledir. Çünkü bileşenler bölgeler, ülkeler ve ayrıca dönemler ile farklılık göstermektedir. Bunun yanısıra her bir göstergenin ve indeksin kendi avantajları ve dezavantajları bulunmaktadır. Giderek artan enerji güvenliği araştırmalarına rağmen halen kabul edilmiş tek bir ölçüm metodu bulunmamaktadır. Bu çalışma uluslararası organizasyonlar ve hükümetler tarafından karşılaştırmalar yapmak ve politikalar üretmek için kullanılan gösterge ve indeksleri dikkate alarak, enerji güvenliği ölçümünün kapsamlı bir analizini sunmaktadır. Kaliteli ve güvenilir data elde etmede bir bariyer teşkil eden mevcut belirsizliğe dikkat çekmek amaçlanmıştır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• ENERJİ GÜVENLİĞİ
• ENERJİ GÜVENLİĞİ ÖLÇÜMÜ
• ENERJİ GÜVENLİĞİ GÖSTERGELERİ
• ENERJİ GÜVENLİĞİ İNDEKSLERİ

A CRITIQUE OF ENERGY SECURITY MEASUREMENT

Öz

Although ensuring energy security is a key concern of the countries all over the world; measuring energy security remains a challenge. There are several indicators and indices to measure energy security. However energy security measurement is a complicated issue because of the difficulty and sometimes impossibility to measure its components. Because the components differ by regions, countries and also by periods. Besides each of the indicators and indices has its advantages and disadvantages. Despite the growing energy security research there is still not an accepted, single measurement method. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of energy security measurement referring to the indicators and indices used by international organizations and governments to make comparisons and to yield policies. It is aimed to call attention to existing vagueness as a barrier to get high-quality and reliable data. 

Anahtar Kelimeler

• ENERGY SECURITY
• ENERGY SECURITY MEASUREMENT
• ENERGY SECURITY INDICATORS
• ENERGY SECURITY INDICES

Kaynakça

1. APERC (2007). A Quest for Energy Security in the 21st Century: Resources and Constraints. Japan: APERC Institute Of Energy Economics.
2. Asif, M. , & Muneer, T. (2007). Energy supply, its demand and security issues for developed and emerging economies. Renew. Sust. Energ. Rev. , 11(7), 1388-1413.
3. Augutis, J. , Krikštolaitis, R. , Martišauskas,L. , & Pečiulytė, S. (2012). Energy security level assessment technology. Appl. Energy, 97, 143-149.
4. Azzuni, A. , & Breyer, Ch. (2018). Definitions and dimensions of energy security: a literature review. Energy Environ. , 7, 1-34.
5. Badea, A. C. (2010). Energy Security Indicators. Belgrade: EC JRC Institute For Energy, Energy Security Unit.
6. Badea, A. C. , Rocco, C. M. , Tarantola, S. , & Bolado, R. (2011). Composite indicators for security of energy supply using ordered weighted averaging. Reliab. Eng. Syst. Safety. ,96, 651-62.
7. Bambawale, M. J. , & Sovacool, B. K. (2011). China's energy security: the perspective of energy users. Appl. Energy, 88(5), 1949-1956. Bazillian, M. , O'Leary, F. , O'Gallachoir, B. , & Howley, M. (2006). Security of Supply Metrics First Report. Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland.
8. Bedendo, M. , & Colla, P. (2015). Sovereign and corporate credit risk: evidence from the Eurozone. J. Corp. Financ. , 33:34-52.

9. Bhattacharyya, S. C. (2011). Energy Economics: Concepts, Issues, Markets and Governance. London:Springer.
10. Blumer, Y. B. , Moser, C. , Patt, A. , & Seidl, R. (2015). The precarious consensus on the importance of energy security: contrasting views between Swiss energy users and experts. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. , 52, 927-936.
11. Blyth, W. , & Lefevre, N. (2004). Energy security and climate change. Paris: IEA
12. Bohi, D. R. , & Toman, M. A. (1993). Energy security: externalities and policies. Energy Policy, 21, 1093-1109.
13. Böhringer, C. , & Bortolamedi, M. (2015). Sense and no(n)-sense of energy security indicators. Ecol. Econ. , 119, 359–371.
14. Böhringer, C. , & Jochem, P.E.P. (2007). Measuring the immeasurable —a survey of sustainability indices. Ecol. Econ. , 63, 1-8.
