A Comparative Analysis of Global Competition: North Atlantic Treaty Organization and Shanghai Cooperation Organization

Year 2018, Issue: 52, 115 - 142, 28.12.2018

Ayça Eminoğlu , Sertif Demir

https://doi.org/10.18070/erciyesiibd.414768

Cited By: 3

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to compare and explain the similarities and differences of NATO and the SCO, in the context of Eurasianism which was part of daily discussion ın Turkey. For this purpose, organization objectives and classification, establishment processes, alliance obligations, threat perceptions, qualifications of members, decision making systems, responsibility fields, mutual interactions and activities were analyzed through comparative method. At the end of analysis, it was determined that there are considerable differences, despite some similarities, between NATO and SCO in aspect of quality, aim and context. Turkey can collaborate with SCO as long as it does not harm Turkey’s commitment in NATO.

Keywords

NATO, SCO, Turkey, Eurasianism

Küresel Rekabetin Karşılaştırmalı Bir Analizi: Kuzey Atlantik Antlaşması Örgütü (NATO) ve Şangay İşbirliği Örgütü (ŞİÖ)

Abstract

Bu makalenin amacı, Türkiye’de gündemde olan Avrasyacılık tartışmaları bağlamında iki örgütün karşılaştırmalı analizini yapmak ve böylece NATO ve ŞİÖ’nün benzerliklerini ve farklılıklarını ortaya koymaktır. Bu amaçla örgütlerin, kuruluş amaçları ve sınıflandırılmaları, kuruluş süreçleri, ittifak yükümlükleri, tehdit algılamaları, üyelerin nitelikleri, karar alma sistemleri, sorumluluk sahaları ve etkinlikleri karşılaştırma yöntemi ile analiz edilmiştir. Yapılan analiz sonucunda, bazı benzerliklere rağmen, NATO ile ŞİÖ arasında nitelik, nitelik, amaç ve kapsam açısından önemli farklar olduğu tespit edilmiştir. Türkiye NATO yükümlülüklerine zarar vermeden ŞİÖ ile yakın işbirliği yapması olası görünmektedir.

