Doğum Turizmi: Sistematik Bir Derleme

Abstract

Amaç: Medikal turizm kapsamında yapılan doğum turizminin önemi gün geçtikçe artmaktadır. Bunun neticesinde de doğum turizmi konusunda farkındalık oluşturacak çalışmaların da önemi artış göstermektedir. Bu doğrultuda çalışmanın amacı doğum turizmi ile ilgili yapılan çalışmaların sistematik derlemesini yapmaktır. Yöntem: Çalışma kapsamında literatür taraması PubMed, Taylor & Francis, ScienceDirect, Web of Science ve Scopus veri tabanları üzerinde gerçekleştirilmiştir. Çalışmanın kapsamı İngilizce dilinde, tam metin olarak yayımlanan doğum turizmi ile ilgili araştırma makaleleri ile sınırlı tutulmuştur. Tarama sonucunda 601 çalışmaya belirtilen veri tabanlarından, 9 çalışmaya ise el ile yapılan taramadan ulaşılmış olup tarama sonucunda toplamda 610 çalışma elde edilmiştir. Belirlenen dâhil etme kriterleri çerçevesinde 19 çalışma kapsama alınmıştır. Bulgular: 2016-2023 yılları arasında yer alan çalışmaların araştırma yöntemleri nitel, nicel ve karma şeklinde olup doğum yapmak için giden annelerin Ganalı, Çinli ve Tayvanlı olduğu tespit edilmiştir. Doğum yapmak için gidilen destinasyonlar ise Amerika Birleşik Devletleri, Hong Kong ve Kanada’dır. Doğum turizmi kapsamında annelerin yurt dışına gitme nedenlerine bakıldığında ise çocuklarına iyi bir gelecek imkânı sunma, vatandaşlık elde etme, daha iyi sağlık hizmetinden yararlanma olanağı, göç etmek, yaşadıkları ülkenin izledikleri politika, kişisel seçim ve yaşanılan ülkeye duyulan güven eksikliği şeklinde tespit edilmiştir. Sonuç: Literatürde yer alan mevcut çalışmaların sistematik derleme yöntemiyle irdelendiği mevcut çalışma sonucunda doğum turizmi konulu çalışmaların niceliksel olarak yeterli olmadığı saptanmış ve doğum turizmine yönelik çalışmaların artırılması gerekliliği ortaya konmuştur. Ayrıca hem derleme hem de alan araştırması türünde yapılacak çalışmalarla doğum turizminin tanımı, avantajları-dezavantajları, anne deneyimleri gibi önem arz eden konulara değinilerek alan farkındalığı oluşturulması gerekmektedir.

Keywords

• Medikal turizm
• doğum turizmi
• sistematik derleme

Birth Tourism: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Aim: The importance of birth tourism within the scope of medical tourism has increased day by day. Therefore, the importance of studies that will raise awareness about birth tourism has also increased. Accordingly, the aim of this study is to systematically review the studies conducted on birth tourism. Method: The literature was reviewed via PubMed, Taylor & Francis, ScienceDirect, Web of Science and Scopus databases within the scope of the study. The scope of this study was limited to the studies on birth tourism published in English as a full text. According to literature review, 601 studies were accessed from the specified databases and nine studies were reached by manual search, and a total of 610 studies were obtained as a result of the search. 19 studies were included within the framework of the specified inclusion criteria. Results: The research methods of the studies conducted between 2016-2023 were qualitative, quantitative and mixed, and it was determined that the mothers who went to give birth were Ghanaian, Chinese, and Taiwanese. The destinations visited for giving birth were the United States, Hong Kong, and Canada. Considering the reasons of mothers traveled abroad within the scope of birth tourism, it has been determined that they provide a better future for their children, acquire citizenship, benefit from better health services, and immigration, because of the policies of the country they live in, personal choices, and lack of trust in the country they live in. Conclusion: As a result of the current study, in which the recent studies in the literature were examined by using systematic literature review method, it was identified that the studies on birth tourism were not quantitatively sufficient and it was revealed that there was a need to increase the number of studies on birth tourism. In addition, it is necessary to raise awareness in the field by addressing important issues such as the definition of birth tourism, its advantages and disadvantages, and mothers’ experiences, regarding studies that will be conducted both in the review and research in the field.