15. Brown, M. A. , Wang, Y. , Sovacool, B. K. , & D'Agostino, A. L. (2014). Forty years of energy security trends: a comparative assessment of 22 industrialized countries. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. , 4, 64–77.
16. Chang, M. C. (2014). Energy intensity, target level of energy intensity, and room for improvement in energy intensity: an application to the study of regions in the EU. Energy Policy, 67:648–55.
17. Chaudry, M, Ekins, P. , Ramachandran, K. , Shakoor, A. , Skea, J. , Strbac, G. , Wang, X. , & Whitaker, J. (2009). Building a Resilient UK Energy System. Working Paper. London: UK Energy Research Centre.
18. Cherp, A. , & Jewell, J.(2011a). Measuring energy security: from universal indicators to contextualized frameworks. In B. K. Sovacool (Ed.), The routhledge handbook of energy security (pp. 330-355). Lund:Routledge.
19. Cherp, A. , & Jewell, J. (2011b) The three perspectives on energy security: intellectual history, disciplinary roots and the potential for integration. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. , 3, 202-212.
20. Cherp, A. , & Jewell, J. , Vinichenko, V. , Bauer, N. , De Cian, E. (2016). Global energy security under different climate policies, GDP growth rates and fossil resource availabilities. Climatic Change, 136, 83-94.
21. Cherp, A. , Adenikinju, A. , Goldthau, A. , Hernandez, F. , Hughes, L. , Jansen, J. , Jewell, J. , Olshanskaya, M. , Soares de Oliveira, R. , Sovacool, B. K. , & Vakulenko, S. (2012). Chapter 5- Energy Security. In T. B. Johansson, A. Patwardhan, N. Nakicenovic, L. Gomez-Echeverri (Eds.), Global Energy Assessment - Toward a sustainable future (pp. 325-384). Cambridge: Cambridge University Pess.
22. Cherp, A. (2012). Defining energy security takes more than asking around. Energy Policy, 48, 841-842.
23. Cherp, A. , & Jewell, J. (2014). The concept of energy security: beyond the four As. Energy Policy, 75, 415-421,
24. Cherp, A. , & Jewell, J. (2013). Energy security assessment framework and three case-studies. In H. Dryer, M. J. Trombetta (Eds.), International Energy Security Handbook(pp. 146-173). Edward Elgar Publishing.
25. Chester, L. (2010). Conceptualizing energy security and making explicit its polysemic nature. Energy Policy, 38,887-895.
26. Christie, E. H. (2009). Energy vulnerability and EU-russia energy relations. J.Contemp. Eur. Res. , 5(2),274-292.
27. Ciuta, F. (2010). Conceptual Notes on Energy Security: Total or Banal Security? Security Dialogue, 41(2), 123-144
28. Cohen, G. , Joutz, F. , & Loungani, P. (2011). Measuring energy security: trends in thediversification of oil and natural gas supplies. Energy Policy, 39(9), 4860-4869.
29. Cox, E. (2016). Opening the black box of energy security: a study of conceptions of electricity security in the United Kingdom. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. , 21, 1-11.
30. Cox, E. (2018). Assessing long-term energy security: the case of electricity in the United Kingdom. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 82, 2287-2299. de Jong, J. , Maters, H. , Scheepers,M. , & Seebregts, A. (2006). EU Standards for Energy Security of Supply. Netherlands: ECN/Clingendael International Energy Programme.
31. Dorian, J. P. , Franssen, H. T. , & Simbeck, D. R. (2006). Global challenges in energy. Energy Policy, 34(15), 1984-1991.
32. Downs, E. S. (2014). The Chinese security debate. China Q. , 177, 21-41.
33. Dyer, H. , & Trombetta, M. J. (2013). The concept of energy security:broadening, deepening transforming. In H. Dyer, M. J. Trombetta (Eds.), International handbook of energy security(pp. 3-18).USA:Edward Elgar Publishing.
34. Erker, S. , Stangl, R. , & Stoeglehner, G. (2017a). Resilience in the light of energy crises – Part I: a framework to conceptualise regional energy resilience. J. Clean. Prod. , 164, 420-433.
35. Erker, S. , Stangl, R. , & Stoeglehner, G. (2017b). Resilience in the light of energy crises – Part II: application of the regional energy resilience assessment. J. Clean. Prod. , 164, 495-507.