Keywords

NATO, ŞİÖ, Türkiye, Avrasyacılık

References

• Akihiro, Iwashita; (2004), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Its Implications for Eurasian Security: A New Dimension of “Partnership” after the Post-Cold War Period”, Slavic Eurasia’s Integration into the World Economy and Community, Sapporo: Slavic Research Centre, Hokkaido University, pp. 259-281.Ambrosio, Thomas; (2008), “Catching the ‘Shanghai Spirit’: How the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Promotes Authoritarian Norms in Central Asia”, Europe-Asia Studies, 60(8): 1321-1344.Andican, Ahat; (2006), “Çin Satrancında Orta Asya”, Avrasya Dosyası, 12 (1): 14-16.Arı, Tayyar; (2013), Uluslararası İlişkiler ve Dış Politika, MKM Yayıncılık, Bursa.Aris, Stephen; (2009), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation: ‘Tackling the Three Evils’. A Regional Response to Non-traditional Security Challenges or an Anti-Western Bloc?” Europe-Asia Studies, 61(3): 457–482.Bailes, Alyson JK; (2007), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Europe”, China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 5(3): 13-18.Bailes, Alyson JK., Dunay, P., Guang, P. and Troitskiy, M. (2007) “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization” SIPRI Policy Paper, 17.Baizakova, Kuralai I.; (2013), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization’s Role in Countering Threats and Challenges to Central Asian Regional Security”, Russian Politics and Law, 51(1): 59–79.Blank, Stephen; (2006), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization as an Energy Club, Portents for the Future,” Central Asia-Caucuses Institute Analyst, 1-3. Brzezinski, Zbigniew; (2009), “An Agenda for NATO”, Foreign Affairs, 88(5).Carroll, William E.; (2011), “China in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization: Hegemony, Multi-Polar Balance, or Cooperation in Central Asia”, International Journal of Humanities and Social Science 1(19): 1-8.Cheng, Joseph Y. S.; (2011), “The Shanghai Co-operation Organisation: China’s Initiative in Regional Institutional Building”, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 41(4): 632–656. Çakmak, Haydar; (2003), Avrupa Güvenliği, Ankara, Akçağ Yayınları.Çolakoğlu, Selçuk; (2004), “Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü’nün Geleceği ve Çin”, Uluslararası İlişkiler, 1(1): 173-197.Çomak, Hasret ve Gökalp, Ayşegül; (2009), “2010’lu Yıllarda Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü’nün Geleceği ve Türkiye”, Orta Asya Toplumlarında Sosyal, Siyasi, Ekonomik Arayışlar Kongresi, 22-24 Ekim 2008 Bişkek / Kırgızistan, Kocaeli Üniversitesi Yayınevi.Dönmez, Suat; (2010), “Güvenlik Anlayışının Dönüşümü: İttifak Kavramı ve NATO”, Basılmamış Doktora Tezi, Ankara Üniversitesi.Dwivedi, Sangit Sarita; (2012), “Alliances In Internatonal Relations Theory”, International Journal of Social Science & Interdisciplinary Research, 1(8): 224-227.Ekrem, Erkin; (2012), “Türkiye’nin Şanghay işbirliği Örgütü Üyeliği”, http://www.sde.org.tr/tr/authordetail/-turkiyenin-sanghay-isbirligi-orgutu-uyeligi/1107, (27.01.2017).Gaddis, John Lewis; (1997), We Now Know: Rethinking Cold War History, Oxford University Press.Gaddis, John Lewis; (2005), The Cold War: A New History, New York, Penguen. Germanovich, Gene; (2008), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization: A Threat to American Interests in Central Asia?”, China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 6(1): 19-38. Graham, Craig, Ozment Turner, Kagan; (2014), The Heritage of World Civilization, Ninth Edition, USA, Pearson.Guoping, Cheng; (2012), “SCO: A Wonderful Book” Chinascope, pp.23-25.Gürkaynak, Muharrem; (2004), Avrupa’da Savunma ve Güvenlik Ankara, Asıl Yayınevi.Hale, William; (2013), Turkish Foreign Policy Since 1774, London, Routledge.Hass, Marcel de; (2007), “The Shanghai Cooperation and the OSCE: Two of a Kind”, Helsinki Monitor, 46. Heywood, Andrew; (2013), Küresel Siyaset, Çev. Nasuh Uslu ve Haluk Özdemir, Ankara, Adres Yayınları.Holsti, Ole, Hopmann, T. and Sulliva, J.; (1973), Unity and Disintegration in International Alliance, New York, Wiley-Interscience Publication.Huasheng, Zhao; (2006), “The Shanghai Cooperation Organization at 5: Achievements and Challenges Ahead” China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 4(3): 105-123.İşyar, Ö. Göksel; (2013), Avrasya ve Avrasyacılık, Bursa, Dora.Jia, Qingguo (no date),”The Success of the Shanghai Five: Interests, Norms and Pragmatism”, http://www.comw.org, (08.04.2018).Liska, George; (1962), Nations in Alliance: The Limits of Interdependence, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.Mate, Robert; (2009), "NATO of the East?: An International Relations Analysis of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization", Midwest Political Science Association 67th Annual National Conference, The Palmer House Hilton, Chicago, IL, http://citation.allacademic.com/meta/p363868_index.html, (25.05. 2013).Mccalla, Robert B.; (1996), "NATO's Persistence After the Cold War", International Organization, 50(3): 445-475.Morgenthau, Hans J.; (2006), Politics among Nations: the Struggle for Power and Peace, 7th. Edition, Mc Graw Hill, New York.Morozov, Evgeni (08.06.2006) “NATO’s Evil Twin?”, TCS Daily, http://www.tcsdaily.com/article.aspx?id=060806A, (15.10.2017)NATO 2014 Zirve Bildirisi, http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_112964.htm, (11.11.2014).NATO stratejik Konsept 2010, http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_82705.htm, (09.10.2013).NATO Stratejik Konsept, 1991, http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_23847.htm, (11.08.2013).NATO Stratejik Konsept, 1999, http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_27433.htm, (11.11.2014). Özdal, Barış ve Genç, Mehmet; (2005), AGSP’nin Türkiye-AB İlişkilerine Etkileri, İstanbul, Aktüel Yayınevi.Özdaşlı, Esma; (2012), “Çin ve Rusya Federasyonu’nun Perspektifinden Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü”, MAÜ SBE Dergisi 4(6): 108-122.Pantucci, Raffaello ve Alexandros Petersen (05 Mayıs 2013), “Türkiye, ŞİÖ için AB’den Vaz mı Geçecek?”, http://www.dunyabulteni.net/?aType=yazarHaber&ArticleID=18900, (15.11.2014).Sander, Oral; (1989), Siyasi Tarih 21 Baskı, Ankara, İmge.Sander, Oral; (2011), Siyasi Tarih 23. Baskı, Ankara, İmge. Shilong, Yang; (2012), “The Balance Power of the SCO” Chinascope. Snyder, Glenn H.; (1990), “Alliance Theory: A Neorealist First Cut”, Journal of International Affairs, 44: 103-123.Sönmezoğlu, Faruk; (2013), Uluslararası Politika ve Dış Politika, İstanbul, Remzi.ŞİÖ’nün Kuruluş Bildirgesi, http://www.hrichina.org/content/5203, (26.08.2012).ŞİÖ’nün Temel Dökümanları, http://www.hrichina.org/content/5207, (11.11.2013).Telatar, Gökhan; (2005), “Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü: 21. Yüzyılın Bölgesel/Küresel Çekim Merkezi”, Atilla Sandıklı ve İlhan Güllü (Der.), Geleceğin Süper Gücü Çin: Uzakdoğu’daki Entegrasyonlar ve Şanghay İşbirliği Örgütü, İstanbul, TASAM.Walt, Stephen M.; (1987), The Origins of Alliances, Cornell University Press Ithaca NY, 273-281.Waltz, Keneth; (1979, reisssued in 2010), Theory of International Politics, Illionis, Waveland Press.We Now Know: Rethinking Cold War History adlı kitap incelemesi, Howard H. Lentner, City University of New York, Published on H-Teachpol, February, 1998. Weber, Steve; (1992), “Shaping the Postwar Balance of Power: Multilateralism in NATO”, International Organization, 46(3): 633-680. Wolfer, Arnold; (1968), “Alliances”, David L. Sills (ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, New York, Macmillan.Yiğit, Süreyya; (2012), “Türkiye, Büyük Orta Asya ve ŞİÖ Pekin Zirvesi” Ortadoğu Analiz, 4(44): 52-67.