Comparative Accuracy of Fecal Sedimentation, Fluke Finder, and Coproantigen ELISA for Diagnosing Fasciola hepatica in Sheep

Abstract

Fasciola hepatica is the primary helminth in the Fasciolidae family responsible for causing zoonotic fascioliasis worldwide. This study aims to investigate the occurrence of Fasciola hepatica infection (FHI) in sheep of different ages, sexes, breeds, and management practices. Additionally, the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of fecal sedimentation methods (SS) and Fluke Finder (FF) instruments were compared to recently developed commercial kits, specifically the coproantigen enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (C Ag ELISA). A total of 92 fecal samples were collected from animals naturally infected with FH (46 ewes and 46 rams) across various districts of Mosul, Iraq. FHI prevalence was 15.2% (CI = 8.3–25.5) with SS, 16.3% (CI = 9.1–26.9) with FF, and 20.6% (CI = 12.4–32.3) with C Ag ELISA. When C Ag ELISA served as the gold standard, both SS and FF showed high accuracy—94.6% for SS, 95.7% for FF, with a Kappa value (κ) of 0.877. Although the sensitivities were 73.7% and 78.95% respectively, outdoor feeding was the strongest variable associated with FHI (Odds ratio (OR) 3.2; 95% CI: 19.9 to 56.5, P = .01), followed by age of 3-5 years (OR 3.1; 95% CI: 17.6 to 50.0, P = .02). Despite management efforts and medication, FHI continues to impact the study area. Both SS and FF proved accurate and demonstrated high agreement; however, they detected only 75% of infected animals. Sheep aged 3–5 years that grazed outdoors showed significantly higher infection rates.

Keywords

• Fascioliasis
• fluke finder
• sheep
• coproantigen ELISA
• liver fluke

Kaynakça

1. 1.Howell A. Update on liver fluke in sheep and cattle.Livestock. 2024;29:162-166.
2. 2.Hassan NA, Diab M, Bayoumi AM, et al. Review onfascioliasis in animals and human. New Valley Vet J.2025;5(1):69-79.
3. 3.Stuen S, Ersdal C. Fasciolosis—an increasing challenge inthe sheep industry. Animals (Basel). 2022;12(12):1491.
4. 4.Lan Z, Zhang XH, Xing JL, et al. Global prevalence of liverdisease caused by Fasciola. J Glob Health. 2024;14:04223.
5. 5.Hayward AD, Skuce PJ, McNeilly TN. Influence of liverfluke infection on production. Int J Parasitol.2021;51(11):913-924.
6. 6.Kadhum NK, Karim SM, Mansour KA, et al. Liverfascioliasis indicators. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2022;36(3):653-657.
7. 7.Bargues MD, Angles R, Coello J, et al. One Healthinitiative in fascioliasis. Rev Bras Parasitol Vet. 2021;30(2):e025620.
8. 8.Novobilský A, Solis NA, Skarin M, et al. Flukicide efficacyin sheep. Int J Parasitol Drugs Drug Resist. 2016;6(3):141-147.