36. Faas, H. , Gracceva, F. , Fulli, G. , & Masera, M. (2011). European security -a Europeanperspective. In A. Gheorghe, L. Muresan (Eds.), Energy Security - International and Local Issues, Theoretical Perspectives, and Critical Energy Infrastructures (pp. 9-21). Springer.
37. Frondel, M. , & Schmidt, C. M.(2014). A measure of a nation's physical energy supply risk. Q. Rev. Econ. Finance, 54, 208-215.
38. GEA (2012). Global Energy Assessment – toward a Sustainable Future. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39. Glynn, J. , Chiodi, A. , & Gallachoir, B. O. (2017). Energy security assessment methods: Quantifying the securityco-benefits of decarbonising the Irish Energy System. Energy Strategy Reviews, 15, 72-88.
40. Gnansounou, E. (2008). Assessing the Energy Vulnerability: Case of Industrialised Countries. Energy Policy, 36(10), 3734-3744.
41. Golušin, M. , Muinitlak-Ivanović, O. , Andrejević, A. , & Vučenov, S. (2014). Survey of socio economic growth in SE Europe – new conceptual frame for sustainability metrics. Jecon Surv, 28:152-168.
42. Golušin, M. , Munitlak-Ivanović, O. , & Redžepagić, S. (2013). Transition from traditional to sustainable energy development in the region of Western Balkans – current level and requirement. Appl. Energy, 101, 182-191.
43. Gracceva, F. , & Zeniewski, P. (2014). A systemic approach to assessing energy security in a low-carbon EU energy system. Appl. Energy, 123, 335-348.
44. Grubb, M. , Butler, L. , & Twomey, P. (2006). Diversity and security in UK electricity generation: the influence of low-carbon objectives. Energy Pol. , 34, 4050-4062.
45. Guivarch, C. , & Monjon, S. (2017). Identifying the main uncertainty drivers of energy security in a low-carbon world: the case of Europe. Energy Econ. , 64, 530-541.
46. Guivarch, C. , Monjon, S. , Rozenberg, J. , & Vogt-Schilb, A. (2015). Would climate policy improve the European energy security? Clim. Change Econ. , 6(2),1550008.
47. Gupta, E. (2008, March). Oil vulnerability index of oil-importing countries. Energy Policy, 36(3), 1195-1211
48. Haar, L. , & Haar, L. N.(2019). A financial option perspective on energy security and strategic storage. Energy Strategy Reviews, 25, 65-74.
49. Hughes, L. (2012). A generic framework for the description and analysis of energy security in an energy system. Energy Policy, 42, 221-231.
50. IEA (2008). Toward a sustainable energy future. Paris: IEA.
51. Jansen, J. C. , & Seebregts, A. J. (2010). Long-term energy services security: what is it and how can it be measured and valued? Energ Policy, 38, 1654-1664.
52. Jewell, J. (2011). The IEA Model of Short-Term Energy Security (MOSES): Primary Energy Sources and Secondary Fuels. IEA Energy Papers. Paris: OECD Publishing.
53. Jewell, J. , Cherp, A. , & Riahi, K. (2014). Energy security under de-carbonization scenarios: an assessment framework and evaluation under different technology and policy choices. Energy Pol. , 65, 743-760.
54. Jewell, J. , Cherp, A. , Vinichenko, V. , Bauer, N. , Kober, T. , Mccollum, D. , van Vuuren, D. P. , & van Der Zwaan, B. (2013). Energy security of China, India, the E.U. and the U.S. under longterm scenarios. Clim. Change Econ. , 4(4), 1340011.
55. Jingzheng, R. , & Sovacool, B. K. (2014). Quantifying, measuring, and strategizing energy security: determining the most meaningful dimensions and metrics. Energy, 76, 838-849.
56. Jun, E. , Kim, W. , & Chang, S. H. (2009). The analysis of security cost for different energy sources. Appl. Energy, 86(10), 1894-1901.
57. Kanellakis, M. , Martinopoulos, G. , & Zachariadis, T. (2013). European energy policy—a review. Energy Policy, 62, 1020-1030.
58. Kaufmann, D. , Kraay, A. , & Mastruzzi, M. (2010). The worldwide governance indicators: methodology and analytical issues, Policy Research. Working Paper Series No. 5430. The World Bank.