Keywords

• Medical tourism
• birth tourism
• systematic review

References

1. 1. Gül MK, Özkan Ç, Öztürk Ö, Küçük S. Türk halkının sağlık turizmine yönelik metaforik algıları. Journal Of Gastronomy, Hospitality And Travel (Online). 2022;5(1):145-156.
2. 2. Köse G, Öter EG. Sağlık turizmi perspektifinde babymoon: Güncel durum ve geleceğe ilişkin değerlendirmeler. In: Ahi Evran III - Uluslararası Bilimsel Araştırma Konferansı; 3-5 Mayıs, 2023; Bakü, Azerbaycan.
3. 3. Aydın R, Yılmaz E. The impact of medical tourism on women's health. Journal of Applied Tourism Research. 2020;1(1):45-52.
4. 4. Pařízková A, Clausen JA. Women on the move: A search for preferred birth services. Women and Birth. 2019;32(4): e483-e491.
5. 5. Ji Y, Bates BR. “Better than bank robbery”: Yuezi centers and neoliberal appeals to market birth tourism to pregnant Chinese women. Health Communication. 2018;33(4):443-452.
6. 6. Allotey AA, Kandilige L. The conundrum of birth tourism and American ‘jackpot babies’: Attitudes of Ghanaian urban dwellers. African Human Mobility Review. 2021;7(3).
7. 7. Brar S, Kale M, Birch C, Mattatall F, Vaze M. Impact of birth tourism on health care systems in Calgary, Alberta. BMC Health Serv Res. 2022;22(1):120.
8. 8. Kang T. New media, expectant motherhood, and transnational families: Power and resistance in birth tourism from Taiwan to the United States. Media, Culture & Society. 2018;40(7):1070-1085.

9. 9. Barrett JF. Birth tourism-an opinion. J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2023:385-386.
10. 10. Nori M. Asian/American/Alien: Birth tourism, the racialization of Asians, and the identity of the American citizen. Hastings Women's LJ. 2016;27:87.
11. 11. Berghuis K. Stopping the practice of citizenship for sale. Center For Immigration Studies. 2020.
12. 12. Chee WC. How family policies redefine families: The case of mainland China–Hong Kong cross‐border families. International Journal of Social Welfare. 2021;30(4):478-489.
13. 13. Cheng KM. Medical tourism: Chinese maternity tourism to Hong Kong. Current Issues in Tourism. 2016;19(14):1479-1486.
14. 14. Jaramillo J, Goyal D, Lung C. Birth tourism among Chinese women. MCN: The American Journal of Maternal/Child Nursing. 2019;44(2):94-99.
15. 15. Rodriguez C. Chinese maternity tourists and their “anchor babies”? Disdain and racialized conditional acceptance of non-citizen reproduction. In Marginalized mothers, mothering from the margins. Emerald Publishing Limited. 2018:91-106.
16. 16. Rahim H, Page S, Mattatall F, Mitchell I, Guichon J. Maternity care providers’ perceptions of the implications of birth and gestation tourism for patients, health care providers, and the Canadian health care system. Canadian Public Policy. 2020;46(4):492-507.
17. 17. Choi SY, Lai RY. Birth tourism and migrant children’s agency: The ‘double not’in post-handover Hong Kong. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies. 2022;48(5):1193-1209.
18. 18. Freckelton A. Could Canada abolish birthright citizenship? Journal of International Migration and Integration. 2022;23(2):701-731.
19. 19. Lozanski K. Mobilizing mobilities: Birthright tourists as willful strangers in Canada. Mobilities. 2020;15(2):146-160.
20. 20. Wang SH. Fetal citizens? Birthright citizenship, reproductive futurism, and the “panic” over Chinese birth tourism in southern California. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space. 2017;35(2):263-280.
21. 21. Lim J, Sun WD, Zhang L, Mikhael M. Birth tourism is associated with fewer neonatal intensive care unit admissions: A healthy migrant effect? American Journal of Perinatology. 2020;39(08):883-888.
22. 22. Onwuzurike C, Ungaretti J, Cejtin HE. A County hospital experience with reproductive travelers to the United States for obstetric care: Maternal and neonatal outcomes. Journal of Women's Health. 2022;31(6):864-869.
23. 23. Philipsborn RP, Sorscher EA, Sexson W, Evans HH. Born on U.S. soil: Access to healthcare for neonates of non-citizens. Matern Child Health J. 2021;25(1):9-14.
24. 24. Mikhael M, Cleary JP, Dhar V, Chen Y, Nguyen DV, Chang AC. Birth tourism and neonatal intensive care: A children's hospital experience. American Journal of Perinatology. 2016;33(14):1415-1419.
25. 25. Boichak O. Geopolitics of reproduction: Investigating technological mediation of maternity tourism on the Russian web. Big Data & Society. 2019;6(2):2053951719868491.
26. 26. Harden M. Unmade in America: The gendered politics of birth tourism in the United States. Political Geography. 2023:107;102972.
27. 27. Altan-Olcay Ö, Balta E. Class and passports: Transnational strategies of distinction in Turkey. Sociology. 2016;50(6):1106-1122.
28. 28. Bednarski A. Birth tourism, citizenship, and the politics of deservingness in Canada: analyzing parliamentary and newspaper media discourses from 1990 to 2021. [master of arts]. University of Alberta. 2022.