9. 9.Kamaludeen J, Graham-Brown J, Stephens N, et al.Triclabendazole resistance. Vet Rec. 2019;184(16):502.
10. 10.Abed AN, Al-Fatlawi MA. β-tubulin gene detection. IraqiJ Vet Sci. 2024;38(3):671-675.
11. 11.Sargison ND, Scott PR. Triclabendazole resistancediagnosis. Vet Rec. 2011;168:159.
12. 12.Rekani AM, Mero WM. Molecular characterization ofFasciola. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2023;37(2):315-323.
13. 13.Hendrix CM, Robinson CV. Diagnostic Parasitology forVeterinary Technicians. 6th ed. Elsevier; 2023.
14. 14.Felefel W, Shabian A, Eassa SM, et al. Parasitic infectionsprevalence. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2023;37(2):469-477.
15. 15.Calvopina M, Romero-Alvarez D, Diaz F, et al. Diagnosticmethods comparison. PLoS One. 2018;13:e0203811.
16. 16.Olaogun SC, Byaruhanga C, Ochai SO, et al. Diagnostic comparison study. Pathogens. 2022;11:1398.
17. 17.Bosco A, Ciuca L, Maurelli MP, et al. Mini-FLOTACcomparison. Parasit Vectors. 2023;16:260.
18. 18.Zárate-Rendón DA, Vlaminck J, Levecke B, et al.Diagnostic technique comparison. Am J Trop Med Hyg.2019;101:59-61.
19. 19.Palmer D, Lyon J, Palmer M, et al. Copro-antigen ELISAevaluation. Aust Vet J. 2014;92:357-361.
20. 20.Munita MP, Rea R, Martinez-Ibeas AM, et al. ELISA kitscomparison. BMC Vet Res. 2019;15:414.
21. 21.Kajugu PE, Hanna RE, Edgar HW, et al. CoproantigenELISA specificity. Vet Parasitol. 2015;212:181-187.
22. 22.Nur Hafizah S, Noor Izani NJ, Ahmad Najib M, et al.Immunodiagnosis review. Malays J Med Sci. 2023;30:25-32.
23. 23.Mungube EO, Bauni SM, Tenhagen BA, et al. Economicsignificance. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2006;38:475-483.
24. 24.Berhe G, Berhane K, Tadesse G. Fasciolosis prevalence.Trop Anim Health Prod. 2009;41:1503-1504.
25. 25.Fleiss JL. Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions.Wiley; 1981.
26. 26.Baratloo A, Hosseini M, Negida A, et al. Sensitivity andspecificity. Emergency (Tehran). 2015;3:48-49.
27. 27.Mikaeel FB. Fasciola prevalence. Iraqi J Vet Med.2020;44:113-119.
28. 28.Al-Alo AZ, Albishtue AA, Al-Dujaily AH. Liver fluke survey.Acta Sci Vet Sci. 2019;1:2-8.
29. 29.Villa-Mancera A, Jiménez-Cortez H, Robles-Robles M, etal. Climatic risk factors. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2024;38(4):731-737.
30. 30.Modabbernia G, Meshgi B, Kinsley AC. Climatic effects onFasciola. Parasitol Res. 2024;123:300.
31. 31.Tawfeeq DA, AlBakri HS. Caprine theileriosis detection.Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2024;38(3):693-699.
32. 32.Darwish DA, Masoud HM, Helmy MS, et al. Enzymecharacterization. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2024;38(1):215-223.
33. 33.Hammami I, Amdouni Y, Romdhane R, et al. Fasciolaprevalence Tunisia. Vet Med Sci. 2024;10:e1575.
34. 34.Delgado NU, Pereira AE, Martínez RA, et al.Seroprevalence Colombia. Rev Bras Parasitol Vet. 2023;32:e009923.
35. 35.Conceição MA, Durão RM, Costa IH, et al. Sedimentationmethod evaluation. Vet Parasitol. 2002;105:337-343.
36. 36.Becker AC, Kraemer A, Epe C, et al. Coproscopicalmethods comparison. Parasitol Res. 2016;115:2581-2587.
37. 37.Ploeger HW, Ankum L, Moll L, et al. Rumen flukesidentification. Vet Parasitol. 2017;30:42-46.
38. 38.Alstedt U, Voigt K, Jäger MC, et al. Fluke infectionsGermany. Animals (Basel). 2022;12:876.
39. 39.Hassan NM, Helal MA, Elsawy BS, et al. Haemonchosisepidemiology. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2025;39(2):419-429.
40. 40.Düwel D, Reisenleiter R. Coprological diagnosiscomparison. Angew Parasitol. 1990;31:211-217.
41. 41.Andrews SJ, Cwiklinski K, Dalton JP. Fasciolosis. CABI;2021:1-15.
42. 42.Kurnianto H, Ramanoon SZ, Aziz NAA, et al. Fasciolosis prevalence Indonesia. Vet World. 2022;15:1438-1448.
43. 43.Kahl A, von Samson-Himmelstjerna G, Helm CS, et al.Coproscopical diagnosis comparison. Vet Parasitol.2023;319:109956.
44. 44.Mezo M, González-Warleta M, Carro C, et al. CaptureELISA development. J Parasitol. 2004;90:845-852.
45. 45.Takeuchi-Storm N, Denwood M, Hansen TVA, et al. Farm-level risk factors. Parasit Vectors. 2017;10:555.
46. 46.Ruiz-Campillo MT, Barrero-Torres DM, Abril N, et al.Immune responses in infection. Vet Res. 2023;54:2.
47. 47.Hasan SD, Hussain KJ, Hassan WS, et al. Genetic diversitystudy. Iraqi J Vet Sci. 2023;37(4):915-920.
48. 48.Niedziela DA, Naranjo-Lucena A, Molina-Hernández V, etal. Transcriptomic responses. Front Immunol.2021;12:729217.