59. Kisel, E. , Hamburg, A. , Härm,M. , Leppiman, A. , & Christie, M. O. (2016).Concept for energy security matrix. Energy Policy, 95, 1-9.
60. Krishnan, R. (2016). Energy security through a framework of country risks and vulnerabilities, Energy Sources, Part B: Economics. Planning, and Policy, 11(1), 32-37.
61. Kruyt, B. , van Vuuren, D. P. , de Vries, H. J. M. , & Groenenberg, H. (2009, June). Indicators for energy security. Energy Policy, 37(6), 2166-2181.
62. Laldjebaev, M. , Sovacool, B. K. , & Kassam, K. A.S.(2016). Energy security, poverty, and sovereignty: complex interlinkages and compelling implications. In L. Guruswamy (Ed.), International Energy and Poverty: the Emerging Contours (pp. 97-112). UK: Routledge.
63. Le Coq, C. , & Paltseva, E. (2009). Measuring the security of external energy supply in the European Union. Energy Policy, 37, 4474-4481.
64. Lefevre, N. (2010). Measuring the energy security implications of fossil fuel resource concentration. Energy Policy, 38(4), 1635-1644.
65. Leung, G. C. K. (2011). China's energy security:perception and reality. Energy Policy, 39, 1330-1337.
66. Lima, F. , Portugal‐Pereira, J. , Lucena, A. F. , Rochedo, P. , Cunha, J. , Lopes Nunes, M. , & Szklo, A. S. (2015). Analysis of energy security and sustainability in future low carbon scenarios for Brazil. Nat. Resour. Forum, 39, 175-190.
67. Löschel, A. , Moslener, U. , & Rübbelke, D. T. G. (2010a). Energy security – concepts and indicators. Energy Pol. , 38, 1607-1608.
68. Löschel, A. , Moslener, U. , & Rübbelke, D. T. (2010b). Indicators of energy security in industrialised countries. Energy Policy, 38(4), 1665-1671.
69. Månsson, A. , Johansson, B. , & Nilsson, L. J. (2014). Assessing energy security: an overview of commonly used methodologies. Energy, 73, 1-14.
70. Martišauskas,L. , Augutis J. , & Krikštolaitis, R. (2018). Methodology for energy security assessment considering energy system resilience to disruptions. Energy Strategy Reviews, 22, 106-118 .
71. Martchamadol, J. , & Kumar, S. (2014). The aggregated energy security performance indicator (AESPI) at national and provincial level. Appl. Energy, 127, 219-238.
72. Mischke, P. , & Karlsson, K. B. (2014). Modelling tools to evaluate China's future energy system – a review of the Chinese perspective. Energy, 69, 132-143.
73. Molyneaux,L. , Brown, C. , Wagner, L. , & Foster, J. (2016). Measuring resilience in energy systems: insights from a range of disciplines. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. , 59, 1068-1079.
74. Narula, K. , & Reddy, B. S. (2016).A SES (sustainable energy security) index for developing countries. Energy, 94, 326-343.
75. Narula, K. , & Reddy, B. S. (2015). Three blind men and an elephant: the case of energy indices to measure energy security and energy sustainability. Energy, 80, 148-158.
76. Norvaiša, E. , & Galinis, A. (2016). Future of Lithuanian energy system: electricity import or local generation? Energy Strateg. Rev. , 10, 29-39.
77. O'Leary, F. , Bazillian, M. , Howley, M. , O'Gallachoir, B. , Blyth, W. , Scheepers, M. , Seebregts, A. , & Tol, R. (2007). Security of Supply in Ireland. Dublin: Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland.
78. Oshiro, K. , Kainuma, M. , & Masui, T. (2016). Assessing decarbonization pathways and their implications for energy security policies in Japan. Clim. Pol. , 16, 63-77.
79. Peña Balderrama, J. G. , Broad, O. , Sevillano, R. C. , Alejo, L. , & Howells, M. (2017). Technoeconomic demand projections and scenarios for the Bolivian energy system. Energy Strateg. Rev. , 16, 96-109.
80. Pleßmann, G. , & Blechinger, P. (2017). How to meet EU GHG emission reduction targets? A model based decarbonization pathway for Europe's electricity supply system until 2050. Energy Strateg. Rev. , 15, 19-32.
81. Radovanović, M. , Filipović, S. , & Golušin, V. (2017). Energy security measurement – A sustainable approach. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 68, 1020-1032.
82. Ren, J. Z. , & Sovacool, B. K. (2014). Quantifying, measuring, and strategizing energy security: determining the most meaningful dimensions and metrics. Energy, 76, 838-849.
83. Rose, A. , Wei, D. , & Paul, D. (2018). Economic consequences of and resilience to a disruption of petroleum trade: the role of seaports in U.S. energy security. Energy Pol. , 115, 584-615.
84. Samuelson, R. D. (2014). The unexpected challenges of using energy intensity as a policy objective:examining the debate over the APEC energy intensity goal. Energ Policy, 64, 373-381.
85. Simpson, A. (2007). The environment–energy security nexus:critical analysis of an energy ‘love triangle’ in Southeast Asia. Third World Q, 28, 539-554.
86. Sovacool, B. K. (2011). Evaluating energy security in the Asia pacific: towards a more comprehensive approach. Energy Pol. , 39, 7472-7479.
87. Sovacool, B. K. (2013). An international assessment of energy security performance. Ecol. Econ. , 88, 148-158.
88. Sovacool, B. K. , & Mukherjee, I. (2011). Conceptualizing and measuring energy security: a synthesized approach. Energy, 36, 5343-5355.
89. Sovacool, B. K. , Mukherjee, I. , Drupady, I. M. , & D’Agostino, A. L. (2011). Evaluating energy security performance from 1990 to 2010 for eighteen countries. Energy, 36(10), 5846-5853.
90. Sovacool, B. K. (2016). Differing cultures of energy security: an international comparison of public perceptions. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. , 55, 811-822.
91. Sovacool, B. K. , Valentine, S. V. , Bambawale, M. J. , Brown, M. A. , de Fatima Cardoso, T. , Nurbek, S. , Suleimenova, G. , Li, J. , Xu, Y. , Jain, A. , Alhajji, A. F. , & Zubiri, A. (2012). Exploring propositions about perceptions of energy security:An international survey. Environ Sci. Policy, 16(1), 44-64.
92. Sovacool, B. K. (2012). The methodological challenges of creating a comprehensive energy security index. Energy Pol. , 48, 835-840.
93. Šprajc, P. , Bjegović, M. , & Vasić, B. (2019). Energy security in decision making and governance – Methodological analysis of energy trilemma index. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 114, 1-9.
94. Stirling, A. (2010). Multicriteria diversity analysis: a novel heuristic framework for appraising energy portfolios. Energ Policy, 38, 1622-1634.
95. Suehiro, S. (2008). Energy intensity as an index of energy conservation: problems in international comparison of energy intensity of GDP and estimate using sector-based approach. IEEJ Energy J. , 7, 58-71.
96. Umbach, F. (2010). Global energy security and the implications for the EU. Energy Policy, 38, 1229-1240.
97. US Chamber of commerce. (2011). Index of US Energy Security Risk 2012. Washington:US Chamber Of Commerce.
98. US Chamber of commerce. (2015). Index of US Energy Security Risk 2015. Washington: US Chamber Of Commerce.
99. Valentine, S. V. (2011). Emerging symbiosis: renewable energy and energy security. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. , 15, 4572-4578.
100. Vivoda, V. (2010). Evaluating energy security in the Asia-Pacific region: a novel methodological approach. Energy Pol. , 38, 5258-5263.
101. von Hippel, D. , Suzuki, T. , Williams, J. H. , Savage, T. , & Hayes, P. (2011). Energy security andsustainability in Northeast Asia. Energy Policy, 39, 6719-6730.
102. Wang, J. J. , Jing, Y. Y. , Zhang, C. F. , & Zhao, J. H. (2009). Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision making. Renew Sustain Energy Rev. , 13, 2263-2278.
103. Winzer, C. (2012). Conceptualizingenergy security. Energy Policy, 46, 36-48.
104. Yergin, D. (1988). Energy security in the 1990s. Foreign Aff. , 67(1), 110-132.
105. Zhang, L. , Yu, J. , Sovacool, B. K. , & Ren, J. (2017). Measuring energy security performance within China: Toward an inter-provincial prospective. Energy, 125, 825-836.
106. Zhou, P. , & Ang, B. W. (2008). Linear programming models for measuring economy-wide energy efficiency performance. Energy Policy, 36(8), 2911-2916.